I think there are a lot of assumptions there. I can't recall attitudes to sex work coming up much in the quest. I'm not sure you know any of the Gōketsu's attitudes to it except (obviously) Hazō's and possibly Mari's, and while Hazō's made his stance on LGBT equality public, he's never spoken out about sex work or its role in relation to Uplift.
Good point. I think the only mentions have been the Granny with the Sexy Laundry (who thought about walking into the wild, to be eaten by Chakra beasts, back during the famine, to save food for younger mouths), and Ami when she said that even the "ladies of the night" didn't have to sell their hearts away.
 
I guess I'm a little worried about that. But overall a responsive plan maker is good, especially when votes are this divisive. You mentioned a plan that people won't vote on anyway which is the important part. we should make sure the Changes actually successfully wins new voters

Didn't realize lithosealing was originally in, which confuses me more why it was removed. But I really don't want to lose mutants vote now, and I haven't heard anyone saying their vote is dependent on lithosealing. Hopefully mutant can explain reasoning and we can persuade
@Ishtar did just that right now and just voted to reject due to it. Honestly no lithosealing is kinda a deal breaker to me too, as I don't consider the plan likely to be viable if we don't do shock and awe to convince Itachi of our value first. But there is literally no other alternative to vote on right now, except for "Reject Akatsuki, continue Clan Politics" which I disagree with vehemently.
 
Last edited:
@Ishtar can you confirm more explicitly that if we add iron nerve, to the best of your knowledge you think you would vote for buggy's plan?
If so, then yeah I think we should put it back in. Since one person strongly opposed, one person strongly agrees, and the rest generally want it as well

Edit: oh wait I'm mixing up iron nerve and litho
i dunno how to rephrase things but I think you get the general idea
 
Last edited:
[X] Action Plan: Politely Decline

Yeah if I was gonna vote acceptance I'd want it strong, explicitly mention iron-nerve, probably leak lithosealing, anything to make the play during this conversation.
Okay, if i go back to explicitly mentioning iron-nerve, would you support it again? If i mention Lithosealing outright, then Mutant won't support it.

@Left-Hand Mutant, would you support that still? Iron Nerve and not Lithosealing?
 
I can stake my vote in the minimum of iron-nerve, and I'll offer de-voting for No and Politely decline if it ends up going hard and includes lithosealing.

[X] Action Plan: Not Actually a Fleshed Out Action Plan

Voting in faith that the minimum change will be made. @Buggy
 
I think talking about karanium or Enma is premature. We need to convince itachi of the threat first. But if it'll get the bomb vote I'm for it.
 
I think talking about karanium or Enma is premature. We need to convince itachi of the threat first. But if it'll get the bomb vote I'm for it.
My impression from reading the chapter is he is already convinced as to the Dragons being an apocalyptic danger, no? He just doesn't think our value to the Dragonwar is really that high, because we appear to be little more than a Jounin Sealmaster to him right now, and he believes that we have made no progress despite working on the Rift for so long because we did not share 3D Sealing which Hazou explicitly points out in internal monologue would convince him otherwise.
 
My gut feeling is that he also isn't truly treating the dragon war as an existential threat. Especially when he says he disagrees with our priorities.

Edit:
Like even asuma who was supporting us from the start. Didn't go all in till he saw the dragons himself
 
I can stake my vote in the minimum of iron-nerve, and I'll offer de-voting for No and Politely decline if it ends up going hard and includes lithosealing.
Done.



And would anyone else oppose if we mentioned lithosealing? Would anyone agree? It would be a equal exchange of votes at this point, and I think revealing it would really help with convincing Itachi and slam-dunking this plan.
 
And would anyone else oppose if we mentioned lithosealing? Would anyone agree? It would be a equal exchange of votes at this point, and I think revealing it would really help with convincing Itachi and slam-dunking this plan.
You know my stance on the topic... I hesitate to outright remove my support just because its not in there, but its a very heavy preference and I believe it would massively help the plan if it were there, and it seems like Ishtar at least would disavow the rejecting plans if it were added back in, so it'd be an exchange of votes at worst. Plus at this rate the plan needs changing into something more appealing to pull in more votes anyway, since at status quo we seem unlikely to end up winning, from looking at the votes over the past 12h.
 
