we already import copper to make tools and weapons, so the main advantage will come if we discover how to make bronze, which is unlikely. And not important in the short term.

Also, Restore Order has basically already won, and if one of them wins but the other doesn't we're doing a risky and potentially ineffective action. So since we HAVE to half-ass it, we might as well full-ass it instead.
This. This is the only reason I switched because restore order is too dangerous to do as a secondary.
 
As long as people are aware that possibility of events derailing the plan exists, i suppose that's ok. Who knows? Maybe another comet sighting or other seafaring civ making landfall.

Just remember that AN did advise us the danger of mono-focusing.
We're also heavily rewarded for monofocosing.

Megaprojects provide unparalleled benefits, being strong at war means no one can beat you, actions taken in the same turn have repeatedly shown to have potential synergy, etc.

The trick is to not monofocus to the point where other areas suffer too much. A single turn is not going to do that.
 
we already import copper to make tools and weapons, so the main advantage will come if we discover how to make bronze, which is unlikely. And not important in the short term.
Also, Restore Order has basically already won, and if one of them wins but the other doesn't we're doing a risky and potentially ineffective action. So since we HAVE to half-ass it, we might as well full-ass it instead.

Have to disagree on your point about copper imports. Getting outside sources of metal is neither cheap nor efficient. Can you imaging getting Canada to supply all the steel for US? The transportation cost along will make the accountants hang someone from a tall building, and we have good land routes. Our current supplier (metal worker) is trading using primitive boats, and salty air will damage the ingots. And if we are getting ores, then our smelters will be at the mercy of supplier; who may or may not undergo issues of their own. All in all, metal is good and getting local sources are better and cheaper.
 
This implies not cracking down on corruption , which is the source of problem, is somehow a good idea.
That's because Restore Order isn't cracking down on corruption. It's busting down heads to impose order. See Yakuza and Mafia for how that can end up with orderly corruption. Again the Project immediately busts us down to Stability -2 and that has consequences.
We're also heavily rewarded for monofocosing.

Megaprojects provide unparalleled benefits, being strong at war means no one can beat you, actions taken in the same turn have repeatedly shown to have potential synergy, etc.

The trick is to not monofocus to the point where other areas suffer too much. A single turn is not going to do that.
As we've seen with the Spirit Talkers, we can juat as easily cause problems through such monofocus.
Adhoc vote count started by Sivantic on Apr 19, 2017 at 2:21 AM, finished with 19249 posts and 58 votes.
 
Also, Restore Order has basically already won,
9 votes or 5 people switching is not that much.

This. This is the only reason I switched because restore order is too dangerous to do as a secondary.
Do strategic voting near the end of the voting period unless you're looking for a compromise. Heck, game the system and vote Restore Order x2 + Establish Annual Festival if you're that worried, heavily decreasing the chance of a single Restore Order.

[X] [Secondary]Grand Sacrifice
Why that over a festival? Until our slots are out festivals cost less econ and give chances at a side bonus. Sacrifice is not efficient as a secondary action, it should really be taken as a main.
 
Have to disagree on your point about copper imports. Getting outside sources of metal is neither cheap nor efficient. Can you imaging getting Canada to supply all the steel for US? The transportation cost along will make the accountants hang someone from a tall building, and we have good land routes. Our current supplier (metal worker) is trading using primitive boats, and salty air will damage the ingots. And if we are getting ores, then our smelters will be at the mercy of supplier; who may or may not undergo issues of their own. All in all, metal is good and getting local sources are better and cheaper.
We import most of our clothes from Asia? And a fair amount of metals, rare earths, produce, luxuries, etc.

To quote myself, "we already import copper to make tools and weapons." I acknowledged previously ~2 pages ago that producing copper domestically would be nice. It's simply that the economic and independence benefits are the only immediate material gains of note.

9 votes or 5 people switching is not that much.
glhf
 
We import most of our clothes from Asia? And a fair amount of metals, rare earths, produce, luxuries, etc.
That shit doesn't count, the time it takes us to cross from Asia to North America takes probably a week at most, it probably takes months for the shipment of metals in the stone age for something 1/1000th the distance. And a lot less as well as damage is delivered
 
Look certainly there is a risk that the police force we are creating will be used against the common folk, but as things stands with how much our population and territory has grown we cannot not have a police force. Just because there will be unpleasant side effects in the future does not invalidate the necessary benefits having an actual police force would do for our polity.
 
