Voting is open
Can't even sense anything to instant transmission to? I know Goku used it to travel between distant planets.

If we can't than that is another reason to look forward to the next level of ki sense.
In theory, yes. In practice you're surrounded by dead world after dead world. Anything that's not even more powerful than a Super Saiyan 2 wouldn't register from that range. Beyond that, it gets harder and harder. Goku needs a powerful -- or familiar -- ki signature to lock onto.

That's what you lack.
 
In theory, yes. In practice you're surrounded by dead world after dead world. Anything that's not even more powerful than a Super Saiyan 2 wouldn't register from that range. Beyond that, it gets harder and harder. Goku needs a powerful -- or familiar -- ki signature to lock onto.

That's what you lack.
Mostly meant that when we can sense stuff that isn't alive we should be able to teleport to it.
 
In theory, yes. In practice you're surrounded by dead world after dead world. Anything that's not even more powerful than a Super Saiyan 2 wouldn't register from that range. Beyond that, it gets harder and harder. Goku needs a powerful -- or familiar -- ki signature to lock onto.

That's what you lack.
Being in the Afterlife/Higher World/Other Dimension also seems to help. But I'm fairly sure that's because there's some sort of amplification effect and/or space-warping magic to help with that.
 
Last edited:
Can't even sense anything to instant transmission to? I know Goku used it to travel between distant planets.
1) Did Goku ever use it to reach a planet he hadn't visited before, and where no one he knew was located? It may well be possible to lock onto the ki signature of a high-powered individual you know, or the overall broad-spectrum "life signs" of an entire planet, from much greater ranges than you could lock onto any single living being on that planet who is unknown to you except as a big ball of ki.

If we can't than that is another reason to look forward to the next level of ki sense.
:D I don't disagree.

So if there was anyone of SS2 power or more in the galaxy we would know about it. Is there?
No speed limits. Range limits? Yeah. An SSJ2-level power level, you figure you could get a read on from several systems away, but it could easily be lost in the sheer size of space. Higher? Who knows? It's entirely theoretical.
Space is big. To expand on what Poptart said...

The galaxy is between 100 and 180 thousand light-years in diameter, depending on how you count. Garenhuld is somewhere out in the outer halo of stars surrounding the galaxy, extremely remote. Her closest stellar neighbors may well be tens of light-years away, and it may well be hundreds of light-years to the nearest inhabited system.* One light-year is about six trillion miles or about ten trillion kilometers.

Now, Kakara has phenomenal ki senses and can detect an adult human from "well over the horizon." Even if we interpret that pretty ambitiously (say, a power level of five is visible out to a thousand kilometers), it's easy to understand how over interstellar distances billions, or tens if not hundreds of billions, times greater... even a very powerful ki signature can get lost in the shuffle.

I mean, even to conclude that power levels in the high single-digit billions can be seen from interstellar distances, we have to assume that they 'leak' a much higher proportion of their ki than low 'merely mortal' power levels. Which is believable. We also have to pretty much forget about the inverse square law, which may well be reasonable where ki is concerned.
__________________________

*It's hard to estimate the density of inhabited systems in Dragonball... At least for me at present.

Alright, update written! I'm going to be doing the usual and edit tomorrow before posting. Night, all!

No hard speed limits that anybody's found yet, and yes, it certainly does, for DBS reasons.
If there were lightspeed limits on ki sense, we would have very little to worry about from going Super-Saiyan Two; it would be a long lifetime before the ki pulse from our transformation reached any star that is likely to be inhabited by anyone capable of sending word to the Enemy. We'd be blue before the word got out.

So yeah, ki sense being effectively an ansible, that is to say instantaneous across arbitrarily long distances, really does seem a necessary part of your plot. I salutes and supports that.

He has three paternal aunts, all of whom are in some way estranged from the ruling house (except the one, but she suffers from a severe intellectual disability and is a non-factor for different reasons).
Finding out what Lord Vegeta's two fully functioning sisters think about all this seems like it might be important. Although, as you say, 'estranged,' so their leverage would be limited.

Wait. Didn't one of Yammar's daughters marry Raditz or one of the other Senzus?

