This is thebestplan. We should do this thing. We should very very much do this thing. Can we do this thing?
 
Keep in mind, although Enterprise doesn't have the diplomacy reroll, they have a whopping 10 presence. They're far more likely to get things right the first time around.
 
Member world Excelsiors are good, but they don't respond to events- or at least don't do so in a way that benefits US.

There is the possibility that increased member world fleet defenses would delay garrison requirement increases in such sectors.

The problem is that it is only a matter of time before a 300+ affiliate becomes a full member, and in that time, the affiliate only gives us so much in the way of resources and crew. It's worth trying to estimate, from the size of that gift, whether we can even reliably afford to build the ships it takes to meet our defense requirement out of that quantity of resources and crew.

Hmm, tricky to say with all the different resources we're getting (including pp and rp), but overall, if we assume an average affiliate bonus of 10br 10sr 0.3O/E/T (including tech-based bonus) over 7 years (20 avg annual diplo rolls and some events), then it just might be enough to scrape together a ship or starbase to fulfill additional garrison requirements.

For those of you who don't follow the shipbuilding thread, there's a new sheet that Oneiros is working on.

Eh that's overstating it. If it's anything like a typical designing/engineering project, less than half of the time is experimenting and setting up the base, and the rest is filling it out and baking it.

(And now I'm kinda hungry.)

I'd say Mbeki due to his first contact bonus, but he could probably use more experience first.

Mbeki doesn't have a first contact bonus. He has a non-first contact bonus.

"A talented communicator and scientist, gain +1 Presence, re-roll non-First Contact Diplomacy."
 
Last edited:
There is the possibility that increased member world fleet defenses would delay garrison requirement increases in such sectors.
Okay, but remember that we ALSO want good event response, which is the point I keep trying to make here. For event response it's desirable to have ships that can make it places in time, and that perform well when they get there. Look at our sector garrison events, and note how many of them come from the Excelsior flagships like Kumari.

Hmm, tricky to say with all the different resources we're getting (including pp and rp), but overall, if we assume an average affiliate bonus of 10br 10sr 0.3O/E/T (including tech-based bonus) over 7 years (20 avg annual diplo rolls and some events), then it just might be enough to scrape together a ship or starbase to fulfill additional garrison requirements.
Yeah, but that's one ship. Good enough for a place like Betazed that just adds a few points to our defense for an existing sector. But for a species like Rigel or the Caitians where we end up with a whole new sector to cover? It's nice, but we shouldn't kid ourselves into thinking it pays for itself that quickly.

So rushing a world to 300+ status for the extra resources is going to prove unwise. Five or so years later, that species is joining us, expecting us to immediately garrison a new sector. And the resources they gave us over the preceding years aren't enough to pay for a whole sector garrison fleet. Maybe a Centaur-A or even a cruiser, but that's not going to be enough.

The excited discovery that advancing species like the Amarki to 300+ status got us extra resource trickles is in large part responsible for our present growing pains, in hindsight. We got the trickles, but they didn't enable us to build enough ships quickly enough to cover all the garrison requirements we now have five years down the line from having added the Amarki, Rigel, Caitian, and soon the Apiata sectors.

Mbeki doesn't have a first contact bonus. He has a non-first contact bonus.

"A talented communicator and scientist, gain +1 Presence, re-roll non-First Contact Diplomacy."
Yeah. Noted and edited that into my last post I think. You're right.
 
Let's just wait until we actually know where the Kadeshi are going to jump behind that idea, and that the idea is even feasable, everyone.
 
(slightly edited to sound better)

I admit that I love the idea of us patting the Kadeshi refugee fleet on the head, making sure they remembered their mittens and lunchboxes, and sending the little tykes out to explore the galaxy. Bravely, the Kadeshi refugee fleet sets out to find a Promised Land in the Gamma Quadrant! Revving up their drives, they proceed to calmly, in perfect crisp formations, om nom nom their way across the galaxy in their fleet of boxy little von Neumann ships for sixty years...

Then the Bajoran wormhole opens up, and we learn that we accidentally broke the Dominion. :D
 
Last edited:
God knows we should already have some clue about that, if like, literally anyone in the UFP has paid any attention to them at all. Actually...

@OneirosTheWriter is it feasible to ask the Kadeshi where they're headed and then make plans for what to do about their journey with that knowledge?
 
(slightly edited to sound better)

I admit that I love the idea of us patting the Kadeshi refugee fleet on the head, making sure they remembered their mittens and lunchboxes, and sending the little tykes out to explore the galaxy. Bravely, the Kadeshi refugee fleet sets out to find a Promised Land in the Gamma Quadrant! Revving up their drives, they proceed to calmly, in perfect crisp formations, om nom nom their way across the galaxy in their fleet of boxy little von Neumann ships for sixty years...

Then the Bajoran wormhole opens up, and we learn that we accidentally the Dominion. :D

"Nice try, assholes."

 
Hmph. Spoilsport. :p

Would you be willing to do an alternate one of "aack they are going Homeworld on us and we're cast as the Taiidan?"

[makes puppy eyes to best of ability]
 
A little baby Salvage Corvette carrying a Weyoun with a put-out expression.

