The grief shower was suppose to take longer. The writing however only implied that it took a few minutes.

I figured most of that time was spent actually taking that shower.
Sabrina seemed to find the sonic shower rather disturbing.
... yep, that was pretty good for two minutes in the shower.
I think I can pinpoint the exact moment we got lost in thought creating the thing:
You sigh, and straighten in the chair.

You gesture with both hands, sweeping them inwards from your sides, and some of the Grief you've been lugging around all day pours in, dozens of spheres gravitating in to a common center. They smack into each other, moulding into one larger blob, and a moment of concentration and focus warps the entire structure into a clear glass cylinder with some vaguely high tech fittings.
This bit of text took almost half an hour.
 
Last edited:
so how long can sabrina lose herself for without realizing it?

we know the average is 30 minutes, but can we shorten it? Extend it? Develop something with magic not grief to help us notice and not lose ourselves?

we must answer these questions before seriously going into grief constructs or familiars
 
OK, I have an interesting hypothesis now: Sabrina loses time whenever she uses Grief to produce a region of space operating under alternate physics. Consider several ways of accomplishing the shower:
  1. Shower emits water. Shower is a Grief construct that requires no physics breaking or magic on the part of itself or its user.
  2. Shower emits high-power femtosecond-pulsed holography to selectively ablate grime throughout the entire 3D volume. Shower is a Grief construct that has no physical principle of operation, instead using magic. However, the action (a pulse of coherent light, modulated to interfere constructively in specific voxels) is completely physical, so the reality-warping is confined to the Grief itself.
  3. Shower fills with water and emits high-intensity ultrasonic waves, inducing cavitation. The resulting field of tiny water jets produce a thorough scrubbing action. This is a common parts-cleaning process and requires no physics-breaking, like 1.
  4. Shower fills with air and does sonic stuff. Cavitation is impossible since the medium is a gas. Removing contaminants as in 3 without scorching the user is impossible in principle. Absent specification of a physical mechanism, the shower will apply some sort of reality-warping to function as a "sonic shower". Shower requires its own reality-warping powers, available to apply to arbitrary objects without Sabrina's input.
1-3 are hypotheticals to illustrate my point: I think the shower came out as an Artifact that applies conceptual properties to other objects. The Barrier was a pocket of space with arbitrary physics under your control. I suspect it is that kind of task that causes Sabrina to trance out.

In other news, if my hypothesis is correct, either you've actually made two Barriers, or the shower counts as a familiar (capable of independent reality-warping).
 
so how long can sabrina lose herself for without realizing it?

we know the average is 30 minutes, but can we shorten it? Extend it? Develop something with magic not grief to help us notice and not lose ourselves?

we must answer these questions before seriously going into grief constructs or familiars
30 minutes is not the average, it's the longest any Grief creation has taken us so far.

Well, it doesn't use water.

The barrier itself didn't seem to take long at all to make; it's the stuff inside, which might or might not be optional; the Grief Shower and other Grief objects are the same kind of stuff we filled the Barrier with.
 
OK, I have an interesting hypothesis now: Sabrina loses time whenever she uses Grief to produce a region of space operating under alternate physics. Consider several ways of accomplishing the shower:
  1. Shower emits water. Shower is a Grief construct that requires no physics breaking or magic on the part of itself or its user.
  2. Shower emits high-power femtosecond-pulsed holography to selectively ablate grime throughout the entire 3D volume. Shower is a Grief construct that has no physical principle of operation, instead using magic. However, the action (a pulse of coherent light, modulated to interfere constructively in specific voxels) is completely physical, so the reality-warping is confined to the Grief itself.
  3. Shower fills with water and emits high-intensity ultrasonic waves, inducing cavitation. The resulting field of tiny water jets produce a thorough scrubbing action. This is a common parts-cleaning process and requires no physics-breaking, like 1.
  4. Shower fills with air and does sonic stuff. Cavitation is impossible since the medium is a gas. Removing contaminants as in 3 without scorching the user is impossible in principle. Absent specification of a physical mechanism, the shower will apply some sort of reality-warping to function as a "sonic shower". Shower requires its own reality-warping powers, available to apply to arbitrary objects without Sabrina's input.
1-3 are hypotheticals to illustrate my point: I think the shower came out as an Artifact that applies conceptual properties to other objects. The Barrier was a pocket of space with arbitrary physics under your control. I suspect it is that kind of task that causes Sabrina to trance out.