That said, finding out the position of Vegetan nobility is actually a vote option that we could spend an action point on, so it's not like I'm expecting you to tell me anything other than maybe "oh yeah, one of Lord Vegeta's sisters is Raditz Senzu's wife and presumably is Not Happy about all this."

He has three maternal aunts and one maternal uncle, but by all accounts Vegeta never favored them and Dandeer has kept them away from anything resembling power.
Gotcha.

Yeah. I mean, how do you quit being a super-saiyan? It's not like an object you can give away. You can renounce the right to transform but no one can enforce that, and if you know the secret of mastering the transformation you're as strong as anyone else on the planet. Come to think of it, that could be one of the big things the Seers select for in picking Scions; they won't pick a kid who might lay down the power and responsibility because it would raise too many questions.

Also, the system has a built-in "retirement plan" for Lords who grow weary of their duties- namely, as soon as you have grandchildren you can pass them on.

Come to think of it, that raises another question... @PoptartProdigy, is there ever more than one generation of Patriarch or Matriarch at the same time? I'd think so, because the Scion can ascend to lordship as soon as an heir is born. There have to have been times when there was an eighty-year-old great-grandmother Matriarch, whose fifty-year-old son ascended to a Patriarch after his thirty-year-old son became Lord upon the one of his little daughters being identified as a viable Scion or something.



...We have Seers. Checking would be easy.
Seers tend to have ethics problems with poking around inside people's mindspaces. Also, do YOU want to scry inside Valentine Somerlad's head to see if there's a pissed off disembodied super-saiyan floating around inside? I don't, because:

1) EWWW. More importantly...

2) Much like Jaffur, the disembodied ball of pissed-off super-saiyan energy that is Vegeta Vegeta would have a great deal of power and nothing to do with it. Meanwhile, the shade of a scrying Seer operates at a few percent of the Seer's normal power level, which even for us isn't enough to stand up to a super-saiyan. It's entirely possible that the result of someone trying to scry into Lord Vegeta's head would be that their mind appears inside his mindscape and eats a Final Flash before they even know what's happening. It's not just distasteful, it's dangerous.

Considering Murks seems to have given up, that probably isn't the case. And by socializing, we would have shown our sincerity of trying to work with them for a better solution, shown to Tamar we were treating his subordinates well and we'd learn more about them.
But it's not like Sings-through-Murk is going to be walled up in an oubliette to starve if we don't socialize with him, it's not like he even surrendered to us personally or like we're the only powerful figure involved here. He was picked up by one of Berra's squads and given medical treatment.

Look, I'm going to be honest, I'm not literally 100% sure you're wrong, I'm not saying it would have been absolutely useless. But I was very far from the only person who did not vote to do it, and I am not responsible for the fact that plans including this action did not receive widespread support. I am not unmindful or unconvinced of the merits of socialization votes IN GENERAL and am open to supporting them in future year votes. I therefore find having people keep picking at me over this, and having to defend myself over it, rather tiresome.

I've already just plain put one person on Ignore because I don't want to deal with endless bitter sarcastic salt and recriminations over this. Could we maybe just stop? Please?
 
1) Did Goku ever use it to reach a planet he hadn't visited before, and where no one he knew was located? It may well be possible to lock onto the ki signature of a high-powered individual you know, or the overall broad-spectrum "life signs" of an entire planet, from much greater ranges than you could lock onto any single living being on that planet who is unknown to you except as a big ball of ki.
Actually, yes. New Namek. However, he had an example of Namekian Ki from Piccolo (how he knew which planet was the right one), and it was so far away that he couldn't detect it. So instead he went to King Kai's planet, which granted him a significantly larger range.
Yeah. I mean, how do you quit being a super-saiyan? It's not like an object you can give away. You can renounce the right to transform but no one can enforce that, and if you know the secret of mastering the transformation you're as strong as anyone else on the planet. Come to think of it, that could be one of the big things the Seers select for in picking Scions; they won't pick a kid who might lay down the power and responsibility because it would raise too many questions.
Presumably using the same measures as that could/would be placed upon someone who accidentally transformed. And it be enforced by the other Super Saiyans.
Seers tend to have ethics problems with poking around inside people's mindspaces. Also, do YOU want to scry inside Valentine Somerlad's head to see if there's a pissed off disembodied super-saiyan floating around inside? I don't, because:

1) EWWW. More importantly...

