You know, on learning that the leader of Tokyo is named Akane, I find myself wondering.

Way back when, before PMAS, there was Sayakaquest. Which had much the same community as PMAS, especially early PMAS, including Firn himself. And it had a Tokyo girl by the name of Akane too.

So I find myself wondering if this Akane is also a punch-guca.
everyones favorite Muscle-Wizard
Adhoc vote count started by Firnagzen on Feb 19, 2019 at 6:31 PM, finished with 149660 posts and 2 votes.

  • [X] The question of who gets aid first shouldn't be an actual issue. You have a teleporting cloner. There are entirely too many ways to leverage that so that each group gets a single clear seed at the exact same time.
    [x] Ask if the Tokyo Council has rules regarding mercenary work; fighting, evacuations, consultation, and things of that nature. Mitakihara has an emergency due at

Adhoc vote count started by Firnagzen on Feb 19, 2019 at 6:31 PM, finished with 149660 posts and 2 votes.

  • [X] The question of who gets aid first shouldn't be an actual issue. You have a teleporting cloner. There are entirely too many ways to leverage that so that each group gets a single clear seed at the exact same time.
    [x] Ask if the Tokyo Council has rules regarding mercenary work; fighting, evacuations, consultation, and things of that nature. Mitakihara has an emergency due at
 
We'll want to ask more about these "problem" groups.

This is also goot indicator who knows about lichbomb (probably rather common knowledge) and witchbomb. I think the "agresive" or "conspiratory" groups knew full truth or are led by girls knowing it. The "leaders" who know about witchbomb also know that they live on borrowed time - and are more and more desperate while searching for ANY solution that will help them. Some will welcome Sabrina as their Salvation, some will be cynical about her and some will have their own bizarre plans in motion (see Kamehameha's magical girls in Magia Record for example).
Adhoc vote count started by Firnagzen on Feb 20, 2019 at 11:18 PM, finished with 149681 posts and 12 votes.

  • [X] Enjoy your coffee. This is some damn good coffee, just how you like it.
    [X] Ask more questions, and let Sayaka do the same.
    [X] Ask more about the politics of the Council. Example questions:
    -[X] Is the desire of some groups to unseat Toshimichi based on personal grievances, or just general chafing under authority?
    -[X] Do multiple group representatives form larger "voting blocs" in the Council regarding certain issues?
    --[X] If so, what are the main voting blocs? Any major players or "meta-factions" we should be aware of?
    --[X] Do the "bloodthirsty" or "desperate" groups form a coherent bloc, or tear at each other too?
    --[X] Which blocs is Osaki part of?
    -[X] How dangerous are the "bloodthirsty" groups? Has there been actual violence?
    --[X] How does the Council actually enforce its rules? What happens if they're violated?
    -[X] What are the Council's restrictions on group behaviours outside of Tokyo?
    --[X] North Tokyo was hired by Sendai to aid in a conflict, are there any rules about mercenary work?
    [X] Ask about your proposal in particular. Example questions:
    -[X] Were there any proposals about how to accept your offer that seemed to be gaining general support?
    --[X] You could simply cleanse twenty seven seeds, then use Sayaka's cloning abilities to make sure every Tokyo team received a Clear Seed simultaneously.
    -[X] What are the main arguments against accepting your aid?
    --[X] You heard that the Meiji group rejected your offer entirely. Does Kurenai know why?
    [X] The question of who gets aid first shouldn't be an actual issue. You have a teleporting cloner. There are entirely too many ways to leverage that so that each group gets a single clear seed at the exact same time.
    [x] Ask if the Tokyo Council has rules regarding mercenary work; fighting, evacuations, consultation, and things of that nature. Mitakihara has an emergency due at
    [X] blank out for a moment
    [X] Hug Mumi. Mentally.
    [X] Enjoy your coffee. This is some damn good coffee, just how you like it.
    [X] Continue conversation, have Sayaka engage them too. Check consistent, complete information is present, follow up.
    -[X] Enjoy the coffee. Ask to sweep for Incubators.
    [X] Let us learn all rules that apply to Tokyo citizens? What about contracting abroad? Who is the girl holding foreign policy authority?
    [X] Detail the voting positions for and against our offer, who holds them, and outline the presumed motivations. Meji in particular. Who voted for our plan, or offered a substitute?
    [X] We would like introductions to every leader.
    [X] Ask for tour to Psychology Department. We wish to have business there.
    [X] Violence is part of Council debate? Define 'boodthirsty.' Can we hear some of the history? Kyuubey talks about Council matters?
    [X] Are there Council activities that don't relate to conflict? Are there taxes?
    [X] Enchanting - talk shop about baseline humans in the magic environment. Move topic to Soul Snuggles.
    [X] Redshirt arm
    [X] discreetly inquire as to who knows about the "facts of life" and whether it is public knowledge
 
