If we stay...honestly, we can't see a path to victory. We'll do our best to come up with something,
Negotiating with a resurrected Pain might turn into the least-bad remaining option, so discuss contingencies for that. In particular, what sorts of leverage Leaf would have in such a negotiation, or could reasonably secure if we start working on it now, without seriously compromising our other interests. Shikamaru will surely have ideas.
 
This seems simplified to the point of losing the meaning of the original so I'm not sure I want to use most of these rewordings. What is the extra stuff you want added exactly?
What points do you feel are lost? I think that they read basically identically, with mine featuring less repetition (and being clearer as a result).

I want to share how we cracked Minatosealing and ask about the seals going to the Akatsuki/the Tower's seals and at least vaguely name-drop Hiashi. In rough order of importance.
 
What points do you feel are lost?
Feels like there's several lines that require a lot of inference on the part of the QMs to a degree I don't want to put on them. Things like "Implication: Minato" or whatever seems pretty unclear to me and I'm not even a QM. I want to explicitly lay out the mind games behind a given path personally.

I want to share how we cracked Minatosealing
Seems reasonable, I'll try to work that in tomorrow morning.

ask about the seals going to the Akatsuki/the Tower's seals
What about them? Let Hazou look at them first? I think that if people found out Naruto let him do that they would be fucking pissed but OTOH I suppose they don't need to find out.

and at least vaguely name-drop Hiashi
Why?
 
Things like "Implication: Minato" or whatever seems pretty unclear to me and I'm not even a QM. I want to explicitly lay out the mind games behind a given path personally.
I agree on that one, but the others seem plenty clear to me. I'd like the extra XP given that we're now FOOMing.

(The rest of it I have responses to but largely I don't care a lot.)
 
Fair enough.

I'd like the XP regardless as we'll need pretty much every scrap, and I think you repeat yourself a lot. I might take another crack at wordcount reduction while making sure clarity is preserved.
I don't disagree there are a couple repeated things, some of that was at request of other voters though who wanted certain things emphasized.

I'll give it a shot myself tomorrow while I work in the other stuff you wanted (Besides maybe the Hiashi comment) but no promises on the brevity. I do like getting every point where we can but I like a clear message to the QMs more.
 
@Shrooms

What's the motivation for asking Naruto to run the clan? (Instead of e.g. Mari or Noburi who I think we've already told is next in line?) And I'm a bit confused but are we asking him to take over for us now? Or just in a hypothetical future where we were no longer around
 
There's a clear Doylist explanation to "why does a 30 minute conversation take one in game day" and that's because to fully model everything that happens within a day would be absurdly taxing on the QMs.

Isn't this what the xp abstraction is about? Presumably Hazou is training / researching / keeping his skills sharp / doing necessary-but-not-interesting-enough-to-be-in-the-chapter clan head duties, and so on. I expect if you actually wanted to model all of that, you would be getting a lot fewer XP points per day overall.

Also, I suspect the QM-had-fun xp would go well into the negatives with that type of micromanaging. :]

Incidentally, one of my biggest pet peeves is incredibly slow-paced serialized fiction. There's a quest? story? something over here that has 2 million words and covered two weeks of in game time. That's 100 words per *minute* of in game time, with *no* time skips, not even for sleeping.

This quest on the other hand, with its million words, is a lot more brisk, and enjoyable to read. (Although I would love a few more time skips even here!)
 
Which is all downstream of us having a kind of leisurely mindset towards this. We're not obsessed with power-seeking, the way Ami or Oro are. That reflects in how not-obsessed, laid-back Hazou is. He doesn't have "how can I maneuver to greater power today?" as the top idea on his mind
I feel like there are a number of reasons for this, and none if it is because of thread desire/voting habits.

To piggyback off of what Heleor said, our XP per day is, effectively, Hazo's power-seeking actions, abstracted and put into the background. Any time we get XP, thats from training or researching or whatnot in an effort to get power. That includes all the SC xp, the 'Ami style training' Xp, and so on.

However in terms of a written story, this writers don't want to write 'numbers go up simulator', and the thread, although trying to optimize constantly, is forced to deal with actual story elements. I'm not blaming the QMs for this, an actual story is much more fun to read than a spreadsheet, but the kind of power-seeking obsession you are talking about here is not functionally possible with the format of the quest. Again, ignoring that all the XP we are constantly gaining IS actually that exact power seeking going on in the background, but is evidentially not enough.
 
Incidentally, one of my biggest pet peeves is incredibly slow-paced serialized fiction. There's a quest? story? something over here that has 2 million words and covered two weeks of in game time. That's 100 words per *minute* of in game time, with *no* time skips, not even for sleeping.

This quest on the other hand, with its million words, is a lot more brisk, and enjoyable to read. (Although I would love a few more time skips even here!)
Just for fun, after I finished compiling the big list of events I checked the date of the starting chapter (when we decoded the poetry) both in-universe and irl. Since that day, about a year has passed in the world of Marked for Death, and about a year and a half has passed in the real world. A 1.5x ratio isn't really all that slow, and it came as a bit of a surprise given how it often feels like everything's happening so fast there's no room for any time to pass.
 
