Was Ugolino's the one you were saying was limited GM? 'cause it seems like it could be pretty hax, especially if we can duplicate various witch's powersets. Also it seems obvious that it would let us "degrief" witches and probably return them to some state of sanity. Heck, using this we could probably get that "mutual contract" thing set up, especially if we can reform some witches and have them go reform other witches...
We're going up against Oriko...Firn has pretty much said we need to be as OP as possible from the get to.

Also, Is our soul weird because she is "connected" to us as an avatar of SV? From the first post we know she has a mind of her own. Can she hear us, or are we just lurking in her subconscious?
Remember AsukaQuest? Yeah its like that.
 
Remember AsukaQuest? Yeah its like that.
SV is the as yet unnamed character, the unnamed character is SV. Is there a displaced character lurking somewhere else in the character's mind? No. She has some character that I extrapolate, but will be based largely off the thread.

The thread is currently confused over what Wish to make? So too, then, is our protagonist. Thread goes 'oh shit' to whatever new development? So does she. Etc. (I... need to get you guys to name her soon. This is clunky.)

Was Ugolino's the one you were saying was limited GM? 'cause it seems like it could be pretty hax, especially if we can duplicate various witch's powersets. Also it seems obvious that it would let us "degrief" witches and probably return them to some state of sanity. Heck, using this we could probably get that "mutual contract" thing set up, especially if we can reform some witches and have them go reform other witches...
Ugolino's is not the limited one, that's celdak's.
 
Last edited:
Refresh faster GM, I ninja'd you :p

I have zero good suggestions for names mainly b\c I'm an unoriginal hack when it comes to it.
 
[X]Dirtnap
EDIT: Our poor protagonist is going to be bipolar. We can't argue for something to be in-character when we are the character...

EDIT2: Sorry Dirtnap, turns out that is actually your vote, not Ugo's
 
Last edited:
Seems like grief control of some sort is winning on and off for the past 5 pages of debating with interludes of others that get turned down. Or if going by single vote only the GM grab bag means to win anything option is winning.

Honestly I think should probably just have the GM pick whichever one is winning/he likes best or fuse the current strains and get going on the story. Otherwise we'll debate this forever and never get going. I'm admittedly biased though since grief management has been my vote the whole time, but starting to worry this thread will die in chargen.
 
Seems like grief control of some sort is winning on and off for the past 5 pages of debating with interludes of others that get turned down. Or if going by single vote only the GM grab bag means to win anything option is winning.

Honestly I think should probably just have the GM pick whichever one is winning/he likes best or fuse the current strains and get going on the story. Otherwise we'll debate this forever and never get going. I'm admittedly biased though since grief management has been my vote the whole time, but starting to worry this thread will die in chargen.

Nah, quest won't die in chargen. There's enough interest and people are always going to have their own opinions.
 
I'll shift my vote to
[X] Plan Dirtnap
Just in case Firnagzen isn't summing up the grief related votes this should even it up with the means to victory option even as a single vote.
 
Just in case Firnagzen isn't summing up the grief related votes this should even it up with the means to victory option even as a single vote.
I am, actually.

Vote is now closed.

Vote tally:
##### 3.17
[x] I wish to control the power and effects of grief and witches
No. of votes: 2
Lord K, Snow

[X] I wish to never die.
No. of votes: 1
Walker of the Yellow Path

[x] I wish for ability to feed my own witch with my grief and be able to summon/tranform into her without any damage to my own mental faculties or control.
No. of votes: 1
celdak

[x] I wish for the means to fix everything
No. of votes: 6
Random832, TheDamnedDesire, Sightedjt, MrLZRS, Rellow, Muramasa

[x] I wish that no one on this world, especially you Incubator, knew or remembered that I exist.
No. of votes: 1
qsurf

[x] I wish for control over you.
No. of votes: 1
FlatlineAskari

[x]Fine! I wish to control grief! My own! That of others! The grief of the Witches! All of it!
No. of votes: 6
Dirtnap, Ugolino, Schwer-Muta, Shadowward, Retsof, inverted_helix

[X] I wish that everyone knew about Puella Magi and Witches! That for centuries, this world has been aware of you and your Entropy, Kyuubey! That helpless girls are not so unaware of the deal they make with you, but is in accordance with real consent and awareness! Give me that world, a fairworld, where there are rules even YOU must follow! Let my Soul Gem shine, Incubator!
No. of votes: 2
Jemnite, NephyrisX

[X] I wish be be able to purify Witches into another stage in the Puella Magi life cycle. Drown in Sorceresses and die!
[X] I wish that instead of becoming Witches, Puella Magi simply become normal humans when their magic runs out!
[X] I wish that Witches could harmlessly eat/feed on grief by forming contracts of mutual benefaction with either humans with high enough potential or Magical Girls!
No. of votes: 1
jacobplm

[X] I wish it was possible to be able to purify Witches into another stage in the Puella Magi life cycle. Drown in Sorceresses and die!
No. of votes: 1
Lilithium

[X] I wish that Witches could harmlessly eat/feed on grief by forming contracts of mutual benefaction with either humans with high enough potential or Magical Girls!
No. of votes: 1
Uvigz

Counting:
[x] I wish to control the power and effects of grief and witches
and
[x]Fine! I wish to control grief! My own! That of others! The grief of the Witches! All of it!
as one vote.
 
