Voting is open
S-rank by parts with sealing.
  • Explode nonsummoners.
    • Research MARS stack to drop before reverse summoning. Too big to tank or escape.
  • Missile.
    • Research support seals to stack macerator speed. +20 +20 +20...
      • Tune macerator ejection for consistency, precision.
      • More speed by shrinking size from 100kg? Or raising size if speed comes from force damaging what is stored?
      • Synchronize activation time. Accept random delay?
      • Distance finder for aiming. Wind speed?
      • Let Kagome sort it out.
    • Stack Rocket Jump seals to launch payload? Save seals by skipping lower speeds.
    • Civilian research team to engineer high accuracy 'barrel', payload shape. Strong payload to survive heat, speed.
    • Long range, too fast to react with Sub.
    • Need stunt, months of training to use? Not a RW roll anymore...
  • Not being there.
    • Seal to make escaping to 7th Path same speed as substitution. Take a mild?
    • HLAMole seal for friends without Earth element.
  • Defense.
    • Research blur seal. Harder to be hit by single target attacks.
    • Blur clones.
      • Design special paper lantern.
      • Research seal to change heat in lantern.
      • Research seal to 'leash' heat change seals, regulate paper lantern height, distance from center.
      • Research clone seal to attach to paper lanterns.
      • Add MARS payloads.
    • Genjutsu defense.
      • Chakra passes through air to reach target brain.
      • Detect chakra with chakdar or Minato seal for bonus to resist?
      • Research seal to neutralize detected chakra?
 
Would a fully clothed statue of Jiraiya be less tasteless here? In other words, is it the nudity or the statue?
Yes, a fully clothed statue would be less tasteless.

It will be kitsch to have a giant colossus of Jiraiya straddling the gate. However, people will probably acknowledge that it's kitsch in the way that Jiraiya would have liked (after all, he named his clan Gouketsu and gave them the colors red and green – his ego was not small).

Nudity in statuary is exceedingly rare, if it exists at all in MfD. Especially for former Kage, war heroes, generals, and statesmen often in living memory, a nude statue would be quite unusual. For reference, imagine having a nude statue of JFK or Winston Churchill straddling the front of your house, except only a couple years after the person died.

Historically, nudity in sculpture was reserved for (ancient heroes and mythological figures)[Heroic nudity - Wikipedia], usually not the living or recently dead. Note that the article is in reference to Ancient Greece and Rome, both of which were much more pro-nudity than other medieval cultures. Scanning the history of medieval Japanese sculpture, I can't see any sculptures of notable figures that are nude, and we've established a setting which has even stronger nudity taboos than the equivalent in medieval Japan (e.g. historically baths were mixed but in MfD baths are gender segregated). So yes, nude statuary will be tasteless.

Again, if it's in some private, out-of-the-way corner of the estate, it'll probably get written off as an eccentricity or fetish. If it's forcing essentially everyone that enters the estate to walk under Jiraiya's exposed genitals, that's not going to have a positive connotation.
 
No. Salt has to be separately mostly through evaporation, which ES would not help with. Also, this is literally the most boring task we could use ES for.

Maybe we'd need water element jutsu and a stunt, but still, my idea was "drain all the salt from a place at once without having to wait for evaporation". Actual salt mines from ancient dried lakes do exist, that said. And rock salt in mountaineous terrain etc.
 
Again, if it's in some private, out-of-the-way corner of the estate, it'll probably get written off as an eccentricity or fetish.
"The fetish statue of Jiraiya over that pond is a decoy for the fish god sex cult, itself a decoy for the Wakahisa koi" is ingenious but not enough. Nonja are trained to see underneath the underneath so we should hide the Jiraiya naked statue behind ukiyo-e screens, they'll never suspect that we're hiding something behind the three layers
 
Maybe we'd need water element jutsu and a stunt, but still, my idea was "drain all the salt from a place at once without having to wait for evaporation". Actual salt mines from ancient dried lakes do exist, that said. And rock salt in mountaineous terrain etc.
noburi has a jutsu that allows him to draw the water from the air and i don't think it was a clan secret, just a cantrip; but i have no idea if he lost it in the multiple reality restructuring events the elemental nations have gone through.
 
We have somewhere between "several hundred" and "nearly a thousands civilians living on our estate... would it be possible to copy the Uchiha's "city unto itself" layout without the Madara implications?
You do not need to build a fortress city to fit all your civilians (which, I will note, about equal the population of a large rural village). Asuma has given you plenty of space for a normal clan compound.

