She's probably limited to acting on the terms of her wish. She can decide whether or not Sayaka contracts because as a puella magi she falls under her domain, but as a totally mundane human Kyosuke is in a seperate magisterium.
 
Eh...well, she specifically said she could have saved Sayaka, but if she did she would have had to negate the fact that she contracted and whatnot. She couldn't save Sayaka without removing violindude's healing, and therefore she has (at least some) limits.

A: Save Sayaka, she never contracted. violindude no healing.
B: Things stay as they were, more or less. Dead blueberry, happy violindude.

She could not perform
C: Save Sayaka, heal violin dude anyways.
And therefore cannot be (completely) omnipotent, though there's no denying she's a reality warper of incredible power.

Well, yes. I wasn't trying to state otherwise. I was trying to say that she has options.

That seems to be quite strange in the limits. She can fuck with the Incubators' grief seed system and bring back the dead, but she can't heal violin dude's hand while keeping Sayaka alive/non-contracted (a much simpler task imo)? Doesn't mesh to me.

She can't bring back the dead. She can make it so that their deaths never happened in the first place. It's a different ability. She can't manipulate reality directly. She can only arrange circumstances. She can't heal Kyousuke's hand herself, so she is forced to let Sayaka contract (and die) if she wants it healed. Basically, I think it;'s related to the intentions of her wish. She cannot interfere with what other meguca wished for. So, she's forced to have everything they wished for available as options. Sayaka wished for Kyousuke's healing, so Madoka cannot prevent Kyousuke's healing from being a valid wish, which means that without that contract, she's forced to have him need healing. It comes partly from her speech during the final episode. She said that her intention when making her wish was for others' wishes to have meaning.
 
Well... I don't know what.

(Recording start)

(Sound of door opening)

"Hello, Mami, Homura. How's it going?"

(Sound of footsteps, a door closing, and some chairs being moved)

"It's been a while. It's nice to see you."

"Hi."

"You've been eating well? It's good to s-"

"S-Sabrina."

"Yes, Mami?"

(A few seconds pass in silence)

"I... I wanted to just... keep to o-our... previous conversation, OK?"

"Whatever you need, Mami."

(Sound of paper shuffling)

"Then, first..."

"How are you?"

"I'm doing fine, thanks... A little bored, but nothing I can't deal with, after all we-"

"U-um... C-can we keep t-this...?"

"Ah, right, sorry Mami. Go on."

"Ri... Right. First, we have some con... concerns about some things y-you said last time. If you-you could... clarify for us...?"

(No verbal answer is given)

"Then... Y-you said... you could have... Wished Ky-Kyuubey, away, right?"

"Yes and no."

"W-What do you mean by that?"

"Well, I had the potential, certainly, but it wasn't something I could Wish for."

"Explain."

"There would've been no point, you know? I had a purpose here, and just Wishing here away wouldn't have made sense, right?"

"Purpose?"

"Ah, you know this already. I was here to break systems and hug megucas, and I would've been all out of of sys-"

"S-Sabrina."

"Sorry. I mean I had a... mission, you could say, to destroy that wretched system the Incubators made."

"Why not Wish it away?"

"There would've been no point, then. It's like starting a show and cutting right to the end, it's not what I was here for."

"B-but... it would've made everything... better."

(Sound of cloth moving) "Maybe."

(A long silence)

"So, how's everyone doing?"

"Fine."

"Did you buy Madoka that chair?"

"Yes. She liked it."

"Good. Hey, can I send a letter to someone? Or two someones?"

(Sound of paper shuffling)

"Thanks." (Sound of scribbling)

"Done."

(Sound of paper shuffling)

(Slience)

"I know you don't like them, but please?"

(Sound of paper being folded)

"Thank you."

"M-moving on..."

"Sure."

"You've said... y-you could break free anytime you wanted."

"Yes."

"That you... you're always holding b-back."

"Right."

"D-does this... Is this about your... p-powers?"

"Mmm... not really."

"Clarify."

"I mean, kind of? My powers are a big part of it-"

"Y-you haven't... made any m-more f-f... familiars?"

"Eh, they're not really familiars, more automated contructs-"

(Sound of somebody shifting)

"... No, I haven't."

(Sound of scribbling)

"And your B-Barrier..."

"You know I haven't."

(Sound of scribbling)

"A-and have y-you... ever tried W-Wi... Witch K-Kissing someone?"

"No! You know I wouldn't..."

"Enough."

(Sound of scribbling)

"Sorry."

"... It's fine. Go on?"

