Now this is with conservative estimates of RP gain from events and number of colonies started. As simple as using an estimate of 15 RP per quarter we have 44 RP left 2317, 50 rp left 2318, and 72.5 RP left 2319 which would allow 7 boosts over that time period. Conservative estimates only allow one boost.
Over the last 3 years the average has been something like 25rp per quarter. Also you are neglecting the 10rp reward per accession and GBZ colonies, unless they are supposed to be included in the 2 per year?
 
Well, Excalibur was only mentioned in an omake AFAIK, so if it doesn't actually exist, the dates would line up better and make room for the canon Excelsior refit. Still won't align directly, unless there was a Khitomer crisis-related small build gap.

IIRC Excalibur was mentioned by Onerios himself when the thread was on a Fall-of-Rogers kick, but not in any threadmarked posts.
 
Last edited:
Over the last 3 years the average has been something like 25rp per quarter. Also you are neglecting the 10rp reward per accession and GBZ colonies, unless they are supposed to be included in the 2 per year?
Well I wanted to go with very low end estimates, and why I put an example of how just 5 more rp per quarter would be a big boost in RP totals, 25 means we are boosting 5 times each research phase. And forgot about the GBZ colonies and bonus rp from members joining. If we assume one colony a year from the GBZ that is an extra 2 income each year, and membership boosts of 10 this year and 20 the next two years of one off. That will give us a cushion for when we get the new generic teams after the current ones graduate in 3 years.
 
IIRC Excalibur was mentioned by Onerios himself when the thread was on a Fall-of-Rogers kick, but not in any threadmarked posts.
This is the only time Oneiros has mentioned the USS Excalibur:
Of course I'm a bit skeptical we actually have the kind of continuous communication with our EC ships suggested here anyways...
Not continuous - regular data packets. Of course, the time delay involved at those distances, even with subspace comms, is considerable, but it is helpful. It became more of a thing when the Miracht was lost, though it has a lot of its origins in the loss of the USS Excalibur, shortly before the start of the quest. Always good to be able to keep tabs on your biggest risk takers, even if only to try to piece together what went wrong, or figure out where to send pick-up crews (Miracht).
 
Out of curiosity, when the Generics graduate, have we given any thought to their names? Presumably we will end up giving them names.
 
I'm not so sure about crew ratings being so easily transferable, since narrative and omakes have implied that some of the increased capabilities of "crew rating" are actual physical changes to the ship. USS Enterprise-B is a special case here, in that its warp core and other systems were supposedly massively tweaked and customized, yet her crew ratings were transferable when she was scuttled. We also have the counterexample of the USS Miracht, which could not transfer her crew rating upon her destruction.
What I'm saying is that it would be easier to destroy ship veterancy than to create. If Excelsior worked its way up to a Blooded crew at some point prior to 2293 despite how little time that offers, the chaos of the post-Khitomer era and its impact on personnel could easily suck the ship back down to 0 XP.

With the Enterprise-B, I think the implication is that in part because of informal status as 'fleet flagship,' transferring a third of the crew of the ship to a new ship really IS likely to improve performance- either because they're a genuinely higher caliber of personnel than the average for the rest of the fleet

I'd also like to point out that we did have some Excelsiors start off at blooded or veteran status - see this quoted snapshot of the front page. Enterprise started out at veteran (and ka'Sharren's bonus made that elite). Sarek started out as blooded, or at least was blooded during the Biophage crisis. Courageous, I think started out as blooded - her crew rating increased to veteran in 2302.Q3.
Yes, but those were Explorer Corps ships. You know, the hand-picked "best of the best of the best" elite crews.

That all said, the Khitomer crisis is as good as excuse as any to explain away any partial "reset" in crew ratings like this.
:) Thankee!

Assuming there was only the single 3mt berth at San Francisco available and Excelsior production started in 2380s, not really.

It's made worse by the fact that Kumari was under construction from 2298 to 2302.

