Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
I realized I was teeing up an overly easy 'well actually...' for the necromancy faction.
What is the nature of a Karak? A city (state?) made by dwarves, claimed by dwarves or populated by dwarves? If populated, will it stop being a Karak when only dwarf skeletons are in it and one human. If its claimed, will it stop being a Karak after the dwarves have run out of bodies to throw at the hordes of undead. :V:V:V
 
I agree about the sulphuric acid, but actualllyyy..... Mathilde can shower in lava, as long as she's wearing Kragg's belt

There's a lot more to lava than just heat. The heat won't do crap, but the toxic fumes will. Especially since people insist on not dealing with our Arcane Marks, and we have one that literally attracts all gases and fumes to our face, to the point that we are exceptionally vulnerable to weapons involving either of those things.
 
Last edited:
I agree about the sulphuric acid, but actualllyyy..... Mathilde can shower in lava, as long as she's wearing Kragg's belt
It wouldn't be very comfortable though, since rock is heavy. Though the extra toughness from the belt might prevent bruising.
There's a lot more to lava than just heat. The heat won't do crap, but the toxic fumes will. Especially since people insist on not dealing with our Arcane Marks, and we have one that literally attracts all gases and fumes to our face, to the point that we are exceptionally vulnerable to weapons involving either of those things.
This is a very good point. We need to train the gas mark so we can finally take a lava shower.
 
Mathilde cannot unilaterally annex a Karak without instantly having war declared against her by pretty much everyone. Including the Dwarves she just annexed.
Unless things go really bad in a lot of ways, I don't think Mathilde could become a villain villain. But I could easily see her becoming a sort of "you fools, you're only meddling in my plans because you're too short-sighted to see that my way is the only way to- okay look I know they all say that but I actually mean it and the data is sound so please stop trying to besiege my volcano lair, didn't you read my paper?"

"Okay fair point but look if you go to Barak Varr talk to the local bookseller and ask for his books on Dwarven volcanology, there's this concept called 'hydrothermal power', that's why I'm in a volcano lair, it's totally not for the evil style points."
One of these feels like a nexus step to the other on this particular branch of crazy, but I'm not quite sure which follows on from which. :)

"Didn't you review the Proceedings from the Symposium? The only way to power the manufacture of Wayberstones is with the Tectonic Shackle of Thungni! With word from Dum that Chaos is stirring, I had no choice!"
 
Last edited:
It wouldnt be very comfortable for someone with witchsight either, as stone is an excellent insulator of magic.
Ohh, it's been a while since someone dropped that line. Nice!

But y'know, it might be nice. Sensory deprivation chambers are used for relaxation. Though frankly, I think molten rock is going to carry a good amount of aqshy.
I wonder if there's a possible gilding like thing for the brights in that?
 
Maybe, like, if we got Princess or something with not even theoretical authority, but even that still feels weird.

Weird? It'd be great - a real slap across the face for all anti-magic folk in the Empire and it get Thorgrim's beard in a twist.

This is advisor quest, can we really also be the big boss?

We had becoming Margravine of Sylvania and ruling a principality in the Border Princes with Barak Varr support as job options.
 
She's either a quick study or quick to earn the trust of Apprentices that have been here longer, as there's the telltale signs of very careful breaches of the rules of the dorm rooms.
How long has Eike been here at this point? Weeks or months?
"Only fourteen left to find, then," you say, and smile at her look of shock. "Come with me, I'll give you some hints for the next few.
Are (some of) the nooks findable based on clues in the other ones, like a fun little treasure hunt? That's pretty cool.

You dismiss it and step forward yourself, and he nods as he turns to your true self. "No outsiders may be allowed past the second line of defence until a majority of each generation of the Regency Council agree to opening our doors to visitors once again," he says. "We shall have to talk here. Can I offer you a drink?"
Governed not just by a Council, but by one split into generation-based chambers and requiring a vote to pass each of them? I am most curious what events exactly lead to that...
At first glance, he appears fairly typical for a Dwarf of advanced years who is almost but not quite yet a Longbeard, but the more you look, the more discrepancies you spot. The only metal on his person seems to be the axe on his hip, and the rest of his clothing is fabric and leather - and reptilian leather at that, instead of the more typical goat. His hair and beard are unornamented and hang loose instead of being kept under control by rings and plaits, but seems no less carefully tended for it. He's thinner and wirier than the Dwarves you're used to. And he's also looking at your Illusion with growing thoughtfulness.
He's the first non-fallen Dwarf of Vlag we see up close, right?
"Our population is two thirds of what it was when we were stolen," he corrects, "but it was once lower, and has been climbing steadily for over a century.
So Vlag managed to just decide to have more children while literally lost in the Warp and the Ankor as a whole (especially the Old Holds) are declining while neighboring the Empire in the material realm? Shame on Thorgrim.
Karak Vlag is fascinating. Ever will I mourn the path not taken and in this particular moment I dearly wish we were helping Belegar drag the Karaz Ankor out of its death spiral.
Oh yeah. If we had stayed on as Loremaster then I'd definitely vote to advocate in favor of good relations and maybe some population exchange.
the first three generations are numerous enough to have meaningful representation.
Only one generation from before the Escarpment survives? No Living Ancestors in Vlag?
It almost certainly doesn't. They still kept the teaching to the "some, even barest relation to Thungni necessary". And they are no longer in survival mode. While i have no doubt they will retain lot of their current radicalness, they fundamentally did not change that much.

