Brockton's Celestial Forge (Worm/Jumpchain)

Master vs Thinker debate.

Thinker: while the thinker did know what to do or say to convince you to do something bad, and it was probably gradual not from j-walking being the worst you ever did you murder. But at the end of the day it was you who did it. As opposed to the Master situation the plane is 100% on you, but you are likely to handle it much better than the after math of being mastered. But at the end of the day you are a bad person, or at least someone who has sunk low. And you need to acknowledge that you have done wrong and work roots improving. Even if you didn't even notice that you reached that low.

Thinker: morally you have sunk low, and if you don't like that you will need to work towards fixing yourself. But in the long wrong you will feel better once you improve.
What about Contessa? She can run a path to turn anyone into scum if given enough time and if she can actually path them. Don't say she's an exception, she actually exactly a perfect example. The argument is that thinkers bring you into lows but that's something you choose to do. PTV works with that as well ultimately, if it is possible, even with a 0.00000001% chance of happening, she'll make it happen. Coil too, he could run timelines to know exactly how to push your buttons, especially combined with Dinah and Lisa. The thing about the universe is that literally anything is possible, life is a series of exception and twists of turns no-one expects. Of course, this within itself is an exception, but humans are inherently flawed as well, should you really be blamed for being human and for having any weakness in your mental state that thinkers could exploit, does that mean that everyone is a bad person because there's always the possibility that they could do wrong?

I'm not really saying Uber and Leet are fully innocent, but I want others to realize that things like this aren't so clear cut and trying to rationalize by simplifying things in order to justify more extreme actions is partially the kind of thing that put Taylor into a downward spiral in canon.
 
With the city in a state of emergency and the PRT in charge of all Parahuman matters I fear that Piggot will do something horrible to him.

So in that city there is now.

E88
ABB
Merchants
Coil
New Wave
Faultline
Undersiders
Protectorate/PRT
Dragon
Dragon slayers
And now a biotinker.
With Aperion as the cherry on top.

Piggot is going to crash any moment now. I hope for hilarity that she goes beserk and tries to kill Blasto and fail of course.
 
So in that city there is now.
Don't forget individual joining or possible ones too, like Damsel of Distress. March seems to want to bring someone or people from New York that are interested in powers, there just so happen to be Adepts in New York, people that do rituals and stuff to get closer to their trigger events and be more powerful, so it sounds highly likely that the Adepts are coming too. There's also The Teeth and Butcher, who were driven out of New York, and could be smelling another opportunity Boston Games style.
 
Something that seems to be getting overlooked is that Leet actually built an "internal scanning probe" to stab Labyrinth with. He wasn't able to bring himself to stab and/or murder a child, but he still built the thing and Uber and Marche were able to get him up to the edge of doing so. The fact he was regretting not killing said child screams that there a lot going wrong in his head. The fact that the other two were pushing him to do it means I'm hoping they have just long enough to see the freight train right before it impacts their broken bodies. I have zero pity for those who deliberately target children.
 
I remember Lord stating that Joe would need Perks from the Magitech Constellation to make any real progress in curing case 53s, but I'm curious how much he can do towards that goal with his current abilities.
 
Last edited:
On the whole 'master vs thinker' debate. So Stockholm syndrome is considered a potential defense in court because when you are powerless against someone and think that they are saving your life *your brain can re-wire itself to protect your life.* It is similar with children of criminals who have their parents convince them to commit crimes. When someone can refute your argument perfectly sensibly every time and make it seem like doing something bad was your own idea or utilize logical fallacies in a way that make a person 'have to' agree with them? Then it's a thinker with a master sub-rating. Jack can make almost any cape work for him if he gets power over them and can talk to them because he knows exactly what to do to break them. Uber could design a perfect argument every time so that Leet feels like he has to agree. This related to why people with mental disabilities and children get a lot of slack (most of the time) in court.

What's happening with Leet reminds me more of real life cult brainwashing that I've read about, particularly NXIVM, rather than Stockholm syndrome. Leet's even being exposed to sleep derivation and he's going along with it willingly. With NXIVM, at the beginning, Allison Mack was probably was a brainwashed victim also, but then she went on to become the number two person in NXIVM, coming up with the idea to brand women as slaves.