[x][Main] More Blackbirds
[x][Secondary] Restore Order
[x][Secondary] Restore Order x2


people being partial to loved ones again?

better grab dem shurikens cause mass Blackbird lobotomy is the solution here
 
Don't compare large scale shipping to and from large population pools with smaller scale shipping to and from smaller population pools? kk
I'm not the one who brought up CAN-US trade

It's mostly due to how fossil fuel is bullshit in reducing the cost of transportation with internal combustion engines and compact size/energy content. At the pre-copper age, we do not have anywhere near this kind of power. Remember, the whole concept of insurance is result of huge growth of shipping; therefore we know that sending things over large body of water is very risky and costly. The point is, do we want other civs to have metal supply as possible leverage?
 
It's mostly due to how fossil fuel is bullshit in reducing the cost of transportation with internal combustion engines and compact size/energy content. At the pre-copper age, we do not have anywhere near this kind of power. Remember, the whole concept of insurance is result of huge growth of shipping; therefore we know that sending things over large body of water is very risky and costly. The point is, do we want other civs to have metal supply as possible leverage?
To quote myself, "we already import copper to make tools and weapons." I acknowledged previously ~2 pages ago that producing copper domestically would be nice. It's simply that the economic and independence benefits are the only immediate material gains of note.
Order is of more urgency.
 
[x][Main] More Blackbirds
[x][Secondary] Restore Order
[x][Secondary] Restore Order x2

This is going to be entertaining at least.
 
Certainly Metal Tools like our military are necessary for our polity to not be outdone by our neighbors, but making sure your polity doesn't collapse from internal tension is also phenomenally important, so we need to do this now.

Next turn we should probably do Expand Warriors and Study Metal though, or at least we need to do one of them definitely.
 
Look certainly there is a risk that the police force we are creating will be used against the common folk, but as things stands with how much our population and territory has grown we cannot not have a police force. Just because there will be unpleasant side effects in the future does not invalidate the necessary benefits having an actual police force would do for our polity.
Which is why people are voting for Blackbirds. This does not signify we should immediately try and use them to beat people's head in.
 
Next turn we should probably do Expand Warriors and Study Metal though, or at least we need to do one of them definitely.

[X] [Main] Mega project - The Garden
[X] [Secondary ] Mega project - The Garden x2

[X] Kick the garden.
^JK

Real:
[Fut] [Main] New Settlement - Eastern Hills
[Fut] [Secondary] Study Metal
[Fut] [Secondary] New Trails
or
[Main] Expand Warriors
[Main] New Settlement - Eastern Hills

I just want the new province bonus... and we can do a main study metals + Main Survey action afterward
 
Last edited:
There's a potentially very potent synergy in doing so however, and considering our current problem it's a synergy that we cant overlook.
The synergy is there if we wait a turn.
If we don't, the admin roll might fail and the narrative becomes "We tried to do a restore order, then realized that we kinda needed more blackbirds first." and we get no synergy.
 
The synergy is there if we wait a turn.
If we don't, the admin roll might fail and the narrative becomes "We tried to do a restore order, then realized that we kinda needed more blackbirds first." and we get no synergy.
And then something happens next turn that makes it so that we can't afford to Main or Double Secondary Restore Order. We have the time to do it now, better to seize the opportunity, then to push it back to next turn and then we can't do it because of some disaster.
 
The synergy is there if we wait a turn.
If we don't, the admin roll might fail and the narrative becomes "We tried to do a restore order, then realized that we kinda needed more blackbirds first." and we get no synergy.
synergy doesn't occur a turn apart, as far as i know

Except that it has an equally likely chance of exasperating the situation. We're mixing two new things and hoping they end up the way we want.
better than hiding from it
 
And then something happens next turn that makes it so that we can't afford to Main or Double Secondary Restore Order. We have the time to do it now, better to seize the opportunity, then to push it back to next turn and then we can't do it because of some disaster.
We wouldn't have to because we would be taking care of the situation this turn anyway. Restore Order is not required for that.
JK or no, it still counts as your vote.
Don't tell him that >3>
 
Back
Top