Voting is open
Oh, hey, did we ever find out if Kaioken affects Spirit Bomb donations?

I'm picturing it now: a row of healing tanks (like on the Cold Empire's ships) filled with the SSJs who aren't Kakara. When she gives the signal, they all go FPSSJ, then hit Kaio-Ken, then donate their energy and pass out so the sweet sciency magic can go to work.

Kakara calls them her 'beatdown batteries'.
 
Some fairly...significant...revelations have today come to light in this quest's shared-canon RP, none of which are available to Kakara. Ideally, the place to discuss those is in the RP's OOC thread, but if you must discuss them here, I feel urged to make special note of the spoiler policy.
 
Last edited:
Some fairly...significant...revelations have come to light in this quest's shared-canon RP, none of which are available to Kakara. Ideally, the place to discuss those is in the RP's OOC thread, but if you must discuss them here, I feel urged to make special note of the spoiler policy.
Folks might want to follow an above example and do an extra level of them.
 
Some fairly...significant...revelations have come to light in this quest's shared-canon RP, none of which are available to Kakara. Ideally, the place to discuss those is in the RP's OOC thread, but if you must discuss them here, I feel urged to make special note of the spoiler policy.
sorry if I annoyed you. I don't really like the idea of going on that thread just to ask my questions and then leave, and searching for info in it would take quite a bit. I thought it would be fine if I spoilered my questions.

Still if you prefer it, I'll stop asking. Maybe i'll search there sometime.
 
sorry if I annoyed you. I don't really like the idea of going on that thread just to ask my questions and then leave, and searching for info in it would take quite a bit. I thought it would be fine if I spoilered my questions.

Still if you prefer it, I'll stop asking. Maybe i'll search there sometime.
Poptart isn't talking in a wink wink nudge nudge manner here. What you see is what you get; just earlier today Things came up in the RP that Poptart would be extra super vexed to have talked about here outside spoilers. That's it.
 
[x] Combat Precognition. While she's unpracticed in it, its very nature means that it is literally a matter of life or death, whenever it would come up.
 
Once we have a body again, there is no reason to assume we won't be able to project our spirit into Heaven for brief periods just as we were doing mere months ago when we tried to learn the Spirit Bomb from our ancestors.
Um, yes there is - we found and disabled the limiter on our Sight, remember?
Okay, what's your evidence then?
No? It's not. We have no such evidence.
The fact that it's a comprehensible thought is technically evidence. Less pedantically, it seems weird to deliberately design a system where one of the skill-trees leads absolutely nowhere useful, and weird in a way which seems very much out of character for @PoptartProdigy.
So the evidence basically amounts to metagaming, but it does exist. (And it's not enough to make the option seem extremely prospective. I just assumed it was low-cost enough to be worthwhile anyway.)
Incidentally, why is this argument such a priority to you guys? You're investing what feels like a bizarre amount of effort for... the chance to win an argument? I guess you could also be trying to quash my line of thinking, but that doesn't seem terribly likely.
So I'm planning to write in an option to Pastsight (or possibly Helldive) the Talts to see if they had any insights into USSJ next time we get a research period. Feel free to vote for or against it then. Sound good?
 
it seems weird to deliberately design a system where one of the skill-trees leads absolutely nowhere useful, and weird in a way which seems very much out of character for @PoptartProdigy.

Bear in mind that those forms weren't introduced by Poptart, they were already present in the source material. I don't think Poptart is under any obligation as a QM to invent a payoff for every possible avenue of research that they've chosen not to retcon out of existence.
Incidentally, why is this argument such a priority to you guys? You're investing what feels like a bizarre amount of effort for... the chance to win an argument? I guess you could also be trying to quash my line of thinking, but that doesn't seem terribly likely.

I think you may be overestimating the amount of effort people are putting into this because multiple people disagree with you. To the best of my recollection, my last post was the first time I personally got involved in this discussion, and it wasn't exactly a high-effort post.
 
Um, yes there is - we found and disabled the limiter on our Sight, remember?
...How exactly is our abilities getting better a reason to think we will be LESS able to do the things we used to do, that we did before we were subject to such limitations?

The fact that it's a comprehensible thought is technically evidence. Less pedantically, it seems weird to deliberately design a system where one of the skill-trees leads absolutely nowhere useful, and weird in a way which seems very much out of character for @PoptartProdigy.