2) Much like Jaffur, the disembodied ball of pissed-off super-saiyan energy that is Vegeta Vegeta would have a great deal of power and nothing to do with it. Meanwhile, the shade of a scrying Seer operates at a few percent of the Seer's normal power level, which even for us isn't enough to stand up to a super-saiyan. It's entirely possible that the result of someone trying to scry into Lord Vegeta's head would be that their mind appears inside his mindscape and eats a Final Flash before they even know what's happening. It's not just distasteful, it's dangerous.
Seers aren't limited to mindscapes, you know. They have a variety of applications, beyond seeing through time/space, such as being able to see magic, ki and even more abstract stuff.

Plus, there's fun stuff, like "Peering into the future to see the result of this action". Therefore getting the information without actually mind delving. :p
 
Presumably using the same measures as that could/would be placed upon someone who accidentally transformed. And it be enforced by the other Super Saiyans.
Those restrictions are quite unwelcome and unpleasant and would probably sit ill with someone who'd had years or decades to get used to the transformation in its mastered state. All in all, I suspect that a Scion or Lord who was truly unhappy with their status would just grimly "wait it out" until the grandchildren are born, possibly shoveling as much as possible of their duties off on their Scion or duly delegated regular saiyans in the meantime.

There COULD be exceptions to this rule... but the House system has only been in place for about ten to fifteen generations, as far as I can tell. The total number of Gokun and Vegetan Lords and Ladies that have ever lived up to this point is probably somewhere between twenty and forty.

That's a lot and a long time compared to the memory of any person in the system, but it is nowhere near long enough to "ring the changes" on every possible combination of circumstances regarding Lordship, Scions, and the succession.

Seers aren't limited to mindscapes, you know. They have a variety of applications, beyond seeing through time/space, such as being able to see magic, ki and even more abstract stuff.

Plus, there's fun stuff, like "Peering into the future to see the result of this action". Therefore getting the information without actually mind delving. :p
I'm not sure how much blatant hax is actually possible in this case, because in this case we want information specifically regarding the contents of "Valentine Somerlad's" mind and whether there's a pissed off fully conscious super-saiyan in there. About the only thing I can think of would be if the Seers in question try to predict the result of un-Sealing Lord Vegeta, and there could easily be a lot of problems with that. There could be dozens of possible results (greatly confusing the issue), or... who knows?

I'm not saying "this is a stupid and impossible plan." But the obvious way of gathering the information you want would be dangerous and unpleasant, and the indirect ways of gathering it sound like they could turn out to be pretty difficult. Something to bear in mind.
 
When we finally get up to the higher seer levels we are going to be so awesome. There is a reason we have been delaying picking a style. We were hoping to develop more seer abilities to build a style around.
 
I'm not sure how much blatant hax is actually possible in this case, because in this case we want information specifically regarding the contents of "Valentine Somerlad's" mind and whether there's a pissed off fully conscious super-saiyan in there. About the only thing I can think of would be if the Seers in question try to predict the result of un-Sealing Lord Vegeta, and there could easily be a lot of problems with that. There could be dozens of possible results (greatly confusing the issue), or... who knows?
Well, if the result is "death", that's telling. Otherwise, the Seer would logically tell others what they saw in the mind. Meaning that it'd be Seen.

Basically, imagine there being 2 Seers and Apra in the room. Seer A is prepared to Mind-Delve Valentine, with orders to inform Apra of what they found, while Seer B looks into the future to see the result of that action. If it's death, Seer B has the operation aborted. Otherwise, Seer A would exit Valentine's mind and inform Apra. Seer B sees this, and informs them.
 
When we finally get up to the higher seer levels we are going to be so awesome. There is a reason we have been delaying picking a style. We were hoping to develop more seer abilities to build a style around.
That... wasn't a very good reason, honestly. Inventing your own style sounds like the kind of thing you do after you've at least reached journeyman level in one or more of the existing styles.

Like, in real life, schools of martial arts are generally founded by people who are already good at one or more existing martial arts styles.

Well, if the result is "death", that's telling. Otherwise, the Seer would logically tell others what they saw in the mind. Meaning that it'd be Seen.