Last edited:
Unforeseen Consequences pt. 2
It takes you a moment to decide on your Wish, what you are willing to sell your soul for. Things like being able to control Witches, summoning unspeakable horrors from beyond the veil of reality, and so forth flash across your mind, before you settle on one. Despite your slumped over position against the wall, you lean forward, staring at Kyuubey. "I wish to control grief! My own! That of others! The grief of the Witches! All of it!"

Twinned sharp inhales from the two girls by your side, and the beginnings of a confused, "Wha-"

"I see," the Incubator says, without inflection. Its eyes begin to glow, becoming little novas of light, and it stretches its ear appendages towards, into you. Dimly, you can hear Madoka and Sayaka, watching on in awe, gasp.

"Contract successful. Your soul has successfully reduced entropy."

A wave of pain explodes outwards from your chest, suffusing every fiber of your being. Your jaw clenches to bite back a scream, as Kyuubey slowly withdraws a brilliantly shining white gem that floats aloft before you. Without prompting, you reach out with one hand and grasp it, clutching it tightly to yourself.

A deep breath.

And again.

Your free hand reaches out, and you flex it, the lack of pain that had been a constant since you awoke is an almost euphoric drug in and of itself. A smile comes to your face unbidden, and you rise smoothly to your feet, feeling better than you have for as long as you can remember. Not that that's terribly long, of course.

The two girls, after a moment of hesitation, stand, too. Madoka smiles at you, but her smile is now tinged with a little worry, and what you think is trepidation. Sayaka's frowning at you, still suspicious and still wary of you. Kyuubey winds through their feet like the cat that it imitates, tail lashing furiously.

[] Introduce yourself
-[] Write-in name.
-[] Choose a tone. (Cool, friendly, cheerful, etc.)
-[] Choose how much to reveal. (IE. Do you know their names, etc.)

[] Leave
-[] Goodbyes?
-[] Write-in name.
-[] Choose a tone. (Cool, friendly, cheerful, etc.)
-[] Choose how much to reveal. (IE. Do you know their names, etc.)

[] Write-in action
-[] Write-in name.
-[] Choose a tone. (Cool, friendly, cheerful, etc.)
-[] Choose how much to reveal. (IE. Do you know their names, etc.)


=====​

Do you want to be mysterious know-it-all? Do you want to be the cheerful, unflappable authority figure? Do you want to be the renegade bitch? Or someone else? None of these are binding for the future, just how do you want to present yourself to the girls right now.No, there's no real significance to the examples. They're just examples.
 
[] Introduce yourself
[]Hi...
-[] "I'm...I'm...SV..Sv...Um. I...I need a second to think. Starts with an S..."
-[]Sabrina?
-[]Tone: I have no idea what's going on, who I am, or how I got here. And I just made a contract with bunnycat. This was clearly a good life choice.
-[]Be completely honest about yourself and what you remember directly, without mentioning any series/meta information yet. What do you remember?
 
Last edited:
[x] Introduce yourself
[x]Hi...
-[x] "I'm...I'm...SV..Sv...Um. I...I need a second to think. Starts with an S..."
--[x] "...Sabrina Vient...?"
[x] Thanking tone. If you hadn't turned up just then, I'm not sure what I would have done. Well, other than bleed I guess.
[x] I'm sorry, may I have your names? So that I can thank you properly. (Keeping quiet about series + meta info)
 
Last edited:
[x] Introductions
[x]Hi, Im Sabrina
[x]Thanking tone. If you hadn't turned up just then, I'm not sure what I would have done. Well, other than bleed I guess.
[x]I'm sorry, may I have your names? So that I can thank you properly. (Keeping quiet about series + meta info)
 
[X] Introduce yourself.
-[X] "Hello, my name's Sabrina. I'm... kinda confused right now? I guess I'm pretty lucky you two found me."
--[X] "I'm sorry, may I have your names? So that I can thank you properly."
-[X] Tone: Inquisitive. Likes to explore, to discover. Wants to fill in the gaps of her knowledge and memories. It's quite an exciting mystery to solve.
-[X] Be open about personal information. No meta-knowledge.
 
Back
Top