It has occured to me that an easy way to keep banshee slayers in place is to use ushankas with little seal-carrying slots on the inside.

That is all.
 
Interlude: Chosen for the Grave, Part 24: Send in the Clown
Interlude: Chosen for the Grave, Part 24: Send in the Clown
It was a pleasant morning at the Suspicious Foreigner Estate. For the sake of Orochimaru's resocialisation, I'd grudgingly accepted having meals with Earl and Oli instead of having extra time to pursue the deeper arcana of the Snake Element or recreate the Bloodline Limit transplant technology we'd unfortunately refused to carry over to the CftGverse. Oli had just finished regaling us with his exploits at the Leaf General Hospital (where he was busy annoying Tsunade with his attempts to move neurology past "brain disorders are caused by evil spirits partying it up inside your skull") when we heard the familiar ominous sound of a messenger calling from the main gate.

Orochimaru perked up. "Ah, finally, more raw materials. Now we can finish fine-tuning the Snake-Infested Swamp of the Underworld Technique."

"Remember, Orochimaru," I replied, "we do not kidnap people who might be missed, by which I mean anyone at all and suggestions to the contrary are blatant slander, so stop looking at me like that, you two. I'll go see what they want from us."

The message this time was neither a terrifying summons from the Hokage nor a a high-pitched scream that only we in all the world could decipher. Instead, it was a hand-drawn map, together with a calling card.

I rolled the map out across the coffee table, and the four of us leaned over to study it.

"This is near the Iron border, I think," Earl commented eventually. "I've heard rumours about villages disappearing in that area lately—more frequently than usual, I mean."

Oli and I winced, while Orochimaru nodded as if Earl had said, "It's likely to rain tomorrow" or "A lunatic like Hidan would never use his powers to help set up world peace".

"There's a cross-shaped mark there," Oli said, tapping an open area next to a forest (one of the two types of Fire Country terrain) with his finger. "Do you think it's an invitation to meet someone at that spot?"

We turned as one to the card. I flipped it over.

"Flufflec dot query," Orochimaru read out, taking a little longer to sound out the unfamiliar name. "Is this some kind of code?"

In a sense, I supposed it was.

"I have no idea," I said. "I don't think I've seen a flufflec.query before. That said, if it really is an invitation… there can only be one flufflec.response."

-o-​

Flufflec, the Loremaster of Chosen for the Grave, was simultaneously exactly like and nothing like I had imagined him. On the one hand, here in the flesh, he looked like a maniacal clown in heavy makeup—you know the one I mean. On the other hand, here in the flesh, he looked like a maniacal clown in heavy makeup. At first, I was honestly lost for words.

"Not what you expected?" Flufflec gave a theatrical bow. "Ah, but wouldn't the alternative be dull? No, with all those years of entertainment to repay, my dear Valerian, I had to start by putting on my game face."

Suddenly, he shook his head violently, like a bull trying to shrug off a fly. "Ugh. I'm sorry about that. It's been like this ever since I got isekai'd, and I have no idea why. I mean, I assume you haven't been turning into your avatar, going around gathering morally dubious allies and exploiting overpowered supernatural abilities to prepare a bid for world domination and so forth."

"Eheheh." I gave an uneasy laugh. "No, that's certainly not something that would ever happen to me."

"Listen," Flufflec went on, his voice developing a trace of urgency, "I need you to stop me before it gets any worse. I swear to you, I'm not actually a homicidal sociopath with a twisted sense of humour, but given what I've already done, and the fact that my powers let me—"

He cut off abruptly, only to wiggle a finger admonishingly in his own face. "Ah ah ah. Spoilers in spoiler tags only, if you please. I am ever so sorry about my more boring half, my dear Valerian. Don't worry. I'll be sure to keep him under lock and key while we play our game.

"Speaking of games, I don't mind an audience, but I really was hoping for more of a show of courage from Team QM. And a protagonist actually being in possession of a telescope? It's like I don't even know you anymore."

It was my idea that the others hang back and watch from a safe distance. Anime had taught me that the essence of manliness was to charge into encounters headfirst, figuring out the enemy's abilities as and when they hit you in the face. However, better anime had taught me that against somebody with completely unknown powers which might well be the equal of our own (if not worse—he was a player, and they were the ones who typically got the cheat abilities), it made more sense for one person to provoke him into tipping his hand while the others watched and analysed, finding weaknesses to exploit in Round 2. Besides, if things went badly, which they probably would, I had the ultimate escape card ready while my friends did not.

"Then again," Flufflec drawled, "nothing makes the heart beat faster than a private show."

He snapped his fingers. Nothing seemed to happen.

"Much better."

"What did you do?" I asked warily.

"I had one of my happy little friends use seals to cut this area off from the rest of the world," Flufflec said. "My powers don't let me use chakra like you, but they make it ever so easy to gather those little yellow circles, and the people who live and die for them. That's why—"

He snapped his fingers again in mid-sentence, and a razor-sharp kunai hit the middle of my chest.

-o-​

As it happened, I did not possess the aforementioned essence of manliness. I was well aware that, from a ninja perspective, I made wet tissue paper look like solid rock. As such, I'd come in wearing enough long-duration buffs that to an Uchiha I would light up like a Christmas tree made of lasers. The kunai, despite its scary precision, merely took off my level 94 Pangolin Conditioning Technique (and also scared the bejeezus out of me even though we'd figured I would be walking into some sort of ambush).

Three missing-nin appeared around me, spaced so that whichever way I turned, at least one would be outside my line of sight. Before anything else, I had to reposition.

"Substitution Tech—"

Oh, crap.

Forget convenient boulders or the classic log, the area around me was bereft of so much as a stray pebble. I made a mental note to avoid, in my next life, walking into ambushes set by people with a brain.

