Man, I can't believe it's been 10 years already. I remember picking this quest up one day in my way to University. Now I've got a degree and a job. Wild how time flies but, somehow, you've managed to keep it going @Firnagzen ! Congratulations, and may we one day see the ending you have for us.
 
I've lurked since around 2022, (or maybe 2021?). I made this account because I wanted to watch the thread and keep up with the updates instead of constantly having a tab open. I'm glad to have been here.

This story was what got me into PMMM. I initially read it blind and was very confused on what was happening, but the quality was great and I loved the characters so I stuck around. I eventually inferred enough to understand the plot. After I while, I started watching PMMM for the first time and read some other PMMM fanfics before looking back at my old inferences and wondering what I was smoking at the time. Still good with a different perspective, though, and I had a good chuckle.

Glad to see that the story's still going on strong after 10 years. Looking forward to more.
 
Last edited:
This epilogue just gave me diabetes so powerful it manifested like a Stand and proceeded to beat me to death. This is the only way to go I can accept!

Genuinely brightened my day, I am sitting here with the dumbest smile ever on my face. Thank you for THE quest of PMMM, @Firnagzen!
 
The following are factoids I choose to believe


- Good Morning Mitakihara continues to be the most popular morning talkshow in Meguca Japan

- Warehouse-kun was eventually condemned and torn down, the site is today home to a State of the Art Meguca Science Lab and Training Facility

- The Truancy Officer Officiated Mami and Sabrinas wedding

- Feathers wrote a Tell All semiautobiography and topped the Tokyo Best Seller list for six non consecutive weeks, before retiring in obscurity

- Sabrinas bid for reelection to public Meguca office on a campaign that is just "Pants" is currently losing ground to Orikos Hat in the polls.
 
- Warehouse-kun was eventually condemned and torn down, the site is today home to a State of the Art Meguca Science Lab and Training Facility
The Witchcraft Advanced Research Environment for Harnessing the Occult and Unconventional Schoolgirl Education.
"A little, yeah," Sabrina says, bouncing lightly on her feet. "Mami's still setting things up with Sayaka."

"We were awake. I'm surprised you're not with her." Homura gives her best friend a measured look, to which Sabrina just shrugs, and grins.

"Mami chased me off," she admits easily.
I love that ten years later a Sabrina sighting without Mami is still a rare occurrence.
 
The Witchcraft Advanced Research Environment for Harnessing the Occult and Unconventional Schoolgirl Education.
(Pictured: A junkyard.)

"Just think of it as saving on the cost of maintenance and repairs after particularly volatile experiments slash training sessions. Also in the grant submission make sure to refer to the landfill part as a dynamic surface hostile barrier simulator."

Edit:
That should be:
Dynamic Aggregate Surface Hostile Barrier Overload Acclimitization Remotely Driven Simulator.
 
Last edited:
Ten years already? Good grief how time flies. Been lurking for about eight years, made this account after years of manually checking the thread to actually Watch it.

Haven't ever voted on any plans, because for most of my history I've been reading late on nightshifts (and doubt any ideas would be great at the best of times), but its been a delight reading both the story itself, and the thread, for all its ups and downs, you can easily see how much care is in both.

A few months after I started reading the thread, my partner of five years left on bad terms, saddling me with debt that meant I had to change jobs and eventually move house. For a long time that left me in a bad place, working horrendous hours just to make ends meet, and so much less trusting of my fellows.
But eight years later, in a better job, a nicer house, with more friends, and ready to take chances on new relationships even while also being happy single, and I can sincerely say that in part, it was all of you that helped get me here. For so long this story, this thread, the discussion around it, the arguements and agreements, the valuable insight everyone has had that helped me look back on my own circumstances, my own relationships, the scars left behind, what was and what wasn't my fault in all of those.. You all have been a constant fixture in tumultuous times.

This story is all about helping, even saving people. That it's each and every individual that matters. Well, as someone who was helped, maybe even saved in part by all of you, it, you, all really do help.

So thank you, for helping me break out the system I was stuck in, and I hope that all of the rest of you who need help get it.

Thank you to Firn, and to all you other posters and lurkers. For so many years gone already, and many more to come.
 
Goddess- it's been a good while since I caught up to this- I still haven't, with everything going on, but it feels so wild how long this has gone on, I hope it continues on until that happy ending for everyone.

I feel kinda bad about just- Iunno, I didn't feel like I know enough to really vote on things, and then while waiting for updates I ended up busy with things and basically just hit a pause on keeping up with things and I'm still busy, just feels like I have to block out a good chunk of time not worrying about other stuff to give it a good readthrough- still, I do trust that everyone else knows enough to do them justice, I'm rooting for all of y'all, especially Firn for writing all this time

I'll have to get back to some other things but- I hope that I can catch up to this again sometime, it's wonderful stuff, all this, I look forward to it. Take care!
 