Last edited:
Ah, I did forget about the Witch names. I'll add 'em next update.

It's not a problem; not like we have a particular need to worry about imposters here.

Hold the fuck up. I just realized something.

Okay. In the Sendai conflict, Akiko was attempting to hire on the North Tokyo faction. Meanwhile, the University group was on the verge of bringing in the Osaki faction, on the opposite side of the conflict. Both factions are members of Tokyo Council. What does this say about the relations between the two factions? And how much would have Tokyo imploded had they been brought in?

Aaand you liked this post. Please hold while I panic.
 
You know, on learning that the leader of Tokyo is named Akane, I find myself wondering.

Way back when, before PMAS, there was Sayakaquest. Which had much the same community as PMAS, especially early PMAS, including Firn himself. And it had a Tokyo girl by the name of Akane too.

So I find myself wondering if this Akane is also a punch-guca.
I wouldn't be surprised if Akane of PMAS rules Tokyo with an Iron Fist.
 
Sabrina could well have fucked up in Sendai and sparked a meguca civil war throughout Japan, because I'm pretty sure that the Tokyo groups all have contacts with groups in other cities, being able to bring them in on their conflict.
 
Sabrina could well have fucked up in Sendai and sparked a meguca civil war throughout Japan, because I'm pretty sure that the Tokyo groups all have contacts with groups in other cities, being able to bring them in on their conflict.

Sabrina: ...... MAMI... MAMI
Mami: what?
Sabrina: I accidentally Sarajevoed Japan : (
 
Given the general description of how Tokyo looks, with skyscrapers that "dwarf the Skytree", it seems that weird gigantism in architecture in general is just a thing in the PMMMverse and there's no way that isn't because of wish magic.

:V

(Episode 5, bluray version, hospital building.)

(You could always interpret it as ten wards per floor and they're just numbered like that for some reason, but honestly the skylines of Mitakihara are consistently huge, soooo...)
 
Okay! Time to analyze the politics of Tokyo!


Majestic. Kurenai (and Yuri, of course) has put us off balance just by welcoming us, and even better it feels like our fault for being surprised by a male that knows about magical girls. Looks like they're trying to regain the initiative after we surprised her with 20 minutes to prepare for our visit. They're good.


Trying to throw us off a little more? Doesn't seem very effective.


They have propaganda to encourage new contractees to join the council. Useful.


So, sounds like Akane is the leader overall, with magical girls in teams composing the nominal selectorate, and representatives of teams forming the real selectorate. Out of the representatives, Akane will need to keep a certain number aligned behind her (half? Less? We don't yet know how much of a majority the council needs in order to make official decisions), who will be the winning coalition. The Chiyoda team are also all essential supporters for Akane, as she needs to keep them happy with her rule in order to remain their representative.


Akane is basically the President then. I'm not sure I'm reading this correctly, but it sounds like other groups help Chiyoda farm witches? That means a lot less work for the Chiyoda girls, and would certainly be a system set up by Akane in order to keep them happy with her leadership. A bribe *ahem* campaign contribution, if you will.
Furthermore, decisions are made by majority vote. One would think that this requires Akane to have over half of the representatives aligned behind her, but we don't know how many parties there are. If there are a large number of small parties, Akane will not need as many representatives to support her, because her ideas only need more votes than the next most popular decision in order to win. Small parties whose ideas won't win suck up some of the representatives from everyone else, so that the second most popular idea has less votes, and thus it takes less votes for the winning idea (Akane's) to win.
I'm not sure, but large amounts of arguing seems to me like it might be indicative of many smaller parties all trying to make their opinions heard.


