The 125th tragedy.
The room the war council met in was seeped in symbolism. they sat on high seats to loom above those who would speak before them to reflect their authority in war, the typical fax stone decorations were peeled back revealing solid metal to reflect the cold brutality of strife, and most importantly the entire floor was a great window showing the world beneath their feet so that they would ever be reminded what they fought to protect. There was other symbolism and imagery draped about the room, but the 3 symbols of authority, brutality, and purpose had appeared in some variation for as long as the Dawiar had had war councils. In ancient days the first clans would carve images of their children on the walls of their war rooms. To stand before the war council was to be reminded of their terrible purpose, and crushing responsibility. Toral was here to call them all idiots, politely.
"The council recognizes thane Toral of the Stone whisper clan, what do you bring before the council?"
"I come bearing the wisdom of the ancestors, and insight into our foe"
there was a pause, Toral knew he was pushing his luck. The council could refuse to hear him, and the only reason to bring up the wisdom of the ancestors was if you wanted to use it to tell them they were wrong. To claim to bring the ancestors wisdom was practically the same as calling them all fools. Still, they were desperate for understanding of their foe. When he caught the eyes of the council speaker dipping to the world beneath him he knew they would listen.
"The council will hear your words, but speak with caution."
"I have spoken with the prisoner, and compared his words to the actions of his people and their allies, and I fear we are reenacting the 125th tragedy."
Toral paused, to see if any the council knew that one. The 200 tragedy's Grungni had laid before the first high council to argue for a single codified set of laws where collectively well known, but few knew more than the most famous handful. With any luck, they wouldn't know this one, and he could present his argument unopposed. After a pregnant pause the council speaker once again spoke, this time through grinding teeth.
"the council is unfamiliar with that tragedy if you would... enlighten us?"
"Of course, it is one of the less well-known tragedies. Some 30 years before Grungni codified the laws of honor 2 clans sought to come to an accord. One was the Flint Carvers, a small clan of miners looking to sell the metal they mined from the mountain, and the other where the Stout Hammers, a clan of mighty warrior looking for a new source of Irion. Normally such a simple trade would be of little issue, but for one thing. among the flint carvers the right of combat was invoked by striking a hammer upon the ground, and among the Stout Hammers it was custom to emphasize a point by striking the earth with one's weapon. Of course, 2 clans can scarcely greet one other without needing to emphasize a point. So during the course of negations, the Stout Hammer diplomat struck a mighty blow against the stone with his Warhammer, and the somewhat nervous warriors of the Flint Carvers reacted as they though appropriate and slew the unprepared stout hammer delegation. "
here Toral paused, letting the implication sink in. He had timed his visit so that the second of clan Bright Shield would be in the seat, hopefully, his reputation for rashness was well deserved.
"Thane Toral, I fail to see how this is similar. The Laws where in the first contact package sent to the Federation, they would know about the right of challenge. Either explain yourself or cease your slander against my clan."
Toral did not smile, it would do no good to tip his hand too early. Instead, he looked to the speaker and waited for permission as was proper, a nod was all the permission he needed to present his evidence.
"I beg your pardon counselor, but it appears that is not the case. First there is how the Starfleet vessel began evading a good 40 seconds before returning fire implying they did not have their weapons powered, second there is the fact that the first volley of torpedoes did significant damage to the hull, more than any subsequent volley until the shields failed entirely, this is likely because they had kept their shields down or at least at a low setting perhaps as a show of peaceful intentions or to facilitate the use of their transporters. Thirdly there is the conduct of the other vessel. It violated protocol by intervening, and allowed itself to take near crippling damage to evacuate the crew of the Polaris. I do not think they would have done so had they been aware that had the Polaris offered honorable surrender the crew would have been returned unharmed. Finally, there is my conversation with the prisoner. While deception is always possible when dealing with aliens, he would have gained little by acting as ignorant of our customs as he has been. I truly believe he does not understand his position."
All eyes now turned on the Bright Shield counselor, his earlier boasts of his clan being the one to best the Federation in ritual combat turning to ash in his mouth.
"That they were too foolish to understand our ways excuses nothing! they were told of our Laws, any dishonor that comes from failing to understand the Laws falls on their head, not ours. We have brought no dishonor to our people. You deliver no insight or ancestral wisdom, only an insult."
"Indeed counselor, the laws as they are applied to modern life is something any
Dawiar would be able to understand" Toral paused for a second to let the subtle emphasis sink in before continuing.
"however the 125th tragedy does not end in dishonor. For one warrior of the Stout Hammer clan survived the battle and limped back home to report the seemingly treacherous attack. Then it was the Stout Hammers turn to react as they thought was appropriate. They stormed the holds of the Flint Carvers and treated them as oath breakers should be treated. Not a one of them was spared and all of their works were pulled down. By the time the stout hammers learned of the custom that had caused the attack it was too late, the flint carvers were no more, their only remaining legacy was as one of the great tragedies of the age before the Laws."
Again there was a pause, this time a far more ominous one.
"It is indeed fortunate that the power imbalance between us and the Federation is not truly so great then. "
Toral had been wondering when the Far Strider clan would speak. It was they who had found the new "allies" who provided them with the means to strike back, and the clan who stood to lose the most should the Dawiar turn from war.
"Our sworn allies have pulled the curtain back on the Federations illusion of strength. The great vessel that shamed us years ago is the only one of its kind, and they have sworn that Starfleet can spare few ships. If we can match the Caitians, the Federation will do nothing."
"For so say the enemies of the Federation."
"Have care Thane. We are sworn to them, and they to us. Our honor is their honor in this matter. Do you think them, deceivers?"
yes
"No of cores not, but I fear they may have been deceived. The Federation seems to often seek to hide its true strength. Who is to say they have not done the same to the Cardassians?"
"Do you have evidence of this? Or are you merely slandering our oath sworn allies?"
"I do actually. My clan maintains a few points of contacts with the Seyek, when pressed they reported seeing at least two different vessels of the same make as the one that shamed us."
The council falls silent as the implications sink in. At best the Federation's true strength is an unknown, and at worst the Cardassians have tricked them into attacking a sleeping giant for their own gain. Few who sit on the war council are known to be optimists. As is his duty, the council speaker breaks the silence.
"Thane Toral, has your conversation with the prisoner given you any more insight into the Federation?"
"yes. They seem almost comically disinclined to spill blood. I do not know if it is some strange sense of alien honor or a reaction to just how fragile a world truly is in the face of what their ships are capable of, he seems convinced that the Federation will try to seek peace at least one more time. Though given how they likely viewed the destruction of the Polaris It is likely their diplomat may well show us exactly how many ships like the Sarek the Federation really has. If the council finds I am not overstepping myself, I would recommend listing to what they have to say."
the idea that the whole thing was a missed custom of trial by combat kind of stuck in my head. so, this is a scene if that is what actually happened. I
think I got the grammar mostly right this time. Also, fun fact. I rolled 2d100 for the number.