Whoops. Fixed.
Thing is, when you pray to something, you're expecting it to act nondeterministically. You expect it to respond to your prayer, and not just carry on like clockwork. That interferes with science if the thing is your representation of the natural world.
Edit: This isn't a problem for most religions; their god isn't directly the natural world. It would pose a problem for a few, like pantheism.
False actually.
Our current example of major religious behavior is the Sacred Warding ritual. This ritual exists in three parts:
-The passing of the curse. In this ritual, the shamans will take select young cows from the Sacred Herds and pass the curse through them using needles from other cursed cows.
-The protection of the curse. The shamans will take this curse and transfer it to People using needles. After suffering the cow-curse, and recovering, the People will be protected by the Star Pox.
-The price of the curse. In order to make room for the Sacred Herds, the young cows must be slaughtered after the curse fades from them. As a result, we must identify the finest cows of the Sacred Herds so that we may ensure that we give thanks to the cow spirits for their gift of the warding.
The entire ritual is expected to be deterministic.
Our shamans are willing to adapt or abandon rituals that don't work. Our people perform prayers because they hope for effectiveness, but as they lack the tools to understand whether it's because the prayers are lacking or whether the prayers don't do anything, they take it on faith.
Rituals are the way we intervene in the natural world. Some rituals are simple enough that anyone taught properly can perform them, such as cooking ore to make metal, or letting grapes rot to produce wine.
Other rituals interacting with the soul are the domain of the shamans and priests to intercede with the spirits, we know for instance, certain chants can sooth the possessed and spiritually disturbed, we know that tattoos and needles can be used to effect changes upon a person.
I think we need to swap to megaproject support. Working these out by inches is tying us down for way too long, and we're losing a possible secondary each turn from Law while on balanced.
Well...AN also mentioned that we could have had a really exciting time if we rushed the temple, because instead of gradual religious debate while the priests hammer out what we believe in, we'd cram a hundred years of religious debate and thought of how to build the temple into thirty.
Expect some of the cut and thrust of debate to become literal.
I think this means we should be careful about always rushing projects that aren't just raw works of engineering.
-The Library is probably fine, but in the rush to write EVERYTHING down, some incidents may occur with the writing process. Though I don't see any incidents that would hurt it's functionality, just generate some events while we deal with quadrupling the number of scribes over the course of a generation.
-The Dam/Mountain should be fine, with Dam being slightly riskier if we take less than 3 turns to do it, since we might not be giving the soil and bedrock enough time to adjust to the water burden. Unlikely to matter, we have a lot of experience at this.
-The Place to the Stars should be fine. Construction might not account properly for long term patterns unless we have a 5+ Study Stars streak maintained though.
-Grand Palace should not be rushed for the same reasons as Great Temple, there will be administrative changes involved in the process, and we'd need the time to adjust for bad decisions along the way.
-The Games really should not be rushed. It's a social engineering project.
HOWEVER, rushing the final stretch isn't so bad.
Pretty sure Study Stars is how we get Calendars. Note how we actually can't make more festivals anymore, instead we just improve our existing ones.
Agreed, you really can't add more festivals until you improve timekeeping, and timekeeping is advanced through astrology.
Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all have the single god doing everything. And each has cultures that provided major scientific advancements.
Yes. But none of them HAVE a clockwork god. None of them have a god that is "alien, but knowable", or that represents nature.
Actually:
-Medieval Christian alchemists searched through the Bible for ways to interpret the universe through the Word of God. God was considered to be unknown(in fact, Alien and Unknowable describes the early periods pretty well), but that you could find patterns in nature through the hand of God the Creator. They actually managed to discover a lot about Chemistry by trying to backsolve random bible ciphers into chemical formulas. Other Christian scholars did the same with divine numerology and geometry.
-Early Islamic Scholars felt that advancing their understanding of God without a Prophet bringing His Word directly must be done through the study of the world and reality itself through geometry, patterns and naturalism, as God's hand and breath shapes all things.
-Jewish study of the Kabbalah did a lot with mathematics as well.
-Taoist Scholars engaged in astrology, chemistry, pharmacology and numerology in their quest to approach the alien but knowable Absolute, which was the most important and unapproachable, potentially non-sentient force in the universe, but responded to the proper rituals and forms.
--Though in a funny evolution of things, it changed to literal forms. Taoist talismans are caligraphic command/requests to the spirits structured like imperial edicts, complete with a seal of the divine court stamped to mark that it is properly filed.
---Yes, you change the weather by submitting your properly filled requisition forms for particular kinds of weather, then burning it with the proper amounts of bribes and offerings in the hope of intervention. Your form might still be rejected if it's against divine policy or if you screwed up and pissed off one of the mid level functionaries who 'misfile' it. Or if someone else had a better bribe or form.
----Forged forms exist.
----Every year the inspector of the gods is bribed with sweet sticky cake so he can't talk about your misdeeds by dint of being too busy chewing through the stuff.
----Sun Wukong obtained long lives for his entire tribe of monkeys by destroying the census of destined death, so the system can't figure out when they are supposed to die and never come around to collect until it's too late.