Hmm

Been a while, hasn't it? A measure of dedication.

I wouldn't say that this is my favorite, or even that it's been all that important to me. But, regardless, reading these other posts makes me think of the fact that this *is* really important to people. That people have loved and enjoyed it, made it part of them. But I have liked this enough to keep going, keep reading, even voting from time to time. So you have my gratitude.

People have found value, found change, in this. Reminds me of my relationship with PMMM. I love it, obviously, obsessed enough to find my way all the way down here. But . . . It's been a while. A long, long while. And so my emotions have faded, worn away . . . I care less now. A whole lot less. Perhaps it's just become a part of me, perhaps I've forgotten, perhaps something else has taken its place. Like, I've been reading lots of webnovels (Nowhere Stars in particular- it definitely has Madoka DNA and is getting a proper published version soon) and things of that nature.

I've changed- actually, I'm going through a big change right now. And, you know what, I'm greatful that this is here. Sure it's more of a distraction, sure I don't get much besides idle entertainment— but I need that right now. So . . .

Honestly, I don't know what I was trying to say. Maybe it was something like, "I'm glad that this exists."
 
I haven't quite been here for the full ten years, but this story still has the honor of being my longest open tab, to the point that it's outlived one of my phones completely.

It's been an excellent ride so far, with some excellent people adding to it. Here's to another ten years, unless of course Firn manages the miracle of actually finishing before then.
 
Huh, ten years huh

i haven't been here since the very start, and kinda fell off from the later parts

but still, being able to be in the longest running ridehas been, quite excellent if i sure say off myself, i hope that we can stay until the very end
 
10 years and I was here for.... checks real quick... seven of them holy crap. It's been a a hell of a journey even if I've been a massive lurker for most of it lol.
 
I marathoned most of this thread over the course of a summer to catch up. I'm no ten-year vet, but I've still lurked around here for a while.
 
I joined the quest when my previous quest, Magical Girl Escalation Taylor, died. I read many stories, but I try to only participate in a single quest. I have enough issues keeping things stra--- organized* in my head without conflicting vote strategies getting in the way. I'm not voting much now because I know I stink at social stuff, so am saving my votes for when I have something to add to the conversation.

*Hey, there's not a lot of "straight" characters running around in this story.
 
I would say "here's to 10 more!" but hopefully it doesn't take that long to finish this :V

Anyway, thanks ro Firn for starting this and sticking to it! This helped get me into questing, and even though I don't participate much anymore, I still look forward to each update.
 
Adhoc vote count started by StellarMonarch on May 24, 2024 at 12:40 AM, finished with 148 posts and 6 votes.

  • [X] Make some calls
    -[X] Ask if Rin is willing to help Niko with the Soujus victims
    --[X] Offer financial compensation?
    -[X] Contact the Murasaki Shrine Maidens and schedule a meeting for tomorrow
    --[X] Consult Yuki, should we ask to claim a building now or later? Also, the omiki thing
    --[X] Ask if there are any other groups they're acquainted with that might want to join the meeting
    --[X] Decide whether to meet them on the way to the Kagoshima group meeting or on the way back.
    [X] Make some purchases
    -[X] Get the cake for Kagoshima
    -[X] Snacks and drinks for the upcoming trips
    -[X] Picture frames to bring home and a camera
    -[X] A gift for Nagisa and Mr Momoe?
    -[X] A perch for Mugin
    [X] Visit the Iowa group leader
    [X] While we're there, we should chat with Yuki if she's available
    -[X] Pick Yuki's brain about how to build our eventual moon colony (our ulterior motives may involve dates with Mami on the moon)
    -[X] H-hugs?
    [X] Track down Kyouko and Yuma
    -[X] Figure out whether Kyouko and Yuma want Yuma to go to school
    --[X] Offer some alternatives if traditional schooling doesn't appeal: we could also try online or home schooling
    -[X] Either way, introduce Kyouko to our hackerguca so she can deal with Yuma's legal guardianship


Next update should take us through the calls and the shopping.
 
Idle thought, I really want to see what happens when there are multiple power boosters in the same room. So far there's the Iowa girl, Sayaka and Kazumi who copied her powers and then the Murasaki girls have a magic amplifier.

I want to see if we can do the Skyrim exploit and have the girls boost each other over and over. Probably doesn't work but sounds interesting

What happens if Sabrina, Sayaka, Homura, Mami, Yuki (etc) gets a boost?

