Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
Mathilde is paranoid and filled with suspicion.
But the trick here is that she does not allow that paranoia turn her into a self sabotaging fool like she was a stereotypical 40k inquisitor.
We, and therefore Mathilde, have been suspicious of Egrim from day one.
But instead of pre emptively killing, or sidelining, him, we pull him into our orbit and made being loyal into something beneficial to him.
Being suspicious of everyone, and everything, can be a useful tool, but if it is the only tool you have, you are as doomed to failure as a carpenter with nothing but a hammer.
 
Last edited:
She has had a vast river of gold pass through her fingers and not had it stick in a way that'd you'd be able to clearly say that yes, she has it. It's been spent on books that are now in a library she controls but does not own and research materials and infrastructure with at minimum dual-use.

Her idea of going on vacation is to leave for a few months to murder dark elves and even her very nice home doubles as part of a superweapon. It's complicated, in the best way.
This.

Mathilde has repeatedly has opportunities to acquire great wealth and freely passed it up, usually without hesitation. She consistently sees wealth as a lesser temptation than things like knowledge, research opportunities, or accomplishing a good deed.

Even in a case where she could have kept a good deal of money she had already considered freely given (the jewels from Borek before he disappeared), she decided to give that wealth to Gotrek's widow rather than take the alternative options of compensation even when no one else would know or care. That's the Vow of Poverty mentality--that the appeal of money is greatly lessened beyond practical uses and good causes.

Remember, Mathilde discovered a huge pile of treasure in Karag Nar when she infiltrated it and could have taken anything from it and no one would ever have known, but she never even considered it. She laid down on it for a bit for fun, but the appeal of acquiring any of it was absent--instead, the appeal was on accomplishing the mission and doing the right thing.

It's not that she's poor--as we've seen, the Vow of Poverty doesn't actually mean living in poverty. It's that she isn't tempted by money beyond a "is there a practical use I can immediately see for this", and if the answer is "no" then it becomes a burden in the "I guess I'll have to find some way to deal with this, ugh" sense.

It's telling that the transcendent boon she got from Belegar was spent on building a public library for everyone that would survive long past her own lifespan--not named after her, either. It's not a matter of legacy, it's about seeing a tragic problem in the world and wanting to do what she can to fix it.

Heck, even the latest gambit to buy up a bunch of ithilmar and sell it to Laurelorn was used to secure a book deal with the Library of Mournings rather than just straight wealth.

The assassination of the late Tsar? Asked for a project that would benefit both Kislev and the Empire, not herself.

The temptation of money is not absent, but it is remarkably limited and vastly overshadowed by the temptation of knowledge, good deeds, or magical opportunities (research or material). Which is exactly the kind of mentality that the Vow of Poverty wants to cultivate.
 
Kind of like how a Witch Hunter Elector Count once found out that his spymaster was under the thumb of the Lahmians, and decided to work behind the scenes to liberate her from that conspiracy rather than treat her as a threat to be expunged. Paying it forward and all that.

That's an extremely strong parallel, really.
 
Either way, this is why I'm pushing for the Supreme Patriarch position. When Mathilde acted as a teacher and a leader to a group of wizards, it turned out pretty damn well.

She would have to brush up on some stuff, get some allies among the colleges. But I think it be a excellent goal for the future.
The moment either Mandred or Roswita get elected to the Big Chair I'm going to vote to try for the position. The narrative possibilities of being the SP in and of itself don't really interest me enough at the moment. But being the SP serving those Emperor's? Yes please.

Mandred because godmother, and I really want to develop that more.

Roswita because of the combination of Mathilde's well-natured smug at inserting herself into a position directly subordinate to Roswita without her say-so after the disaster that was their first meeting, and Roswita not being able to be annoyed by it at this point, since she is now perfectly aware that Mathilde is an utterly reliable ride-or-die Empire/VanHal supporter.
 
Mathilde is paranoid and filled with suspicion.
But the trick here is that she does not alow that paranoia turn her into a self sabotaging fool like she was a stereotypical 40k inquisitor.
We, and therefore Mathilde, have been suspicious of Egrim from day one.
But instead of pre emptively killing, or sidelining, him, we pull him into our orbit and made being loyal into something is beneficial to him.
Being suspicious of everyone, and everything, can be a useful tool, but if it is the only tool you have, you are as doomed to failure as a carpenter with nothing but a hammer.

