But for the most part we aren't planning on killing her at all, let alone for those reasons. We just don't want to try to talk someone down after they've already shown they are not going to stop.
Yeah, I'm not really on board with any plan that involves diplomacy. That's already been tried, and Evelyn is just not in the right headspace for it to take effect. Killing her, however, is too extreme. Maybe she'll get put down later, but it won't be by us. Doing so would send all kinds of signals to the nation (and, by extension, the other kings), most of which that I'm pretty sure we don't want to send. Keep it in the cards as an absolute last resort if all else fails, but don't keep it as anything else. Absolute last resort only.
Also, nwish is right. Kill or talk are not our only two options. They may be limited, but there are more than just two. We just gotta get creative!
And in my plans I am not seriously relying on talking. At best talking can help us stall for a time, either for reinforcement or to move everyone out of building so we can collapse it on Evelyn if all else does not work. If you look closely with exception of my very first suggested plan I don't have Mirage doing talking to her, so it is not like I actually spend actual manpower on it or expect big results from it. I don't see why people are stuck on diplomacy as if it some key element of approach. I mean I named some of my plans as such but it is just a name in the end.
Here is another edition without even mention of talking that for some reason are such concern for people. Frankly I don't consider it as critical element of any of my plans so it is not hard for me to remove this part. If anyone interested in one of previous variants they are free to pick up them.
Short description
Plan A. Marco and Hego beat Evelyn with Lizzy and Mez as support
Plan B. Mez openly hypnotize Evelyn while using dropped by Evelyn tech to obscure her own ability to use mind control
Plan C. Lizzy drops roof on Evelyn
Plan D. We run away leaving Evelyn to authorities.
Long description
[] Plan: Removing all leads v2
-[] Have Marco help Hego to knock out Evelyn , with Lizzy and Mez as support. Task Mez with making sure that Evelyn does not speak about Mirage history. Interrupt her, subtly hypnotize or even nonlethaly shoot at her if all else does not help to keep Evelyn quiet. Accuse Evelyn of attempts to hypnotize her audience if Mez needs to make explanations for her interruptions. Try to keep Mirage from Evelyn attention.
-[]While Evelyn distracted by fighting have Mez and Mirage recover dropped by Evelyn mind control goggles. Then make it look like Mez is using them on Evelyn to hypnotize her into surrounding while actually using her own powers. If it does not work stall for a time, have Lizzy use her bugs to move unconscious supers from hall, then have her bugs chew on what is left of support columns to bring roof on Evelyn. Hopefully Hego or Marco will protect Winston if he does not leave by then. With early warning Mez can use wings to take Mirage and fly out of it. If it is not enough and Evelyn still keep going seems like a good time to run away and leave her to authorities.
-[]If Evelyn subdued one way or another attempt to gain her custody. Bring out possibility that unstable powers are detrimental to her health and she needs to be immediately checked at genetic research facility. Plus if she needs medical help her powers can prevent normal equipment from working. You have sufficient lab, but if others don't trust you entirely it can be collaboration with Liv Amara assuming you can still find her in the aftermath.
-[]Try to recover Sinatron processor on the basis of needing to learn what exactly he injected Evelyn with and where he acquired it.
-[]If Evelyn successfully captured make sure that she does not awaken until her powers are dealt with or she is not in the position to use them. Decide on her future fate depending on what was said or done during fight. Make sure to gather all available information from her or from Sinatron databases to recover both her secret tech and information that she possess on you so you have option to secretly visit Syndrom island and remove all data on Mirage that he kept there. Or ask Jumba if he have anything that can remove islands from maps.