Meanwhile, in a Gaen Musical Science Bunker somewhere, someone captures the prevailing mood:
Star got blown up
and you're to blame
Mentats you give Sci
A bad name
 
Last edited:
He's not actually breaking any rules to justify a threadban, though, is he?

You *could* make an argument about him being disruptive to the thread. However, *threaten with threadban* is, IIRC, somewhat against the rules. If you think someone is being too disruptive and they don't listen to reason, report them and go on with the discussion.

I think this would only be done if the Cardassians were desirous of a war. Given how GBZ has been turning out, I do not think they are desirous of one at the current time.

Well, Cardies like to think they are Hard Cardassians Making Hard Decisions, and may make some sort of 'they are fuckos, but they gib results' justification about stupid things like 'protect Licori'.
But I doubt that will work out well for them, both because lol Licori are hazard for everyone around, and because letting them do this shit is basically casus belli.

And they *know* it, Cardassians are not stupid and understand perfectly that protecting Licori from repercussions is basically breaking Treaty of Celos in spirit, which they do not want to do.
 
Last edited:
I think the reqs for Threat to increase is probably quadratic or so. Or nonlinear in some way.

Licori crisis isn't so serious when the GBZ and Cardassians is a thing.
Wut? The GBZ sitch is a cabinet war - sure, military assets are at stake, but nothing else is. The Licori situation has lunatics trying to start artificial supernovas. It's an existential threat in the making.
 
The war between the Morshadd Empire and the Ked Paddah began two years ago, and has raged on ever since. The Ked Paddah were the aggressors, apparently declaring war and launching a sweeping attack of Licori border worldsafter a particular science experiment induced outright panic. From what we are told, it may have been a test (failed, thankfully) that could induce a core collapse in a main sequence star.

Wow. This was literally the exact same thing that got the Licori into a war in the first place. They've still been pouring resources into artificial star collapse despite the war being ongoing for multiple years since then.

The only reasonable conclusion to draw from this is that the Licori PLAN TO USE THIS ABILITY.

No wonder everyone including the Pacifist Federation is getting ready to put them to bed. They've been funneling resources towards a weapon of mass destruction in the middle of a war. That can only mean that someone in their society intends to use this.

These people are lunatics. If they'd been totally successful they'd be burning their own worlds in the tests alone. Just, wow, just wow.

The Federation needs to issue our own Ultimatium for them to prepare for a peaceful restructuring before they decide to fully use this ability on populated systems.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, in a Gaen Musical Science Bunker somewhere, someone captures the prevailing mood:
Star got blown up
and you're to blame
Mentats you give Sci'
A bad name
'Cause baby we got bad sci'
You know it used to be mad sci'
So take a look at what you've done,
'Cause baby, now we've got bad sci', hey!
Now we've got problems,
And I don't think we can solve 'em.
You made a really big boom.
And baby, now we got bad sci', hey!
 
Wut? The GBZ sitch is a cabinet war - sure, military assets are at stake, but nothing else is. The Licori situation has lunatics trying to start artificial supernovas. It's an existential threat in the making.
The Licori aren't a power on par with the Federation.
The Federation needs to issue our own Ultimatium for them to prepare for a peaceful restructuring before they decide to fully use this ability on populated systems.
I understand an ultimatum has already been issued to the Licori government?
 
Last edited:
Wow. This was literally the exact same thing that got the Licori into a war in the first place. They've still been pouring resources into despite the war being ongoing for multiple years since then.

The only reasonable conclusion to draw from this is that the Licori PLAN TO USE THIS ABILITY.

No wonder everyone including the Pacifist Federation is getting ready to put them to bed. They've been funneling resources towards a weapon of mass destruction in the middle of a war. That can only mean that someone in their society intends to use this.

These people are lunatics. If they'd been totally successful they'd be burning their own worlds in the tests alone. Just, wow, just wow.

The Federation needs to issue our own Ultimatium for them to prepare for a peaceful restructuring before they decide to fully use this ability on populated systems.

Well, remember that mentats are created by individual noble houses and seem to act semi-independently beyond that. I don't know that you can use their individual actions to determine the intentions of their government/society.

You *could* make an argument about him being disruptive to the thread. However, *threaten with threadban* is, IIRC, somewhat against the rules. If you think someone is being too disruptive and they don't listen to reason, report them and go on with the discussion.

True. I guess the most we could do is that everyone informally agrees to no longer respond to ThoughtMaster's posts, and his votes don't get counted in tallies.
 
Wow. This was literally the exact same thing that got the Licori into a war in the first place. They've still been pouring resources into despite the war being ongoing for multiple years since then.

The only reasonable conclusion to draw from this is that the Licori PLAN TO USE THIS ABILITY.

No wonder everyone including the Pacifist Federation is getting ready to put them to bed. They've been funneling resources towards a weapon of mass destruction in the middle of a war. That can only mean that someone in their society intends to use this.

These people are lunatics. If they'd been totally successful they'd be burning their own worlds in the tests alone. Just, wow, just wow.

The Federation needs to issue our own Ultimatium for them to prepare for a peaceful restructuring before they decide to fully use this ability on populated systems.
Oh god, I missed that.