"Holding back."

"Ah, yes. It's more about methods than powers. I mean, my powers are a big part of it, but there's just... things I could've have done, but didn't..."

"O-o-out concern?"

"... Partially. I guess... I've taken risks. But they paid off, didn't they?"

"I-I..."

"Yes."

"See? It's all good."

"Could've been more careful. Specially with..."

"Eh, things worked out in the end."

"Savior complex."

"Terminator."

"... Air head."

"Gasp!" (Sound of cloth shifting) "You wound me, Homura-chan!"

(Sound of clearing throat)

"A-about... your 'Savior Complex'... D-did it... a-a-always have to be y... You?"

"What do you mean?"

"Y-you had... have a tendency to..."

"Distrust others."

(Silence)

"Uh... well, I don't think that's true. I mean, I made the networking, divided tasks and all, right?"

"You made it."

"Somebody had to."

"S-Sabrina... this isn't something any-body else would've noticed. Y-you have a... a thing to t-take matters into y-your own hands..."

"Only when there's nobody else who can."

(Sound of someone shifting)

"When I don't know there's someone else who can."

"That's rather... c-convenient."

(Sound of huffing) "What do you expect me to do? Call God for help? There's just so many-"

"Can you?"

"Can I what?"

"Call God."

"Where does this come from?"

"There's..." (Silence)

"Wow, so confident in me, aren't you? Thank you."

"A-answer the q-question, please."

"... Yes."

(Silence)

"W-w-what does t-that...?"

"Was that why you did it?"

"Hm?"

"Why you ended... here."

"Ah, I guess? No, not really. It's just that... well, you wouldn't have liked it, for one."

"W-we...?"

"No."

"Me?"

"... You."

(Silence)

"Can I have a glass of water?"

(Sound of water being poured, followed by sound of glass knocking on wood)

"Thanks."

"So-so you... h-had to sol-solve everyt-thing y-yourself b-bec..."

"Mami."

"... because..."

"Deep breaths, Mami. Here, drink."

(Sound of deep breathing, followed by glass knocking on wood, then sound of pouring water)

"S-so you had to... do what you d-did, because i-it had to be you, and Homura wouldn't have liked it if... you c-called... 'God' for help?"

"I guess."

"What else?"

"I'm not sure... but I don't know if I would have... kept on existing, had I done that."

"This is about...?"

"Yeah."

"Y-you mean y-you would have... d-d-died?"

"Maybe? I don't really think so, but the possibility is there, I guess."

"S-Sabrina... What does this... a-all mean? I..."

"We're done."

(Sound of paper shuffling)

"H-Homura-"

(Sound of chair moving)

"Thank you for your time, Sabrina."

"Thank you for yours, Homura, Mami."

"Anything else you need?"

"A hug?"

(Sound of footsteps, followed by sound of cloth rustling)

"You take care of youself, OK?"

(Sound of cloth rustling, followed by footsteps)

(Sound of door opening)

"You too."

(Footsteps fading away)

"Mami?"

(Sound of slow sighing, followed by sound of chair scrapping against floor)

"W-well... g-good night, Sabrina. S-see you next time?"

(Sound of chuckling) "I'll be here."

(Sound of footsteps)

"See you, Mami."

(Sound of door closing)

(Recording end)
Very IC i love it
 
This mortal coil pt. 3
It takes you just a heartbeat to decide.

You let your guard down.

You let yourself feel the weight.

"Tired," you whisper, answering honestly. "So very tired."

"Sabrina?" Mami asks. "What's wrong?"

You take a shuddering breath. "Too many things happening at once. Just... too many things going wrong, all at once," you say. "I don't... I don't think I can deal with everything."

And sometimes, you wonder if you can deal with anything.

There's so much to do to set up for the future. Walpurgisnacht and Feathers and... magical girls, and Witches. You need to figure out something, but there's precious little for you to start from. You think that enchantment might help you with de-Witching, and you don't know what you'll do if you can't.

"Oh, Sabrina," Mami says, hugging you close. You close your eyes, just letting her soothe you. She nudges you over towards the bench - you're aware of Homura and Sayaka and Madoka and Hitomi arriving, but Madoka obviously urges them to pull back for a moment.

"You don't have to deal with everything alone," Mami whispers gently, rubbing your back soothingly.

It feels odd, being the one comforted.

"I'm-" you say, voice hitching. "I'm trying."

It's true. You involve your friends where you can, but you're so worried for Mami. You're worried for Homura, and now Sayaka. And not to forget Madoka, either. You worry about how much you can put on them, and... maybe more practically than that, they don't have the time to spare, either.

