Hell, how would you define Kirika's powers if they are "anti-magic"? She uses magic that eliminates magic? Is it some kind of selective nullification magic, or is it something distinctly different from magic and grief altogether?
You're talking about this question like Kirika has some kind of answer. Kirika, a girl so uninterested in experimentation that her solution to dealing with a witch she couldn't cut with her claws was to make even bigger claws.
 
[x] Muramasa

The interesting thing about Kirikas power is that it doesn't seem to affect things that were created by magic.
In the fight Mami's ribbons only go limp and don't disappear:
Mami's ribbons go limp, losing their animation.

It also only kills the time stop magic from Homuras shield, but not the shield itself:
A shriek of clashing gears and flying sparks from Homura's shield.

Time restarts, colour spinning back into the world as Homura looks at her shield in shock. Even through the tears in your eyes, you can see some of the gears glowing red hot and the shield vibrating madly on her arm.

Our grief cloud dissipates when the anti-magic hits, but I don't think the grief itself disappeared, only the magic.
It just isn't a stable construct without the magic binding it together, similar to how she melts witches.
But doesn't make them disappear outright.
The pulse tears the control of the Grief cloud away from you, and the cloud dissipates.

If Kirika has to fight a magical girl that relies on premade weaponry or super strength or something like that, her anti-magic could be useless.

Edit: Something else I just noticed: Homura's hammerspace didn't get affected by the anti-magic zone. Maybe it only works on active abilities and not passive ones, like shield storage?
 
Last edited:
To be honest, that we were able to take down Kirika with the Warhammer and one good grief marble shot, even if she was distracted by Homura gunning down Oriko, shows that her anti-magic is a great ability, but can be worked around.
 
[x] Muramasa

I kinda want to leave a post-it note on the clone explaining what happened. Assuming the clone didn't just poof into thin air or melt.
 

... It'd be bad form for me to be insufferably smug at this point, wouldn't it. Fuck. :sad:

Most of the short-term actions look great, except for -
--[x] Who were those girls, and why was that group after you?
--[x] The Tohoku and Fukushima group? Why are they involved in this?
- this. Homura specifically wasn't willing to discuss it over a telepathic party line, what could possibly make you think that discussing it openly in front of Mami is a good idea? Do a couple of high-altitude transsonic Crazy Ivans or something to throw off pursuit, set down somewhere random, and ask to speak to Akiko alone.

As for actually ending the war, I think I've got the beginnings of a maybe-workable plan.
Okay. At this point, we have massive leverage over the Sendai group (we could make them virtually immortal, we could join the other side and doom them, and they probably currently think they owe us their lives. If we tell them to jump, they will jump or give us a fucking good reason not to) - but none over its opponents.
However! Sendai aren't the aggressors. There's no action we can ask them to take that'll end the war in a way we're happy with. (Bar a couple of long-shot options that we're not desperate enough for yet - exile, faked deaths, anything like that).
So; how do we turn the leverage we have into a war-ending bargaining position?
We can take them over. Talk Akiko into taking a demotion, and take direct personal responsibility for them.
Then, we go to their opponents in a spirit of sincere regret and contrition. Our subordinates have erred, and we cannot permit them to be harmed. We're going to be dealing with a Walpurgisnacht soon, and need cannon fodder. They owe us. We have territory to hold, and obligations to keep. Whatever reasonably-plausible excuse or combination of excuses, we just need them alive.
However, we also acknowledge the need to make amends, and are willing to offer effectively limitless reparations as long as the hostilities end.
We're personally dangerous enough and our support is valuable enough that, with a bit of luck, they'll take the deal.
 
We're doing fine. Backing out and not finding the problem isn't the answer. It's a risk but at this point, it's one we need to more or less take.
 
We're doing fine. Backing out and not finding the problem isn't the answer. It's a risk but at this point, it's one we need to more or less take.
... Are you reading completely different posts to the posts I'm posting?
I want to find out the problem in the immediate future. I just don't want to potentially witchbomb Mami on top of picking a fight with the local approximation of the forces of justice and righteousness.
"Hey, Homura?" you reach out again.

"Sabrina?" Homura sounds surprised to hear from you so soon.

"What did you mean, when you said that the Sendai girls aren't totally blameless?" you ask.

Homura doesn't respond immediately. "You should have asked before you left," she says tonelessly. "They were... not gentle about their... operations."
Or do you think Homura gave us that non-answer for no reason? :/
 
Remember what we thought of them when we thought they were going to take the 5 grief seeds and leave (and with a teleporter, there's no way that's legitimately the actual cost of their travel). How many other girls have they done that to without someone like us to intervene?

Plus, remember how we shadowderped about them killing off a rival healer when we were debating whether to talk about Yuma existing? We still don't technically know they don't do that.
 
... Are you reading completely different posts to the posts I'm posting?
I want to find out the problem in the immediate future. I just don't want to potentially witchbomb Mami on top of picking a fight with the local approximation of the forces of justice and righteousness.

Or do you think Homura gave us that non-answer for no reason? :/
Orrrrrrrr it could just be Homura being Homura. I find them making enemies through extortion more plausible than the witchbomb, and regardless, what makes you think we can get a private moment without triggering alarm bells for Mami right now?
 
@FlatlineAskari

I have some concerns about this clause, relating to a perception that this may create among the Ishinomaki meguca towards us.
We can easily make token resistance, argue the terms and sums to their heart's content. If they'll settle for no less, though, there's very little they can't demand of us in exchange for peace.
Orrrrrrrr it could just be Homura being Homura. I find them making enemies through extortion more plausible than the witchbomb, and regardless, what makes you think we can get a private moment without triggering alarm bells for Mami right now?
They have a lot of people gunning for them hard. Plenty of plausible reasons, very few of which we want Mami to hear. Mami won't be happy being (briefly) left watching over the rest with Kirika, but it beats the hell out of finding out the hard way that they're somewhat worse people than we thought.
 
They have a lot of people gunning for them hard. Plenty of plausible reasons, very few of which we want Mami to hear. Mami won't be happy being (briefly) left watching over the rest with Kirika, but it beats the hell out of finding out the hard way that they're somewhat worse people than we thought.
But we're not going to be able to hide the revelation by going with any plan that involves negotiation and if it's a worst case scenario, better to ask the people who aren't going to just blurt out the details of what happened after they refused to heal.
 
Back
Top