I went straight to Plan B.

"Earth Element: Shadow Clone Technique!"

Early canon was wonderful in some ways, and one of those ways was having shadow clones that not only didn't pop when hit, but could actually regenerate from fatal damage. Hiruzen's ability to solo two unkillable Kage and one only slightly less unkillable S-ranker at once made a lot more sense when you realised that Kishimoto had not yet grasped the concept of ninjutsu power levels.

"Substitution Technique! Substitution Technique! Substitution Technique!"

I was just about to relax after securely concealing myself in a squad of earth shadow clones when Flufflec waved a hand casually in my direction.

"My dears, your dance partner for this beautiful evening is number seven from the right."

"Substitution Technique!"

"Number three from the left."

"Substitution Technique!"

"The one in the middle. Are you even trying now?"

It seemed increasingly certain that Flufflec's power was what I thought it was, I decided as I used the Body Flicker Technique to evade kunai after kunai while praying that the universe didn't get confused by a ninjutsu that couldn't exist and decide to grue me. I'd have to take him out fast and hope that his missing-nin lackeys didn't stick around once he was no longer in a state to pay them.

I needed something that worked fast, before the melee missing-nin could get through my wall of clones.

"Water Element: Water Gun Technique!"

Bizarrely, I'd found through experimentation that the Hōzuki ability to transform into water was actually a ninjutsu rather than a Bloodline Limit, meaning the usual restrictions on my ability to use Kishimoto's most absurdly OP powers did not apply. Research in the Basement was a lot safer for me these days, given that every room already had a convenient drain for all the blood.

Oddly, Flufflec didn't appear intimidated as I formed my fingers into a finger gun and pointed it at him dramatically. Nor did he react as a super-fast projectile possibly made from part of my finger (Kishimoto was unaware of the concept of biomass) began to zoom towards him.

Instead, at the last second, a random gust of wind caught the deadly but also tiny sphere of water, shifting its trajectory just enough that it slammed into the tree behind him.

"I know what you're thinking," Flufflec said sympathetically. "'If only my balls were bigger.'"

I felt a flicker of annoyance. Well, if that was the way he wanted to play it…

"Fire Element: Great Fireball Technique!"

I actually had to downcast this one, as a Great Fireball at full level 94 power would have left me well within its blast radius (as well as quite possibly half the Fire Country—at higher levels, the scaling on some of these techniques broke down harder than Sasuke's characterisation between the original and Shippūden).

Watching the humongous, vaguely-spherical inferno flying towards him with little more than academic interest, Flufflec snapped his fingers one more time.

"Water Element," came a shout from the missing-nin nearest him, "Water Formation Pillar!"

The curved watery barricade couldn't entirely cancel out the fireball—luckily, we'd never finalised an elemental advantage mechanic—but it lasted long enough for Flufflec, already in position, to get out of the way without even getting his purple suit singed.

There was no way Flufflec had different ways of snapping his fingers to indicate different contingencies. My worst suspicions were confirmed. If Flufflec had briefed his minions in advance on exactly how to counter my attacks, then he knew my battle plan better than I did. He really did have some kind of omniscience-related power.

Establishing that alone made this battle worth it. Now, there was just one thing I needed to confirm before I made my escape. Did Flufflec have any way to fight that didn't rely on his minions?

"Chidori!"

Ordinarily, it would have been a terrible idea for a non-Uchiha to use Chidori—if you didn't have the Sharingan's pseudo-precognition, its speed boost was so big you became unable to track potential counterattacks. That was how Kakashi had lost his eye. However, in this instance, closing the gap to Flufflec really fast was the only way to make sure his minions couldn't use a ninjutsu to intercept again, and the technique's notorious one-hit-kill potential should be enough to force him to reveal any trump cards of his own.

So of course Flufflec sidestepped very slightly, and, lacking the ninja reflexes for course correction, I ploughed face-first into the tree behind him.

"Witness the power… of the Uchiha…" I slurred as I learned firsthand why ninja wore forehead protectors.

I regained awareness of my surroundings just in time to see Flufflec fish an extremely evil-looking, jagged steel knife out of a jacket pocket and saunter up to my prone body.

"Why so serious, Valerian?" Flufflec simpered. "I think somebody needs a second smile."

I didn't waste time trying to get to my feet.

"Flying Thunder God Technique!"

Nothing happened.

Flufflec tsked disapprovingly. "I did say this area was sealed off. And now you're stuck with terrible last words."

The knife plunged unstoppably towards my throat.

-o-​

"…And that's how I single-handedly defeated Flufflec and his three killer missing-nin without a scratch on me, the tree thing notwithstanding."

My three housemates exchanged strange looks as I sank triumphantly into the sofa after a long journey home.

"Val," Earl said slowly, "are you sure you didn't get any kind of concussion from the tree thing?"

"Fairly, why?"

"You realise you haven't actually told us anything? You just came in, said, 'And that's how I single-handedly defeated Flufflec' et cetera, and then sat down as if that was the end of the conversation."

"Right," I agreed. "That was key to my plan."

Those strange looks didn't get any less strange.

"If I told you how I beat him in-update," I explained impatiently, "he'd be able to read it in advance like he read everything else that happened in our fight. Timeskipping the finale and the explanation was the only way to take him by surprise."

"It's worse than I thought," Earl said after a second. "Come on, Val, we're taking you to the hospital for a proper check-up."

"What are you talking about?" I demanded. I'd just had a very exhausting battle and a very exhausting journey back, and there was absolutely no way these three were dragging me all the way across Leaf. "I'm perfectly fine!"

"There is no need to waste Valerian-sensei's time with a hospital visit," Orochimaru agreed.

"Exactly! Listen to Orochimaru!"