In other news, if my hypothesis is correct, either you've actually made two Barriers, or the shower counts as a familiar (capable of independent reality-warping).

'...Your familiar is a SHOWER!?!'

'What can I say, I like being clean.'



Kriemhild Gretchen Madoka to Dedolere Sabrina
 
EDIT: I got confused.

A thought:

It might be possible to make Grief objects that don't trigger our friends' anti-Witch instincts.

Why? Because we've already made a Grief object that doesn't trigger a specific meguca's Witch senses:

Well, a little less time than you'd expected for experimenting, then, you muse as you step back into the Barrier.

Interestingly, you don't feel the same... nauseating sense of wrongness a normal Witch Barrier gives you. Probably because it's your Barrier. You somehow doubt that that'd be the case for your fellow puella magi, though.

... your fellow puella magi, yes. You're... you're still pretty sure you're not a Witch. You think.

You hope.

The Barrier itself. While normal Grief objects trigger Sabrina's senses as well as anybody else's, this one doesn't affect Sabrina that way.

It might be possible to learn to attune specific Grief objects to specific megucas, allowing us to use Grief stuff in everyday life, so long as we don't need to see anybody magical outside our normal circle of friends.

Of note, the reason the Barrier didn't affect Sabrina's senses might be in how she made it; she didn't simply will it up, but focused on how she had analyzed another Barrier worked beforehand. Of course, it might just be a conceptual thing, but I figure it can be done.
 
Last edited:
The thing is, IIRC, our own stuff does ping our Witch senses, but it doesn't feel "wrong" to us like normal Witch stuff does when it is ours, likely because if is ours.

I don't think the barrier was any different in that regard.
 
A thought:

It might be possible to make Grief objects that don't trigger our friends' anti-Witch instincts.

Why? Because we've already made a Grief object that doesn't trigger a specific meguca's Witch senses:



The Barrier itself. While normal Grief objects trigger Sabrina's senses as well as anybody else's, this one doesn't affect Sabrina that way.

It might be possible to learn to attune specific Grief objects to specific megucas, allowing us to use Grief stuff in everyday life, so long as we don't need to see anybody magical outside our normal circle of friends.

Of note, the reason the Barrier didn't affect Sabrina's senses might be in how she made it; she didn't simply will it up, but focused on how she had analyzed another Barrier worked beforehand. Of course, it might just be a conceptual thing, but I figure it can be done.
probably need to focus a day or two on it when we have the chance. maybe see another barrier as well.
 
The thing is, IIRC, our own stuff does ping our Witch senses, but it doesn't feel "wrong" to us like normal Witch stuff does when it is ours, likely because if is ours.

I don't think the barrier was any different in that regard.
Checking, I guess that's right.

The Witchy feeling and the 'Wrong' feeling are different things.
 
The witchy feeling is "This is Grief."
The 'wrong' feeling is "This is Grief, but it's not mine, even though I wished to control all Grief! Error! Paradox!"

It's 'wrong' to us the same way witches are 'wrong' to Godoka.
 
OK, I have an interesting hypothesis now: Sabrina loses time whenever she uses Grief to produce a region of space operating under alternate physics. Consider several ways of accomplishing the shower:
  1. Shower emits water. Shower is a Grief construct that requires no physics breaking or magic on the part of itself or its user.
  2. Shower emits high-power femtosecond-pulsed holography to selectively ablate grime throughout the entire 3D volume. Shower is a Grief construct that has no physical principle of operation, instead using magic. However, the action (a pulse of coherent light, modulated to interfere constructively in specific voxels) is completely physical, so the reality-warping is confined to the Grief itself.
  3. Shower fills with water and emits high-intensity ultrasonic waves, inducing cavitation. The resulting field of tiny water jets produce a thorough scrubbing action. This is a common parts-cleaning process and requires no physics-breaking, like 1.
  4. Shower fills with air and does sonic stuff. Cavitation is impossible since the medium is a gas. Removing contaminants as in 3 without scorching the user is impossible in principle. Absent specification of a physical mechanism, the shower will apply some sort of reality-warping to function as a "sonic shower". Shower requires its own reality-warping powers, available to apply to arbitrary objects without Sabrina's input.
1-3 are hypotheticals to illustrate my point: I think the shower came out as an Artifact that applies conceptual properties to other objects. The Barrier was a pocket of space with arbitrary physics under your control. I suspect it is that kind of task that causes Sabrina to trance out.

