Explorers, as we want more excelsiors roaming bringing in colony spots, providing resources and RP and also finding new warp capable species to become members of the Federation.

Glad to hear it, thanks. Looking at the options in that light...

So unless something seriously shifts, the vote is between Safeguard (nix) and Fleet Upgrades (tryrar). Comparing the two, both have the following in common:

Refit for Connie (35), Expanded Intelligence (40), Amarkia Outpost (10), the needed Allocation (20), and the Explorer Corps Recruitment drive (20), totalling 125.

Safeguard has the mining colony (8), and two diplo pushes (20), vs Fleet Upgrades with the Renaissance project (20).

What were the discounts applied to the Safeguard option, that saved it a few points?
 
As for why diplomatic pushes, we have increased our pp income by 17 and RP by 12 so far and the bonuses from the Rigellans will be added for the coming year. Getting affiliates to 300 and later members is huge for our ability to take actions.

Also we are the federation, we are the diplomatic faction out there so let's play to our strengths.
 
[X][Council]Plan Fleet Upgrade

I'd really like the starbase, but that's fine.

@Yeangst, actions speak louder than words, but diplomacy is action. Diplomacy is not sitting around doing nothing. Diplomacy is us setting ourselves up so that if the Cardassians actually go to war, or if we are compelled to go to war against Cardassia, it will be us-plus-our-three-biggest-friends fighting the war, not us alone.

Remember the biophage? The decisive ACTION that won the battle of Kadesh was Sulu flying to Klingon space to round up a Klingon battlegroup.

Derek, which plan of the surviving four do you endorse?

And if we had a bunch more pp, I'd love to do more diplomacy. But as it stands, there's a decent buffer for most of our affilliates. And we have too many other needs right now. We're in a much better diplomatic position than we were during the biophage crisis. The Klingons are still friednly with us, and itching for a fight even more than they were last time. We have full access to the Amarki fleet in the event of a full blown conflict. We have Rigellians and Caitians very friendly, and probably willing to lend some ships and resources.
 
They are important (either a second or third tier power, probably second tier), but I hope we get a few random events with them pushing them up to affiliate status, then we can do a push at full effectiveness with them next year. The number of random events we get with a species seems to scale with how many ships/planets/colonies they have, so chances should be pretty good.

Though I think we may be making unwarranted assumptions about the Seyek. Here is what exactly was said about them:

We have met the Seyek of Rethelia, and received some aid from them. Apparently they are thrilled to encounter not just a new species, but a multi-species federation. Apparently they too form a multi-species state.

Rethelia is a resource-rich planet, but also a desert world. I believe this is why, despite the plentiful resources, I have been taken to task by almost every Seyek that sees the Courageous that she must be hugely wasteful of resources. "Why don't you fly something more reasonable?" they ask me. Clearly they've never spent time in the helm of one of these.

Look at the bolding. They are a state. They identify themselves as being from a specific planet, not multiple planets. I believe we may be looking, not at an interstellar Federation like our own, but simply at a single planet which has multiple intelligent species inhabiting it.
 
Hmm...

I'm actually tempted to switch to Safeguard. I like the Rennie, but postponing one more year to get a mining colony (reducing our resource problems) and pushing diplomacy with two affiliates... toughie.
 
Design/refit schedule:

2306 Centaur refit
2307 Constitution refit
2308 Renaissance
2309 Constellation refit
2310 Ambassador (possibly earlier if the general techs suffice and we can spare the pp)
2311 Escort design (possibly earlier ...)
2312 medium cruiser design
2313 Excelsior/Oberth refit?
 
Last edited:
[X] nix

I'd prefer starting the Rennaissance now over the Constitution, but I'd rather just have the Constitution than start both at once. And more diplo pushes is our best security, since it means more allied fleets in case of full out war. If a war started over the Apiata or Indorians, we can probably expect a near doubling of our fleet strength from member and affiliate fleets. The more of those we have, the less likely the Cardassians are to start something.
 
[Still trying to catch up]

Yeah, it's insane how much this quest blew up - more than a 100 pages of discussion since 2306 started.

Well, because we'd already have it being designed, while the ConnieB refit will always be available and an option in such a case.

Well getting the Constitution-B right now is very convenient in our schedule, because once the Centaur-B's finish in two years, we can almost immediately start the Constitution-Bs in their births.

edit: not "almost", it's guaranteed since the Centaur-Bs start in Q4, while the refit "research" starts in Q2.

On non-affiliates a diplomatic push gives a single roll to advance them a year, with full affiliates we gain a roll each quarter. The reasoning for this is kind of arbitrary aside from it works the way it does because it does.

@OneirosTheWriter, can you add this to the gameplay mechanics post? I can't even find a post that mentions this.
 
Last edited:
Design/refit schedule:

2306 Centaur refit
2307 Constitution refit
2308 Renaissance
2309 Constellation refit
2310 Ambassador (possibly earlier if the general techs suffice and we can spare the pp)
2311 Escort design (possibly earlier ...)
2312 medium cruiser design
2313 Excelsior/Oberth refit?
You're assuming people will vote for your idea on refits/projects and not for a plan that puts off the Rennie for some other "Important" thing. You know what they say about assuming...
 
Hmm...

I'm actually tempted to switch to Safeguard. I like the Rennie, but postponing one more year to get a mining colony (reducing our resource problems) and pushing diplomacy with two affiliates... toughie.
We need to get that sweet, sweet SR flowing as soon as possible.

And what's having the Rennie a year earlier compared to having more friends?
 
You're assuming people will vote for your idea on refits/projects and not for a plan that puts off the Rennie for some other "Important" thing. You know what they say about assuming...
You're assuming that we'll keep pushing the Rennie further if we don't pick it this year. You know what they say about assuming....
 
You're assuming people will vote for your idea on refits/projects and not for a plan that puts off the Rennie for some other "Important" thing. You know what they say about assuming...
Are the people voting for the rennie this year going to vote against it next year out of spite? If not we can be pretty confident it will win next year unless war breaks out or something crazy happens.
 
Though I think we may be making unwarranted assumptions about the Seyek. Here is what exactly was said about them:



Look at the bolding. They are a state. They identify themselves as being from a specific planet, not multiple planets. I believe we may be looking, not at an interstellar Federation like our own, but simply at a single planet which has multiple intelligent species inhabiting it.
I forgot about them. That does make it a tougher choice.
 
Back
Top