If you don't explicitly imitate the Uchiha, but still build a fortress, the connections will be present but less salient, as you might expect.

Does the Details segment of my plan provide adequate enough aesthetics to overcome the defensive tone of the estate (statues that double as lampposts, many gardens, artistic carvings, wooden facades, zen garden/koi pond, etc)?
@Paperclipped, @eaglejarl... questions/comments/concerns? I want to remove ambiguity where possible, and would like to know your thoughts on this plan.
[x] (Goketsu Estate): With a Population Like Ours, We Need a Town Unto Ourselves
Words: 295
  • Sanity Check everything (and vet hires) with Gaku, Mari, and Kei
Should probably be "have Gaku vet hires", rather than spending Hazou, Mari, or Kei's time on this. I'm assuming you mean to vet businesses, not literally every laborer or apprentice they have hired.
  • Design:
    • Hire Shikamaru-recommended KEI-architect from NFF (flatters Shikamaru ; spotlights program).
Great, clear political motive.
  • Have designs based on Uchiha Compound (flatters Sasuke ; "city unto itself" layout we need)
  • Require architect collaborates with...
    • Kagome (maximize trap-setting potential).
Great. This implies that the bones of the compound are going to be cold, utilitarian lethality. Treat everyone like an enemy until proven otherwise. Lots of potential written cues to express that. I like the idea and the clear political message.
  • Noburi (medical checks).
  • Mari (general I&S defenses)
  • Kei (sanity checks/optimization)
I can't imagine what you mean by medical checks or I&S defenses in terms of architecture. I suppose you want to make sure there's a central clinic somewhere...?
  • Construction:
    • Hire KEI-affiliated construction crews from NFF (spotlights program ; increase KEI connection).
      • Monitor for corruption.
There are no KEI-affiliated construction crews since KEI is a group of ninja and they don't do construction.
  • Hazou teaches Reo Earthshaping.
    • Using Earthshaping, fix structural faults in (and hyper-condenses) all building materials (increases defensiveness). Use where proper, but Main Building will only use Hazou's Earthshaped materials.
    • Work with construction crews/engineers to ensure Earthshaped material is safe to use.
Great way to save Hazou's time. It will take Reo a bit of time until he's able to fix structural faults (level 10 ES to join components, level 30 to seamlessly connect components and remove all internal flaws). Getting him to L40 for condensing stone will take longer. However, having him condense literally everything the estate will be constructed with is infeasible -- there will be a lot of stone quarried, and checking literally every single brick for internal flaws would be very slow and very chakra-expensive.

I take it that everything is being constructed out of stone from this section and the next?
  • Details
    • Wooden facades
The intention is to nod to Leaf's architectural influences while still maintaining allegiance to the Uchiha style? I assume it's not to hide that the buildings are made of stone -- not only would it be really hard, but approximately everyone in Leaf will be able to see the buildings being constructed.
  • Several Kagome-approved...
    • Research Facilities (separated from other buildings)
These are already outside of Leaf by order-of-Kagome.
  • Underground Evac Buildings (civilians)
Great detail, will maybe save lives.
  • Goketsu Event Building
Is this meant to hold the whole clan, possibly on the order of 1000 people?
  • ES-Reinforced walkways (QoL improvement)
Stone walkways -- great. What does ES-reinforced mean here, and what do you intend for it to get you over ordinary paving/cobble?
  • Build Hotsprings/Bathhouses (increases hygiene and health)
Probably was going to happen anyway, since there's a hot spring to develop.
  • Using HOWs, create many lampposts (increases visibility at night)
    • ES-condensed marble statues, holding the seal aloft?
Awesome detail. It's great political messaging to have statues of Leaf heroes like Hashirama and Tobirama illuminating the dark.
  • Lots of gardens with water features, flowers, and fruit trees (supplements Food Bank)
Lovely detail. Picking fruit as the characters walk will be a nice scene fluff.
  • Subtly incorporate defenses...
    • Benches that're comfortable, but also reliable cover
    • ES-condensed MEW walls around garden/park perimeters
Again, ES-condensing will require time. Also, MEW is not exactly the prettiest stone (and would be associated with "we put this up quickly because we needed to, and left it up because we were too poor for any alternatives"). Also, be aware of the OPSEC implications of using higher-tier ES abilities in public (though it's not really a clan secret risk since ES is already a publicly available ninjutsu).
  • (If Koi can live indoors) The Koi Pond Building
    • Built to Wataru's standards
    • Only entrance is breezeway, connecting to Main Building.
    • (FOOM Opsec) Zen Garden in same building, exclusively for meditation by Goketsu Ninja.
      • This should not be allowed to interfere with the Koi Pond's ecosystem in any way
      • Thigh-high, ES-condensed MEWs around the pond (as debris guards)
I don't get why this section -- for one, most WHOOSH training is not Resolve training, esp. with the pyramid rework. For another, why are debris guards needed? I don't get what result you intend to get from this section.
  • ES gold filigree into important buildings, using shapes reminiscent of sealwork
  • ES Private monument to clan's fallen in the heart of estate (provides solace).
Great details.
  • With Mari, Hazou Earthshapes fully anatomically accurate Jiraiya Colossus. Clothe in Arachnid Silk garments.
Great detail. See EJ's post above. Also, consider the logistics of getting clothes onto statues and hardening those clothes against the elements (or changing clothes frequently).