Basically, commit to anything in a way that'd cash out into us having concrete power of some type, rather than ending up as a combat- and manipulation-incapable researcher who also never does any research.
god, yes. if only

(I think maybe what I really want is for the great seal and rift/necromancy plotlines to never have happened. Or only one of them at a time. The two of them put together have kinda wedged us into a corner in terms of the narrative and our decision-making, and I think it's been terrible for quest fun.)
 
A seal having essie-tier impact does not require essie-tier infusion TN. Kagome didn't need essie+ Sealing to make Skywalkers, and they had global causal impact on the setting
Well if you had an idea like that you should have shared it! I don't think we had any ideas like that.
Ami and Kabuto somehow manage
Ami specifically rants about how difficult dealing with him and not being dissected is. So I don't think that example is particularly helping your point.

Kabuto seems to be an exception to many of the rules regarding interacting with Oro. But a suggestion of "be Kabuto" is not actionable or practical.
Cloud somehow managed
We don't know anything about the internal political situation of Cloud. In Leaf literally their entire cultural/governmental structure is based around the Hokage.
Well, that's the point, I don't know. But they're clearly extremely laid-back about various eldritch stuff, compared to the Human Path's Thinkers. The lore alone, that we could've extracted from the eager talkers on the Seventh Path and re-sold to lore-interested individuals on the Human Path
Re-sold? To who? We can't even sell literal diamonds without provoking a crisis.
 
[XP is for background stuff]

This quest on the other hand, with its million words, is a lot more brisk, and enjoyable to read. (Although I would love a few more time skips even here!)
Thank you very much for this, and yes, you got it exactly right about what XP represents IMO.
Although it's 3.1 million words. 😊
 
What's the motivation for asking Naruto to run the clan? (Instead of e.g. Mari or Noburi who I think we've already told is next in line?)
Because if we leave we want to bring them too. Also Noburi doesn't want the job he would just do it if he had to. Mari is the same way.
I'm a bit confused but are we asking him to take over for us now?
The main conceit of my plan is that his actions need to make sense regardless of which path Hazou takes. To me it is clear that even if we stay, doing misc clan head shit is just not the best use of Hazou's time. And if we go, he protects what we leave behind much better than if Hazou just abandons his post
 
[X] Action Plan: A Shorter Treason Dragon

What points do you feel are lost? I think that they read basically identically, with mine featuring less repetition (and being clearer as a result).
- While neither plan commits to staying or leaving, I see Shorter Treason Dragon as taking a somewhat more optimistic attitude towards the possibility of leaving
- The Goketsu / Uzumaki section is more shortened than the rest (I think, I didn't count), which seems to me like it could result on placing less emphasis on it

I like both of these changes, and I'm voting A Shorter Treason Dragon over Schrodinger's Treason Dragon not because it's shorter but because I think it's slightly better.

Kabuto seems to be an exception to many of the rules regarding interacting with Oro. But a suggestion of "be Kabuto" is not actionable or practical.
Perhaps 'figure out why Kabuto is an exception' could be actionable, though it doesn't seem very promising.
 
[X] Action Plan: Schrodinger's Treason Dragon
Word Count: ~370
  • Hazou doesn't know what to think, and needs time to consider. And, somewhat obviously, wouldn't tell Naruto so he can maintain deniability either way.
    • Potentially noteworthy, regarding Hazou's fears of Goketsu being punished/ exploited by Akatsuki should he defect, that Jiraiya always intended Naruto to become Clan Head.
      • Hazou's unsure what Naruto thinks about it. The Uzumaki legacy is certainly important too.
      • But, treason-wrangler Naruto could plausibly take advantage of this fact from Jiraiya's will to undermine treason-Hazou's political influence/authority. This could even be additional grounds to make treason-Hazou go rogue.
      • Naturally, this grants Naruto access to Pangolin armor techniques without getting Kei in trouble.
      • Goketsu's new patriarch being Naruto himself adds yet more psychological deterrence for Akatsuki enacting retribution on the remaining Goketsu, lessening some consequences of leaving.
      • Would this be okay if Hazou didn't leave?
    • If he stays... honestly he's not sure how they can win currently. He'll think of more options but it looks pretty grim right now. Not that leaving is especially promising.
      • The extent of 3D sealing's abilities remain unknown. Maybe investigating its capabilities will make it more obvious if it can fortify Leaf against invasion, making surviving the aftermath of the rearguard attack viable.
    • Either case, Hazou needs to spend time healing and teach Orochimaru lithosealing.
    • Does Naruto want the key to cracking Minato's notes? Akatsuki doesn't know it and tmay come back to interrogate Naruto if they fail infusions, but it would mean the secret is still with Leaf even if Hazou leaves.
    • What resources is Naruto willing to share with Hazou? It needs to be things Naruto would share in either Hazou decision, ostensibly out of gratitude for Hazou's election help, so neither of them are biased towards expecting a given decision and to maintain deniability. To be clear, nothing is fine too, but Hazou may as well ask.
      • Jutsu? Any relevant Lore, like Whirlpool or something? Any remaining Minato Sealing insights for sealing/3D Sealing? Any mind-strengthening tricks for researching with parallel SCs?
      • Can Hazou examine the other Akatsuki seal submittals?
      • SC for Kagome. They didn't tell him to stop researching the Rift and in Hazou's estimation is likely a jonin-level sealmaster himself. In fact, he is regularly overlooked, which could be an advantage.
@FaintlySorcerous I shortened the plan some and implemented the first two of your asks, I'm still unsure what the point of the Hiashi comment is so I've left it out.