Ignoring the canon refit of the Excelsior to remove its prototype transwarp engine, the best schedule we could hope for is:
2276-2282: Excelsior prototype construction
2282-2286: Excalibur construction
2286-2290: Enterprise construction (ST canon commission date was 2293)
2290-2294: Courageous or Sarek construction
2294-2298: Courageous or Sarek construction
2298-2302: Kumari construction

Well, Excalibur was only mentioned in an omake AFAIK, so if it doesn't actually exist, the dates would line up better and make room for the canon Excelsior refit. Still won't align directly, unless there was a Khitomer crisis-related small build gap.
Yeah, the dates don't really line up well at all unless we posit a second three-megaton berth that was decommissioned for some reason. Or blown up by the Klingons or otherwise lost in the early 2290s.

Something like:

2280Q1-2285Q2: NX-2000 Excelsior prototype construction period at Sol.

2285Q1: Crew deducts for USS Excelsior.

==LOTSA EMBARRASSMENT HAPPENS==

[Awkwardly, while 'Tiny' may no longer be in Starfleet service, "Mr. Adventure" might be. :D ]

2285Q3-2286Q4: NX-2000 USS Excelsior completes refits to function at regular Starfleet standards, though not five year mission capability, at the Sol shipyard. Follow-on NCC-2001 and NCC-2002 are ordered for Sol berth. Second three-megaton berth built at Andor.

2287Q1-2290Q4: NCC-2001 Excalibur construction period at Sol; Excalibur is built from the keel up with the full set of modifications needed to be five-year-mission capable. NCC-2003 is ordered and assigned to the Andor berth.

2289Q1-2293Q4: NCC-2003 Courageous construction period at Andor.

2291Q1-2293QX: NCC-2002 ??? construction period begins at Sol.

==KHITOMER HAPPENS, CARTWRIGHT CONSPIRACY REVEALED==

2293QX-2294QX: The President, taking personal command of Starfleet in the wake of the Cartwright conspiracy, authorizes continued Excelsior construction on schedule, as a symbol of Federation unity and commitment to exploration. Personal appeals from Kirk play a significant role in this decision. NCC-2002 is slightly rushed into service for political reasons, in order to recommission the new ship as USS Enterprise promptly, after the decommissioning of NCC 1701-A.

2294QX: Former NCC-2002 build commissions as NCC-1701-B USS Enterprise. Captain Kirk lost aboard Enterprise during commissioning trials.

2294QY: Many Andorians view the Cartwright Conspiracy as an attempt by a human-dominated Starfleet to 'fight the Klingons to the last Andorian.' Anti-Starfleet terrorists from an Andorian secessionist movement, smuggling antimatter charges, manage to gut the three-megaton berth at Andor. Lor'Vela shipyard is shut down, not to reopen until the Kahurangi admiralty.

2294QY: [Optional: Lt. Cmdr. Nash ka'Sharren of the USS ??? foils attack on the one-megaton berth? :D ]

2295Q1-2298Q4: Excelsior production continues at Sol regardless. NCC-2004 USS Sarek is completed in Sol shipyard.

2299Q1-2302Q4: NCC-2005 USS Kumari is completed in Sol shipyard.

Chen loophole abuse. By ordering two prototypes, we get them faster. All be it at greater cost.
We can not start a third hull until the Ambassador and the C are out and checked over.
Leslie:

"I'm working on it, I'm working on it!"
 
Last edited:
Out of curiosity, when the Generics graduate, have we given any thought to their names? Presumably we will end up giving them names.
Oneiros is probably going to give them names like he does for new teams requested in the snakepit, but he might ask for suggestions. The nice thing about them is that they already have a reasonably well defined history. For example Generic Team 4 could be the Isolinear Optics Laboritory.
 
Also, there are few things that would upset the Hawks more than a hint of Danegeld. If you ever wanted to get Stesk and the Hawks to vote the same way, suggest that.
 
Man, that map. With the affiliation of the Tauni our coreward expansion is looking to be as extensive as our spinward expansion. We should expect 3 new sectors.