@Paperclipped seconding request for feedback.
Okay! Posting my backup idea!

[x] [Estate] Links
???/300 words
  • Design
    • Blend design elements from other clan compounds to represent the links to Leaf we have so far:
      • Uchiha, representing Hazou's ancestors.
      • Nara, representing Kei's marriage to Shikamaru.
      • Senju, representing Jiraiya's teammate (and Noburi's maybe-apprenticeship, but that's still early days).
      • Orochimaru's compound (he might feel slighted if we ref Tsunade but not him).
      • Sarutobi, representing Jiraiya's sensei.
      • Yamanaka, representing Hazou/Akane's relationship with Ino.
      • Aburame, representing our budding business relationship.
    • Architects are also encouraged to invent creative and modern design elements — we're a research clan, after all.
All solid. I assume you'll be speaking with each party (except Orochimaru) about how you can blend in their elements in a respectful way. I like the very clear political message, emphasizing your connections with Leaf at large, with the modernizing elements representing the clans' progressive, future-looking attitude.
  • Construction
    • Hazou creates quartz for highlights.
Great, so mostly traditional Leaf buildings with flashes of white crystalline stone. It's a solid aesthetic!
  • Details
    • Hide Koi pond for FOOM OPSEC training.
      • Add koi gutters (to low-civilian areas).
Remember that koi can't get too far away from each other, otherwise they'll lose their schooling benefit that compounds their chakra capacity. If they're swimming all over in gutters, they'll likely not be usable for chakra tapping.
  • Bathhouses.
    • Add waterslides.
Amazing.
  • Great Hall suitable for larger events.
    • Decorate with huge dragon skeleton carving.
Also amazing. Again, meant to hold the whole clan?
  • Cafeteria.
  • School.
  • Clinic/Mental Health Offices
Solid. While it's not strictly necessary, I appreciate having all these things listed out, as it helps me construct a mental map.
  • Connect up aqueduct/sewers.
What does this mean? IIRC, the sewers are not quite ready for a public deployment and for the aqueducts, the compound has wells (and is also pretty far from the high-elevation water sources in the mountains).
  • Gardens/Greenhouses for Phytosealing Botanical Gardens to come.
Great details. Is Hazou making his phytosealing intentions public?
  • ES relief carvings that resemble 2D/3D sealing on surfaces to hide real seals in the noise.
On only key buildings, I assume, to save Hazou's time? Imitating 3D sealing means imitating the Great Seal, I think, as there exist no other reference to imply that 3D sealing exists for people not named "The Sage of the Six Paths". Also, it'll be rather hard to hide ink-and-paper seals on random building fronts, but I suppose that's what the quartz is for. There's probably a peppery-white quartz type that makes that feasible, especially for seals that are written small.
  • Research facility.
  • Subterranean complex.
    • Civilian evac shelters.
  • Lampposts.
    • Statues holding daybright seals?
  • Monument to the Lost [Temporarily in Another Path].
See above for commentary.
  • Statues.
    • Jiraiya colossus.
    • Other Gouketsu VIPs (incl Gaku, hehe)
    • Hazou's Uchiha ancestors pre-Kurosawa split (ask Sasuke for help).
Good details. I assume these are statues in public squares and gardens?

hmmm is there any way to automatically spend Noburi's Tsunade XP on his mednin skill right before she starts involving him in surgeries?

