- Location
- Florida
what I'm hearing is that magical girls are immortal superhumans and we ethically should look for a way to offer it to deserving people (boys?). griefhax: an item that allows us to fulfill wishes and/or create magical girls/boys.
Mundanes cannot sense or voluntarily interact with barriers that we know of, so yes, that witch would have in fact managed to kill everyone in the world eventually. Or at the very least reduced humanity to huddled souls constantly fighting the wandering familiars and fleeing from the location of the barrier as it slowly travels in search of more to consume.Would that first Witch have have been able to kill off everyone in the world?
Not the world as it is today, I don't think. We know for a fact that Homura's mundane weaponry works perfectly well on Witches and it is possible for strong enough individuals (i.e. potential magical girls) to survive for at least a while in a labyrinth without getting Kissed or brainwashed by a Witch.
what I'm hearing is that magical girls are immortal superhumans and we ethically should look for a way to offer it to deserving people (boys?). griefhax: an item that allows us to fulfill wishes and/or create magical girls/boys.
Mundanes cannot sense or voluntarily interact with barriers that we know of, so yes, that witch would have in fact managed to kill everyone in the world eventually. Or at the very least reduced humanity to huddled souls constantly fighting the wandering familiars and fleeing from the location of the barrier as it slowly travels in search of more to consume.
The fact that a barrier/Witch is present in an area is always going to be plenty evident by the fact that any Kissed victims will have, you know, a glaring tattoo of the Witch's emblem on their necks. Pinpointing the location might require a manhunt sized search without a convenient tracking device but I don't think it was even ever confirmed that mundanes (or at least potential girls) couldn't voluntarily enter a Barrier they knew the location of. If nothing else, they could wait for the Witch to bring in a bunch of victims and slip in with then.I mean, the hypothetical only Witch in the world could just witch kiss people and never leave it's barrier or invite people into it, and just end the human race by eventual mass suicide.
The fact that a barrier/Witch is present in an area is always going to be plenty evident by the fact that any Kissed victims will have, you know, a glaring tattoo of the Witch's emblem on their necks. Pinpointing the location might require a manhunt sized search without a convenient tracking device but I don't think it was even ever confirmed that mundanes (or at least potential girls) couldn't voluntarily enter a Barrier they knew the location of. If nothing else, they could wait for the Witch to bring in a bunch of victims and slip in with then.
The fact that a barrier/Witch is present in an area is always going to be plenty evident by the fact that any Kissed victims will have, you know, a glaring tattoo of the Witch's emblem on their necks. Pinpointing the location might require a manhunt sized search without a convenient tracking device but I don't think it was even ever confirmed that mundanes (or at least potential girls) couldn't voluntarily enter a Barrier they knew the location of. If nothing else, they could wait for the Witch to bring in a bunch of victims and slip in with then.
Could the Witch hypothetically never invite anyone into its barrier?
Maybe, but that's not exactly normal Witch behavior to say the least. I think the only Witch we've ever seen who has never tried to do it was Walpy and only because it doesn't have one.
(Also, if all they were doing is Kissing people, the suicides can be interrupted the way Madoka did with Hitomi, the Familiars would be the only thing needed to watch for and they would probably bring people into their labyrinths to be fought even if the main Witch did not - which would make this Witch that didn't bring in people to personally kill very survivable itself, if you think about it.)
The potentials can see Kisses. Opening up the portal might also be automatically done by the Witch itself when the Witch detects somebody nearby since, as mentioned, keeping shut even when people are on the doorstep is far from usual behavior.It is in fact canon that normal people can't see Witch Kisses, and opening the portal to a Witch's Labyrinth is an explicitly magical act. A witch could presumably refuse to invite people, since that's apparently exactly what Walpurgis is doing when not materializing.
Hmmm... This leads to an interesting question actually: Could Sabrina force open Walpurgisnacht's barrier and bust her way inside?It is in fact canon that normal people can't see Witch Kisses, and opening the portal to a Witch's Labyrinth is an explicitly magical act. A witch could presumably refuse to invite people, since that's apparently exactly what Walpurgis is doing when not materializing.