- While neither plan commits to staying or leaving, I see Shorter Treason Dragon as taking a somewhat more optimistic attitude towards the possibility of leaving
As somebody who wants to leave so bad it physically pains me, I think obviously favoring leaving to Naruto makes it too obvious we're going to, which defeats the point of maintaining deniability for him, in my opinion of course.

- The Goketsu / Uzumaki section is more shortened than the rest (I think, I didn't count), which seems to me like it could result on placing less emphasis on it
Not really sure what this means.
 
@eaglejarl

I wanted to bring up the retcon again. If the toad lore was received back when chapter 506 happened, then we would've told Itachi more about what we know of the Tenfold Abomination (in 619.5). We especially wouldn't have been able to hold back our knowledge since our deceit is piss-poor. Imo it's a bit unsatisfying to not have the lore when we needed it, but then realize we actually had it according to the timeline.

I understand if you intend to do nothing about it (e.g. some reasoning about how what we know of the tenfold abominations is actually very vague or how noburi forgot to tell hazou about the critical lore we needed asap) since keeping the timeline and player knowledge consistent is really hard, but some more information on this would be very much appreciated.
 
Last edited:
@Shrooms
What's the motivation for asking Naruto to run the clan? (Instead of e.g. Mari or Noburi who I think we've already told is next in line?) And I'm a bit confused but are we asking him to take over for us now? Or just in a hypothetical future where we were no longer around
At present, Noburi is your official heir. In the shinobi world, this kind of information is typically public within your own clan (to ensure a smooth transfer of power if you suddenly die on a mission). It is also, unless deliberately kept secret, something monitored by other political forces, who may wish to befriend/corrupt/prepare blackmail material on/etc. your heir in advance, or at least be aware of their beliefs and policy preferences in order not to be blindsided when they take over and start running things differently.

I feel like there are a number of reasons for this, and none if it is because of thread desire/voting habits.

To piggyback off of what Heleor said, our XP per day is, effectively, Hazo's power-seeking actions, abstracted and put into the background. Any time we get XP, thats from training or researching or whatnot in an effort to get power. That includes all the SC xp, the 'Ami style training' Xp, and so on.

However in terms of a written story, this writers don't want to write 'numbers go up simulator', and the thread, although trying to optimize constantly, is forced to deal with actual story elements. I'm not blaming the QMs for this, an actual story is much more fun to read than a spreadsheet, but the kind of power-seeking obsession you are talking about here is not functionally possible with the format of the quest. Again, ignoring that all the XP we are constantly gaining IS actually that exact power seeking going on in the background, but is evidentially not enough.
Thank you for this, and I agree: XP is an abstraction for the training and such that happens in the background, and closer time tracking would not be fun for anyone. (As a side note: we're also very generous with Hazō's time. Somehow he's able to do two full-time jobs (clan head, researcher) and get meetings with very busy people whenever he wants, regardless of whether he has Shadow Clones available.)

@eaglejarl @Velorien @Paperclipped Given the retroactive nature of the toad sage update and the urgency of the current situation, how do you feel about declaring something like "Noburi and Hazo immediately realized the severity of this situation and rushed to inform Kei and Shikamaru of this information and the reliability of the source shortly after Noburi returned from that meeting"? I've tried to think of several possible responses for convenience.
This wouldn't take any FP or wordcount. Hazō and Noburi went straight to the Nara estate and told Kei and Shikamaru what Noburi had learned. The two said they had no idea about it but they would discuss the implications and check the family's private records to see if there was anything relevant.
 
@eaglejarl

I wanted to bring up the retcon again. If the toad lore was received back when chapter 506 happened, then we would've told Itachi more about what we know of the Tenfold Abomination (in 619.5). We especially wouldn't have been able to hold back our knowledge since our deceit is piss-poor. Imo it's a bit unsatisfying to not have the lore when we needed it, but then realize we actually had it according to the timeline.

I understand if you intend to do nothing about it (e.g. some reasoning about how what we know of the tenfold abominations is actually very vague or how noburi forgot to tell hazou about the critical lore we needed asap) since keeping the timeline and player knowledge consistent is really hard, but some more information on this would be very much appreciated.
We'll remove Itachi's mention of the Tenfold Abomination to preserve continuity. It's worth noting that this is actually to your (slight) advantage overall. Itachi went on to say that he didn't want to share Akatsuki forbidden lore unless Hazō joined, since otherwise he'd potentially be spilling it to all of Leaf. If you weren't going to get meaningful lore out of him regardless, it's better to have a potential enemy unaware of how much Hazō knows.
 
Back
Top