Basically, imagine there being 2 Seers and Apra in the room. Seer A is prepared to Mind-Delve Valentine, with orders to inform Apra of what they found, while Seer B looks into the future to see the result of that action. If it's death, Seer B has the operation aborted. Otherwise, Seer A would exit Valentine's mind and inform Apra. Seer B sees this, and informs them.
What I'm trying to get across is that the Sight isn't perfect, does not confer true omniscience and doesn't automatically make it safe to do things that seem unsafe, just because you've foreseen a good outcome.

I'm sure that by cleverness you can lawyer up some seemingly airtight ways to figure out what's going on with Lord Vegeta's seal. However, the fact remains that you ARE potentially asking one or more Seers to either risk their life by poking around inside Vegeta's mind, or to interpret future clues to determine a very high-stakes course of action in the present. This is not impossible, but...

Um... do you understand what I'm getting at? Like, I get that you seem quite excited about the clever ways you're thinking of to avoid the danger, but do you understand that the danger is nonetheless real, and that real people might seek to avoid this danger, especially since they're taking the risk on behalf of a man who is almost universally hated?



EDIT:

Also, something about trying to hax the universe even harder by using one Seer to inform us of the potential results of an entirely different Seer's course of action and ensure that seemingly risky courses of actions are in fact safe... feels a bit like the old "put a bag of holding inside a bag of holding" thing. The effects could get weird.

I'm reminded of a snippet from a particular Harry Potter fic- while it has flaws, the snippet in question is pretty good in my opinion. Suffice to say, for those unfamiliar or indifferent, that it involves the activities of a very, very Ravenclaw Harry, who has just gotten his hands on a Time Turner.

Thursday.

If you wanted to be specific, 7:24am on Thursday morning.

Harry was sitting on his bed, a textbook lying limp in his motionless hands.

Harry had just had an idea for a truly brilliant experimental test.

It would mean waiting an extra hour for breakfast, but that was why he had cereal bars. No, this idea absolutely positively had to be tested right away, immediately, now.

Harry set the textbook aside, leapt out of bed, raced around his bed, yanked out the cavern level of his trunk, ran down the stairs, and started moving boxes of books around. (He really needed to unpack and get bookcases at some point but he was in the middle of his textbook reading contest with Hermione and falling behind so he hadn't had time.)

Harry found the book he wanted and raced back upstairs. The other boys were getting ready to go down to breakfast in the Great Hall and start the day.

"Excuse me can you do something for me?" said Harry. He was flipping through the book's index as he spoke, found the page with the first ten thousand primes, flipped to that page, and thrust the book at Anthony Goldstein. "Pick two three-digit numbers from this list. Don't tell me what they are. Just multiply them together and tell me the product. Oh, and can you do the calculation twice to double-check? Please make really sure you've got the right answer, I'm not sure what's going to happen to me or the universe if you make a multiplication error."

It said a lot about what life in that dorm had been like over the past few days that Anthony didn't even bother saying anything like "Why'd you suddenly flip out?" or "That seems really weird, what are your reasons for asking?" or "What do you mean, you're not sure what's going to happen to the universe?"

Anthony wordlessly accepted the book and took out a parchment and quill. Harry spun around and shut his eyes, making sure not to see anything, dancing back and forth and bouncing up and down with impatience. He got a pad of paper and a mechanical pencil and got ready to write.

"Okay," Anthony said, "One hundred and eighty-one thousand, four hundred and twenty-nine."

Harry wrote down 181,429. He repeated what he'd just written down, and Anthony confirmed it.

Then Harry raced back down into the cavern level of his trunk, glanced at his watch (the watch said 4:28 which meant 7:28) and then shut his eyes.

Around thirty seconds later, Harry heard the sound of steps, followed by the sound of the cavern level of the trunk sliding shut. (Harry wasn't worried about suffocating. An automatic Air-Freshening Charm was part of what you got if you were willing to buy a really good trunk. Wasn't magic wonderful, it didn't have to worry about electric bills.)

And when Harry opened his eyes, he saw just what he'd been hoping to see, a folded piece of paper left on the floor, the gift of his future self.

Call that piece of paper "Paper-2".

Harry tore a piece of paper off his pad.

Call that "Paper-1". It was, of course, the same piece of paper. You could even see, if you looked closely, that the ragged edges matched.

