Mami already said it wasn't a big deal right now and we do have to talk to Kyubey about it. If it's that pressing, we should release some of it.



First we should just be able to sense Nagisa if she's at the hospital. Second just how much meta are you willing to share with Homu right now? Because the amount of foreknowledge you want to discuss with her is going to raise a lot of questions if not a gun in the face.
Soul gem storage is more an experiment than "we need to do this ASAP"- though I'd rather do it before it becomes an issue than after.

Frankly, with Homura, we should effectively go full meta. (for mutually useful information) It's a gamble, but given we've already dropped more than we should if we're playing dumb...

If nothing else, we can avoid meta completely and just check that she'd be in the area around that time/offer to talk to her at the hospital around that time-and ask her to help with Charlotte when the seed's spotted.

We can short circuit Sayaka's objections, if any, by pointing out that there isn't much time before the seed starts to eat people at the hospital and Homura's right there. Us trusting Homura for the witchstomp might cause issues with Mumi in the long term, but the potential reward's worth it. (Defusing the Sayaka-Homura thing before it even starts, Homura gets to play hero by >saving the poor innocent civilians at the hospital which can only help relations overall, and most importantly we try to avoid an Episode 3 fiasco.
 
Mami already said it wasn't a big deal right now and we do have to talk to Kyubey about it. If it's that pressing, we should release some of it.



First we should just be able to sense Nagisa if she's at the hospital. Second just how much meta are you willing to share with Homu right now? Because the amount of foreknowledge you want to discuss with her is going to raise a lot of questions if not a gun in the face.
What? I can't even imagine how badly we'd have to fuck up to get a gun in our face. She isn't totally fucking insane and she has all the reasons in the world not to shoot us seeing as how Mami and the others would be more than a little suspicious that the newbie just mysteriously disappeared, she still needs all the help she can get for Walpurgisnacht, and she especially needs our help because of our grief manipulation power. Us knowing of the secrets of soul gems and everything only makes us more valuable.

Perhaps you can irritate her into threatening us if you start spewing a crapload of info without any explanation of its source, but even then she'd have to be retarded to follow up on such a threat.
 
What? I can't even imagine how badly we'd have to fuck up to get a gun in our face. She isn't totally fucking insane and she has all the reasons in the world not to shoot us seeing as how Mami and the others would be more than a little suspicious that the newbie just mysteriously disappeared, she still needs all the help she can get for Walpurgisnacht, and she especially needs our help because of our grief manipulation power. Us knowing of the secrets of soul gems and everything only makes us more valuable.

Perhaps you can irritate her into threatening us if you start spewing a crapload of info without any explanation of its source, but even then she'd have to be retarded to follow up on such a threat.
Going full meta boils down to "Yes, we know everything, here's the proof, and we want to help you win- if everyone lives."
 
What? I can't even imagine how badly we'd have to fuck up to get a gun in our face. She isn't totally fucking insane and she has all the reasons in the world not to shoot us seeing as how Mami and the others would be more than a little suspicious that the newbie just mysteriously disappeared, she still needs all the help she can get for Walpurgisnacht, and she especially needs our help because of our grief manipulation power. Us knowing of the secrets of soul gems and everything only makes us more valuable.

Perhaps you can irritate her into threatening us if you start spewing a crapload of info without any explanation of its source, but even then she'd have to be retarded to follow up on such a threat.

Hmm, I would still be very careful as to how we present this information. It's becoming a bit more obvious that we're manipulating Mami and the others and even Homura to an extent.
 
Hmm, I would still be very careful as to how we present this information. It's becoming a bit more obvious that we're manipulating Mami and the others and even Homura to an extent.
All the more reason to come clean, with reasons, to Homura if it becomes possible. Miscommunication's a killer in PMMM after all, and Homura's unlikely to find anything wrong with "I want to live and I want everyone else to live, including you and Madoka."- which would be the literal truth for the character. :D

Now, if we come across as a manipulative potential threat with an unknown agenda...
 
Hmm, I would still be very careful as to how we present this information. It's becoming a bit more obvious that we're manipulating Mami and the others and even Homura to an extent.
That doesn't mean that I think we should just whip out the whole thing. It would strain our relationship seeing as how we have no satisfactory explanation for how we know this or why anyone should listen, and also it's just kind of weird.

Just don't give away anything to anyone but Homura, and just enough of it to convince Homura to take an alternative course of action. If she takes offense to being "manipulated" then well, I've frankly got no clue how to deal with that because it's a really illogical thing to take offense over being pushed in a direction that will be beneficial for you and your goals and call it "manipulation".
 