So the evidence basically amounts to metagaming, but it does exist.
That's not evidence, it's speculation. As noted, Poptart is under no obligation to make every imaginable line of research bear fruit for us. We're expected to use basic common sense and prioritize techniques that are likely to work or that synergize well with what we already have.

Which means, well, we need to employ common sense and not obsess over forms and techniques that are already horribly, horribly outgunned and overshadowed by the superior form we mastered at the age of NINE.

Incidentally, why is this argument such a priority to you guys? You're investing what feels like a bizarre amount of effort for... the chance to win an argument? I guess you could also be trying to quash my line of thinking, but that doesn't seem terribly likely.
Personally, I just find it frustrating that you pick this as a hobbyhorse. Of all the many, many skills and forms we have, this is the one where we have the least reason to think there's buried treasure.

We know there are ways to increase power level or the effectiveness of our power (Jaffur and Tabe's tricks). We know there are higher forms that we could some day unlock if we could find a secure location to train them. We know almost every single one of our combat skills could be materially improved or enhanced in some way. We know our Sight can be honed into a powerful weapon. We know that the Oozaru form represents only slightly explored potential, more than our ancestors or even the Z fighters themselves realized. We know that we are woefully, woefully lacking in Style training, though that's a tough problem to solve when all the masters of our particular style are slaves on Garenhuld.

But for some reason you keep circling back to ASSJ and USSJ, two forms that appeared in a single story arc (the Android/Cell Saga), and which were explicitly outclassed within that very arc by Goku and Gohan attaining the FPSSJ form. When the only known instance of anyone using them in the game continuity resulted in them being butchered by a pair of FPSSJs, one of whom was a child, probably little or no better at fighting than we are now, despite having massive numerical superiority.

It's just... it's frustrating, because you keep bringing it up over and over as if these conversations we were having about it weren't even happening. And because you seem to have singled out the least effective technique possible for us to research, out of all the dozens of things we could train in or use our Sight to get information on. The one technique where we have gotten not even a hint that there's anything there to find beyond the obvious, where in the prologue and backstory we were told that the only group to seriously explore the form in modern times was horribly killed and failed miserably despite having several advantages.

Almost anything else we could do, would seem a more efficient use of our time.

If you really want to find a useful way to apply Sight to our ongoing power-up researches, why not advocate for us using Pastsight to scry on the Cell Games and try to work out how Cell did Perfect Multiform? Or more generally on Tien's use of Multiform? Perfect Multiform is an ability we've been seeking for a long time, one that would have trivialized the battle with Dandeer, one where we've encountered persistent setbacks and interruptions in our researches despite having already made partial progress. Why not focus on that?

So I'm planning to write in an option to Pastsight (or possibly Helldive) the Talts to see if they had any insights into USSJ next time we get a research period. Feel free to vote for or against it then. Sound good?
Typically, QMs don't just let you research infinity topics freely. The more things you research, the less progress you make on any one thing. We're not going to be able to satisfactorily investigate what abilities the Talts mastered in a single Sight session, if only because we'd need to observe many of them for an extended period to be sure we'd seen everything they knew.

This would distract us from other researches that, on a per-hour-invested and per-vision-used basis, are far more likely to bear fruit.

Plus there's the risk of our Sight steering us to the killing of House Talt, which was horrific enough to traumatize both Lord Vegeta and Raditz Senzu for life. I don't want Kakara getting an eyeful of that slaughter.
 
[x] Combat Precognition. While she's unpracticed in it, its very nature means that it is literally a matter of life or death, whenever it would come up.
 
...How exactly is our abilities getting better a reason to think we will be LESS able to do the things we used to do, that we did before we were subject to such limitations?

That's not evidence, it's speculation. As noted, Poptart is under no obligation to make every imaginable line of research bear fruit for us. We're expected to use basic common sense and prioritize techniques that are likely to work or that synergize well with what we already have.

Which means, well, we need to employ common sense and not obsess over forms and techniques that are already horribly, horribly outgunned and overshadowed by the superior form we mastered at the age of NINE.

Personally, I just find it frustrating that you pick this as a hobbyhorse. Of all the many, many skills and forms we have, this is the one where we have the least reason to think there's buried treasure.