"I have my scalpel and gag right here," Orochimaru went on as he reached into his labcoat. "We can begin the examination immediately."

In the end, I decided it was safest to stay overnight for observation.

-o-​

What do you do?

Voting ends on .
 
Last edited:
We have some more time to think this over, I'd rather give the plans more thought. For instance, I'd be happy with researching CATEARS or MARS, depending on which seems easier to Hazou

Also, great chapter! Super fun.
 
There's another way to defeat a foe with localized omniscience: it doesn't matter if they can make the perfect choice for any given decision if there is no route that leads to victory. All you need is enough overwhelming superiority that you can account for and neutralize every theoretical counter or escape route.

Easier said than done of course, so simply neutralizing the omniscience is far preferable when possible.

I wonder if the 'evil personality fighting for control' drawback is specifically Fufflec's burden, or if it's something shared by all player isekais? (which we can presume more of exist because, in all honesty, it would be extremely odd for only one player to come along for the ride).
 
There's another way to defeat a foe with localized omniscience: it doesn't matter if they can make the perfect choice for any given decision if there is no route that leads to victory. All you need is enough overwhelming superiority that you can account for and neutralize every theoretical counter or escape route.

Easier said than done of course, so simply neutralizing the omniscience is far preferable when possible.

I wonder if the 'evil personality fighting for control' drawback is specifically Fufflec's burden, or if it's something shared by all player isekais? (which we can presume more of exist because, in all honesty, it would be extremely odd for only one player to come along for the ride).
I think your obvious power would be the ability to control chakra beasts. :V
 
There's another way to defeat a foe with localized omniscience: it doesn't matter if they can make the perfect choice for any given decision if there is no route that leads to victory. All you need is enough overwhelming superiority that you can account for and neutralize every theoretical counter or escape route.
This is true, but it relies on you knowing the confrontation is coming, and having all your pieces in place, before they become aware of you, as otherwise they can simply utilise the greatest defence in the shinobi world and not turn up to the fight. And really, at the point where you're able to set up that level of overwhelming superiority completely without the enemy's knowledge, what power they have is irrelevant.
 
This is true, but it relies on you knowing the confrontation is coming, and having all your pieces in place, before they become aware of you, as otherwise they can simply utilise the greatest defence in the shinobi world and not turn up to the fight. And really, at the point where you're able to set up that level of overwhelming superiority completely without the enemy's knowledge, what power they have is irrelevant.
The Angel without Mercy says hello
 
Previous plan featured Snowglobe scenes, would rather reserve that for Vel

[X] Action Plan: Are Your Wits Wandering? Better Go Catch Them!
Word Count: 282
  • Mareo/Kumafuwafuwa (can be offscreened)
    • Leaf may have resources that could help Mareo's condition, if Hazou gets permission. He wanted to first verify if Mareo/Kumafuwafuwa want him to try.
  • Ino
    • Hazou had any Goketsu that was able learn YSJ, as Ino asked a while back.
    • As far as Hazou can tell, it works. Was there anything else Ino wanted him to try with YSJ?
    • Additionally, while YSJ is technically a Leaf jutsu now he wanted to ask permission to share.
      • Explain Mareo situation. Hazou wondered if YSJ could help keep Mareo focused.
    • If Ino agrees, have Kei pass a permission request/brief explanation to Asuma through the 7th Path.
  • Tsunade
    • Prep proposal with Mari/Noburi, ask Noburi to help pitch idea. Bring any interested civilians, especially any who read Tsunade's book.
    • Noburi informed Hazou the hospitals are more understaffed than usual, and there aren't enough medic ninja.
    • From GED, there's more literate Leaf civilians than ever. Goketsu wants to provide civilian nurses. They can't use medical ninjutsu, but they can identify symptoms like fever or dilated pupils, write reports for medical ninja, administer herbal treatment, and save doctors time. They can also socialize with bored patients stuck in bed.
    • They could shadow medic nin to learn before fully stepping into an assistant role. A few can teach a course at the GED once proficient.
    • The NFF has been spreading literacy outside Leaf. If the idea works, perhaps this system could be expanded nationally?
    • Aside: Explain Mareo situation. Is there any treatment Tsunade knows of to help?
  • Sealing (Offscreen)
    • Work on whichever of these Hazou thinks is easier:
      • MARS (Single ARS that triggers 2 seals)
      • CATEARS (Single ARS triggered by chakra adhesion)
 
Massive backlog of things I wanted to respond to! Entirely unrelated note, my semester ended yesterday.

Hazō has never felt responsible for his part in the Pangolin War," Kei said. "To him, his tally of innocent deaths runs in the mere dozens. He is in no position to imagine your feelings or mine after dooming thousands to death or to undying despair. Unlike you, I am unable to put numbers to the civilian casualties I am indirectly responsible for. On the other hand, I have a vague grasp of the size of the Condor Clan, and know that every one of its members is subject to the cultural genocide I have facilitated. Next to that, some mere civilian vessel is barely a scratch upon my soul."

"What are you saying?" Akane asked. For a second, Kei was afraid Akane would attempt to comfort her, which was the diametrical opposite of Kei's intent.

"You and I cannot escape our sins," Kei said. "Even if Hazō succeeds in flinging open the gates of Death, you cannot offer the resurrected the homes that you reduced to ash, nor restore the time they lost while this world left them behind."

Akane nodded. Her head did not come all the way back up.

I really like this. Kei offering not absolution, but acknowledgement of culpability. You can't improve yourself if you can't acknowledge what is, and is not, you're fault. And Hazou leaned too hard into the "you were just following orders" bit. Hazou might be the driver, but Kei and Akane are the moral compasses, even if they have VERY different thought processes and methodology.