Make our agenda clear and persuade her that it'll help with the endgame and Homura'd probably agree- she gets on fine with Kyouko and had no issues with promising her the city post Walpurgisnight. She's really not that picky with allies- Homuplomacy/hilariously botched Mami interactions aside.

Telling her that Sabrina has witch names/future knowledge inside her head and no idea how it got there won't stop her from seeing her as, at worst, another body to throw against Walpurgisnight if we confirm we're not a threat to Madoka and don't intend to try and get her to contract.
 
Last edited:
That doesn't mean that I think we should just whip out the whole thing. It would strain our relationship seeing as how we have no satisfactory explanation for how we know this or why anyone should listen, and also it's just kind of weird.

Just don't give away anything to anyone but Homura, and just enough of it to convince Homura to take an alternative course of action. If she takes offense to being "manipulated" then well, I've frankly got no clue how to deal with that because it's a really illogical thing to take offense over being pushed in a direction that will be beneficial for you and your goals and call it "manipulation".

It's manipulation for deliberately witholding information, because reasons. We may be doing it for a good cause and Homura may follow through with it because she can't see a better alternative but that doesn't change the fact that we're not being completely forth comming. That's reason enough to distrust us and our motives though that's a worst case scenario. We very well could've earned enough good will at that point that Homura can overlook it.
 
With Ugolino, Homura has most likely figured out something's up with us, even if we might have some kind of Amnesia. We need to inform her that basically, her goal is the same as ours, but we're trying to save everyone we can at the same time.

Good communication with Homura is pretty much critical for us right now...and then bridging that communication with Mami. Having those two fight side by side will bode very well for our survival and eventual success.

Anyways, my vote:
[x]Ugolino (however, I'm iffy about letting any grief in our Soul Gem...can't we manipulate it into a gem or something to carry around in our pocket?)
 
[X] Ugolino

Uh, Firn? About the school which Madoka, Sayaka, and Mami attend. It's Mitakihara Middle School, not High school...
 
Bad idea number forty(Dependent on bad idea number 4 working, IE, the one about trying to convert grief into other forms of energy): We attempt to convert the Grief of a witch barrier into thermal energy, kill it without even entering the place. Grief Seed Flambe, anyone?
 
Entanglement pt. 3
You sit up and stretch, before bouncing to your feet. You'd had a dreamless sleep, and feel refreshed and ready to go for today. Maybe you'll talk to Homura again today, and try to persuade her to be a little less Murderface?

Your mouth twists a little as you walk over to the bathroom to clean up, though. You're currently deceiving everyone around you, and a little unhappy with that. All of them are good people, and it doesn't sit very well with you. Still, you don't really see a better way for now.

And speaking of better ways... you frown at the Grief cloud that's still trailing you around. There has to be a better way to deal with it. You consider stuffing it into your Soul Gem for now, and while your instincts tell you that it's possible they also tell you a better way is possible. You frown at the cloud, forcing your will upon it, and it compresses down, coalescing down into the now-familiar deep purple solid, before crunching down even further into a tiny, solid marble.

You tentatively poke at the marble with your finger, but it seems inert, and doesn't make your finger glow purple or anything. Shrugging, you pocket the marble.

Morning ablutions done, you wander over to the kitchen. "Good morning, Mami!" you greet cheerfully.

This early in the morning, Mami's hair lies limp and slightly bedraggled instead of her usual drill style. "Hm? Good morning, Sabrina," she replies, somewhat blearily, eyes staring dully at the mixing bowl in front of her. Her hands move with practiced motions, and yet... you watch as she misses the edge of the bowl with an egg twice in a row.

Not a morning person?

"Here, let me help with that," you say, gently grabbing the egg and bumping Mami out of the way. "Pancakes?"

You take the muffled grumble Mami makes as a yes, supressing a grin at the distinctly un-Mami noise. Not a morning person, then. She wanders off into the living room and collapses on the couch.

Two minutes later, she apparently startles awake, and bustles back into the kitchen, this time looking considerably more alert. "Ah, Sabrina? You shouldn't..."

"No, it's alright," you say, busily mixing the batter. From the flour and butter and various other ingredients strewn around, it seems that Mami had been making pancakes. There's also a ricecooker, already out and running, presumably to prepare lunch.

"I'm the host here," the blonde counters, moving around you to grab the frying pan in preparation.