They are unapologetic about their survival and methods used to get to it, but they still heed traditions to some degree.
The thing I haven't seen mentioned is one of the biggest things they partially discarded. Namely, the deference to their ancestors. I mean they were ruled, like is appropriate to Dwarves, by the oldest generation. And then the children rebelled against their own parents and uncles because they didn't trust their judgement when it came to their own circumstances. What do you think how much Second Generation cares about the opinions of the dead Zeroeth Generation and before? Enough to respect and value their input definitely, but not enough to take it as holy gospel like so so many of the Karaz Ankor do.

Forget free love, dislike of alcohol, Rune-poking. Considering younger generations equally worthy of being listened to as older ones is the most radical change of all.
Honestly, if anything Karak Vlag seems like a foil to Karag Dum: Both caught up in Chaos's direct attentions, but while one fell all the way down in their quest to survive and remain free, the other was more moderated and careful in their approach and so, while they were unable to solve the problem entirely by themselves, still remained uncorrupted enough to rejoin the Karaz Ankor when help finally came.
We have no idea how far they have actually fallen. Maybe Dum just has mind control runes.
E) sex for pleasure.
I don't think sex for pleasure is new. Unabashedly talking about sex for pleasure might be though. If a high dignitary in an emissarial position feels comfortable propositioning to the most respected outsider during her first visit, what kinds of conversations on the subject happens between friends and neighbors?
And Vlag hasn't had experience with non-hostile outsiders in quite some time. It's possible the Vlag locals might default to thinking of her as 'one of them' because that's the only mental category they really have for non-Daemons.
Especially because Daenins often looked like one of them, so appearance isn't a good criterion for differentiation.
A lot of the time, there was. Vlad didn't take power until about 1800, and he ruled it mostly legally until he tried to take the throne by force in the 2000s, which isn't super great but there were like three Elector Counts doing the exact same thing at the time, and Vlad very much described himself as part of the Empire who had as much of a right to vie for the throne as everyone else. After the Vampire Wars ended in the 2100s Sylvania becomes part of Stirland, and though lots of it are under the influence of various Vampires it's not in open rebellion against imperial control until the self-proclaimed Countess von Carstein that was opposed to Abelhelm. And even then that wasn't all of Sylvania, just Drakenhof.
The Vampires used to send taxes to the Haupt-Andersens? I thought the whole thing about pro-Vampire Sylvanian culture is that the blood tax can be more palatable than an actual grain/money tax.
Who wants to destroy dwarf democracy?
Besides it hasn't been established that Mathildes children will be dwarves (metaphysically or otherwise) and I doubt either her or Pan are getting pregnant anyway, so it would be kind of a dead end as far as royal clans go.
They are a republic. Nowhere was it stated that they are a democracy. The (soon to be renamed) Regency Council gives equal representation to members of each generation, but we don't know if said representatives are elected, let alone through universal suffrage. Look at pre-1800 republics throughout IRL history. Most of them were very restrictive regarding who gets to vote. If voting was even the mechanism that the government was elected by.
 
Last edited:
No Living Ancestors in Vlag?
There's at least one.

All the Dwarves that stood between the Daemons and the Karak were those Longbeards old enough to remember another world, but the first Dwarf to emerge is an Elder even amongst these, who would likely be somewhere in his fourth century if the passage of time could still be known with any confidence.

Well, maybe, "in his 4th century" might actually mean he's in the 300s...
 
How long has Eike been here at this point? Weeks or months?

One of those.

Are (some of) the nooks findable based on clues in the other ones, like a fun little treasure hunt? That's pretty cool.

It's ambiguous whether they're deliberately hidden or just quirks of local geometry.

I feel like this is a bigger deal than Mathilde realizes. It would mean that something akin to mass production of the simplest runes is very much possible. It also might mean that, despite conditions, Runesmith (or Rune-poker) apprenticeships were relatively high.

I think people are zooming in on "MASS PRODUCED RUNES CONFIRMED!!!!!" and missing the "we only did this because the alternative was being enslaved and tortured forever and weaponized by an evil god that seeks the destruction of everything we value, and even then it was so shameful that the Apprentices that taught us erased themselves from all the Karak's records and committed suicide by daemon once they were done, and all of us consider this normal and appropriate".

He's the first non-fallen Dwarf of Vlag we see up close, right?

Yes.

Only one generation from before the Escarpment survives? No Living Ancestors in Vlag?

Anyone born before the Escarpment is considered to be in the same generation, no matter their age.

The Vampires used to send taxes to the Haupt-Andersens? I thought the whole thing about pro-Vampire Sylvanian culture is that the blood tax can be more palatable than an actual grain/money tax.