Considering the scope of what he's been doing though, I think if it goes to court, people will take into consideration the Thinker backed brainwashing, but he also has a history of doing illegal stuff even prior to being brainwashed. He also won't have the benefit of being a pretty, young blonde haired girl, so I doubt there'll be much mercy from the court or the jury.
 
remember Lord stating that Joe would need Perks from the Magitech Constellation to make any real progress in curing case 53s

Hmm, I just peeked at the possible Magitech perks, and I'm not too familiar with some of the settings they come from...anybody have any idea which ones might be best for this? I do know Mage the Awakening, and magic there is pretty broad and up to the imagination of the player and the tolerance levels of the game master when playing it, so maybe Technomancy? Though Crimson Saint and the paired Mega Bomb/Guru perks both look potent as well, I'm not as familiar with those settings....

Edit: and to avoid double posting, I think I'll mention that Toy Box usually tries to recruit new Tinkers that show promise... what happened to their recruiter? Is he wandering about the Bay even now, rushing around every time Apieron makes an appearance only to arrive too late to make contact? Also, it would seem to me Apieron is perfect for the Elite as well... (well, from their viewpoint at least).
 
Last edited:
What about Contessa? She can run a path to turn anyone into scum if given enough time and if she can actually path them. Don't say she's an exception, she actually exactly a perfect example. The argument is that thinkers bring you into lows but that's something you choose to do. PTV works with that as well ultimately, if it is possible, even with a 0.00000001% chance of happening, she'll make it happen.

————

I'm not really saying Uber and Leet are fully innocent, but I want others to realize that things like this aren't so clear cut and trying to rationalize by simplifying things in order to justify more extreme actions is partially the kind of thing that put Taylor into a downward spiral in canon.

If Contessa runs a path to turn me into a scumbag, then more so than with any other thinker's involvement, I am now a self-assured, card carrying piece of shit. God help anyone who wants me to be redeemed, who thinks I ought to have a second chance due to power based influence on me, because plot device fedora said no. Being awful is now assuredly my fate.

In the case of Leet, a hypothetical redeemed future version of him ought to be happy that Uber was not that strong and that Marche was not YET a discount contessa. That's the only reason any good in him would have managed to survive long enough for him to turn his life around.

I wouldn't say it's an undue rationalization to say Leet perhaps ought to face some harsh punishment for what's he's done. But yeah, anyone of the mindset that that punishment ought to be delivered onto him forcefully as he cackles maniacally, because he's just too far gone and "I" need to take him down a peg, is kind of missing the point. He ought to accept punishment onto himself if it comes to him, but beyond that he ought to work to atone in appropriate ways if he wants to be better, because punishment for punishment's sake in any scenario is just stupid. I know the worm setting isn't exactly going to offer any rehabilitative support, so I'd say Leet's best chance is to get offered a PRT rebranding on the grounds of his new apparent potential and then to be assigned a therapist. Though with their weird rotating therapist schedule thing, Leets still gonna have to pick up most of the slack for his self-betterment on his own.

And if he doesn't want to change, he just ought to be taken down quickly, without anyone else's moral opinion of him overcomplicating the process with weird punishment fantasies or ill-justified extreme actions. I agree there. I think that would indeed contribute to a downward spiral in this case. It doesn't seem exactly inappropriate to get a bit extreme, though, while Leet is in the midst of aiding terrorism and trying to Tron download a city of people.

Edit: and to avoid double posting, I think I'll mention that Toy Box usually tries to recruit new Tinkers that show promise... what happened to their recruiter? Is he wandering about the Bay even now, rushing around every time Apieron makes an appearance only to arrive too late to make contact? Also, it would seem to me Apieron is perfect for the Elite as well... (well, from their viewpoint at least).

Toybox could just digitally contact him at this point. I'd say we're looking at a few possibilities:

1. No one at Toybox is interested in bothering the powerful mega-tinker while he's in the middle of an 8-way gang clusterfuck.

2. No one at Toybox wants to be made obsolete within their business by including an apparent "whatever the fuck I want to build" tinker who seems to be happy enough already doing "mercenary work" on his own. This doesn't preclude them hiring him for specific tech issues and a short term basis.

3. No one at Toybox wants the attention bringing in Apeiron would level at them, because he's kind of become a Big Deal recently to the PRT.