Who are the people we are?" Akane interrupted. "I thought I was someone who'd never kill innocent people like that. I thought I could kill people for the good of Leaf, or to save my life, or to save my loved ones. I thought that was within the limits of the Will of Fire. But there were thousands. I killed more people than Leaf has ever had ninja. My life isn't worth that. My loved ones' lives aren't worth that. The good of Leaf isn't worth that, not when all those deaths barely make a difference to anything back home.

That's a rough truth. But Akane's belief in the will of fire and the belief of a righteous cause was always going to cause a travesty. It's just sad that it was one that large. And yeah, that was needless. I imagine that if Akane was in the room when Asuma insisted to Shikamaru that murdering a bunch of civilians for no strategic value was necessary, something might have broken then too.

"I can offer you nothing to solve your crisis of identity. My own remains an appalling mess despite concerted effort. However, if you are filled with regret and loathe the person you have become, there I am entirely on familiar ground."

1) Kei no.
2) Given her multiple new partners, the Snowglobe, the continued shift in nationality, repeated name change, and long-running imposter issues, and ongoing existential threats, I'd honestly say Kei is doing rather well at self-determination.
3) Kei no.

Hazō is mistaken if he believes absolution is possible for either of us. Nothing we do with our lives from here on out can change the past, and the balance sheet of karma to be calculated only at the end is a naïve delusion for those unwilling to take responsibility."

Akane gave something that could theoretically be described as a smile. "You really do have a unique way of cheering people up."

"At least I am good for something," Kei said wryly

A bit on a negative side, but I do appreciate the desire to not abdicate responsibility, and to update behavior sooner rather than usual. I meant to type later, but I think I'm going to just call this a enlightened autocorrection.

please correct me if I have misunderstood, since I recognise I have psychological insight to humble the most brilliant duck

I immediately started thinking of iconic ducks. Both Daffy and Donald aren't very self-aware, but Darkwing duck and the ones from the mighty ducks cartoon are decently insightful. So, insight to humble them would be great, if a bit fantastic.

says so."

"This," Kei exclaimed, raising a finger, "this is the essential part! Here is where I hold the advantage over you, as one who has hated herself for many years and was surprised by the scale of the atrocity caused by her irresponsibility, not the fact. Akane, this is not 'you now'. This is who you have always been. You are not a fallen paragon of morality, for your morality was always impossible, always waiting to run into a wall.

"The corollary I must convey to you is that all of your actions thus far have stemmed from this hypocritical, hollow self. Your love for Hazō and your choice to enter a relationship with him—twice, even, to our collective shock. Your dedication to Uplift. Your various passions, great and small. All of them belong to the same Akane who incinerates thousands of innocents at a word from her superiors, not to some ideal self that, you now learn, never existed."

Kei is certainly right about the wall part. And the grounding of Akane and tying the good to the bad as a means to not just rule them irrelevant is good. That's brutal in the phrasings, but not wrong. Also, quite the burn on Hazou, but that's fine and funny.

"So you're saying," Akane concluded, "that I shouldn't feel bad, because I have always been a terrible person."

"Not exactly," Kei said. "I can hardly recommend that you accept your flaws and love yourself in spite of them when I have never succeeded in that herculean task myself, and suspect strongly that the concept is a fiction intended to energise the ignorant for greater productivity. Rather, having accepted that you are Akane who incinerates thousands of innocents, and that this does not represent a reduction of your existing nature or capabilities, only your self-image, you are free to ask what else this Akane does.

"I cannot provide you with a moral impulse to guide your future actions, should you abandon Youth in all its forms. I am barely cognizant of the motivations behind my own. If you wish to join the KEI, or even to take more extreme steps, I have no authority with which to convince you otherwise. However, should you choose to continue to act as a Gōketsu and to work in the name of Uplift… rest assured that in this of all worlds, there can be no rules to prevent a mass murderer from doing so."

Crapsack world indeed. Would have liked a bit more of a focus on the "where do we go from here" from Kei, but given both her mentality and her general role in group dynamics, that is asking too much.

"I will be with you in your inner Swamp of Death, Akane, if you will have me. I will be there as you explore your pain, and master it, and someday integrate it into a new Akane that neither of us can yet imagine. We cannot escape our crimes. We cannot deny them if we wish to grow. However, there is no need for us to face them alone."

It was only hours later, after Akane left and Kei had spent sufficient time calming herself with export tax calculations, that she realised she had forgotten to take her signed copy of Enslaved by the Pirate King II: The Kraken Wakes from Akane, and that the possibility of it being discovered by her family was about to rise astronomically. Still, even as she scrolled through her mental catalogue of means of suicide, Kei decided that the meeting had been worth it.

That is really nice, and the sort of quality bonding I'm here for. Concerning catalogue notwithstanding.

...Yes we do? I very strongly remember Shikamaru needing to threaten to essentially dissolve the village to make her take us seriously enough to come babysit. It's not a matter of believing or not; it's a matter of her thinking "oh yeah there's no way he'll try and coerce you into doing this, and if he does it must be because you agreed to it like a fool"; she doesn't take the threat he poses to us seriously because of her own existing bias towards him, alongside the reputation he's cultivated with her. Assuming that she'll willingly come along to back us up on this seems like a poor assumption imo.

Edit: To clarify, she can believe that we think Oro is a threat, but that doesn't mean she will, nor does it mean that she will intervene on our behalf.

Meant to comment at the time, sorry. I will note that during that chapter, Tsunade seemed to have a couple of moments where she re-evaluated things based on new observations, or at least was actively disappointed in them as opposed to resigned and unsurprised. The fact that she was willing to actually assist with the matter, and it came to an aura clash, means it was at least worth her consideration.

PSA: Update delayed. Also, hiatus starts after it comes out.