What happens if multiple power boosters apply their buffs to one girl?
 
Last edited:
Idle thought, I really want to see what happens when there are multiple power boosters in the same room. So far there's the Iowa girl, Sayaka and Kazumi who copied her powers and then the Murasaki girls have a magic amplifier.

I want to see if we can do the Skyrim exploit and have the girls boost each other over and over. Probably doesn't work but sounds interesting

What happens if Sabrina, Sayaka, Homura, Mami, Yuki (etc) gets a boost?

What happens if multiple power boosters apply their buffs to one girl?

Think about Madoka, who Witched out after a single attack, thanks to the sheer power involved. A feedback loop might fill everybody involved's soul gems faster than even Sabrina can clear them.

I assume you'd cap at the sum of their individual buffs instead of being able to buff buffing a buffed buff.

Depends on exactly how things work, but yeah, I doubt a programming exploit is going to work, and that may be a good thing.
 
Last edited:
Think about Madoka, who Witched out after a single attack, thanks to the sheer power involved. A feedback loot might fill everybody involved's soul gems faster than even Sabrina can clear them.
Very important to consider. Mana bars don't "empty out" in PMMM, they fill up with soul-poison. The best attacks aren't always the most powerful, but the most cost efficient, or ones that simply have special effects that pierce or bypass defenses.

I'm about to re-read the Tokyo council meeting, but I'm 99% sure the Not-a-Meguca leader instantly-almost-witches out one of her friends/power batteries/magical fuses when Sabrina breaks her magic, and that's the kind of thing we don't want Sayaka and the others to accidently do, even with a clear seed duct taped to their Soul Gems. Even if it is more likely that the buffs don't cause a Restoration Potion effect.
 
Still want to experiment with familiars.

There is a few things we could try first like making a Meseeks box though a pokeball with a pokemon inside would be better.

Other precautions would be having backup with us and time stop ready.

Many fear the whole witch thing but keep in mind these familiars would not belong to our witch, thats bot how our powers work, the stuff we make isnt owned by our witch. Our barrier was ours sonething that sabrina made very clear and even stated that felt different from normal witch barriers because it was hers.

The familiars would be Sabrina's familiars not delolere.

And I have a good feeling that they should be capable of leaving our range which would be great for us.

The only thing that could be of worry is the upkeep they could have if we overdo it, since magic is still used to make them unlike normal familiars.
 
Still want to experiment with familiars.
As long as we take appropriate precautions, I'm fine with doing that. But I am going to insist on said precautions.
Once again, Meseeks are beings for whom existence is suffering, and who will do whatever it takes so they can finally die and end that suffering. The entire concept is a moral nightmare, much like most stuff in Rick and Morty. We should avoid that concept as a base for any of our constructs.
The familiars would be Sabrina's familiars not delolere.
We won't know that until we make one, which is why we should prepare for the possibility they will be Dedolore's familiars even if that's unlikely. We'll want a containment sphere of grief in a vacuum to deal with the risk of it accidentally igniting the atmosphere like Sabrina could do casually at any time, enough backup to be able to take on what might be on the level of a Clara Doll, and before we even consider it, we need to try feeding Grief to a normal familiar to make sure that a familiar that inherited our Grief bending wouldn't be able to just instantly mature itself into a Witch without needing to kill people. And of course, we need Sabrina plugged into a Clear Seed and our friends ready to kill the familiar in case the feedback we got when we tried to hyjack a familiar hits us with one we created and we're not mentally up to breaking the connection when it happens.

I still think we should do more basic research and just asking our friends questions about familiars before we try to make our own, since Sabrina is the most dangerous person to be doing that sort of experiment.

I also think we should avoid going for "familiar" in our initial griefhax attempts in the direction of "familiars". That is to say, "fly" instead of "fly familiar", and see if what comes out is a familiar or if it's something else. If it is a familiar, we'll have learned something and established a level of control over the form of the familiar that we wouldn't otherwise have been sure of. If it isn't a familiar, we'll be no worse off for having made the attempt.

Might also be worth considering that a Witch Kiss might be a safer thing to attempt than a standard familiar. Our analysis of a Witch Kiss indicated it had a similar structure and composition to a familiar, but we've never heard of a witch kissed individual maturing into a Witch or a Witch Kissed individual becoming independent of its Witch, thought that again is something we ought to ask more knowledgeable people about before jumping to conclusions.

Either way, we never actually figured out how to make a familiar when we were researching the matter earlier. So doing more observation of existing familiars is required before we'll even be in a position to try to create one of our own anyway. Similar to how we needed to observe barriers in detail before we could figure out how to make one ourselves.
 
Back
Top