Harry reviewed in his mind the algorithm that he would follow.

If Harry opened up Paper-2 and it was blank, then he would write "101 x 101" down on Paper-1, fold it up, study for an hour, go back in time, drop off Paper-1 (which would thereby become Paper-2), and head on up out of the cavern level to join his dorm mates for breakfast.

If Harry opened up Paper-2 and it had two numbers written on it, Harry would multiply those numbers together.

If their product equaled 181,429, Harry would write down those two numbers on Paper-1 and send Paper-1 back in time.

Otherwise Harry would add 2 to the number on the right and write down the new pair of numbers on Paper-1. Unless that made the number on the right greater than 997, in which case Harry would add 2 to the number on the left and write down 101 on the right.

And if Paper-2 said 997 x 997, Harry would leave Paper-1 blank.

Which meant that the only possible stable time loop was the one in which Paper-2 contained the two prime factors of 181,429.

If this worked, Harry could use it to recover any sort of answer that was easy to check but hard to find. He wouldn't have just shown that P=NP once you had a Time-Turner, this trick was more general than that. Harry could use it to find the combinations on combination locks, or passwords of every sort. Maybe even find the entrance to Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets, if Harry could figure out some systematic way of describing all the locations in Hogwarts. It would be an awesome cheat even by Harry's standards of cheating.

Harry took Paper-2 in his trembling hand, and unfolded it.

Paper-2 said in slightly shaky handwriting:

DO NOT MESS WITH TIME

Harry wrote down "DO NOT MESS WITH TIME" on Paper-1 in slightly shaky handwriting, folded it neatly, and resolved not to do any more truly brilliant experiments on Time until he was at least fifteen years old.

To the best of Harry's knowledge, that had been the scariest experimental result in the entire history of science.

It had been somewhat difficult for Harry to focus on reading his textbook for the next hour.

That was how Harry's Thursday started.
 
Last edited:
Being in the Afterlife/Higher World/Other Dimension also seems to help. But I'm fairly sure that's because there's some sort of amplification effect and/or space-warping magic to help with that.
Or due to something similar to the effect of being a higher dimensional being in that lower dimensional barriers are meaningless.
 
The distance may not be meaningless, but "how far are we from the afterlife?" sounds like the kind of question where the answer is the same everywhere in the galaxy.
 
I am with Simon on why the range is increased in the afterlife. Though mechanic wise, it could be that goku was elite in ki sense and his elite talent allowed him to sense the otherworld since he had been there when he died. It could be he reached that point while training on the genkidama and IT since they both involve ki sense.
 
The distance may not be meaningless, but "how far are we from the afterlife?" sounds like the kind of question where the answer is the same everywhere in the galaxy.
Eh. Different parts of the Living World seem to correspond to different parts the Other World. And the Other World is big.
Also, different check-in stations apparently exist for different planets/areas? I'd say retcon, but maybe after Goku, Vegeta and Hercule saved the universe, the number of check-ins were expanded and he got Earth.
 
Last edited:
Oh, and the mystery of why humans are everywhere, often without any knowledge/evidence of more technological past has been solved: according to a 2013 source book, as part of the Supreme Kai's job of spreading life throughout the universe, they'll occasionally take pre-existing lifeforms and transplant them to new planets.

Shin got lazy~

I'm also betting the reason nearly all sapient species are humanoid, and most look similar to humans/Shinjin is for a similar reason. Bet you that's why so many alien species seem capable of interbreeding as well. :drevil:
 
Last edited:
Eh. Different parts of the Living World seem to correspond to different parts the Other World. And the Other World is big.
"Big" compared to "how far can a human being walk in a year" or even "how far can a saiyan fly in a year, traveling at Mach 10 the whole way" is a very, very different thing from "big" in the sense of "space is big."

If every living world had an afterlife that contained real estate a billion miles on a side, so large that you could scatter the entire population of Earth that has ever existed into it at a population density of one person per ten million square miles...

And if those afterlifes had billion mile gulfs separating one from another...

...They would STILL be much, much closer together than different star systems are in outer space.
 
"Big" compared to "how far can a human being walk in a year" or even "how far can a saiyan fly in a year, traveling at Mach 10 the whole way" is a very, very different thing from "big" in the sense of "space is big."

