- Location
- Illinois
I'll re-iterate my reasoning here, on why we shouldn't just gem her.
A. She's been shown to pull Aizen style illusions on meguca with extrasensory abilities - ergo, allowing her to be active near us even momentarily is one of the single worst things we could do, potentially being a straight up loss condition.
B. The absolute safest way of dealing with her is through timestop. We currently are unable to interact with soul gems in timestop without drawing the puella in question into timestop - see Ono. Having us and Homura within Kagari's manipulation range while she's able to act is absolutely fucking terrifying.
C. She's an unrepentant serial murderer who wished to torture another girl to death, and is willing to kill anyone in the way of that goal, up to and including her own sister. Because that is what she wished for, even her witch keeps acting towards that goal. This has two consequences:
1. Because she's shown that even her witch still acts towards her goals, there's a real risk that gemming her wouldn't be enough to stop her from using her power.
2. Any rehabilitation would have to overcome her natural sociopathy and her very wish before it could get anywhere. It's far more likely that even if we managed to gem her, at massive risk to ourselves, we'd never, ever, re-embody her anyway.
Uh, I said kill-on-sight. As in, if by some fucking horrible screwup we actually see her, we slag her head and if the gem is still intact afterwards then that's nice.