I don't know a good way to say this, so I'll be blunt: @Velorien had what Brits and their stiff upper lips refer to as "a sudden and unexpected interaction with a delivery lorry" yesterday. His sweetheart was able to log into QM chat using his account in order to let me know what was going on, but he's going to be unavailable to write until medical technology improves substantially. I have his partial first draft for the update so I'll finish it and have it out probably tomorrow, maybe Sunday. After that, I'm afraid we're going on indefinite hiatus.

Now that enough time has passed for me to comment without being a buzzkill, I have to say I appreciated this April fools joke less than normal. Certainly, it is not on you to account for every reader's mental state. But, coming off a night shift (so I forgot the date had changed)(also working in healthcare, so bad news out of nowhere is pretty much the norm), and being really busy, I just saw the first paragraph, didn't have time or spoons to keep reading, then went about my day, honestly believing that happened. Credit to your writing, for starting off believable and gradually becoming more obviously joking as the post went. But due to days blurring together and not reading the full update, I actually thought Vel was gone and MfD was gone. Very glad when I went back and finished reading, but relief was only slightly higher than frustration at myself at that point.

Ino spends FP to invoke "Princess of the Boar Clan", "Mindwalker", and "Lover on an Untrodden Path".
Ino: Crimson Purification ?? + ? + ? + ? + ? = ??
Hazō spends 1 FP to invoke "Toughened Mind".
Hazō: Resolve 38 + 4 - 9 = 33
Hazō spends 1 FP to reroll.
Hazō: Resolve 38 + 4 + 3 = 45
Ino wins. Hazō takes 6 mental stress. He receives the Mild mental Consequence "Stunned" and the Medium mental Consequence "Scoured Brain".

Obviously this didn't happen (probably (maybe)), but I wonder if the tags are Ino's actual tags. "Lover on an Untrodden Path" in particular is very flattering, honestly. And would have been in that update if it wasn't Ino scouring our brain.

As Hazō headed out of the office, Shikamaru added, "Please convey my compliments to Ino for her selection of bribery material. I had no idea she was so aware of my tastes."

Hazō picked up the pace.

I do wonder how much that was a shot in the dark. I suppose it would depend on how much common ground on the literature Shika and Hazou shared previously. But having one of your best friends dating another good friend, who is sibling to your wife, would make it easy to see when and how information flows from one to another. It would also serve as a reminder how small Leaf and its dating pool is.

So, when the uncap system was originally introduced, it was a three-month free trial lasting up through the end of March. Now, after April Fools is over and we're not panicking about a stressful update, I'm ready to give my retrospective:
When the uncap system was announced, I was interested and tentatively optimistic. I agree with the motives for its inception, and as we saw with the wordcount penalties it's eminently possible to adjust the behaviour of the hivemind by changing the context of our decisions. This new system seemed poised to deliver that same benefit for our adventuring rates.

Unfortunately, the more I saw of the system, in discussions and in action, the more my optimism wore off. It comes with awkward edge cases, unpleasant side-effects, and isn't even all that good at what it's intended to do. Here following are the concerns I have with the current system:

1) Efficacy: The main thrust of the system is that, by forcing us to go out and do things to uncap our skills, we'll go out and have cool adventures on our own accord. The critical flaw, though, is that we are not always raising stats conducive to cool adventures. It would be one thing if we were pushing our Taijutsu or something else in our combat suite, but instead we're pushing Resolve and Sealing and we'll get around to Taijutsu... uh... eventually. The system doesn't not work, we're right now seeing incentive to go do a meaningful research project and uncap our Sealing, but as already mentioned Taijutsu is lying abandoned in a corner. Overall the uncap system is not very good at achieving its desired effects.

2) Edge cases: The premise of uncapping works out pretty well for our main stats. There's always another sealing project to do and another horrific monster to punch (sometimes in that order, in rapid succession), but there aren't many opportunities to use situational or low-level skills like Living Roots or Stealth. We may not have any intention of pursuing those stats right now, but the prospect of pursuing them does not sound simple or intuitive. If we wanted to level Cracking, we'd have to find a meaningful Cracking challenge for someone with level 4 Cracking, and then again at level 9, 14, and 19 before we can even begin to go up against anyone's Trapmaking for real. Finding these meaningful Cracking challenges would be... even if we knew where to look, it would feel horribly petty, wouldn't it? We'd be pursuing uncaps for the sake of uncaps, contriving a 'meaningful challenge' for skills we're not good at so that one day we might have an actually meaningful use for them. It's the awkwardness of fetch quests, just waiting to happen.

3) Side-effects: If a given uncap only affects the next division of five levels, the highest you can possibly move in one training plan is 9 levels. Bar any further elaborations or adjustments, all of which would increase the complexity of the uncap system, 'leapfrogging' stats across ABs becomes impossible. This implication was ratified by the QMs after some discussion of the topic with the hivemind. It's a reasonable decision, given the nature of uncaps, but it's still a bad aftertaste. Options for respeccing are already very limited, and leapfrogging was one of the critical tools for it in many of our build plans. Removing leapfrogging doesn't destroy respeccing, but it makes it much harder and makes many builds that much more calcified, which I find moderately dispreferrable.

Overall, the uncap system is not a failed system. The edge cases can theoretically be patched up as we run into them, and the loss of leapfrogging can just be the necessary price for the system to function. It doesn't stir us to action in quite the way it was supposed to, but we'll need to level Taijutsu eventually so it's not like it won't do anything. It's just... a lot of downsides, is all.

But a piece of advice I've seen from here is that while it's good to point out problems you see, it's better to also help solve them. So I was thinking about alternatives to the uncap system, and I think I have something:

Stagnancy, a mechanic which strongly encourages regular use of your main skills, whatever they happen to be.

