Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
A friendly reminder to new questers to read the Informational threadmarks and FAQ specifically before asking a question. Links below:

Frequently Asked Questions
Here is the Detailed Rune List
Discord.

On Thread Etiquette:

I'm not going to weigh in on the logic of either side's arguments, but I will ask that everyone read over what they write and really consider if the words they used are polite and won't be inflammatory intentionally or not. You cant account for people's tolerances perfectly but at least try to say your piece without saying things that can be easily construed as overly dismissive of the other side of the argument, thank you.

Please endeavour to be cordial. :^)
 
Last edited:
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Nurglish City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse
 
Some kids want ponies. Others want dragon corpses...

[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.

[x] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.

I've been convinced to let karstah study the blade. we got our own research chains to do.
 
Last edited:
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive. Campaign goes high level and my rolls will solely be for how things generally play out + Snorri fighting any heroes/big bads, because man am I tired. After a city falls/retreat, a similar vote will happen until you return home or all three cities are rubble.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City

[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
Karstah will use her own personal time outside of your official duties for her to uncover the mysteries of this blade, how long it takes, if at all, depends on Karstah's own ability. Potential new Rune developed, Karstah will gain expertise.

[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah. Karstah gets a portion of the corpse, she will use it for something. A fitting reward for your heir you reckon, and admittedly you wanted to see what she could do with it. While the contents of your vault are technically her inheritance, she must ask you for material, and you certainly don't plan on dying anytime soon. This would be wholly hers to do with as she wished.
-[X] The whole corpse. You have enough already, let Karstah see what she can create from this.

Votes open and godspeed.
 
Last edited:
Preserve the human bodies and don't do destructive testing on the sword once we are finished purging the lizards we can send out some beardlings to find these people in return their remains.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Nurglish City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
Given how ambitious the dragon gronti plans are I don't think we have the spare actions to research the sword in the future.
And after that we're probably back to fighting over Akazit and Metal 5
[X [Campaign:] Continue the offensive. Campaign goes high level and my rolls will solely be for how things generally play out + Snorri fighting any heroes/big bads, because man am I tired. After a city falls/retreat, a similar vote will happen until you return home or all three cities are rubble.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City

[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
Karstah will use her own personal time outside of your official duties for her to uncover the mysteries of this blade, how long it takes, if at all, depends on Karstah's own ability. Potential new Rune developed, Karstah will gain expertise.

[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah. Karstah gets a portion of the corpse, she will use it for something. A fitting reward for your heir you reckon, and admittedly you wanted to see what she could do with it. While the contents of your vault are technically her inheritance, she must ask you for material, and you certainly don't plan on dying anytime soon. This would be wholly hers to do with as she wished.
-[X] The whole corpse. You have enough already, let Karstah see what she can create from this.

Votes open and godspeed.
Your Campaign tag is borked.

[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive. Campaign goes high level and my rolls will solely be for how things generally play out + Snorri fighting any heroes/big bads, because man am I tired. After a city falls/retreat, a similar vote will happen until you return home or all three cities are rubble.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City

[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
Karstah will use her own personal time outside of your official duties for her to uncover the mysteries of this blade, how long it takes, if at all, depends on Karstah's own ability. Potential new Rune developed, Karstah will gain expertise.

[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah. Karstah gets a portion of the corpse, she will use it for something. A fitting reward for your heir you reckon, and admittedly you wanted to see what she could do with it. While the contents of your vault are technically her inheritance, she must ask you for material, and you certainly don't plan on dying anytime soon. This would be wholly hers to do with as she wished.
-[X] The whole corpse. You have enough already, let Karstah see what she can create from this.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
Snorri already has his hands full. Adding the sword to the research backlog seems counterproductive to me when it could be completed for free some time down the line. Plus extra experience for Karstah is a good thing.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.

My thought for keeping the blade is to avoid overloading Karstah, both in terms of workload and emotionaly. She might not think she deserves all of it.

Also reluctantly I must say we're less likely then her to break the sword, and I kinda want to give it back some day.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.

Voting for the Slaaneshi City because they have slaves to rescue, and because Dawi are less vulnerable to classic Nurglite tactics than Umgi. Taking the blade for ourselves because it's honestly not something I'd expect Karstah to figure out by herself anytime soon, and giving her the corpse because she's frankly earned it.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Give it to Karstah to study.
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
[X] [Campaign:] Continue the offensive.
-[X] Against the Slaaneshi City
[X] [Blade] Study it yourself
[X] [Corpse] Give some to Karstah.
-[X] The whole corpse.
 
Back
Top