4. The people of Toybox think he's a gradually degrading mad scientist, or a master, or any other such negative theory casting Apeiron in a light where they wouldn't want to work with him as a person.
 
Last edited:
Toybox could just digitally contact him at this point. I'd say we're looking at a few possibilities:

1. No one at Toybox is interested in bothering the powerful mega-tinker while he's in the middle of an 8-way gang clusterfuck.

2. No one at Toybox wants to be made obsolete within their business by including an apparent "whatever the fuck I want to build" tinker who seems to be happy enough already doing "mercenary work" on his own. This doesn't preclude them hiring him for specific tech issues and a short term basis.

3. No one at Toybox wants the attention bringing in Apeiron would level at them, because he's kind of become a Big Deal recently to the PRT.

4. The people of Toybox think he's a gradually degrading mad scientist, or a master, or any other such negative theory casting Apeiron in a light where they wouldn't want to work with him as a person.

5. It's only been a few days. Apeiron's public debut was Saturday night the 16th. The current story timeline is Thursday morning the 21st. The Toybox recruiter is still trying to book a hotel room in BB.
 
New WoG on AO3 dropped, looks like the Butcher's coming to town! They want to seek March to prevent from being an eternally screaming voice in someone's head. It would be funny if they came to BB for March then decided to try and hire the Supertinker to help. I wonder if Joe could exorcise spirits of dead Butchers? The kill-takeover thing has to count as some sort of dark ritual, right!
 
New WoG on AO3 dropped, looks like the Butcher's coming to town! They want to seek March to prevent from being an eternally screaming voice in someone's head. It would be funny if they came to BB for March then decided to try and hire the Supertinker to help. I wonder if Joe could exorcise spirits of dead Butchers? The kill-takeover thing has to count as some sort of dark ritual, right!
It sure as hell counts as a possession.
 
New WoG on AO3 dropped, looks like the Butcher's coming to town! They want to seek March to prevent from being an eternally screaming voice in someone's head. It would be funny if they came to BB for March then decided to try and hire the Supertinker to help. I wonder if Joe could exorcise spirits of dead Butchers? The kill-takeover thing has to count as some sort of dark ritual, right!

Wow. So...March's master plan is to Butcherify Joe? Thats...so....evil! Welp. Now Joe has an ethical use for those cages at least.
 
Wow. So...March's master plan is to Butcherify Joe? Thats...so....evil! Welp. Now Joe has an ethical use for those cages at least.

The Butcher isn't a straight up possession master, just a broken shard that reattaches immediately with every previous human host's consciousness still intact, so it would be very interesting to see how Joe would react to becoming Butcher Number Whatever. I assume he counts as a parahuman viable for possession given he was assigned a shard, even if he ended up not using it.

He's already gotten perks that give him conflicting experiences from "past jumps," and if he gets certain perks between now and his possession he might even have experience with entire alternate conflicting lives being dumped into his memory. Assuming that doesn't drive him a bit nuts in and of itself, Joe would probably be one of the most prepared people ever to share headspace with the Butcher's personalities.

I wonder if he could use the throne to set them up a cozy little virtual meeting space, or something like that. Could help with all the collective Butchers' mental health to be given the illusion of having their own bodies again.

I mean, before anyone gets that comfortable, no matter how prepared Joe is, it's certainly going to be a bit of a psychotic shitshow. But a very fun shitshow to read about, I'd imagine.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure the Butcher Shard could connect to Joe, since his shard connection is hijacked by the Celestial Forge fiat and I doubt it will be cooperating with the Butcher Shard. Not that March knows that of course, nor would Joe want to take the risk.
 
I don't think the Butcher shard requires the killer to be a parahuman in order to attach to them. Non-parahumans just rarely kill the Butcher.
 
Brockton Bay Cape Population (HoldMyFOOF)
I did a thing (@Sterlyn told me to!) No guarantees that it's 100% accurate, but it should (in theory) be close-ish. Without further ado,

Brockton Bay Cape Population



Edit: Discounting Apeiron & Co., that's (68/83) Active Capes.