The narrative side of it goes as such: A ninja who neglects their specializations, the skills which they forged in trials by fire, will naturally find themselves losing that 'edge', that something that kept them in top form. It takes more and more effort to simply avoid falling behind, cutting into the rest of their training time.

Mechanically, if a character goes an extended period of time without properly exercising the core skills of their build, they may receive a persistent 10% penalty to their XP rate, increasing in severity the longer the skills remain unused up to a 100% loss of all incoming XP. The penalty is removed/reduced when they go and use those skills in a meaningful way, until the next time they become so lax.

For someone like Hazou, his build is a mixture of Taijutsu-spec and Sealing-spec, so he is expected to engage in both those activities semi-regularly. If he goes a long time without doing any Sealing, he may begin to take an XP penalty until he does a proper sealing project. If he goes a long time without engaging in real combat, he may begin to take an XP penalty until he punches something in the face.

The exact duration 'a long time' represents is up to QM discretion, as is what roles a ninja's expected to stay active in. Given the trustworthiness of the QMs, I anticipate rigid and specific benchmarks would provide no meaningful advantage while bogging the whole thing down in nitty gritty. If y'all say Kei's gone too long without killing something with an exploding kunai, that's good enough for me.

For convenience's sake, it would be nice to have a short grace period before the penalty is properly applied. For example, at the end of an update the QM may state something like "Hazou thinks his Taijutsu is getting rusty. He wants to find some way to get some real practice in, before he starts slipping." and then we have a few updates to seek out a combat challenge to prevent the penalty from being applied in the first place. As with uncaps, NPCs can seek to avoid stagnancy penalties when possible, though if no opportunities are available they may still suffer one.

I believe this mechanic will do a better job of spurring us to do cool and interesting things than the uncap system, with fewer edge cases or side-effects. Firstly, stagnancy always pushes us to exercise what we're good at, meaning the challenges we seek out will always be level-appropriate and a good fit for our builds. Hazou will avoid stagnancy by doing sealing research and punching things, not by getting way out of his depth in social combat or doing Baby's First Lockpicking. Mari, by contrast, will avoid stagnancy by dancing social circles around people and weaving elaborate genjutsu rather than sneaking around unseen. This avoids the awkward edge cases of low-level or situational stats and should do a far better job of, frankly, getting Hazou off his butt and out there punching something.

Secondly, while it is true that stagnancy means we can level skills without actively using them, this is only up to a point: you can only level a stat so much before it becomes a focus of your build and you'll be expected to exercise it on the regular. Thus we allow characters to 'dabble' with as many skills as they like while organically ensuring the growth of our character is accompanied by appropriate feats: Hazou's social stats are not those of a career politician's, at least not yet, but if we choose to seriously push stats like Deceit and Presence so he can 1v1 people in the council room we'll soon find ourselves obligated to out-social people in the council room (or other similar activities), which to me sounds like a wonderful bonding of mechanics and narrative.

Overall, I expect the stagnancy system to be less bookkeeping than uncaps, less awkward than uncaps, and better than uncaps at changing the incentives of the hivemind in the direction of cool adventures that utilize the full potential of our characters. I imagine there are a variety of places where the system can be fine-tuned, but even as it is right now I strongly prefer it to the existing uncap system. What do you think?

I know it's already on QM docket for discussion, but I just wanted to express how much I love this suggestion, and appreciate the thoughtful deconstruction with goals to fix the issues.

Thing is… they're not like you'd expect at all. Like, one of the projects was about facial growths, and there was a ninja who died from using a disguise kit all day every day to hide his. I don't know why that'd kill him—maybe he used toxic paint or something. Anyway

I wonder what happened there. Henge gone wrong, or he just stayed in the form indefinitely. I'm always curious about the boundaries of the Grue, even as I fully acknowledge that the Grue eats, among other things, boundaries of its conception.

But now he thinks of them as worthless old junk that he's only kept because any proper researcher would rather drink a shot of acid than get rid of hard-earned data."

That's really sad that Oro has changed that much. Lingering attachment isn't a high bar, but it still isn't cleared. Maybe, MAYBE he's offering them to us specifically because of who we are, but giving away what's essentially a research journal with your now-dead once-best-friend? That certainly narrows down the possibility space of what Oro does and does not think about other people.

Also, I get that. I have notebooks, assignments, and a couple harder to find lab/text books I've held onto for years. Will I ever need them again? Probably not. Will I be overwhelming mad and disappointed and despondent if I do need them and I got rid of them? Absolutely. Is that worth transferring them over or moving with them half a dozen times? That depends on how much you like carrying boxes full of books constantly. If I had storage seals? No way, never giving them up without a compelling reason.

"Hazō," Noburi said patiently, "as a Leaf medic, I'm forbidden to help somebody off themselves without special dispensation from Tsunade. If you really want to die, go give Kei a passionate hug, tell Yuno you're planning to seduce me, or make Ami think you're threatening her sister's life. There. Quick, easy, no setup required. Also, why have you surrounded yourself with women who'll murder you at the drop of a hat?"

"I ask myself that every day," Hazō confessed.

Because Marked for Death is, at its core, a Romantic Comedy, and possible murder is less of a contrived plot point that most.

Also, let us never tell Noburi that we've actually held hands with Kei AND Snowflake. He must never know.

Also, nothing to do about it right now, but it really sheds light on the fact that were slipping below our peers for combat power. Seals are a force multiplier, but we need things to multiply. I think I did an analysis on the Last Will of fire mission where we saw Hazou is 10 stat points behind Akane in all their relevant stats, which is half a rank tier. Keiko I know is also ahead of him right now. The guys in this family are really slacking.

