I wouldn't necessarily take them as representative of the other Kings
Shego is literally a Super that can shoot plasma from her hands, has been training/fighting since she was a young teenager, has fought people with countless different fighting styles and is completely ruthless and Xanatos is so memetically good at Intrigue that he has a trope named after him
Yes. When I thought Xanatos' Intrigue might be (gasp) 45 or something, which you have to admit is pretty high by CK quest standards... Well, then I was very sure Syndrome didn't have Intrigue 40.
But now, seeing Xanatos swing around Intrigue 72, I have to ask myself... "Am I sure that Syndrome isn't
just a little better than HALF as cunning as Xanatos?"
And my answer is "He probably isn't, but... I'm not
sure anymore."
That's all I'm getting at.
Iirc the turn we recruited her was the exact same one when we got the information on the gala though given that she hasn't admitted to having been the one to give the info and was surprised when she learned what Doof was planning I doubt that it was her
She doesn't have the right Intrigue score if we can rely on that 40 (I'm not sure). On the other hand, she
definitely has high enough Intrigue to trick Doof into thinking she's surprised when she's not.
The thing you have to remember about Mirage is that she has
at least a 21-0 track record of luring supers to their death without them suspecting a trick until it was too late, over and above her other qualifications.
Personally my favourite theory is that the AI that Syndrome is going to introduce isn't completely willing and did what they could to get some help
That is definitely the most likely single explanation I can think of.
Again, spending a turn pursuing those actions when they're so unlikely to succeed and we have ways to make them easier is more of a waste than just using the actions we currently have
To be fair, gambling one action for a 50/50 chance of getting two actions on all subsequent turns sounds like not such a bad gamble. Especially since lowering the DC probably won't lower it enough for us to be truly sure of success, especially in the areas where Doof's base stat is lower. At some point we're gonna have to take the plunge.
Note that the weird thing is that on a we have a massive defensive buff. So while we can't win reliably against Xanatos or shego at their strengths, THeir stats are about -25 lower due to trait shenanigans so they don't win instantly against us.
The problem is that that trait relies heavily on us being underestimated. I'm not sure Xanatos is underestimating us anymore, and Shego may not be either.
Edit: Xanatos has it worse since he can get a max debuff of -45 for aggresive intrigue actions against anything within our HQ. Which includes us .
I mean.
Agent Russ has infiltrated the
shit out of Toontown without, so far as I know, setting foot inside Judge Doom's headquarters. He learned a lot about this gala without infiltrating Syndrome's headquarters. Just because HQ is secure, doesn't mean our entire country is secure.