Bakkasama
There is always a greater fool
- Location
- Buenos Aires, Argentina
- Pronouns
- He/his
As far as my opinión on the situation, well, I have already expressed that I don't think fixing our family situation would require one of them to give up their side of the argument. People can think differently on the issue but as long as we don't keep making it personal we can agree to disagree. We are just saiyan, nobody is perfect or can always be right.
Regarding Lady Vegeta, it is not so much the Sealing itself but how they went about it that I disagree with. It is posible that sealing them was the best choice but to do so without the authority to decide it and not to be punished for it, plus the involvement that one of the heads had in the inner workings of the other clan... it sets a dangerous precedent and makes a mockery the idea of state as the upholder of justice and rights. I can see why she would have thought it necessary since the agresor was the one who had to stop those things from happening and the highest authority. I can also see why she would decide that the same was needed for Jaffur after he almost killed his own mother after learning Vegeta's fate and that he would be denied his revenge. Heck, I even sympathize with her situation. But that doesn't change the fact that she could have gone to Berra first or that she overstepped har authority and got away with it. I could have seen the sealing as a valid alternative or punishment with a few slight modifications or if the situation were different but the way she went about it wasn't right. Once it started, finishing was probably the right choice but that doesn't make it right, just the best of the bad options.
I also think that people might be exagerating with the whole "Dandeel promoting sealing" thing. The woman clearly believes in the ancestors and her problema is less of the saiyan heritage and more about when the bloodthirst that comes from it is too strong. She would, at most, propose it as a way to deal with those who are too violent for peaceful coexistence otherwise and then work her way into using it to disenters. Under different circumstances I might have considered it but with this as a first example of how it would work, it seems like a terrible idea and would now cause more trouble than it would solve.
As for Berra agreeing to it, Dandeer put him in a bad situation. For one, he was feeling guilty for not interfering sooner and once Vegeta was sealed his hand was forced. He couldn't protect Dandeer since it would cause things to be tenser than they are now, as the leader of clan Vegeta, Jaffur, would have rallied his clan against it nd protecting the criminal would be a tacit aproval of her actions. Jaffur, upon learning what happened, almost killed his mother so he couldn't return her to him and he had to woory if he wanted someone like that to rule over half the saiyans. Plus, Jaffur is a mother effing Prodigy and given a few years I am not sure Berra could have stopped him if he wanted. With how bad an impression he gave, I can see why he decided to go along with the sealing. While I want to say that he is 8... he didn't act like it and from an outsider perspective he looked downright vicious. Kakara at least had the advantage of SEEING that he was actually grateful towards her and not that far gone.
So yeah, I can see from where they are both coming from and I can't say they reached the wrong conclusión or had bad intentions. But for an action to be a good action it has to be good in intent, execution and results. They clearly failed in execution and things are up in the air with results since it is not really clear whether it was necessary in the case of Jaffur. Though all the information both Berra and Dandeer had pointed that it was and we think differently because we saw other side of him. So, from their perspective, the results were those of a good action, the intent was too and the execution was what was necessary if complicated by problems with communication but from our side they had good intentions but the execution sucked and it wasn't necessary so the results were plain wrong.
Regarding Lady Vegeta, it is not so much the Sealing itself but how they went about it that I disagree with. It is posible that sealing them was the best choice but to do so without the authority to decide it and not to be punished for it, plus the involvement that one of the heads had in the inner workings of the other clan... it sets a dangerous precedent and makes a mockery the idea of state as the upholder of justice and rights. I can see why she would have thought it necessary since the agresor was the one who had to stop those things from happening and the highest authority. I can also see why she would decide that the same was needed for Jaffur after he almost killed his own mother after learning Vegeta's fate and that he would be denied his revenge. Heck, I even sympathize with her situation. But that doesn't change the fact that she could have gone to Berra first or that she overstepped har authority and got away with it. I could have seen the sealing as a valid alternative or punishment with a few slight modifications or if the situation were different but the way she went about it wasn't right. Once it started, finishing was probably the right choice but that doesn't make it right, just the best of the bad options.
I also think that people might be exagerating with the whole "Dandeel promoting sealing" thing. The woman clearly believes in the ancestors and her problema is less of the saiyan heritage and more about when the bloodthirst that comes from it is too strong. She would, at most, propose it as a way to deal with those who are too violent for peaceful coexistence otherwise and then work her way into using it to disenters. Under different circumstances I might have considered it but with this as a first example of how it would work, it seems like a terrible idea and would now cause more trouble than it would solve.
As for Berra agreeing to it, Dandeer put him in a bad situation. For one, he was feeling guilty for not interfering sooner and once Vegeta was sealed his hand was forced. He couldn't protect Dandeer since it would cause things to be tenser than they are now, as the leader of clan Vegeta, Jaffur, would have rallied his clan against it nd protecting the criminal would be a tacit aproval of her actions. Jaffur, upon learning what happened, almost killed his mother so he couldn't return her to him and he had to woory if he wanted someone like that to rule over half the saiyans. Plus, Jaffur is a mother effing Prodigy and given a few years I am not sure Berra could have stopped him if he wanted. With how bad an impression he gave, I can see why he decided to go along with the sealing. While I want to say that he is 8... he didn't act like it and from an outsider perspective he looked downright vicious. Kakara at least had the advantage of SEEING that he was actually grateful towards her and not that far gone.
So yeah, I can see from where they are both coming from and I can't say they reached the wrong conclusión or had bad intentions. But for an action to be a good action it has to be good in intent, execution and results. They clearly failed in execution and things are up in the air with results since it is not really clear whether it was necessary in the case of Jaffur. Though all the information both Berra and Dandeer had pointed that it was and we think differently because we saw other side of him. So, from their perspective, the results were those of a good action, the intent was too and the execution was what was necessary if complicated by problems with communication but from our side they had good intentions but the execution sucked and it wasn't necessary so the results were plain wrong.