I read the whole thread up to around page 2500 before cheating and reading mostly just the updates. Then I didn't really read the rest of the thread

It did provide a lot of context and knowledge about thinking about microwaved tea. - It made me enjoy PMAS more and helped slow down my reading giving me time to think about each update and also also forced me to think "If I were to vote here, which vote would I do and why" or come up with my own, which isn't something I'd automatically do. Also, the reactions to the updates are part of the experience itself - that's part of how fully published works can be very different from serials. It also allows more suspense about the future when you limit yourself to not just skipping a page.

Also the various omakes in the thread are very fun to read in between chapters.

I can understand completely not reading the whole thread, as it's what I ended up doing, but without the first 2500 pages of the thread, I wouldn't have enjoyed PMAS as a whole nearly as much.
 
You know, someone should give Madoka an Intelligent Device. Y'know, from Nanoha.

Then see if Kyubey would still be capable of making a contract with her.

Why do this?

FOR SCIENCE!
 
Time to try to make an Intelligent Device out of Grief.

We made a phaser, a blaster, and a tricorder, so why not, right?
 
Crap.

Just read the interrogation of Oriko.

She mentioned feathers. Black. With long pinions.

My mind instantly defaulted to this.



Yeah, you've taught me the wonder that is Shadowruns. Thank you.
 
She dead. Kyoko's taking care of Yuma. Yuma's favorite word is tsundere.
This isn't Oriko Magika.

Oriko moved to put Yuma into Kyouko's care, but I don't think she straight up killed Yuma's parents. She also didn't have the time to have Kirika eliminate other nearby magical girls to pump up the Witch population, what orphaned Yuma in Oriko Magika in the first place.

In one of Sabrina's recent conversations with Kyouko, Kyouko specifies she knows how bad Yuma's mother is.

How bad she is.

I don't think she's dead in PMAS.

Sidenote: canonically, her name is Chitose Mako.
 
Well, I have decided that it actually is much faster to just read actual updates after all.

That being said, I do still make it a point to read the comments whenever FLESH OF FALLEN ANGELS is one of the available options.
 
Any meeting with Coobs tends to have an overtly long list of methods via which to kill him. One of which is becoming a vessel of the Blessed Lady and as visceral as Murderface herself. At least, I think. Nobody ever chose that option...
 
Hey, pilot radio nicknames are always given by others, and they are rarely flattering.
1. If you don't have one, your buddies will assign you one.
2. You probably won't like it.
3. If you complain and moan too much about 1 and 2, you'll get a new one you like even less.
My proposals for Callsigns of the mainline Mitakihara meguca, other suggestions welcome, whatever suggestion catches on best wins.
Hey now, those names are actually flattering and ones the owners might like. That's not what callsigns are meant to be (plus we're Sabrina so we don't technically have the right to name ourselves). Here's a more fitting bunch based on your list:

Sabrina: White Savior (Because she is)
Mami: Big Cheese (Because she is too and Nagisa definitely thinks so)
Homura: Dynamite (In every sense of the word)
Sayaka: Wet Nurse (Those baby birds really imprinted on her)
Kirika: C-Block (Nominally stands for "Cast Block")
Oriko: TOTT (The One True Threat, among other meanings)
Kyoko: 8929 ("Yakiniku" which seems self-explanatory... but secretly also "Hakufuku", for anyone familiar with Bleach)
Yuma: MD (Seems short for Medical Doctor, really stands for Mountain Dew because she looks like it and Kyoko can't get enough of her)
 
Homura's definitely Napalm.

Honestly I'm surprised we haven't called Homura napalm, or even mentioned napalm to her yet (Like asking if she has any).
 
so hey how about them votes like there's only 4 so far
Adhoc vote count started by defenestrator on Dec 6, 2019 at 11:33 AM, finished with 63 posts and 4 votes.

  • [X] If any of them have experience with Tokyo, you'd love to hear it. You've got a meeting with them scheduled on Sunday and you have no idea what you're doing.
    [X] There's a reverse-Noriko soul gem collector heading here early next week. We plan to handle it, but if they see them, notify us and do not engage.
    [X] Iowa might be heading in our direction. You're still figuring out what to do about that.
    [X] There's a reverse-Noriko soul gem collector heading here early next week. We plan to handle it, but if they see them, notify us and do not engage.
    [X] Beyond that heads-up, just enjoy yourselves and help the two pairs get comfortable with each other.
 
[X] There's a reverse-Noriko soul gem collector heading here early next week. We plan to handle it, but if they see them, notify us and do not engage.
[X] Beyond that heads-up, just enjoy yourselves and help the two pairs get comfortable with each other.
 
[X] There's a reverse-Noriko soul gem collector heading here early next week. We plan to handle it, but if they see them, notify us and do not engage.
[X] Beyond that heads-up, just enjoy yourselves and help the two pairs get comfortable with each other.
 
But reading the whole thread gives me context into the decisions that shape Sabrina's mental process in each update! :thonk:
You are quite right, and that was exactly my thought process as well!
I lasted until page 3000 before heading to story only, and I believe it took the better part of a year to get through those 3k's... Just a heads up.
 
I didn't even bother reading the whole thread back when I first found it and it's literally a thousand times bigger now.
 
[X] There's a reverse-Noriko soul gem collector heading here early next week. We plan to handle it, but if they see them, notify us and do not engage.
[X] Beyond that heads-up, just enjoy yourselves and help the two pairs get comfortable with each other.
 
Back
Top