Last edited:
I stated that I wanted lithosealing before. Something that I might not have stated is the degree. I moderately support it, specifically hazou saying that he thinks he was ready and prepared to make a litho seal. The only reason it's not heavy support is that itachi will have doubts on if hazou is just being arrogant. But itachi is not a sealmaster even if he is close with one, so hazou can use that on him
 
Okay, someone on discord suggested something like the following:

We start by opening with "we've rediscovered a powerful sealing art that can help". We use this to convince Itachi to invite Ami to the discussion.
If we manage to invite Ami, then we reveal Lithosealing in full to her (and also Itachi, who is standing right there), and work with her to optimize us going with Akatsuki (and also, not getting nabbed by Itachi for Lithosealing).
 
Last edited:
Noted. I've readded it, but as the third plan to mention. Hopefully this means that it won't weaken our prior two arguments like someone was concerned about (if Itachi likes one of them, we may stop there instead of going to the other ideas). The risk is that we run out of Itachi's patience and he doesn't let us finish.

Hmm I'm tentatively leaving my vote, but I honestly believe it's our strongest plan to give to him.

1. It costs Akatsuki nothing. The other plans ask for a lot of concessions.
2. It involves less people
3. It builds off what's already there and what's already happening. He's currently threatening Leaf and getting a deal. Tacking on "oh and Goketsu come with us" is far, far easier than everything else we're suggesting.

I'm also not as big a fan of the other two plans, as getting AMITY involved in necromancy is probably a bad idea and Tsunade is unlikely to want to work with Akatsuki given they killed Jiraiya, she fought them, and they just killed Asuma her predecessor (forcing her to be Hokage), AND are currently bending her over a barrel for it.
 
Added this section in modified form, although I'm a little concerned that Tsunade will be pissed if we're tardy. I'll remove it if other people object
I strongly oppose this change. Kagome can take inventory of the notes, but only Hazo can debrief the Hokage. With Shadow clone disabled, we have to be seen clearly prioritizing loyalty to Leaf above licking our own wounds.

The last plan that sent Hazo to the lab instead of into Leaf to denounce Jashin (and Akatsuki) was disastrous. We should not make the same mistake again.

(Also, unrelated to the above objection, I think that the line "optimize debrief with Tsunade" during the pre-meeting meeting is functionally meaningless without a goal that you are asking the team to optimize towards. But that's a bigger issue I have with MfD plan making in general.)

(My suggested line would be something like
+ Rehearse the report Hazo will give, optimizing the script to maximize political effect of demonstrated loyalty to Leaf
++ Do not attend if Goketsu advisors think Hazo will be accused of framing Asuma)
 
Last edited:
Hmm I'm tentatively leaving my vote, but I honestly believe it's our strongest plan to give to him.
The main issue I see with it is, the first two are cooperative, and this one is antagonistic. I think leading with the antagonistic could run counter to the first two attempts at cooperation, and the third one is like 'alright, fine. Why don't you just demand it'. I... think that works better in a conversation? The other issue is, it would pretty much be a fig-leaf for exfiltration, because we're already under suspicious for murdering Asuma. It might not be enough of a option to prevent negative consequences.

Hopefully Itachi doesn't discount the idea because after two others which he (presumably) found unworkable.


edit: alright, someone else chimed in and also asked for this. I'm moving it back to first, and i've also reworded it a bit to make it more clear to Itachi that this is the straightforward option which costs him nothing.
 
Last edited:
The main issue I see with it is, the first two are cooperative, and this one is antagonistic. I think leading with the antagonistic could run counter to the first two attempts at cooperation, and the third one is like 'alright, fine. Why don't you just demand it'. I... think that works better in a conversation? The other issue is, it would pretty much be a fig-leaf for exfiltration, because we're already under suspicious for murdering Asuma. It might not be enough of a option to prevent negative consequences.