I want this thing.
 
Last edited:
I think I like the idea because it shows that even in an Era where we are getting stuck in a messy Civil War and tensions are flaming up all over, Starfleet is still Starfleet and setting ships aside to wander off and stroll around the galaxy sniffing the flowers and poking things with sticks.

It helps keep sense of the excitement and adventure of Trek alive. Along with the more deadly serious business.

Also I guess I've added more omakes to my list (If only I wasn't working so much. Oh well. Phone typing it is):

1) Ka'Sharren says goodbye to Enterprise and changes the guard with Mrr'Shan. [IN PROGRESS]
2) The Romulan relationship with the Kadeshi. Not a full clients hip but the Romulans have an odd sense of fondness for them out of a feeling of... let's call it mythic nostalgia. Weather they help in the form of "We'll keep you in our thoughts and prayers", "Here have a D-7 or three. We were just going to scrap it anyway. You can use it for storage or whatever" or something in between is to be determined by higher powers.
3) Someone suggesting this idea to Starfleet Command. I'm probably going to use Kuznetsova for that. Though I may try to use someone else.
 
I think I like the idea because it shows that even in an Era where we are getting stuck in a messy Civil War and tensions are flaming up all over, Starfleet is still Starfleet and setting ships aside to wander off and stroll around the galaxy sniffing the flowers and poking things with sticks.

It helps keep sense of the excitement and adventure of Trek alive. Along with the more deadly serious business.

Also I guess I've added more omakes to my list (If only I wasn't working so much. Oh well. Phone typing it is):

1) Ka'Sharren says goodbye to Enterprise and changes the guard with Mrr'Shan. [IN PROGRESS]
2) The Romulan relationship with the Kadeshi. Not a full clients hip but the Romulans have an odd sense of fondness for them out of a feeling of... let's call it mythic nostalgia. Weather they help in the form of "We'll keep you in our thoughts and prayers", "Here have a D-7 or three. We were just going to scrap it anyway. You can use it for storage or whatever" or something in between is to be determined by higher powers.
3) Someone suggesting this idea to Starfleet Command. I'm probably going to use Kuznetsova for that. Though I may try to use someone else.

Why not Commodore T'Faer? They were the one in charge of the crisis fleet, right?
 
I think I like the idea because it shows that even in an Era where we are getting stuck in a messy Civil War and tensions are flaming up all over, Starfleet is still Starfleet and setting ships aside to wander off and stroll around the galaxy sniffing the flowers and poking things with sticks.

It helps keep sense of the excitement and adventure of Trek alive. Along with the more deadly serious business.
We're still doing that even if it doesn't happen with the 5YMs.
 
Er what? The snakepit option says "Request new Starbase I [Write in Sector] 20pp for home sectors or CBZ , 30pp for KBZ", which says nothing about when the starbases would finish.

I mis-remembered. Well, it was in the Snakepit results post anyway. The point is that it's not a mistake or anything; the CBZ starbase really is supposed to take 2 turns more to build

Alternatively, we could build 2 more Constitution-Bs next year and get 10 more defense in about the same time frame. It would fit our shipbuilding plans for Renaissance, though it would be tight, and if we're unlucky, we may need to either delay a Renaissance or sell a Constellation for crew.

I kinda want to delay the Constellation-A refit until at least next year, because it would give as a chance to revise the refit with the revamped ship design spreadsheet.

Miranda refits. Remember those? We ordered it, we got it, and the best time to slot them in is putting them in right after a Connie-B comes out. They fill the berths nicely until we can start making Reniassances in those berths, while at the same time letting us save our resources for Renaissances and to start the Ambassador prototype.

So agreed, we have no reason to ask for a Constellation refit this year... because we're going to have our hands full refitting Mirandas.

If we could get a C4 S3 H3 L3 P3 D4 stat line with something like 50br 30sr refit cost, then I would totally be fine with that, considering the crew savings (over building a new ship instead).

Constellations are too ugly ever to have Presence 3. :)

I meant next quarter.

Sending one of our 5YM ships to accompany the Kadeshi could be cool.

I wouldn't mind exploring in the general direction they're going; "accompany" is a bridge too far. Though I guess it's a Viraan zh'Dohlen decision.

EDIT: And to be clear, we do not have enough spare ships to put together an entire squadron just to follow the Kadeshi around. Not that it seems like anything but a terrible idea if we did have the ships.
 
Last edited:
It's probably a good thing we don't need (or have spare capacity) to handle Constellation-A refits right now, because we're going to be a bit hard up for political will this turn.
 
Anyone have an idea exactly how much we have right now, and how much of that is going into paying off the Cost of our Syndicate fight?
 
Anyone have an idea exactly how much we have right now, and how much of that is going into paying off the Cost of our Syndicate fight?

We're going to have 191 I think. 195 and then we took an anti-Syndicate option that saps 5 additional political will. We paid off the Cost of last year's activities in this year's income, and we'll pay off this year's Cost in next year's income, so nothing changes there. And then of the 191 we owe 50 to the Development faction to spend as they wish.
 
Back
Top