"It's the least I can do, after all, you're providing me lodging," you return, conceding the pancake batter to Mami, since she's already holding the pan and brandishing the spatula. Instead, you move over to check the rice.

"But you're helping me with the Witch hunting, and Soul Gem cleansing, too," Mami says, now expertly flipping the pancakes.

You decide not to answer that, and instead divert it with, "Hey, where do you keep the sesame seeds?"

Mami shakes her head lightly, but answers you anyway. "Uh, on your left... no, up one drawe- That one, yes."

With two people working together, breakfast, and lunch, doesn't take long to prepare. You both sit down in front of a gently steaming stack of pancakes, and you slide a lunchbox over to Mami.

After some contented chewing on the delightful, fluffy pancakes, she looks up at you. "So you'll be going to Shirome today, correct?"

"Yes, I suppose so," you confirm.

"Ok, you'll need a bit of money, and, ah, I forgot to pass you the spare house key yesterday..." Mami muses.

You nod. "Thank you again, Mami, and sorry for all the trouble."

"It really isn't any trouble at all," Mami reassures you.

After finishing breakfast, Mami prepares to leave for school. You're amused to note that she uses her magic to style her hair into the drill shapes, but you're soon leaving the house along side her.

"Ah... You'll want to take a right here, and catch a bus towards Shirome," Mami says as the two of you pass a junction. "You can check the bus routes on the back of the bus stop."

"Ok," you acknowledge. "I'll see you after school today, if something doesn't come up?"

"Yes, see you, Sabrina," Mami replies, before remembering something. "Oh! As a magical girl, you can communicate with other magical girls and potentials by telepathy. Call me if there's anything, OK?" she adds telepathically.

"Like this? Ah, I see," you return in the same manner. "See you later, Mami."

"See you!" she calls cheerfully, waving at you.

It doesn't take very long for the bus to arrive, and when it does, it's nearly empty. You lean back in the seat and close your eyes, enjoying the smooth ride, until someone sits down next to you.

You crack open your eyes and look at the intruder.

It's a girl, dressed in a chestnut red sailor uniform. Vaguely, you recognize it as the school uniform for Shirome.

Rather more attention grabbing, however, is her light grey hair and sea-green eyes. One aristocratic eyebrow is arched at you, and an amused smirk tugs at her lips.

Oriko.

"Hello, Sabrina."

[] AAAAAAAAAAAAH
[] AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
[] NOPE
[] Dive out of the bus.
[] Write-in


=====​

I'll be honest. I'm surprised no one brought up the fact that Shirome is Oriko's school...

And I'm not sure why Sabrina is one of those rare few bastards people who can be bright and peppy in the morning, but, well, apparently she is. And morning Mami is... well.
 
Last edited:
[q] AAAAAAAAAAAAH
-[q] AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
--[q] NOPE
---[q] Dive out of the bus.


[x] Hi! How did you know my name? Do I know you?
 
...Right, the game's up. We're rumbled in every single way possible.


[x] AAAAAAAAAAAAH
[x] AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
[x]Poker face. POKER FACE. POKER FACE. Breathe.
Forced casual.
[x]...Hey. Oriko, is it?
-[x]Soul gem in ring form if it isn't- and it should be.
-[x]Have we met before? What'd she want to talk about?
-[x]Glance for Kirika, not that you're guaranteed to know her if you see her. Ask Oriko where her friend is.
-[x]If she spills the beans about "saving the world"/makes it clear she's onto us...
--[x]Is this the bit where the villain tells us her evil scheme? Keep her talking.
---[x]It won't work. Too many loose ends, too many pointless diversions, and Kyubey's playing her for a fool.
---[x]What is wrong with her? She knows killing people is wrong and there's a better way, so why would she even consider the plan with a huge body count and at least three guaranteed murders?
---[x]Have you seen a happy ending for you in the future if you do this? Even once?
-[x]If things go sour, convert the grief marble and dump directly into Oriko's gem, then run like hell. Out through the window if you have to.
 
Last edited:
Why panic, why not fake ignorance?
Because Oriko isn't stupid. She addressed Sabrina by name, indicating she at least knows things she has no right to know, and her confronting us is definitely going to be part of a plan.

Meaning we're either in trouble, the rest of the cast is in trouble, or this is the mandatory "villain chats with the hero" scene.

In any event, this is our chance to try and get answer/install some self-doubt and/or a deathtrap.
 
Back
Top