I get it...I just don't like the other two plans as much and I don't think he will either. And the issue is he's an essie and we have limited word space with an essie. Maybe have it so we bring up that plan if he seems to be getting annoyed or disinterested.

Because remember, this is directly off the back of last update, where he basically told us we come and abandon everyone or else, and we're now suggesting he work with our village and AMITY, with 0 leverage.
 
I get it...I just don't like the other two plans as much and I don't think he will either. And the issue is he's an essie and we have limited word space with an essie. Maybe have it so we bring up that plan if he seems to be getting annoyed or disinterested.

Because remember, this is directly off the back of last update, where he basically told us we come and abandon everyone or else, and we're now suggesting he work with our village and AMITY, with 0 leverage.
I decided to put it back in front anway. I agree with that reasoning, I just hope it doesn't weaken any of the other pitches.
 
I decided to put it back in front anway. I agree with that reasoning, I just hope it doesn't weaken any of the other pitches.
Maybe frame it as revisiting the previous discussion, now that hazou has shown his importance to the dragon war thereby refuting itachi earlier objections? The demand idea is similar to what hazou previously said about akatsuki hiring hazou, so that framing shows that hazou was actually listening to what itachi said and thought about it

Edit: revisiting with modification framing I should say. Modification being demand instead of hire
 
Last edited:
I strongly oppose this change. Kagome can take inventory of the notes, but only Hazo can debrief the Hokage. With Shadow clone disabled, we have to be seen clearly prioritizing loyalty to Leaf above licking our own wounds.
To be clear my plan has Hazō taking inventory of the notes only after debriefing Tsunade.

The last plan that sent Hazo to the lab instead of into Leaf to denounce Jashin (and Akatsuki) was disastrous. We should not make the same mistake again.

(Also, unrelated to the above objection, I think that the line "optimize debrief with Tsunade" during the pre-meeting meeting is functionally meaningless without a goal that you are asking the team to optimize towards. But that's a bigger issue I have with MfD plan making in general.)

(My suggested line would be something like
+ Rehearse the report Hazo will give, optimizing the script to maximize political effect of demonstrated loyalty to Leaf
Yeah, I'm increasingly thinking he shouldn't delay at all. Tardiness will not look good, and Tsunade will be able to tell if his words are rehearsed.
 
Maybe frame it as revisiting the previous discussion, now that hazou has shown his importance to the dragon war thereby refuting itachi earlier objections? The demand idea is similar to what hazou previously said about akatsuki hiring hazou, so that framing shows that hazou was actually listening to what itachi said and thought about it

Edit: revisiting with modification framing I should say. Modification being demand instead of hire
I like that idea, and you raise a good point that this is similar enough to the prior discussion that it risks 'were you even listening' from Itachi. So, establish our credentials, and then try to re-open the discussion on the basis of "now that you see that Leaf wouldn't killbox me without good reason..."?
 
[X] Action Plan: I Am Once Again Asking For Your Diplomatic Support

Is this my favored plan? Absolutely not.
Am I tactically voting for this because I don't want to join Akatsuki, and the vote is close? Yes!

EDIT:
[X] Action Plan: Politely Decline
 
Last edited:
[X] Action Plan: Not Actually a Fleshed Out Action Plan
[X] Action Plan: Not Actually a Fleshed Out Action Plan - Lithosealing Edition
[X] Action Plan: Go All In With Two Fours
[X] Action Plan: Doing What is Actually Required to Win
 
Re arranging a parley with Enma... doesn't Itachi just have to send a crow to the Conclave and then show up?
It's more about letting Itachi appreciate just how terrible the dragon war is by talking to Enma. It's more clear from my original quote.

Karanium is the crow boss who gave the Karasu lore that let them make anti-dragon sealtech.
 
Back
Top