"Alright," Mami says, still hugging you. "I'm always willing to help you, OK? However I can."

It feels nice, being the one comforted.

You breathe out. "Yeah," you agree. Yeah. She is. A faint smile touches your face. "Thanks, Mami."

"Oh, Sabrina... you've done so much for me," she breathes. "Me, and everyone else. It's the least I can do."

"Mm," you say. "How are you doing, Mami?" you ask.

"I'm... alright," she answers. "I'm worried about you, Sabrina."

"Yeah... Things'll work out, I'm sure," you say, smiling up at Mami. "Besides, I have you and everyone, to help me, right?"

"Right," Mami says firmly. "We can talk over lunch?"

"Yea-"

Sayaka cuts you off. "Hi, Sabrina!" she calls nonchalantly, stretching grandly as if she's just arrived. Madoka, Homura, and Hitomi follow her out of the stairwell. "How're you doing?"

You give her a flat look. "I -we- knew you were there," you say tartly, glancing at Mami. She nods in confirmation. "And you're a terrible actress."

"We didn't look!" Madoka protests.

"I know," you say, smiling as you look around at all your friends, all wandering into the roof - Madoka and Hitomi have rather sheepish expressions, and Sayaka's looking somewhat abashed. Homura is... Homu-ing. She's mildly annoyed, you think, which is frankly to be expected.

Ah, well.

Everyone settles themselves on the stone benches - Madoka on the bench opposite to you, Sayaka and Homura on her left and right. Hitomi sits, at Sayaka's insistence, on her other side. Mami sits beside you, of course.

"Are you alright, Sabrina?" Madoka asks, soft pink eyes anxious as you all start in on your lunch.

"Yeah... more or less," you say with a smile. "I've just had a long morning. A few long days, really."

"Yeah, I'm sure," Sayaka says, glancing up at you from her lunch. "Saved any kittens this morning?"

"... in a manner of speaking," you say. A pair of white and black kittens, in point of fact. A fairly adorable pair.

"What, really?" Sayaka asks, giving you a quizzical look.

"Kiiiind of," you say. You sigh, pressing your lips together. "Though... well. I need to talk to all of you."

Everyone takes notice of that. Mami sits up a little straighter, setting her lunchbox aside for the moment, while Madoka turns an anxious expression on you. Sayaka and Hitomi both look rather curious, tempered by worry. Homura frowns slightly, looking faintly worried.

"What is it, Sabrina?" Mami asks.

"It... well, I might have made our lives more complicated," you say. "Not to put too fine a point on it - I'm... just about unique, as magical girls are. It's not boasting or anything. My powers, my ability to cleanse Grief is unique." You're explaining more for Madoka and Hitomi and Sayaka's benefit, really.

Mami nods.

"Go on," Homura prompts, voice quiet. There's a small frown on her face - she knows where this is going.

You grimace. "I might have made our lives more complicated. I haven't exactly been keeping it quiet, so... word's probably-" no probably about it, but bringing up Oriko is a whole other can of worms, "-spreading. And we might be getting... immigrants at some point."

"I see," Homura says, frown smoothing out into an impassive mask.

She's hiding.

Mami purses her lips. "That... could be problematic," she says thoughtfully. "Mitakihara can't support too many more magical girls." She glances at you. "I mean, I'm sure you can help, Sabrina, but you can't be everywhere."

"Yeah, I know," you agree. "That's why I'm worried about it. And it's more people to manage and more people who might have conflicts with each other."

Homura exhales. "We'll just turn them away," she says without any particular emphasis - but you know what she means.

"Oh..." Madoka says, wringing her hands. "Is there anything I can help with?"

"Don't be silly, Madoka!" Sayaka exclaims, clapping the pinkette on the back. "We'll handle it. Right, Mami? Sabrina, Homura?"

[] Write-in

=====​

Open mouth...
 
Hmmm actually putting Madoka in the driving seat of handling some of the more bitter/jaded magical girls can ease their feelings.
 
[] Can Madoka look into finding some good abandoned apartment buildings or hotels or something?

Not being able to be everywhere is less of an issue if we can put everyone in one place.
Hmmm actually putting Madoka in the driving seat of handling some of the more bitter/jaded magical girls can ease their feelings.
That also puts Madoka in stabbing range of some of the more bitter/jaded magical girls. Homu says nomu.
 
Not really intended to be a full vote here, but part of a vote in how to handle Madoka.