Now this is interesting. In America, gerrymandering is done by shifting the borders around to fit the people. Here, this isn't the case. Instead, gerrymandering is done by shifting people around to fit the borders. I bet Akane either directly or indirectly has a fair amount of say in who gets sent where. This would allow her to stack lots of people who don't like her into the same teams, meaning that they have less impact on representatives since they only need a certain number of girls on the team to vote in the representative. Any more third party girls on a team than are strictly necessary to have a majority are effectively wasted politically. I would expect that girls from Akane's party are relatively spread out, having slim majorities over third party girls in order to maximize their impact on the political makeup of the representatives.

As a bonus, Akane can honestly say that she's trying to put girls together who will work well together, since third party girls will probably get along better with each other than with members of other parties.
Example: Team Tagwen has 10 members, 6 of which are members of the Cheese party, and 4 of which are members of Akane's Cake party. Akane will switch out the 4 members of the Cake party into Team Gogswain, who have 2 members of the Cake party and 8 members of the Cheese party. Now Team Tagwen has 10 Cheese party members (but still only one representative), while Team Gogswain has enough Cake party members that they are the majority. While previously the Cheese party could send 2 representatives to the council, now they can only send one, and the Cake party has a representative that they didn't have before.


Might be an unfortunate side effect of the gerrymandering. Akane's party is more peaceful, so she puts violent and expansionist girls together in same groups so that they won't have as much power (especially when there's no way to expand their territory at all). This minimizes the voices of those particularly bloodthirsty girls, but also means that those entire teams are filled with them, making the teams very difficult to deal with for everyone else.
That being said, it doesn't say why they're like that. Perhaps the desperation for some groups is born of being in situations that they need more grief seeds for? People who are injured and need to buy healing, people who are depressed and desperately gathering enough seeds to survive, or perhaps people who just really like power, or have vendettas like Akiko.





Whew. Okay. So, by my analysis, this seems very similar to the political system of the United States. Less complicated, fortunately, and without term limits, but pretty darn similar. We should probably try and figure out whether Kurenai's group is part of Akane's party, or part of an opposition party.
It's been liked. By Firn. :o
Glad he's got enough time to read the thread now. :)

Now then, how to apply this analysis.
First off, to get them to accept clear seeds, obviously the main person that we need to convince is Akane. However, if she doesn't want to, we have options.
Our best bet would be to convince the other Chiyoda girls, since they're some of Akane's essential supporters. If Akane's ruling correctly the Chiyoda girls will have more grief seeds than they know what to do with, so I wouldn't bet on appealing to their greed or desperation. Then again, as my government and politics teacher once said, the only thing better than having tons of money, is having MORE money. So maybe greed. Probably though, our best bet would be to appeal to their better nature. People sometimes do really dumb stuff when they suddenly grow a moral compass.
The next place we could try to turn would be Akane's supporters among the representatives. They are much closer to the common people, and while their constituents shouldn't be doing too badly at all, they may appreciate a larger buffer between themselves and running out of seeds.
 
and they're just numbered like that for some reason
Ooh! Ooh! Architect had a vision and made every ward a couple of steps higher than the next previous on, so that the whole building could be laid up like a giant spiral staircase!
(Nevermind that is a terrible way to lay out a hospital where you'll have people being moved around in wheelchairs and on gurneys.)
 

Someone in the PMMMverse musta been a nerd who wished for goddamn arcologies if the Tokyo buildings are consistently larger then that. I mean, the Burj Khalifa has 163 stories!

And now I'm picturing Homura with an accordion... "Remove QB, Remove QB"
Absolutely terrible.

Wrong war, although now that the image is also stuck in my head that sounds familiar...

Hmm...
*googles*
Oh hell... I remembered correctly, IT IS A THING!

 
Last edited:
(You could always interpret it as ten wards per floor and they're just numbered like that for some reason, but honestly the skylines of Mitakihara are consistently huge, soooo...)
I mean, sixteen floors is already noticeably tall, and if there are multiple buildings...
(OTOH, living in rural Minnesota might leave me somewhat biased as far as such things go.)
 