There is no one monolithic Vampire Sylvanian culture. All five of the major bloodlines have a presence in Sylvania and each of them operates differently, and individuals within those bloodlines can vary a great deal from each other. Some of them would and possibly still do pay some taxes for the sake of appearance. A little silver to a tax collector today can be cheaper than having a band of Vampire Hunters tramping around the place tomorrow.
 
There is no one monolithic Vampire Sylvanian culture. All five of the major bloodlines have a presence in Sylvania and each of them operates differently, and individuals within those bloodlines can vary a great deal from each other. Some of them would and possibly still do pay some taxes for the sake of appearance. A little silver to a tax collector today can be cheaper than having a band of Vampire Hunters tramping around the place tomorrow.
I would assume the von carstein and blood dragons would the the ones most likely to pay tax's.

Von carsteins for the visage of legitimacy.

blood knights because they do still self-identity (delude themselves) as honourable knights.
 
I would assume the von carstein and blood dragons would the the ones most likely to pay tax's.

Von carsteins for the visage of legitimacy.

blood knights because they do still self-identity (delude themselves) as honourable knights.

Most Vampires who take territory will at some point. You don't have to seem completely legit, you just have to be less blatant than the next guy. Who are the Vampire Hunters going to prioritize, Lord Eripmav who paid three shillings and a goat in tax last year, or the Bloody Beast of Skull Mountain who eats orphans for breakfast?
 
I think people are zooming in on "MASS PRODUCED RUNES CONFIRMED!!!!!" and missing the "we only did this because the alternative was being enslaved and tortured forever and weaponized by an evil god that seeks the destruction of everything we value, and even then it was so shameful that the Apprentices that taught us erased themselves from all the Karak's records and committed suicide by daemon once they were done, and all of us consider this normal and appropriate".

I think that is because we the players from the post-modern post-industrial world do not really care about their cultural norms against mass production, we see it as this annoying thing in the middle of the road to progress, like a giant bearded beached whale that is senselessly here and we have to deal with. I imagine Mathilde is more respectful about the whole thing IC. :V

We were kind of hoping the whale had moved a flipper out of the way, but it just sort of twitched and it now right back where is started.
 
I think that is because we the players from the post-modern post-industrial world do not really care about their cultural norms against mass production, we see it as this annoying thing in the middle of the road to progress, like a giant bearded beached whale that is senselessly here and we have to deal with. I imagine Mathilde is more respectful about the whole thing IC. :V

We were kind of hoping the whale had moved a flipper out of the way, but it just sort of twitched and it now right back where is started.
You know, you really do come up with some of the best, if out there, analogies.

It's is really hard for some people to get that in universe, things like artisans, guilds and mercantilism and protectionism where not just how things were done, but were the right way to do things.
 
Last edited:
We had becoming Margravine of Sylvania and ruling a principality in the Border Princes with Barak Varr support as job options.
Okay if you're the forth person this is clearly on me.
I use emoji's to indicate a joke. That probably deserved a thonk not a think but I didn't think it would make a significant difference.
I hope this clears it up and nobody else feels the need to tell me.
 
Last edited:
Most Vampires who take territory will at some point. You don't have to seem completely legit, you just have to be less blatant than the next guy. Who are the Vampire Hunters going to prioritize, Lord Eripmav who paid three shillings and a goat in tax last year, or the Bloody Beast of Skull Mountain who eats orphans for breakfast?

Mathilde will top that by paying FOUR
entire shillings and TWO whole goats in taxes every year. Now, where should she found her Necromancy Queendom?
 
I'm reading Realms of Sorcery 2E, and god is the worldbuilding miserable. It feels like everything the writer wants to convery has to have a tinge of despair and darkness and they struggle to make sense sometimes.

A particularly weird and annoying tidbit is this: "Generally speaking, most colleges have little or no provision to accommodate women on their premises, meaning those few females apprentices are often given board in some long forgotten room or out of the way dormitory hastily converted to their needs."

I vastly prefer Boney's take
The Grey College's dormitories are segregated by age and gender, and the one that Eike would have been assigned to is one that you are quite familiar with, having spent half of your own Apprenticeship in it. Being Lady Magister might get you within the grounds of the College, but that doesn't mean you can simply wander in as you please. Even Algard would not be able to enter outside of emergencies without the permission of whoever he was visiting. It seems Eike has already granted you permanent permission to visit as you see fit, as the caretaker on watch at the crossroads that leads to each of the residential quarters simply nods to you as you pass.

Eike's is the smallest of the six dormitories and rarely home to more than a dozen young girls, but that doesn't mean it's cramped, nor does it mean there's not privacy to be had. There's a seemingly bottomless warehouse of old and battered but well-made furniture and privacy screens for each Apprentice to customize the portion of the room available to them, and the less social Apprentices can and do take advantage of this to build themselves a solid wall around their bed. You were one of them once, before you found your footing in the atmosphere of easy camaraderie that a shared Wind allows for. Eike seems to be more inherently extroverted than you were at her age, as she's simply screened off her writing desk against one wall and the rest of her space is open to the rest of the room, and she's currently sitting cross-legged on her bed as she frowns at a slim and battered book.
Now that makes a lot more sense to me, and is a far more pleasant reality than "woman being looked at with confusion in the Colleges of Magic".
 
Voting is open
Back
Top