(I'm cautiously optimistic to see the results of the Akamichi training technique for Noburi. I don't want him to get left behind the way it feels like Hazou is right now.)


"The Gōketsu are all kinds of broken, aren't we?" Noburi asked. "If this was an RPG, I'd ban the lot of us."

Fourth wall breaking, warning, and self-depreciation all in one? Truly, the best hat trick.

Noburi hesitated.

"I don't know, Hazō. I suddenly have this vision in my head of you deciding that medicine is the bee's knees—which it totally is—and throwing yourself into it headfirst like you did with sealing, and the next thing I know, you're Hazō the Master Surgeon, and I'm just…"

Aww, buddy. That's really sad. Looks like the inferiority complex is still there. But I'm proud of him for being able to verbalize it. The fact that Iron Nerve would make Hazou good as a surgeon is neither here nor there.

"By the way," Hazō said as Noburi began to sink back into the sofa, "while we're on the subject of medicine, there's actually been something on my mind for a while."

"Don't bother, Hazō," Noburi replied instantly. "They're all folk remedies, and none of them have been proved to work. If you want to stop disappointing your girlfriends, get Mari to teach you some of the Twelve Great Ninjutsu of the Bedchamber or something."

... Okay, now I'm really curious what Ninjutsu are on the list. If we ever see Mari's character sheet, I will be VERY disappointed if these aren't on there.

Then again, at least marriage hasn't stopped her from getting cute girls. Like, even if people don't know about Yuno, they hear that I'm married and way they look at me changes instantly. There's this one really hot Nara surgeon at the hospital and when we were getting busy—"

Hazō's spine turned into ice colder than anything the Yuki Clan could dream of as his missing-nin senses screamed at him. He opened his mouth in warning, but no words came out.

"Go on, my little tapir. Tell me everything about this hot Nara surgeon you were getting busy with."

RIP Noburi. Year [I can't be bothered to check] to [right now]. He's survived by his wife, who murdered him.

The fact that Kei gets More cute girls since got married is honestly impressive, though not unheard of based on polycules I've seen/have become a part of.

Actually, we're doing okay right now," Hazō said. "The money that Orochimaru gave us let us pay off all our debts and left us with about six months of operating expenses at current consumption even if we had no other income. The various things we've got going on will keep us stable, so that six month cushion is actually available for investment. Kumokōgō is fine to let us take the castoff silk from broken webs and so on, and the Meiori are champing at the bit to get their hands on it. We'll see if the stuff works for them, and if it doesn't then I'll negotiate for some bespoke spinning from the spiders."

Woot. Much as I love marked for economics, I love not being poor more. And wow, no more debt to anyone and a money cushion, as part of a deal for one item? That's so good. Amazing even. Good thing we didn't almost ruin it.

Hazō grimaced. "It's a little hairy. After we killed that Dragon the others went on a rampage for a few days. They razed every structure across ten or twenty percent of Arachnid Territory. Something like ten thousand people died. Plus, the Dragons attacked the surrounding ocean territories. We have no idea how many sharks, kraken, and crustaceans died."

"Ouch."

"Yeah. Afterwards they went back to the butte and seem to be asleep again. Or, at least, they aren't making sorties."

"How do they fit up there, anyway? Isn't it, like, fifty or a hundred yards across? I thought you said that the Dragon you killed was hundreds of feet long, but somehow six of them were camping out there?"

Hazō shrugged. "No idea. Regardless, Kumokōgō said that she can't afford losses like that. We need to come up with some way to kill all the remaining Dragons in one shot before she's willing to move again."

20%? That's massive, absolutely massive. And if they get more powerful after consuming denizens... The next kill will not be that easy, I think.

Too bad Kisame can't get in touch and give us estimates on that. But, tens of thousands of deaths. Hazou doesn't seem to feel much responsibility for that. Now I'm honestly wondering the fallout if we did manage to kill another one. I can't imagine it would be fun. Spiders seem nice, and I really don't want Kagome to sign a contract with only, like, 5 spiders left.

"I figure that's about how long it will take me to learn Earth Element. Then I can build the roads myself and we don't have to pay people to do it. Also, because I can be out there alone or with just Gōketsu, I can use mist drain to refill myself and simultaneously kill off the local wildlife." He stood up and brushed invisible lint off his clothes. "I'm in, boss. Let me know when and where you need me. In the meantime, I need to go find an Earth Element teacher, so if there's nothing else...?"

That's a really going point, Noburi would just be a walking road paver at that point.

What makes one an instructor in an element? At what point could Noburi start teaching someone to use the water element? Also, a PEA and Hozuki's mantle Noburi would be an absolute Monster in CQC. Huge Chakra costs, but that's something he can do. Armor up, summon a couple ranged attack toads, and stack buffs while gradually forming his own area denial to the opponent.

Also, this is why Noburi is great. Sees a cool project that will help people, and not only is he on board, he's proactive about doing his best to make it better.

Worse, he'd underestimated how many seals he'd need. If he was going to finish the job, he'd have to make more here and now, with no time to double-check his work.

I'm sorry, there's no way that any version of an entity that became Kagome didn't have enough. Though I guess the act of not having enough in a critical mission is a good catalyst to change behavior to the overly cautious.

Kagami Yūsuke: Deception 1 - 12 = -11

?????????????????????:????????????????????

I'm sorry, did he accidentally just cause a stack overflow or error message in the universe? I'm going to properly respect that by not trying to weaponize it.

High Watcher Kuge Maya accepted her fate with grace as the panicking sealmaster slammed his seal down on the table and triggered a deliberate sealing failure…

Watchers do exist! Did exist. May have existed in one reality... Wonder what caused the guy to panic that much?

