Jeez, man, chill. He's just listing his reasons. That doesn't mean you have to like them, you just have to give them some respect
I deleted the post before I noticed that you had quoted it because I realized I didn't really care about pointing out the hole in his argument in an entertaining way, but I do feel the need to respond to your holier-than-thou grandstanding.
First, wasn't angry. But asserting someone's emotional state in order to discredit their argument without needing to use logic is an unfortunately effective tactic. In order to help you better understand people, I was being sarcastic.
Second, we've been told countless times to not think we can just abuse narrative stuff as a guaranteed win. Making light of yet another attempt by someone to do this by flipping it around in an entertaining way is completely fair game - it's even done by the QMs themselves sometimes after they get asked for the thousandth time about what would happen if we try to abuse the Toonforce.
Third, respect is earned, not given. But even so, I didn't say his argument was dumb, nor did I make fun of him. I simply stated that I didn't view it as credible and demonstrated why.
To conclude, I too was just "listing my reasons". If you didn't like the comparison I made, why not respond with a counter-argument instead?