... I'm nine hundred and ninety-nine percent sure Madoka Verse Taylor Hebert sold her soul for better schools.

Theres an easy way to figure that out. Pick any random public school in America and check the schoolbooks. If they publication date is less than 10 years ago, you've got definitive proof of the wish.

Got reeeeal confused as a kid when I looked up Russia in an atlas and found some place called the Soviet Union.
 
Theres an easy way to figure that out. Pick any random public school in America and check the schoolbooks. If they publication date is less than 10 years ago, you've got definitive proof of the wish.

Can confirm. I'm a student teacher doing practicum at a public school in the next county over. Our American History textbooks are from 2006.
 
"Actually, yeah," you say. "What can you tell me-"

"-about the Osaki group," Oriko completes the sentence, biting off the words. "Three of them coming over, an empath, a healer, a... it's hard to describe. She can make things... hit extra hard. Nothing else, right." Despite the phrasing, it's really not a question.

Here's the cite on Osaki having an empath. So yeah, if we suddenly dump a bunch of Mami pictures in here, they'll sense it. :V
 
Here's the cite on Osaki having an empath. So yeah, if we suddenly dump a bunch of Mami pictures in here, they'll sense it. :V
What I'm hearing is that we absolutely should dump a bunch of Mami pictures in here.

I'll start us off with a screenshot of @ArcadianPhoenix and me in Minecraft:



:V
Adhoc vote count started by Godwinson on Feb 19, 2019 at 6:57 PM, finished with 149663 posts and 4 votes.

  • [X] The question of who gets aid first shouldn't be an actual issue. You have a teleporting cloner. There are entirely too many ways to leverage that so that each group gets a single clear seed at the exact same time.
    [x] Ask if the Tokyo Council has rules regarding mercenary work; fighting, evacuations, consultation, and things of that nature. Mitakihara has an emergency due at
    [X] blank out for a moment
    [X] Hug Mumi. Mentally.
 
Last edited:
Well, I have a fair number of questions, but they mostly pertain to how the Tokyo Council works," you admit. "I'm inclined to try and work with the existing system, since I'd rather not have to go against the entire Council. I want to help. But... first, I suppose I should establish my bona fides."

You smile at Kurenai, and Terumi. "Would you like me to cleanse your Soul Gems? No strings attached, just to show that I can."

Terumi wordlessly offers up her Soul Gem, giving you another shy smile. You beam at her, and give Kurenai a questioning look.

She hesitates for a long moment, before shaking her head.

"It would be best not to," Kurenai says. Terumi's smile dims a little, and she puts her Soul Gem away. But neither of them are...

Both of their Soul Gems are a little more filled than you'd like. Nowhere near any kind of danger zone, or anywhere near average usage, but they're fuller than the absolute cleanliness you can manage for your friends in Mitakihara.

"Thank you, nevertheless," Kurenai murmurs, before quirking a smile. "Yuri would never forgive me if she'd missed that, anyway."

"I could have cleansed her too, when she gets back," you say with a shrug.

"It's not like your powers'll run out," Sayaka says, grinning.

"It's a momentous thing that you can do," Kurenai says. "But for now, it would just make life difficult."

"So I've been told," you say. "But that's the thing. I don't want to just keep this to myself. I want to help everyone I can."

"Which brings us to here," Kurenai says with a sharp nod. She taps her chin thoughtfully. "Why don't I... hm. I have a pamphlet, or would you rather hear it from me?"

It seems a little strange to me that Kurenai's reason for declining a cleanse changes. Why would she turn down a cleanse because of the political climate? This is her territory and no one else should be here. Is the meeting being monitored?
 
I guess the council's moratorium is on accepting all of our cleansing services not just the clear seeds? Even if you're pretty sure no one's watching you'd want to be extra safe if you can spare the grief seeds or it might drastically undermine your negotiating position and you probably have enough spare seeds to survive anyway.

After all with all the girls in Tokyo there are absolutely a few meguca with stealth or surveillance powers.

Edit: Also I want those minecraft skins. :V
 
Last edited:
Imagine a magical girl whose power is being able to tell when someone lies to her.

Imagine a magical girl whose power is being able to make sure someone has to keep their promises.

