Voting is open
As for your premises on ki, it all seems rather theoretical, like you came up with it yourself. Kudos for piecing all that evidence together into a coherent whole, but I feel it was unnecessary. Akira Toriyama gave word of god that ki is made up of, according to the wiki, Genki (lit. "Energy"), Yūki (lit. "Courage") and Shōki (lit. "Mind"). That's where I got the composition of ki I mentioned in my Life Surrounds omake.

...wait, really? I thought it was just a fan-theory that I thought about and decided made sense! Your omake being one case of such, actually.
 
...wait, really? I thought it was just a fan-theory that I thought about and decided made sense! Your omake being one case of such, actually.
Yes, really. You should be proud to have correctly worked out the mechanics of such a core but never explicitly stated part of Dragon Ball with nothing but your own intellect and observations. Congratulations.
 
Last edited:
I'm not, it's genuine praise.

Thank you. That's very sweet. :) But yeah, I'd seen fans such as yourself discussing it, but that particular word of god had slipped me by. So...not so much that I worked it all out myself so much as I traced it back to real-life facts I already knew and articulated the connections. Much as I'd like to take all the credit. :D
 
Styles involve using the whole of the style, and reward using the multiple techniques of the style in concert with bonuses of a magnitude that can cancel out roughly two skill ranks of difference.
I need some more help understanding this quote. As I understand it, if a master of Goku Style with Exceptional Kamehameha went up against a non-style using opponent who had Legendary Kamehameha, two ranks be cancelled out so the opponent would effectively only have Exceptional Kamehameha. Is this correct?
 
Last edited:
Again, there is one form of energy attack which is completely harmless, at least to innocent people, and indeed even bounces right off of them...
 
I need some more help understanding this quote. As I understand it, if a Master of Goku Style with Exceptional Kamehameha went up against a non-style using opponent who had Legendary Kamehameha, two ranks be cancelled out so the opponent would effectively only have Exceptional Kamehameha. Is this correct?

It is correct if the Stylist has been using the Goku style previously. Not for the whole fight, but for long enough to actually be recognizably using the form. If they've been in Vegeta style for the whole fight and switch to Goku for the final blast, they're just firing a Kamehameha. Styles are a matter of unifying disparate techniques into a cohesive whole, and the Kamehameha is a finishing move in that style; its use involves very particular interactions with the rest of the style's movesets, and thus the benefit gained from it is gained by using it in concert with the rest of it. In fluff terms, you fire it at precisely the right moment to take your opponent off-guard, having driven open their guard with your attacks and then taking the moment to drive home a finishing strike. This is something that doesn't work with another style because at levels of mastery that kind of timing is really finicky, and different techniques not only function differently but do different things.

In mechanical terms, you get bonuses on the opposed roll that equate to what two skill ranks give you in terms of roll bonuses. Your opponent isn't penalized; you're boosted. The boost equates to two skill ranks, at master level, but isn't actually boosting your skill. The distinction is important because Elite+ skill ranks come with bonus effects beyond, "your boost gets bigger," to represent that they are truly transcendent forms of mastery over the covered skill. Think, "I am a diligent and intelligent scientist who will do research, some groundbreaking, and contribute to the field and academics in an exceptional but ultimately within-overall-expectations way," versus, "I am Nikola Tesla." Or, another way, "on the impressive end of the peak of the bell curve," versus, "hanging off the right edge of the graph." There is also the fact that a Legendary Kamehameha user who is also a Master Goku stylist needs to have somewhere further up to go.
 
While there is much good to be said for the BOD PL system, it has one major flaw. That flaw is the power level limits. Because while a raw ki quantity makes sense to be limited, that isn't what PL actually is. We know from when Ginyu swapped bodies with Goku that skill in ki use can multiply effective power level tremendously. Ginyu estimated Goku's pre-Kaioken PL at 85k, yet when in Goku's body was only able to achieve 23k. This is a difference of more than x3 that can only be accounted for by the difference in skill level between Ginyu and Goku.
I don't think it has to do with Ginyu being worse at bringing out power than Goku, since Goku noted he couldn't properly use Ginyu's power/body too and could barely sense ki in it, so either this is just because they were just adjusting (unlikely, because then Ginyu would have expected it), because the difference between Ginyu's body and Goku's body was very big (possible) or because they use very different methods of drawing out their power and their bodies aren't suited for the other's method because it doesn't have any "muscle memory" with it.