The canon explanation is allegedly that girls are more emotional, which... simply isn't true. Boys just learn to repress it. So my PMAS-canon explanation is that Coobs chooses to contract girls (for whatever reason).its there any canon or PMAS canon at least explanation for why there are no magical boys? is it based on chromosomal sex or identity? cuz if it were the former you would think, given your meguca appearance reflects your inner view, there'd at least be tales of at last one magical boy through means of one going through transition.
finding out about this could double our potential population.
so brinahax magical boy kyuuyuuusuiikikoThe canon explanation is allegedly that girls are more emotional, which... simply isn't true. Boys just learn to repress it. So my PMAS-canon explanation is that Coobs chooses to contract girls (for whatever reason).
Funnily enough, if you consider the notion that Coobs doesn't understand emotions, then, well, it might be wrongly choosing to contract only girls because of incorrect cultural assumptions.
On the other hand, the out-of-story explanation is that it's a magical girl story, ergo, you have magical girls.
Bottom line, Kyubey just doesn't do it for reasons only he knows. Maybe his spiel about girls being more sensitive was just deflection and he has a true reason he's not saying, maybe it really IS his true reason and just some part of his bizzare alien mentality that makes sense only to him.its there any canon or PMAS canon at least explanation for why there are no magical boys?
The first part is pretty much a rephrasing of what I said, but the second paragraph...Bottom line, Kyubey just doesn't do it for reasons only he knows. Maybe his spiel about girls being more sensitive was just deflection and he has a true reason he's not saying, maybe it really IS his true reason and just some part of his bizzare alien mentality that makes sense only to him.
I personally have a very much darker and more unpleasant theory as to why he only targets females, but said suspicion also involves a ton of extrapolation from somewhat loose circumstantial evidence. So I'm going to refrain from actually saying it out as it would not only be an instant mood-killer, but also probably get people jumping down my throat for suggesting it. And no, it has nothing to do with Kyubey being a closet pervert and mostly to do with hard biology.
The potentials can see Kisses. Opening up the portal might also be automatically done by the Witch itself when the Witch detects somebody nearby since, as mentioned, keeping shut even when people are on the doorstep is far from usual behavior.
Walpy, IIRC, was simply stated not to have a Barrier/labyrinth at all, not that they hid in one until they were ready to hunt. To this day, we still do not know for certain where it comes from or how it comes about at all so it is perfectly possible that Kyubey just makes Walpurgisnacht on the spot on his scheduled date for cleaning house.
If Walpurgisnacht argues that the actors are powerless before the script, we can prove her wrong by blowing her house down.I can imagine it now, Sabrina metaphysically "knocking" on the barrier and entering with a polite call of "actor's union, here to discuss the script!"
You look down at your hands, still busily kneading and infusing Grief with magic, and then you look at the keyboard, with small blobs of Grief resting on every key.[13:35:08] <Fireblade> There is nothing wrong with Hawaiian shirts.[13:35:13] <TomatoPotato> on other people, no[13:35:16] <Fireblade> Nor on me! [13:35:17] <TomatoPotato> yuh-huh[13:35:26] <Fireblade> Whiterabbit back me up here.[13:35:33] <Whiterabbit> other styles suit you better <3[13:35:34] <Fireblade> ...[13:35:37] <Fireblade> whyyyyyyy[13:35:37] <GriefBeGone> Nothing wrong with hawaiian shirts![13:35:37] <GriefBeGone> Unless, I dunno, maybe it's like the shuttershades thing, except in reverse.[13:35:40] <Genesis> shutter shades thing?[13:35:45] <Genesis> do we wanna know?[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> Eh, nothing much to say there, really[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> Mami doesn't want me to wear shuttershades, and I suppose mostly I agree that they don't look good on me, but part of me thinks that it can't hurt to *try*[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> So yeah, the shutter shades thing.[13:35:47] <NotANickname> I mean[13:35:50] <NotANickname> she's right[13:35:56] <NotANickname> shutter shades are No[13:35:56] <EleseCanGoDie> ^[13:36:10] <Fireblade> ... okay, how in the everburning blazes of heck are you typing that fast?