If every living world had an afterlife that contained real estate a billion miles on a side, so large that you could scatter the entire population of Earth that has ever existed into it at a population density of one person per ten million square miles...

And if those afterlifes had billion mile gulfs separating one from another...

...They would STILL be much, much closer together than different star systems are in outer space.
As in, the Other World is just as, if not bigger then the Mortal World.
 
Okay, but I can easily imagine the Other World being bigger in that the parts living beings actually experience are made orders of magnitude larger, without the Other World actually having to occupy more space. So much of the 'Mortal World' or rather its universe is empty, unused space that you could easily compress the space between places people use and move through, and still vastly expand the places people move through themselves.

And yes, yes, writers have no sense of scale, et cetera. I'm sure you can find some simplistic one-liner quote by Toriyama or something that directly contradicts my elaborately reasoned speculations. Just like you can with almost any attempt to make sense of Dragonball in a logically consistent way.

Right now I can't muster the strength to worry about that, though. Feeling tired.
 
Mostly meant that when we can sense stuff that isn't alive we should be able to teleport to it.
...what? You...you presently can't sense stuff that isn't alive.
So yeah, ki sense being effectively an ansible, that is to say instantaneous across arbitrarily long distances, really does seem a necessary part of your plot. I salutes and supports that.

Finding out what Lord Vegeta's two fully functioning sisters think about all this seems like it might be important. Although, as you say, 'estranged,' so their leverage would be limited.

Wait. Didn't one of Yammar's daughters marry Raditz or one of the other Senzus?

That said, finding out the position of Vegetan nobility is actually a vote option that we could spend an action point on, so it's not like I'm expecting you to tell me anything other than maybe "oh yeah, one of Lord Vegeta's sisters is Raditz Senzu's wife and presumably is Not Happy about all this."

Gotcha.

Yeah. I mean, how do you quit being a super-saiyan? It's not like an object you can give away. You can renounce the right to transform but no one can enforce that, and if you know the secret of mastering the transformation you're as strong as anyone else on the planet. Come to think of it, that could be one of the big things the Seers select for in picking Scions; they won't pick a kid who might lay down the power and responsibility because it would raise too many questions.

Also, the system has a built-in "retirement plan" for Lords who grow weary of their duties- namely, as soon as you have grandchildren you can pass them on.

Come to think of it, that raises another question... @PoptartProdigy, is there ever more than one generation of Patriarch or Matriarch at the same time? I'd think so, because the Scion can ascend to lordship as soon as an heir is born. There have to have been times when there was an eighty-year-old great-grandmother Matriarch, whose fifty-year-old son ascended to a Patriarch after his thirty-year-old son became Lord upon the one of his little daughters being identified as a viable Scion or something.
Not even for the sake of plot. I draw it from a moment of DBS in which (not a spoiler, don't worry) Goku has cause to teleport across (arbitrarily long interstellar/-galactic distance of which I'm not entirely sure) by locking onto Gohan's ki. Gohan powers up in response, and Goku feels it.

Yes, one of Vegeta's estranged sisters is Raditz's wife.

There have been multiple generations of living past Lords and Ladies.. That said, they tend not to persist in that state of affairs for very long; old age does for them, as it does most great-grandparents in real life.
@PoptartProdigy : Is the Afterimage Technique known? It did not get used that much after people started getting good ki sense, but it was very effective on foes without.
People moving quickly enough to leave an afterimage behind? I mean, normal humans can, "use," it (wave your hand back and forth really quickly), so I don't think they've forgotten it, no.
*Methods of Rationality snip*
hiss
 
Last edited:
Oh, and the mystery of why humans are everywhere, often without any knowledge/evidence of more technological past has been solved: according to a 2013 source book, as part of the Supreme Kai's job of spreading life throughout the universe, they'll occasionally take pre-existing lifeforms and transplant them to new planets.

Shin got lazy~

I'm also betting the reason nearly all sapient species are humanoid, and most look similar to humans/Shinjin is for a similar reason. Bet you that's why so many alien species seem capable of interbreeding as well. :drevil:

"-and everybody speaks the same language because the stargates put translation nanites in the brains of everybody who uses them."

Cop-out.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top