In other news, if my hypothesis is correct, either you've actually made two Barriers, or the shower counts as a familiar (capable of independent reality-warping).

As stated, the shower and barrir aren't the only times we've lost time. Fir has indicated we've lost time every time we've made any grief construct (barring the wings and musical instruments?)
 
A sliding scale of Witchiness
The witchy feeling is "This is Grief."
The 'wrong' feeling is "This is Grief, but it's not mine, even though I wished to control all Grief! Error! Paradox!"

It's 'wrong' to us the same way witches are 'wrong' to Godoka.
  Sabrina's reaction Other meguca's reactions
Solid/Inert Grief
Eg. Grief marbles
Grief spheres
Mobile Oppression Fortress
Nanofog
Meh. Grief is Grief is Grief OK, there's something there, but not really sure what it is...
Gaseous/Raw/Energetic Grief
Eg. Fresh from Soul Gem
Wings
Enchanted but not specifically active Grief as per [1]
OK, that feels kinda but not quite Witchy...
Enchanted Grief
Eg.Enchanted Grief Chibi[1]
Witch? Kind of weak...
Active Grief
Eg. MECHA GURREN ZILLA LAGAAN
Witch! There's a Witch!
Sabrina's Barrier WIIIIIIITCH
Grief under Witch control Bad wrong no bad WIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITCH
 
Last edited:
  Sabrina's reaction Other meguca's reactions
Solid Grief
Eg. Grief marbles
Grief spheres
Mobile Opression Fortress
Meh. Grief is Grief is Grief OK, there's something there, but not really sure what it is...
Gaseous Grief
Eg. Fresh from Soul Gem
Wings
OK, that feels kinda but not quite Witchy...
Active Grief
Eg. MECHA GURREN ZILLA LAGAAN
Witch! There's a Witch!
Sabrina's Barrier WIIIIIIITCH
Grief under Witch control Bad wrong no bad WIIIIIIIIITCH
will this be put in the front page with the others?
 
  Sabrina's reaction Other meguca's reactions
Solid Grief
Eg. Grief marbles
Grief spheres
Mobile Opression Fortress
Meh. Grief is Grief is Grief OK, there's something there, but not really sure what it is...
Gaseous Grief
Eg. Fresh from Soul Gem
Wings
OK, that feels kinda but not quite Witchy...
Active Grief
Eg. MECHA GURREN ZILLA LAGAAN
Witch! There's a Witch!
Sabrina's Barrier WIIIIIIITCH
Grief under Witch control Bad wrong no bad WIIIIIIIIITCH
Grief under Sabrina's control: WIIIIIIIIIIIIIITTTTTTTCCCCCCHHHHHHHH
 
So, anyone want to make one of those new internal advert banners for this quest?
I wouldn't object if someone did, and I'd submit an advertisement request, but I won't solicit anyone to do it, either. (I'm personally quite meh regarding the ads.)
will this be put in the front page with the others?
Done, under 'Useful Information'.
I love how this is still a thing

we should totally call it that next time we use it!
*twitch* Didn't notice the spelling mistake. Fixed.
 
If tonight's attempt to heal Oriko doesn't work, should we try going out to recruit the soulguca? If she's going to show up in a week anyway, she might be willing to come early if we offer to pay any relocation expenses etcetera.
 
Well, I expect healing Oriko to take several attempts, but if we run out of ideas ... We still need a way to identify her. All we know about her is her power and the continent she resides on.
 
If tonight's attempt to heal Oriko doesn't work, should we try going out to recruit the soulguca? If she's going to show up in a week anyway, she might be willing to come early if we offer to pay any relocation expenses etcetera.
I thought her name was Euroguca.

Maybe we can intercept her if she's close. We would need to try one of the 'Grief vehicle' ideas... and explain to Homumom why we're going sooooo out of our way to help Oriko...

Or maybe Oriko can See her phone number, or something. Can't telepathy someone we haven't met.
 
Last edited:
If Oriko can see which city she's in, we can just hang out in the sky until someone demands to know what the hell is going on.
 
Or we could not drop our plans and obligations for the next couple of days.

You're also assuming the girl's willing to drop her plans and obligations to come back with us in the first place.
 
Back
Top