How do having 2 prototype Ambys work for us? I thought we needed to finish prototype (construction + shakedown) before we could order new hulls? or is this an Enterprise exception?
Chen loophole abuse. By ordering two prototypes, we get them faster. All be it at greater cost.
We can not start a third hull until the Ambassador and the C are out and checked over.
It's definitely an Enterprise exception too. We were told at the time we obtained Chen's bonus that prototyping with it would cause issues. That position was reversed when the Enterprise was lost and the proposal became to build a new Enterprise.
 
Yeah, the dates don't really line up well at all unless we posit a second three-megaton berth that was decommissioned for some reason. Or blown up by the Klingons or otherwise lost in the early 2290s.
It's possible (?) that we commissioned from one of the member state berths, I can't remember if they had their own 2.5+ berths at game start. Alternatively, in the wake of the Rogers crisis, the Council slapped Starfleet's hands and transferred a berth with Excelsior capacity to a member world.
 
Also, I think the comparison of this situation to a trolly car problem isn't very accurate. The Hishimer are not dumb-dumbs just because they're nomadic, and in fact if they're star-crossing they're very aware of thier assets and potential losses. Assuming we can just whisper "hey go this way, trust us it's the best route" and they'll just blindly do that is absurd. As I've kept reminding people, if that's what you assume they're like there's also nothing stopping the Cardassians from doing the same.

Basically it's a trolly car problem where the train is sentient, the switch does nothing, the people on the tracks can reason with or bribe the train, and there's like, dozens of potential tracks it could go down... So it's not really a trolly car problem.

The Hishimir will evaluate our strengths as best they can, and then make a decision from there.
 
So back to the Hishmeri Septs being slavers/raiders, do we want to start making plans now, before they hit our border? Or should we kick it up to the President, and having the decision of which one of the options below taken by the head of the Federation, instead of us? I'd prefer for a plan to be in place before they potentially hit our borders, rather than scrambling afterwards. Plus, getting the big stick ready now makes sense, rather than hoping our border patrols can hold them off.

1) gather a fleet, neutralize them as combatants so they don't bother us or anyone else until they rearm themselves, and free their slaves while we're at it,
2) use a fleet to escort them through Fed space, and let someone else deal with them
3) use a fleet to convince them to not enter/go somewhere else in general/go somewhere else in particular,
4) something else entirely

Edit: Heh, looks like the discussion already started. So it's basically fleet or diplo, at the sec.
 
Last edited:
That's a shame. It might be worth asking about, in case we meet the prereqs earlier than expected - I have a good feeling about those Deep Space stations!

As you should, for at the end of the Deep Space Station tech tree lies Yorktown!



We may be able to trade ressources for tech and starmaps?
Fed: Ressources > Nomads
Nomads: Maps, civ data, tech > Federation

I'm fine with trading information for information.

The Honiani are already over 300 from just the Annual rolls

I missed that. It was hidden behind a Spoiler Tag.
 
Last edited:
So back to the Hishmeri Septs being slavers/raiders, do we want to start making plans now, before they hit our border? Or should we kick it up to the President, and having the decision of which one of the options below taken by the head of the Federation, instead of us? I'd prefer for a plan to be in place before they potentially hit our borders, rather than scrambling afterwards. Plus, getting the big stick ready now makes sense, rather than hoping our border patrols can hold them off.

1) gather a fleet, neutralize them as combatants so they don't bother us or anyone else until they rearm themselves, and free their slaves while we're at it,
2) use a fleet to escort them through Fed space, and let someone else deal with them
3) use a fleet to convince them to not enter/go somewhere else in general/go somewhere else in particular,
4) something else entirely

Edit: Heh, looks like the discussion already started. So it's basically fleet or diplo, at the sec.


I say we use a fleet to either Neutralize them or convince them to go somewhere else. IE Cardassian space.
 
Initially I was like "there's no way the Prez is going to sign off on a sudden strike right to the Hishimir throat" but then I remember Cait is in their path and this is President N'Gir we're talking about.

I know there's a desire to do something proactive people but we're going to have to wait and see on this one. If they [robotic monotone] become a threat [/ robotic monotone] by deciding to rumble with us then we'll send them a stern rebuke.

Although hey, maybe they suffer from overpopulation and we could gain diplomatic points by killing a bunch of them. You never know!
 
Back
Top