We know there are ways to increase power level or the effectiveness of our power (Jaffur and Tabe's tricks). We know there are higher forms that we could some day unlock if we could find a secure location to train them. We know almost every single one of our combat skills could be materially improved or enhanced in some way. We know our Sight can be honed into a powerful weapon. We know that the Oozaru form represents only slightly explored potential, more than our ancestors or even the Z fighters themselves realized. We know that we are woefully, woefully lacking in Style training, though that's a tough problem to solve when all the masters of our particular style are slaves on Garenhuld.

But for some reason you keep circling back to ASSJ and USSJ, two forms that appeared in a single story arc (the Android/Cell Saga), and which were explicitly outclassed within that very arc by Goku and Gohan attaining the FPSSJ form. When the only known instance of anyone using them in the game continuity resulted in them being butchered by a pair of FPSSJs, one of whom was a child, probably little or no better at fighting than we are now, despite having massive numerical superiority.

It's just... it's frustrating, because you keep bringing it up over and over as if these conversations we were having about it weren't even happening. And because you seem to have singled out the least effective technique possible for us to research, out of all the dozens of things we could train in or use our Sight to get information on. The one technique where we have gotten not even a hint that there's anything there to find beyond the obvious, where in the prologue and backstory we were told that the only group to seriously explore the form in modern times was horribly killed and failed miserably despite having several advantages.

Almost anything else we could do, would seem a more efficient use of our time.

If you really want to find a useful way to apply Sight to our ongoing power-up researches, why not advocate for us using Pastsight to scry on the Cell Games and try to work out how Cell did Perfect Multiform? Or more generally on Tien's use of Multiform? Perfect Multiform is an ability we've been seeking for a long time, one that would have trivialized the battle with Dandeer, one where we've encountered persistent setbacks and interruptions in our researches despite having already made partial progress. Why not focus on that?

Typically, QMs don't just let you research infinity topics freely. The more things you research, the less progress you make on any one thing. We're not going to be able to satisfactorily investigate what abilities the Talts mastered in a single Sight session, if only because we'd need to observe many of them for an extended period to be sure we'd seen everything they knew.

This would distract us from other researches that, on a per-hour-invested and per-vision-used basis, are far more likely to bear fruit.

Plus there's the risk of our Sight steering us to the killing of House Talt, which was horrific enough to traumatize both Lord Vegeta and Raditz Senzu for life. I don't want Kakara getting an eyeful of that slaughter.
Seconded, though if stuff that we haven't actually developed count as things to look into, then we might as well throw in kaioken.
A quick question on the discord indicates that we could probably just See 'Good Tien Style lessons', and go from there.
If we want to 'skim' something, then we can just use the Sight's guide in finding 'important things' but I agree that is probably to look at the Talt rebellion.
While were at it, we might as well try to See if there are any paradigm shiftingly effective techniques out there developed in the past hundreds of years, though the 'dumpster fire' state of the galaxy means that they are probably only isolated techniques developed by masters.
We should probably check if we can use the genki dama. The way that ki sense is so closely associated with the Genki Dama implies that we can simply... connect and manipulate the ki we can sense, and just kind of move it around without any physical thereness limitations.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I just find it frustrating that you pick this as a hobbyhorse. Of all the many, many skills and forms we have, this is the one where we have the least reason to think there's buried treasure.

We know there are ways to increase power level or the effectiveness of our power (Jaffur and Tabe's tricks). We know there are higher forms that we could some day unlock if we could find a secure location to train them. We know almost every single one of our combat skills could be materially improved or enhanced in some way. We know our Sight can be honed into a powerful weapon. We know that the Oozaru form represents only slightly explored potential, more than our ancestors or even the Z fighters themselves realized. We know that we are woefully, woefully lacking in Style training, though that's a tough problem to solve when all the masters of our particular style are slaves on Garenhuld.

But for some reason you keep circling back to ASSJ and USSJ, two forms that appeared in a single story arc (the Android/Cell Saga), and which were explicitly outclassed within that very arc by Goku and Gohan attaining the FPSSJ form. When the only known instance of anyone using them in the game continuity resulted in them being butchered by a pair of FPSSJs, one of whom was a child, probably little or no better at fighting than we are now, despite having massive numerical superiority.

It's just... it's frustrating, because you keep bringing it up over and over as if these conversations we were having about it weren't even happening. And because you seem to have singled out the least effective technique possible for us to research, out of all the dozens of things we could train in or use our Sight to get information on. The one technique where we have gotten not even a hint that there's anything there to find beyond the obvious, where in the prologue and backstory we were told that the only group to seriously explore the form in modern times was horribly killed and failed miserably despite having several advantages.