There are plenty of reasons why Kurenai might refuse the offer due to the Council's political issues, and only a few of them are related to magic like those two I just listed.

Hell, she might be an honest person.
 
Well, as should have been expected, I stand, eh, partially corrected.

Toshimichi Akane, huh, from Showa. Powerful.

"Correct," Kurenai says. "Toshimichi Akane claims descent from Emperor Shōwa, but in truth that matters less than the fact that she's charismatic and powerful. She's frequently the only thing stopping Tokyo from turning into all out war."

Balance of power dictated by a single figure engaged in -- well, basically, nobody can start a fight because they'd add her to the other side, which would tilt the balance of power against them. Okay, absent deeper shit that's outright admirable. She's not just charismatic and powerful, she's also intelligent and savvy enough to recognize that this is something she can do at all and to carry it out. Well, hopefully.

Witch hunting is delineated strictly by territory held between groups, which... seem to be static.

I had... kind of feared something like this, but... This isn't quite the right conditions for that...?

... No, wait, it might be. Emphasis on might. If... Gods, that would be a nasty picture, but... Meh. We'll see. Probably not.

Kurenai says, considering. "It's... not bad, I suppose? I don't really have a strong basis of comparison, but we get by, with enough Grief Seeds. Oh, if you look further down, there's a note that groups can be balanced by switching magical girls across teams."

The primary issue, highlighted. If there's not the usual conflict here in Tokyo, what goes on when new contracts bring the city above carrying capacity?

"Who's to be first?" Kurenai asks. "Whoever is first would have an immeasurable advantage."

Conflict. As noted, a clear seed is a weapon.

"Some groups are bloodthirstier than the others, but we keep them in check by weight of threatened collective action," Kurenai says. "But there's... a kind of desperation to some of them. As far as we know, they aren't low on Grief Seeds or anything, but they're always hungry for more."

So, parts of the population are witchbombed. Spectacular.

Well, at any rate, I think it's blindingly obvious that a single clear seed isn't going to cut it here. One per team at *least.*

It's almost a republic, ad-hoc and haphazard. Each group sends a representative to debate in times of import, presided over by the Chiyoda group.

So, let's see here. We need some basic analysis.

First, how are the territories arranged? Does every territory border Chiyoda group, or do some have to pass through other territories to get there?

Second, what's the population per territory? There must be differences, so there's bound to be territories with lower and higher populations -- the question is, how much of a difference?

Third, as a corollary of second, what would happen if a group tried to get the council to redraw territorial boundaries? My bet is gridlock.

Second and Third shouldn't be important as long as Nakahara's assertion about there not being any groups low on seeds is correct. If it's incorrect, they become critical.

First is important in some circumstances -- it will have implications for the possibility of getting everyone to accept a seed simultaneously in the way we have floated.

With all of that said, however... If we simply optimize a little bit more, then the real problem lies only with what would happen if every team got a clear seed at the same time.

[X] The question of who gets aid first shouldn't be an actual issue. You have a teleporting cloner. There are entirely too many ways to leverage that so that each group gets a single clear seed at the exact same time.

(Off the top of my head, each group trades a grief seed for a grief seed's worth of cleanse, or-- no, each group gives us a used seed, we take the used seed, we distribute clear seeds simultaneously via Sayaka once we have all of them ready. Hell, we can have them give the used seeds to Sayaka clones. The worst outcome for them is losing nothing. The best outcome is gaining everything.)

Mentioning coming down against anybody starting a fight is pointless given that solution, I think, and would only come across as warmonger-y when we have a solution that appears to preclude fighting entirely...

Beyond that, um. We should ask about Rionna -- she mentioned friends in Tokyo and I am already not liking where that and "people aware of witchbomb" is going.

We should talk about the aftermath, also, probably. Hm.
 
we should probably get sayaka to copy these guys powers. don't even know what they got just want to make sayaka OP as hell
also pretty sure that the reason she can't copy us is either
A) we are an artificial human, she can't copy powers from things that aren't strictly human
B) we were created from madoka's wish that had the capability to affect all universes and timelines everywhere bouncing backwards and forward through time. we are simply way to powerful and beyond human for her to copy
C) GOTT IST TOTT (we're a witch, she can't copy witches)
 
Back
Top