Kagami Yūsuke: ninja cold war as hideous monsters slowly whittle away the meager scraps left of humanity. The usual

"The usual" is right, but oof, you went right for the heart on that one, didn't you.

Orgy-induced heart attack," Hazō said, straight-faced. "I've arranged to have several attractive twenty-something female Summoners come by and pleasure you until your heart explodes."

"Hah!" This time Mareo bopped him on the thigh with the handle of his cane. "An excellent plan! I approve of this plan wholeheartedly! Tell 'em to bring some decent brandy with 'em, too. If my heart doesn't go, maybe they can get my liver."

Wouldn't be the first person I've met that wants to do this way. Somewhere out there, Mari just got goosebumps, and sneezed. Though, would be a shame when all those attractive summoners are mauled by the Bear.

Oh, Mareo, please go scout out this filthy cave that we found that leads deep into the earth and has some kind of horrific doom fortress thing in it!"

1) IIIINTERESTING. I wonder if it's still there.
2) Lots of doom fortresses in the updates recently. Is this the QM way of saying we need to create another fortress of doom?

It sounds like they're both very good at getting away and maintaining a secretive cover, yet they freely let survivors go to, and I quote, 'spread the terror of the Lord of Despair, Jashin, who comes to claim the lives of man'.

Yes, I know this is LotRoL. Just highlighting that the influence of Jashin is spreading across the multiverse.

Oli and I winced, while Orochimaru nodded as if Earl had said, "It's likely to rain tomorrow" or "A lunatic like Hidan would never use his powers to help set up world peace"

Knowingly, at least. Not that I think moon eye makes any sense. But I can't wait for MfD Hidan to do this... Until the exact moment when defection causes optimal death.

That said, if it really is an invitation… there can only be one flufflec.response."

That's just SUCH a good line. You've been really saving these jokes up, eh?

Substitution Tech—"

Oh, crap.

Forget convenient boulders or the classic log, the area around me was bereft of so much as a stray pebble. I made a mental note to avoid, in my next life, walking into ambushes set by people with a brain.

I went straight to Plan B.

Surprised that didn't skip you down to plan F. And gosh ambushes are powerful. No wonder swift and decisive strikes are the preferred MO.

Nor did he react as a super-fast projectile possibly made from part of my finger (Kishimoto was unaware of the concept of biomass) began to zoom towards him.

Kishimoto is unaware of a LOT of things. 75% of what he wrote previously is on that list as well I think.

—at higher levels, the scaling on some of these techniques broke down harder than Sasuke's characterisation between the original and Shippūden

I audibly started cackling at that, much to the confusion of my partner at work today. Shippuden Sasuke really just is a mess of a plot pawn, isn't he.

So of course Flufflec sidestepped very slightly, and, lacking the ninja reflexes for course correction, I ploughed face-first into the tree behind him.

"Witness the power… of the Uchiha…" I slurred as I learned firsthand why ninja wore forehead protectors.

Breathed in water at this one, well done. And I really want to meet a ninja who uses a custom forehead protector for a Righteous Headbutting Style.

"If I told you how I beat him in-update," I explained impatiently, "he'd be able to read it in advance like he read everything else that happened in our fight. Timeskipping the finale and the explanation was the only way to take him by surprise."

Love it. Really reminds me of a series I've seen, but I can't for the love of me remember which one.

There's another way to defeat a foe with localized omniscience: it doesn't matter if they can make the perfect choice for any given decision if there is no route that leads to victory. All you need is enough overwhelming superiority that you can account for and neutralize every theoretical counter or escape route.

Easier said than done of course, so simply neutralizing the omniscience is far preferable when possible.

I wonder if the 'evil personality fighting for control' drawback is specifically Fufflec's burden, or if it's something shared by all player isekais? (which we can presume more of exist because, in all honesty, it would be extremely odd for only one player to come along for the ride).

Are you perhaps familiar with Worm's Contessa? "There is no path to victory" just gave me flashbacks.

Also, assuming more players are Isekaied, you're Very high up on list of people to be. Which, given your avatar, is going to cause Issues. I can't wait.
 
Obviously this didn't happen (probably (maybe)), but I wonder if the tags are Ino's actual tags. "Lover on an Untrodden Path" in particular is very flattering, honestly. And would have been in that update if it wasn't Ino scouring our brain.

Ino is doing a very brave and scary thing, risking emotional vulnerability by dating Hazou. I'm proud of her. She's not used to this level of weakness, and it's terrifying, but she's going through with it anyway because she isn't going to let fear control what she wants. Good on her, honestly.

It would also serve as a reminder how small Leaf and its dating pool is.

Yeah, Ami and Ino both have despaired at the quality of Leaf's dating pool. A little amusing to see that they both agree on this, considering the distain Ami exhibited towards Ino (when Ami learned we were dating Ino).

Also, let us never tell Noburi that we've actually held hands with Kei AND Snowflake. He must never know.

Given Kei's habitual secrecy and strict preference towards privacy, it's far more likely that we're Kei's dirty little secret, rather than the other way around.

And Snowflake? Well, Snowflake might not even bother to hide it. >:3
 
Also, nothing to do about it right now, but it really sheds light on the fact that were slipping below our peers for combat power. Seals are a force multiplier, but we need things to multiply. I think I did an analysis on the Last Will of fire mission where we saw Hazou is 10 stat points behind Akane in all their relevant stats, which is half a rank tier. Keiko I know is also ahead of him right now. The guys in this family are really slacking.
Seals are force multipliers. It's just that we're also giving them to the rest of the Goketsu, so they get all the benefit of sealing without having to spend a single xp point in it.

What makes one an instructor in an element? At what point could Noburi start teaching someone to use the water element?
We don't need instructors thanks to Jiraiya's notes on the elements.
 
Back
Top