Being suspicious of everyone equally is precisely as dangerous as being suspicious of no one equally, you cannot form a judgement based on that. Mathilde's suspicions are a little hypersensitive (note the Johann issue early on), but they are far from indiscriminate. That is the difference between her and a 40K inquisitor... well that and the fact hat due to the setting she does not confuse a dedication to the good of all that lives with dedication to her state. Absent that totalitarian urge it makes sense for her to be a xenophile and that is where most of her big wins came from, leveraging things in new contexts, from big things like the Waystone Project to small advantages like her Room of Neutrality, or being able to call on the dwarfs and swamp priests for book-mining
 
Last edited:
Max is really good at what he does, but he isn't too focused or ambitious about growing that capability further. Which is fine, because what he does is quite valuable already and being so reliable and consistent is part of that value. Rather than disrespect, I respect that he has made good use of his wizardly potential and acts like a dwarf-quality cog in the important machine that is the Colleges.
I mean, no. Max really, really wants to grow. Just not as a wizard, but as a Smith. I would not be surprised if you found he made his mark on the world in legendary artifacts searched for by many an adventurer millennia from now. His name whispered in the same breath as von Tarnus or perhaps even Kragg the Grim.

Maybe literally so, as while he might not exercise his wind that much, he is a wizard still, one inured to dwarves, and until he crafts True Masterwork, he will last even if world around him does not.
 
Last edited:
I'd personally prefer setting the cap on Mathilde's current ambitions to Magister Matriarch of the Greys and possibly being on the other side of the favor economy, being the wacky guest character in other peoples' stories that helps them out in whatever stomped them.
We've already reached that stage. Gretel was faced with serious troubles when that W-H took an interest in her. Then she asked us for help and we swooped in, saving the day. Gretel-quest must congratulate itself for going to K8P and choosing to befriend us.
 
I'm reading Memories of the Fall right now and the contrast between that and this quest is really interesting; we've not had anyone try to screw us over by claiming credit for our actions, or shifting blame for their actions to us, and it creates a much more positive and hopeful atmosphere here. But in glad for the contrast, because it makes it a lot easier to envision what the environment Egrimm was in was like.
 
Last edited:
Honestly I'm not all that interested in going for promotion. Our current position gives us the authority to go round and basically do all the things we want while also not having a responsibility that holds us down. If we became head of the Grey Order we might have to stay in Altdorf most of the time, I'd rather whiz around having adventures
 
We've already reached that stage. Gretel was faced with serious troubles when that W-H took an interest in her. Then she asked us for help and we swooped in, saving the day. Gretel-quest must congratulate itself for going to K8P and choosing to befriend us.
While you're not wrong, I can't help but note that Mathilde effectively limits her meddling to the people she knows. We've not reached our full potential of Lady Meddler, who spends a large chunk of her time guiding up-and-coming journeymen and young magisters.

Or, hell, maybe at some point Mathilde might teach classes on some given topic.
 
If we became head of the Grey Order we might have to stay in Altdorf most of the time, I'd rather whiz around having adventures

We can still do that if we become Magister/Supreme Matriarch.

Algard sits at a desk all day because a) he is a spymaster and b) he is listed as "dead, presumed missing" on the personnel files, but Stark, the canonical MP, made a name for himself wandering around the Empire taking the fight to the enemy, and we know that in quest Paranoth does the same.

So a leadership position in the colleges does not have to be an administrative position.
 
Last edited:
I mean, no. Max really, really wants to grow. Just not as a wizard, but as a Smith. I would not be surprised if you found he made his mark on the world in legendary artifacts searched for by many an adventurer millennia from now. His name whispered in the same breath as von Tarnus or perhaps even Kragg the Grim.

Maybe literally so, as while he might not exercise his wind that much, he is a wizard still, one inured to dwarves, and until he crafts True Masterwork, he will last even if world around him does not.
I wonder how good of a smith Max is at this point? If we wanted a really good base sword to put enchantments on would he be the best contact for us to go for?
 
I'm reading Memories of the Fall right now and the contrast between that and this quest is really interesting; we've not had anyone try to screw us over by claiming credit for our actions, or shifting blame for their actions to us,
One of the reasons for that is Mathilde's nearly unbroken habit of being the biggest Wizard in whatever endeavour she is involved in.
Only Wizard in Stirland.
Only (surviving) Wizard on the Sylvania campaign.
Magister amongst journeymen on the K8Ps campaign.
Loremaster for the ducklings.
Lord Magister on the Dum expedition.
Project lead on the Waystone Project.

There has never been a time when Mathilde was under the authority of another wizard, or in competition with a wizard while under anyone's authority.
 
Assuming you're talking about steel instead of something exotic like gromril or ithilmar, I can't think of anyone better for making a sword that's both a pretty good sword and very compatible with College enchantments.
Barely ten years in and already the best in one direction. Give him a century and he will be great in them all
 
Assuming you're talking about steel instead of something exotic like gromril or ithilmar, I can't think of anyone better for making a sword that's both a pretty good sword and very compatible with College enchantments.
I don't know what materials we would use I assume that our apprentice would be better at picking materials. Actually that seems like a really cool learning project to assign her if we want her to improve her enchantment skills.
 
Barely ten years in and already the best in one direction. Give him a century and he will be great in them all

It's not a niche with a huge amount of competition. Runesmithing can do most things you'd want a magical weapon to do, and the Empire has a strong cultural bias towards Dwarf-made weapons, so there's not a lot of demand for College-enchanted weaponry.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top