If the technique isn't that useful without being a Seer, then how come it was effective when Roshi did it?
Wait, when did Roshi block someone's ki?
 
Last edited:
Again, there is one form of energy attack which is completely harmless, at least to innocent people, and indeed even bounces right off of them...
The Spirit Bomb is only harmless to those pure of heart. Throw it at a saintly child who carries only the smallest, barest shred of evil in them and they'll blow up as easy as anyone else. Furthermore, you need to be pure of heart to form the Spirit Bomb and Kakara isn't, at least to my knowledge.

Wait, when did Roshi block someone's ki?
When he was fighting that wolfman in the World Martial Arts Tournament.
 
Last edited:
The Spirit Bomb is only harmless to those pure of heart. Throw it at a saintly child who carries only the smallest, barest shred of evil in them and they'll blow up as easy as anyone else. Furthermore, you need to be pure of heart to form the Spirit Bomb and Kakara isn't, at least to my knowledge.
The Spirit Bomb isn't harmless to everyone but those with the purest of pure hearts, its harmless to everyone except evil people. Krillin was able to touch it just fine in the fight against Vegeta, after all, and he couldn't ride the Flying Nimbus, and so was Gohan, who shouldn't be any more or less evil than Kakara. Heck, as Krillin could even form a spirit bomb when he got the ki from Goku, it seems that you just need to be a good person who's willing to risk your life to save/help others to use it, not meet some ridiculous purity standards.


When he was fighting that wolfman in the World Martial Arts Tournament.
Actually, that wasn't Ki Blocking, it was a pressure point, and it didn't just prevent Wolfman from accessing his ki, but completely prevented him from moving. I don't see why anyone shouldn't be able to learn that (though Roshi did have over a century to learn how to find people's pressure points), but it'd presumeably be a lot harder to use against a peer opponent who's actually on their guard, given that Roshi never tried it against Goku or Tenshinhan. Honestly, I think we might actually be underestimating how hard it is to Ki Block in combat too, given that Sensei only managed to use it on us in what was essentially a surprise attack, because it'd probably require a lot of concentration that's easily broken by an enemy combatant.
 
Krillin was able to touch it just fine in the fight against Vegeta, after all, and he couldn't ride the Flying Nimbus, and so was Gohan, who shouldn't be any more or less evil than Kakara.
You don't need a pure heart to throw the Spirit Bomb, but you do need a pure heart to form it and to not get damaged by it. I'm pretty sure Kakara has some evil in her, even if only a tiny amount. The odds of her being completely pure are low.
 
You don't need a pure heart to throw the Spirit Bomb, but you do need a pure heart to form it and to not get damaged by it. I'm pretty sure Kakara has some evil in her, even if only a tiny amount. The odds of her being completely pure are low.
I don't recall that being ever mentioned in the series though.
 
I don't recall that being ever mentioned in the series though.
On the part about purity being a requirement to form it, I remember that someone said it at some point but I can't remember who or when specifically. Krillin wasn't pure of heart so it's rather obvious that you don't need to be pure to throw it. When Goku was telling Gohan to bounce it back, his words were "So long as you don't have any evil in you, you'll be ok."
 
I don't think it has to do with Ginyu being worse at bringing out power than Goku, since Goku noted he couldn't properly use Ginyu's power/body too and could barely sense ki in it, so either this is just because they were just adjusting (unlikely, because then Ginyu would have expected it), because the difference between Ginyu's body and Goku's body was very big (possible) or because they use very different methods of drawing out their power and their bodies aren't suited for the other's method because it doesn't have any "muscle memory" with it.
I think it's just that some bodies simply work the best in certain ways. Goku has been training his body for a while, and is experienced in getting the best use out of it. Ginyu isn't, and neither is Goku for Ginyu's body.