You smile to yourself as farewells fill the screen, and sign off. They're nice people, it seems like, and you'll probably find a reason to go visit them at some point. The real question is whether that's before or after Walpurgisnacht.[13:36:11] <GriefBeGone> By transcending the limitations of mere, base flesh, nay, even that of matter itself. I have achieved a lesser nirvana, for is not harmony being able to speak your mind and to *understand*? Behold the power of this FULLY ARMED AND OPERATION GRIEF-ACTUATED KEYBOARD[13:36:11] <Fireblade> ...[13:36:15] <Fireblade> Fair enough.[13:36:22] <EleseCanGoDie> actually if you're typing with grief[13:36:34] <EleseCanGoDie> isn't it the opposite of fully *armed*[13:36:38] <TomatoPotato> Completely unarmed?[13:36:38] <GriefBeGone> ... yeah, ok, that's true.[13:36:38] <GriefBeGone> Also, minor correction: I haven't transcended the limits of matter, I suppose, since I'm still *using* the keyboard. Maybe I should try plugging directly into the ethernet socket to manually flip bits...[13:36:46] <TomatoPotato> also, 99% sure that's not what nirvana is[13:36:46] <GriefBeGone> Hey, I *did* say *lesser*.[13:36:49] <TomatoPotato> not even close[13:36:49] <GriefBeGone> Fiiiiine.[13:36:54] <EleseCanGoDie> abtwat I gotta get moving[13:36:56] <EleseCanGoDie> anyway*[13:37:00] <Whiterabbit> see you soon! *hugs*[13:37:01] <EleseCanGoDie> later[13:37:12] *** EleseCanGoDie has left #milesgloriosus with the message:[13:37:14] <Genesis> later![13:37:15] <Genesis> aw[13:37:15] <GriefBeGone> Anyway, speaking of going, I should probably be headed off myself.[13:37:15] <GriefBeGone> See you![13:37:19] <Fireblade> Until next time![13:37:20] <Genesis> later~
[13:35:08] <Fireblade> There is nothing wrong with Hawaiian shirts.
[13:35:13] <TomatoPotato> on other people, no
[13:35:16] <Fireblade> Nor on me!
[13:35:17] <TomatoPotato> yuh-huh
[13:35:26] <Fireblade> Whiterabbit back me up here.
[13:35:33] <Whiterabbit> other styles suit you better <3
[13:35:34] <Fireblade> ...
[13:35:37] <Fireblade> whyyyyyyy
[13:35:37] <GriefBeGone> Nothing wrong with hawaiian shirts!
[13:35:37] <GriefBeGone> Unless, I dunno, maybe it's like the shuttershades thing, except in reverse.
[13:35:40] <Genesis> shutter shades thing?
[13:35:45] <Genesis> do we wanna know?
[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> Eh, nothing much to say there, really
[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> Mami doesn't want me to wear shuttershades, and I suppose mostly I agree that they don't look good on me, but part of me thinks that it can't hurt to *try*
[13:35:45] <GriefBeGone> So yeah, the shutter shades thing.
[13:35:47] <NotANickname> I mean
[13:35:50] <NotANickname> she's right
[13:35:56] <NotANickname> shutter shades are No
[13:35:56] <EleseCanGoDie> ^
[13:36:10] <Fireblade> ... okay, how in the everburning blazes of heck are you typing that fast?
[13:36:11] <GriefBeGone> By transcending the limitations of mere, base flesh, nay, even that of matter itself. I have achieved a lesser nirvana, for is not harmony being able to speak your mind and to *understand*? Behold the power of this FULLY ARMED AND OPERATION GRIEF-ACTUATED KEYBOARD
[13:36:11] <Fireblade> ...
[13:36:15] <Fireblade> Fair enough.
Careful Brina, jacking directly into ethernet ports is a slippery slope that quickly leads to figuring out if your brain can run Doom.Maybe I should try plugging directly into the ethernet socket to manually flip bits...
Bah, bad luck. Well, it was worth a shot. And yeah, we should tell them.You take another sip of lemonade, and sigh. "Alright. I've got... one more question, and it's a sensitive one," you say. "I apologise if it causes pain, but it's important that I know - is the Grief Seed that I cleared for you Miss Tanaka's?"
Shock flashes across their expressions for a second before their faces close off. Akemi exchanges a look with Noriko, who shakes her head.
"No," she bites out. "It's the Witch that killed her."
"... ah," you say, grimacing. "Right. I... I apologise for touching a sore topic."
The Shiogama girls fall silent, looking at each other.
"Why did you ask?" Noriko's the one to break the silence, having apparently lost the mental debate.