Almost anything else we could do, would seem a more efficient use of our time.
Just here to point out that whilst there's zero evidence House Talt found anything noteworthy, we do already have a viable research project for making use of USSJ: we were going to see if we could flicker into it for brief instants to mitigate incoming damage and strengthen our own blows. I don't think it was released when we first came up with the idea, but I think Super Saiyan Blue did something similar in Super? It's generally been overshadowed by other research projects though, of which we have also accomplished zilch.
 
Just here to point out that whilst there's zero evidence House Talt found anything noteworthy, we do already have a viable research project for making use of USSJ: we were going to see if we could flicker into it for brief instants to mitigate incoming damage and strengthen our own blows. I don't think it was released when we first came up with the idea, but I think Super Saiyan Blue did something similar in Super? It's generally been overshadowed by other research projects though, of which we have also accomplished zilch.
Perhaps more relevantly, we also see trunks pull off something similar in super, but considering he did it for surprise value once and never again I suspect it will only have situational utility.
 
This sounds like the perfect situation for us to research Perfect Multiform!

You mean See Cell using it right? Since we can't actually unlock it as a Shade.

By the by, Kakara's handling being a Shade pretty well, all things considered. Losing her home seems to bother her more than basically being a ghost, despite it basically being treated rather like cutting a limb off at best, and actively torturing yourself at worst.
 
...How exactly is our abilities getting better a reason to think we will be LESS able to do the things we used to do, that we did before we were subject to such limitations?
What changed, is that before, you were a visitor. You were here for a short period of time, your teacher's interference kept you from having the endurance for a long stay, and Gohan put in a lot of time and effort to allow it.
You can read it either way, and I suppose it might be overshadowed by the confirmation that Carrick actually is the one who put a limiter on our Sight, but I assumed that not actually being able to stay for long was pretty critical to our prior permission.
That's not evidence, it's speculation.
I'm aware that this is a semantic argument and I try to avoid mixing those with any other argument type, but I don't agree with the way you're defining evidence or speculation. (Just to be extra clear: As I use them, speculation is an activity, and evidence is any fact that is causally entangled with another fact.)
Which means, well, we need to employ common sense and not obsess over forms and techniques that are already horribly, horribly outgunned and overshadowed by the superior form we mastered at the age of NINE.
I think you're overestimating the amount of effort I want to spend on this investigation. We certainly have misaligned expectations of how much effort this would take.
Almost anything else we could do, would seem a more efficient use of our time.
I don't know all that much else we could do. There's probably something, maybe a lot of somethings, but I don't know the setting well enough to figure them out - remember, my only experience with it is the DBZ manga - and this looks like it might at least be productive, if not necessarily high on the list.
If you really want to find a useful way to apply Sight to our ongoing power-up researches, why not advocate for us using Pastsight to scry on the Cell Games and try to work out how Cell did Perfect Multiform? Or more generally on Tien's use of Multiform? Perfect Multiform is an ability we've been seeking for a long time, one that would have trivialized the battle with Dandeer, one where we've encountered persistent setbacks and interruptions in our researches despite having already made partial progress. Why not focus on that?
Cool! That sounds like a great idea. Might be weirdly low on the list until we get a body to use it with, but on the list it goes.
This would distract us from other researches that, on a per-hour-invested and per-vision-used basis, are far more likely to bear fruit.

Plus there's the risk of our Sight steering us to the killing of House Talt, which was horrific enough to traumatize both Lord Vegeta and Raditz Senzu for life. I don't want Kakara getting an eyeful of that slaughter.
Maybe; it really depends on the what we can come up with. Also, I think that second risk is negligible compared to the Sorceror Massacre.
In the Interlude where Future Kakara told her the plan, she reacted rather like she'd just been told to cut off an arm.
Well, she had just been told to abandon Jaffur.
 
On a possibly-related note, is Instant Transmission an anime-only thing? I don't really remember it, and I'm pretty sure I read the manga through. Maybe it showed up once during the Buu arc, around the time the magic sword that had that old god sealed inside it got broken? Or perhaps that was the god-who-had-fusion-earrings doing something with magic.
On the other hand, I was also under the impression that Ki users (at least during the Buu arc) didn't actually need spaceships. So my memories clearly do not map to Poptart's expectations.
 