I'd like to point to the latest point episode for this where they confirm that Black is Zamasu in Goku's body. Black explicitly says that fighting Goku and copying his fighting style made him stronger.
 
I think it's just that some bodies simply work the best in certain ways. Goku has been training his body for a while, and is experienced in getting the best use out of it. Ginyu isn't, and neither is Goku for Ginyu's body.

I'd like to point to the latest point episode for this where they confirm that Black is Zamasu in Goku's body. Black explicitly says that fighting Goku and copying his fighting style made him stronger.

...

I prefer Evil Goku forged from the dragonballs rather then Zamasu Mk3!
 
...

I prefer Evil Goku forged from the dragonballs rather then Zamasu Mk3!
Basically Zamasu really liked Goku's body, and used his super dragonballs to steal it. Then he killed the Goku with Zamasu's body. Though they actually met I don't know, when Future Goku died naturally with post frieza power levels and Future Zamasu was in another universe.
 
Basically Zamasu really liked Goku's body, and used his super dragonballs to steal it. Then he killed the Goku with Zamasu's body. Though they actually met I don't know, when Future Goku died naturally with post frieza power levels and Future Zamasu was in another universe.

Yes, I know.

I just like the idea of Black being his own thing, created with the dragonballs rather then another Iteration of Zamasu. Them being 'partners and comrades' seemed more interesting then simply working together because they are the same person. Though for all we know Black Zamasu could be from another timeline altogether
 
So I just finished watching the One Minute Melee between Hulk and Broly. Aside from reminding me about the single redeeming quality of the Broly movie (the pants-shittingly terrifying ruthlessness of the titular character when he's fighting), it's also reminded me of a similarly distinct fighting style in DBZ.

Twin Android Style: This style represents the fighting abilities programmed into Androids 17 and 18 for the sole purpose of killing Son Goku. This style places an extreme reliance on closely coordinating with another user of the style. The style emphasises disrupting the enemy's momentum and needs high efficiency of ki and stamina usage to maintain the constant pressure required. A user's duelling ability is adequate in case they're temporarily cut off from their partner and while the style uses ki techniques often, it sticks exclusively to the basics. The style does very well against Goku Style, unsurprisingly, and rather poorly against Trunks Style, also unsurprisingly. Involved techniques: Hand-to-Hand [Team Fighting, Twin Android partner required, Extreme], Ki Control, Ki Projection [Basic Attacks]. Penalised techniques: Hand-to-Hand [Crowd Fighting], Ki Projection [All save Basic Attacks, cripplingly so], Ki Sense.

@PoptartProdigy

Considering the Power Pole is indestructible in the absolute meaning of the word, is it possible that it's still floating around somewhere out there in space?

According to the OP, the threat of Goku and Vegeta prevented many galactic villains from threatening Earth which implies that both they and Earth were known in the galactic community. That said, does the galactic community know or at least have rumours of a few Earthlings or Saiyans making it out alive?

If it's not too much to ask, do you know anything about planet Tech-Tech and its inhabitants as they were in canon? Information is rather scarce on that front.
 
Last edited:
Considering the Power Pole is indestructible in the absolute meaning of the word, is it possible that it's still floating around somewhere out there in space.
We will likely run into it at the worst possible time, when we are on the grasp of victory and about to deliver the final bl

*CLANG!*

WHAT THE F*** WAS THAT?
 
The style emphasises disrupting the enemy's momentum and needs high efficiency of ki and stamina usage to maintain the constant pressure required.
You might want to rephrase this part. As it is, it sounds like the style is very efficient in using ki and stamina when the advantage of the androids was that they didn't get tired or ran out of ki so they didn't need to be efficient and could fight at 100% for the entire fight if they so wished.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top