I never said physically dangerous. I said dangerous for his surroundings. You understand there's a difference, right? This old-as-fuck dragon that's been around for hundreds of years likely knows a ton of stuff that would be extremely dangerous in the wrong hands, not to mention the secrets he might've uncovered from our mind.
If the dragon knew the secrets we
really don't want found, he would have every reason to use them right now to turn the others against us. Most of his other knowledge is harmless as long as he's kept among saiyans.
...For that matter, if we were worried about the dragon spilling the beans about the conspiracy, we could just give the chibi dragon to Apra to keep for a while! She already knows the conspiracies we're engaged in, and approves, and clearly doesn't want the dragon talking because she's the one who voted for "seal him inside a rock and sink him in the ocean."
Furthermore, I've been reading through the same thread as you and I'm not seeing the power-argument being the primary reason why people vote for head-dragon. It's a consideration but the most liked pro head-dragon posts haven't had that as their central theme.
It was the (spoilery)
origin of the head-dragon vote. It explicitly motivates a significant fraction of the head-dragon voters, without whom the vote would not have a realistic chance of winning. And it continues to be advanced in various forms.
There are other motives for head-sealing the dragon, but most of them don't make sense
as motivations for Kakara that predominate her decision.
If she wants the dragon silenced she should seal it in a rice cooker and bury it somewhere a few miles underground, not keep it in her head to learn
more secrets while she has to watch it continuously.
If she wants the dragon reformed she should be willing to let it interact with other largely virtuous saiyans.
There are, in turn,
counter-reasons for not doing these things and we can chase ourselves round and round about them. But by and large, the only specific motivation that is strongly served by this action for Kakara, that reflects at least a significant fraction of the support for the vote choice,
and that cannot be more effectively served by Kakara acting differently... is the gain in power and knowledge from having the dragon inside her head.
There are a lot of what ifs in this situation. Coming down on a trait evolution of all the things that might go wrong (all of which that would impact quest enjoyment for various people ofc) feels like reaching for me.
My reason for talking about trait evolution isn't because it's the only thing that might go wrong, it's because we can confidently predict that trait evolution is going to happen here. And the single trait most likely to be affected by
this decision is the one that so critically influences whether or not the decision even happens: Ambitious.
I agree with this completely. Head seal makes it harder for Dandeer to directly oppose us via magic (what if some spell messes with the seal) and all of that. I hadn't thought about the extra power giving us a better chance to resist, but given how Jaffur was able to fight the seal (for a brief period) using SS form, you might be onto something.
We don't get access to the dragon's power from this deal unless we make the seal highly permeable and give the dragon access to power, at which point the dragon may simply be able to
meat-puppet us because we just unsealed its psychic abilities while it was inside our mind.
[And people are still telling me this isn't about getting a powerup! Sure, it may not be about the power-up
for them, but that doesn't mean it isn't about that for everyone...]
This is incorrect. If we seal him inside of us, it's been stated that we can let him out at any point. Obviously, that means that if we're going to be too old, it's a simple matter to either go Spirit Saiyan again and reseal him in the exact same way. This is actually simpler than ever breaking the seal on his chibi form (assuming that the point of this is actually rehabilitation and not just blowing smoke).
I would be well content to rehabilitate the dragon
without breaking chibi form. Or saying "well, dragon, YOU were the one that killed a dozen planets, spending centuries in a chibi form is your punishment for that whether you're a nice person now or not." It would hardly be an unfairly heavy penance to pay.
What, for this not being Naruto? Because, um... it's not. The rules are different, there's no reason to expect sealed ancient evils to be tappable for power in this setting as they are in that one.
Or for us not getting control of the dragon's power? Well, we got a fairly detailed explanation of how the seal works, and it included
nothing about us being able to access the dragon's power without giving the dragon control over that power.
Mostly my worry about the Chibi option is the possibility that he might just fall by the wayside in favour of more rewarding options.
Given our ability to lock him inside a box in our head and leave him there for the rest of our lives under the head-seal option, why would this
NOT be a problem with head-sealing?
I mean, at least if he's a chibi dragon, other people can interact with him when we're too busy to do so for weeks or months at a time. He may be unpopular in doing so, but he
could. In theory. As a head-dragon, he's trapped in a featureless prison cell whenever that happens. No way out, no way to even ask Kakara to be allowed to talk to her if Kakara just locks down the seal to block him out.
Are you being purposefully obtuse?
Why yes, yes I am. How perspicacious of you to notice.
As to the rest of what you said, we have at least one person who we know could take charge of watching the chibi-dragon who already knows our only really damaging secrets and is in fact one of our co-conspirators: Apra. In a few years after the Sealing is undone, that secret becomes irrelevant and we can start dealing with chibi-Dazarel ourself.
Which actually strikes me as a good plan, because
we have too much on our plate. I don't want our attempts to reform Dazarel
right now to distract us from getting Jaffur un-sealed*. I don't care if he's immediately available or not because we have so many options for researching power-ups and techniques and so much to do that dealing with him isn't actually a priority.
But if it's years before we have time to focus some attention on him, I don't want him spending those years locked inside a bottle in our mind and having time to marinate in that situation.
________________________
*(Or offend Jaffur
by having us visit him with a dragon trapped inside a seal the next time we meet him; that's been mentioned before. And I can't remember anyone explaining why Jaffur is likely to be anything other than upset at the idea of people locking the dragon inside a sealing bottle much as he was locked away.)