[2021-04-29T05:49Z] |16| Added Scrub to Merchants, adjusted counter.
[2021-04-15T21:19Z] |15| Added counters.
[2021-04-15T20:49Z] |14| Removed 'ENE' suffix from Protectorate/Wards, Gully set to 'Disaster Relief'; Lightstar set to 'Disaster Relief'; Purity & Rune Reactivated, Damsel of Distress added; Travelers Arrived, Cody went to Brazil China, Coil is still scum, News at 11.
[2021-03-04T22:35Z] |13| Triumph Confirmed Alive
[2021-01-29T03:14Z] |12| ABB cape status' confirmed
[2021-01-28T15:53Z] |11| Almost forgot that Triumph got his teeth kicked in.
[2021-01-28T07:45Z] |10| Chen added to Apeiron & Co.; Lung fuckin' REKT, waiting to see a body for confirmation; Oni Lee & March status unknown, presumed living but severely injured.
[2021-01-15T20:27Z] |9| Gully now 'Semi-Inactive'
[2021-01-05T01:25Z] |8| I forgot Crusader existed, too; fixed. Tacked Oliver onto Travelers.
[2021-01-04T06:28Z] |7| Assault is active again; I completely missed him getting healed, apparently.
[2021-01-03T06:55Z] |6| Added Travelers (as Inactive) because they'll probably show up sooner or later; Fixed the changelog date.
[2021-01-02T01:47Z] |5| Added Changelog for convenience.
[2021-01-02T01:21Z] |4| Remembered to change the Active Cape Count from Edit No. 3
[2021-01-02T00:47Z] |3| Realized Velocity & Assault were incapacitated, Set to Inactive
[2021-01-02T00:20Z] |2| Unfucked BBCode for ABB URL's; Remembered that Dinah exists and added her; was reminded Gully exists, added her
[2021-01-02T00:17Z] |1| Added Active Cape count.
[2021-01-02T00:15Z] |0| Posted Roster
[2021-__-__T__:__Z] |T| Changelog Template, Ignore me.

Feel free to tell me what I did wrong, I'll probably fix it.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure the Butcher Shard could connect to Joe, since his shard connection is hijacked by the Celestial Forge fiat and I doubt it will be cooperating with the Butcher Shard. Not that March knows that of course, nor would Joe want to take the risk.

I don't think the Celestial Forge is in the habit of "not cooperating" with anything. In fact, with the possibility of a second trigger, it seems quite likely that the Forge is at least superficially mimicking a shard and will act as such in regard to Joe, if not the rest of the setting.

If the Butcher can't posses him, I'd say it's just because he doesn't read as a parahuman at all, not because the Forge is stopping it. If the Butcher can posses him, I'd say it's for similar reasons as to why Noelle can spawn clones of him with a connection to his original shard and bits and pieces of forge knowledge.

I don't think the Butcher shard requires the killer to be a parahuman in order to attach to them. Non-parahumans just rarely kill the Butcher.

Nope, I'm quite certain the rule of the butcher is that it attaches to parahumans. If a normal person kills them they just attach to the nearest parahuman instead of the person who killed them.
 
Last edited:
Wow. So...March's master plan is to Butcherify Joe? Thats...so....evil! Welp. Now Joe has an ethical use for those cages at least.
Since she work with actually alien influence over her thoughts and is not that sane anyway.

I would then buy if the idea is to have flechette kill the butcher to then kill flechette and be with her forever...
...until Zion appear and show his clear displeasure from two pieces of a shard that can hurt him being combine together and added to a cluster.
if he can pass his clear disgusts from some many 'monster capes' in the same place. Because he dislike how disfigured their shards are. I think. I can be really wrong here.
 
I don't think the Butcher shard requires the killer to be a parahuman in order to attach to them. Non-parahumans just rarely kill the Butcher.
Unless Butchers spontaneously develop new brain connections* when connected to the new Shard, it sort of has to go through the connection set up by the previous Shard (unless the scenario you mentioned happens where it is someone with no previous powers, which is not relevant to Joe I don't think). So either the Butcher Shard can order the prior Shard around or the prior Shard is cooperating in allowing it to use the connection at the same time, or something like that.

* can't remember the term
 
...until Zion appear and show his clear displeasure from two pieces of a shard that can hurt him being combine together and added to a cluster.

Scion is a depressed space lump, at least until Jack convinces him to embrace his inner psychotic murderer. I think you vastly overestimate how much he would care. Really, I doubt that he would care at all.
 
Back
Top