Since we're time skipping, we're going to miss out on at least another level that might make a difference.

@Paperclipped, any thoughts? It should be a straight leveling within a pyramid level with no complications.
Noburi will level MedNin to the highest possible level with all available shadowing + regular XP prior to being tested. I'll take care of this.

Would lamp-posts be perceived as a gesture of enmity towards the Nara?
Lamp posts cast lovely shadows. It would be at worst neutral. If you study the way lights are placed in the Nara compound you could actually make something that would be appreciated as a homage.
 
Hi all, new to the quest here. I just found it yesterday morning, and have been binging it since. Right now I am at chapter 213, there's a lot of really good things about this quest and a couple things which really annoyed me. But this is good, because contrasting viewpoints lead to a better overall quest, and everything went the way I like it would be boring.
Out of curiosity, are you still reading? If so, did it move more in the positive/negative direction, or did it stay the same?
 
[X] (Estate) Don't commit to anything yet

There's been a lot of ideas and talk and corrections from the QMs floating around changing the calculus, and this isn't an urgent task. I don't hate the plans I've seen, but it's probably best to circle back to it later when we have more time to let the feedback settle.
 
Make the layout of the estate an outline of Jiraiya that can only be seen from aboveground.

Make his dong where the front gate opens up.
 
since it doesnt look like we reached a quorum on the previous plans gonna go ahead and propose a pretty straightforward training plan. Putting Intimidation at Eff. 30 and bumping RW so she's got better attacking ability. I'm more inclined to level RW again given the FS buff (not that we will be using it on the 7th path).

[x] Kei Training Plan: Scary Older Sister
Intimidation: 20 -> 23
Ranged Weapons: 40 -> 46
 
Updated with several details (blue).

Okay! Posting my backup idea!

[x] [Estate] Links
???/300 words
  • Kei/Mari/Gaku check all:
  • Design
    • Blend design elements from other clan compounds to represent the links to Leaf we have so far:
      • Uchiha, representing Hazou's ancestors.
      • Nara, representing Kei's marriage to Shikamaru.
      • Senju, representing Jiraiya's teammate (and Noburi's maybe-apprenticeship, but that's still early days).
      • Orochimaru's compound (he might feel slighted if we ref Tsunade but not him).
      • Sarutobi, representing Jiraiya's sensei.
      • Yamanaka, representing Hazou/Akane's relationship with Ino.
      • Aburame, representing our budding business relationship.
    • Architects are also encouraged to invent creative and modern design elements — we're a research clan, after all.
    • Hire Shikamaru-recommended KEI-architects from NFF.
  • Construction
    • Hazou creates quartz for highlights.
    • ES to add gold filigree to important buildings.
  • Details
    • Hide Koi pond for FOOM OPSEC training.
    • Bathhouses.
      • Add waterslides.
    • Great Hall suitable for larger (1000+ person)events.
      • Decorate with huge dragon skeleton carving.
    • Cafeteria.
    • School.
    • Clinic/Mental Health Offices
    • Connect up the aqueduct we built, and the sewers in preparation for when they're ready for deployment.
    • Gardens/Greenhouses for Phytosealing Botanical Gardens to come.
      • Flank the entrance with statues of Hashirama with unique plants flourishing from his ninjutsu, and Tobirama studying those plants and carrying research scrolls hanging over his arm.
      • Add fruit trees to supplement food supply.
    • ES relief carvings that resemble 2D/3D sealing on surfaces to hide real seals in the noise.
    • Subterranean complex.
      • Civilian evac shelters.
    • Lampposts.
      • Statues holding daybright seals?
    • Monument to the Lost [Temporarily in Another Path].
    • Statues.
      • Jiraiya colossus.
      • Other Gouketsu VIPs (incl Gaku, hehe)
      • Hazou's Uchiha ancestors pre-Kurosawa split (ask Sasuke for help).
 
Last edited:
Why would we suddenly start levelling RW now that she has all the sweet Nara jutsu to level, which effectively serve to immobilize the opponent if they land, thus allowing any Ranged Weapons to land easily? Certainly, levelling RW would still make ample sense afterwards, but we haven't nearly done the levelling of those yet.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top