In light of that detail, this war can't end with Licori independence intact. They're been working on a weapon of mass murder instead of fleeting up, after all. The current Licori government/culture is simply too dangerous to remain intact.
 
Not sure what Ainsworth is smoking, because this is a defeat. We have one ship slightly damaged, and one ship severely damaged. They have two ships slightly damaged. Its not even an attritional victory, because the damage to the Sydraxian ships will probably not require more than a month or two of repairs, tops. I guess this is why the Conniebee is just a stopgap cruiser; it really is showing its limitations as a combatant.

Good news is that the Courageous survived, though its down at least 1E of crew and we now have yet ANOTHER excelsior in need of longterm repairs. Bad news is that the Licori have shown themselves to be dysfunctional as a society to the point where they can't be trusted as friends, as neighbors, or even with their own safety. I guess its good to see that the Federation government seems to be treating this with due seriousness, if nothing else.

Recent situation. Because replacing the diplomat of a foreign nation is not a 'shrugs' situation.

Its very analogous to the Orion Syndicate's disabling of the Courageous. In both cases, we knew that (minor power) would do grave harm to us if it could, but we didn't take them seriously because we thought they lacked the ability. Once that ability has been demonstrated, we are forced to take them more seriously.

Unlike that Orion situation, however, the Lecarre are protected by the Treaty of Celos. If we had found out about this at any time prior to the signing of that treaty, I'd want to destroy some Lecarre outposts and ships as a deterrent against them trying this again. It's even possible that we could then pressure their leaders into negotiating a lasting peace. Unfortunately, the timing just completely fucked us over.

There's not much we can do about the Lecarre right now. We'll need to wait until either a) they try to do this again in violation of the Treaty of Celos, or b) we've weakened the Ashalla Pact to the point where we can act against the Lecarre without fear of Cardassian reprisals.

You could just threadban Thoughtmaster instead.

Let's not thought police.
 
Last edited:
Well, remember that mentats are created by individual noble houses and seem to act semi-independently beyond that. I don't know that you can use their individual actions to determine the intentions of their government/society.
That the experiments were not shut down constitutes acquiescence/support. If the Licori government couldn't do that then they're a de facto failed state that is a direct threat to all their neighbors.
Let's not thought police.
He's getting us hit with in-game punishments. It's not thought policing anymore.
 
Let's not thought police.

Actually, let's. Because what do you call assigning militarization for discussion?

He's getting us hit with in-game punishments. It's not thought policing anymore.

You aren't any better. e: Worse, actually:
Then it's war the instant that's confirmed.

Again, war the instant that's confirmed. In this case, however any means short of weaponizing the biophage, but NOT short of weaponized Genesis are acceptable if necessary to win.
 
Last edited:
Well, remember that mentats are created by individual noble houses and seem to act semi-independently beyond that. I don't know that you can use their individual actions to determine the intentions of their government/society..

Does it really matter if it's only one noble house that burns a billion men, women, and children in an afternoon while the rest of their civilization watches?

The fact is that their system allows for this to happen. If we don't want to wake up one morning to Billions of lives lost (Even by Accident!) then something has to be done!
 
2314.Q2
30 br
60 sr
5 rp
15 qloath
15 seyek
Challorn damaged, -1 E
Courageous damaged -? Crew
Exeter light damage

So 3 ships damaged but we likely gained the resources needed for repair
 
If/when the Licori are put down, I'm expecting any provisional governments to be overseen at least partially by the Gaeni. Their societal mores align closely enough that it wouldn't be too politically untenable, and they are just mad scientist enough to understand what the licori are doing and stop it.
 
Yes, a dodgy escort is dodgy. This is not a surprise. It's canon that high-end escorts with sufficiently skilled pilots are basically impossible to hit in small scale battles.
Hmm, interesting, seeing as such made a hit rate of 90% for the Syndraxians vs an 83.87% hit rate for us. I wonder if it is possible to increase our hit rate? Gunnery practice or something to improve accuracy might work, or maybe adding a method so that targeting can be done manually?
 
Last edited:
No, because we don't know what sort of Evasion level either our ships or the Sydraxians' ships have. That said I'd give the advantage there to the Sydraxians' because we had two Cruisers (Constellation and Constitution) to their Cruiser and Frigate.

Evasion is dependent on three things: size, engines, and veterancy. Of those, engines is a minor contributor.

The Kalindrax is a large cruiser, bigger than a Jaldun, about 1.4 to 1.6mt. The Constitution is a 1mt cruiser. We should have the evasion advantage over the Kalindrax by the tune of ~2-3%. The Hasque is a 700 to 800kt escort, and the Constellation is a 700kt (800kt with retcon) cruiser. They should have approximately equal evasion, but this is the Challorn, which should get an evasion bonus from being blooded. We should there have the evasion advantage to the tune of ~3-5%.

Overall a Federation evasion advantage exists, unless it was mitigated by doctrine or foreign analysis. Speaking of doctrine, they have a +9% doctrine or FA advantage. I actually don't see any doctrine or reasonable years of FA that could get us that in a 2v2 battle like this one.
 
Back
Top