On a possibly-related note, is Instant Transmission an anime-only thing? I don't really remember it, and I'm pretty sure I read the manga through. Maybe it showed up once during the Buu arc, around the time the magic sword that had that old god sealed inside it got broken? Or perhaps that was the god-who-had-fusion-earrings doing something with magic.
On the other hand, I was also under the impression that Ki users (at least during the Buu arc) didn't actually need spaceships. So my memories clearly do not map to Poptart's expectations.

According to the wiki, of the reliability of which I am admittedly unsure, Instant Transmission first turned up in the manga around the same time as it did in the anime (i.e. in the leadup to the Androids being a thing).
 
On a possibly-related note, is Instant Transmission an anime-only thing? I don't really remember it, and I'm pretty sure I read the manga through. Maybe it showed up once during the Buu arc, around the time the magic sword that had that old god sealed inside it got broken? Or perhaps that was the god-who-had-fusion-earrings doing something with magic.
On the other hand, I was also under the impression that Ki users (at least during the Buu arc) didn't actually need spaceships. So my memories clearly do not map to Poptart's expectations.
In the anime, ki users definitely need spaceships unless they have Instant Transmission and a good enough ki sense to lock on to someone at their target location.
 
In the anime, ki users definitely need spaceships unless they have Instant Transmission and a good enough ki sense to lock on to someone at their target location.

Except Freeza, Cell, Buu, other arcosians, and probably lots of other aliens. It's just humans/Saiyans/Namekians who get screwed.

Though, admittedly, it would take a while to fly anywhere at sublight speeds.
 
Last edited:
I'm aware that this is a semantic argument and I try to avoid mixing those with any other argument type, but I don't agree with the way you're defining evidence or speculation. (Just to be extra clear: As I use them, speculation is an activity, and evidence is any fact that is causally entangled with another fact.)

I think you're overestimating the amount of effort I want to spend on this investigation. We certainly have misaligned expectations of how much effort this would take.

I don't know all that much else we could do. There's probably something, maybe a lot of somethings, but I don't know the setting well enough to figure them out - remember, my only experience with it is the DBZ manga - and this looks like it might at least be productive, if not necessarily high on the list.
Any fact that is casually entangled with another fact is meaningless, though, since that doesn't give you any metric for determining what is and isn't evidence. Every fact is casually entangled with every other fact, and if your adjective can be applied to literally everything it's not a useful adjective. Under your definition, yes, there is evidence that Ussj can meanignfully improve our combat strength. There's also meaningful evidence that eating more cheese would improve our combat strength, but I don't plan to have Kakara do that either.

To put it another way, saying that we should research USSj under that logic fails any bayesian definition of evidence, in that it doesn't destinguish between worldlines where researcing it would be a good idea and wordlines where researching it would be bad, which means you should be defaulting to your priors and the priors for any given act are that it is not, in fact, the best use of your time. From over here, this reads like an extended campaign in pascal's mugging yourself on the topic.

Don't disagree with the speculation point, though.
On a possibly-related note, is Instant Transmission an anime-only thing? I don't really remember it, and I'm pretty sure I read the manga through. Maybe it showed up once during the Buu arc, around the time the magic sword that had that old god sealed inside it got broken? Or perhaps that was the god-who-had-fusion-earrings doing something with magic.
On the other hand, I was also under the impression that Ki users (at least during the Buu arc) didn't actually need spaceships. So my memories clearly do not map to Poptart's expectations.
Instant Transmission is used in manga, too, although not as extensively (during DBZ) since a lot of the anime usage comes from filler arcs and movies. In addition to its important showings during android/cell and Buu arc, though, it's highly plot critical in super.
Except Freeza, Cell, Buu, other arcosians, and probably lots of other aliens. It's just humans/Saiyans/Namekians who get screwed.

Though, admittedly, it would take a while to fly anywhere at sublight speeds.
Neither Cell nor Buu travel through space, in my recollection. I'm certain cell can, but iirc when buu was traveling around destroying planets, he was teleporting.

Also, reminder that "sublight" is (almost certainly) not a thing that matters in the DB universe, so there shouldn't be anything preventing Ki users from travelling between the stars as long as they can survive it, are willing to endure the boredom, and can keep their energy up.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top