[X] "Actually, Madoka, there is something you can help with.."
-[X] Avoid Homura's glare.
--[X] Explain to Madoka that, as magical girls, the group (Mami, Homura, and Sayaka) need to avoid darker emotions, to avoid accumulating excess grief whenever you're not around. Sure, things probably won't get bad really quickly, but it can happen, and it's a risk we don't want to expose our friends to.
---[X] Ask Madoka if she would be willing to be the group's "Mental Health Officer", to help keep their spirits up. It's not something easy, and it's not something a magical girl can safely do, because comforting and cheering people up can sometimes produce grief in the person doing the comforting and cheering. Tell her that you can't think of anyone who is better suited to the task -- You mean, she can make Homura smile! Yep, you saw that, it cannot be denied!

[X] Gadjo

EDIT: Okay, because people don't seem to understand, I did not intend for this vote to actually be used. It was intended to get the idea of giving Madoka something useful and not-magical-girl to do to help out there.
 
Last edited:
[] Can Madoka look into finding some good abandoned apartment buildings or hotels or something?

Not being able to be everywhere is less of an issue if we can put everyone in one place.

That also puts Madoka in stabbing range of some of the more bitter/jaded magical girls. Homu says nomu.
There's vetting, besides its a way of making her feel useful as independent listener and judgement free confort instead of sideline her, which can be bad. The reason for picking the jaded ones is that they shut down any contracts, since madoka represents their innocence past selves. Blast it will write more later PSvita is a pain to write on.
 
Stupid idea here, how about we ask Madoka to convince her dad to sell a house to Sabrina? It gives us a place to house wandering megucas and keep them in one place so we may keep a better eye on them/easier to find them for cleansing.

It also gives her something rather important to do that only she can do. heck, it gives her some concrete to point to and say, "I helped make that."

we might need to acquire some phat stacks of cash though.
 
[X] "Actually, Madoka, there is something you can help with.."
-[X] Avoid Homura's glare.
--[X] Explain to Madoka that, as magical girls, the group (Mami, Homura, and Sayaka) need to avoid darker emotions, to avoid accumulating excess grief whenever you're not around. Sure, things probably won't get bad really quickly, but it can happen, and it's a risk we don't want to expose our friends to.
---[X] Ask Madoka if she would be willing to be the group's "Mental Health Officer", to help keep their spirits up. It's not something easy, and it's not something a magical girl can safely do, because comforting and cheering people up can sometimes produce grief in the person doing the comforting and cheering. Tell her that you can't think of anyone who is better suited to the task -- You mean, she can make Homura smile! Yep, you saw that, it cannot be denied!
 
Homura exhales. "We'll just turn them away," she says without any particular emphasis - but you know what she means.

"Oh..." Madoka says, wringing her hands. "Is there anything I can help with?"
"Could you, like, permanently disable your psychotic train-wreck of a girlfriend? It's asking a lot, I know, but trust me, you'll be doing the world a huge favor."
 
[q] The neutral pacifist route is not working, time for a genocide run! (Cookie to any who get the reference)
 
I like the idea of Madoka being in charge of the mental health. Maybe Hitomi could be a voice of reason, too? She's probably the most normal person on the rooftop right now.

What else do we need to talk about?
Training Sayaka and maybe the picknick come to mind, since they concern everyone.

Finding someone to train Ono is mostly our problem and having Mami try to recreate our anti-pain ring will probably have to wait until after school.
 
"Also, before you ask, making a contract won't help. She'll just steal your power and ruin everything."

*to Homura* "See, now she knows making a contract is pointless anyway."

Homura: "I wouldn't do that!"

Sabrina: "Even if you thought you could protect her forever that way?"

Homura: "Okay, I'd probably do that."
 
Last edited:
[X] "Actually, Madoka, there is something you can help with.."
-[X] Avoid Homura's glare.
--[X] Explain to Madoka that, as magical girls, the group (Mami, Homura, and Sayaka) need to avoid darker emotions, to avoid accumulating excess grief whenever you're not around. Sure, things probably won't get bad really quickly, but it can happen, and it's a risk we don't want to expose our friends to.
---[X] Ask Madoka if she would be willing to be the group's "Mental Health Officer", to help keep their spirits up. It's not something easy, and it's not something a magical girl can safely do, because comforting and cheering people up can sometimes produce grief in the person doing the comforting and cheering. Tell her that you can't think of anyone who is better suited to the task -- You mean, she can make Homura smile! Yep, you saw that, it cannot be denied!

Madoka is the Heart of the group after all...
 
Back
Top