And my first omake, ever. Specifically, the Captain of the T'Mir wondering why she's alive with an untouched ship when so many more powerful ships were devastated.
Yes, I know that targetting is RNG-based OOC.
Captain's Log, USS T'Mir, 21471.6 - Captain Samyr Kanil
Logic dictates that I should not be making this log. Logic dictates that an Oberth-class science vessel should not survive a battlefield full of cruisers. Logic dictates that a science vessel should not survive when the veterans of the Romulan Quarantine Fleet were devastated.
And yet, I am making this log. The T'Mir made it through the battles around Kadesh without taking a single strike to the hull. The T'Mir was not targeted at all by the suicide shuttle ambush. The Biophage did not follow up with an infection beam when the shields fell over Koba. And we were only barely targeted over Kadesh itself.
Did the Biophage not recognize the tactical uses of my ship's sensor suite, and so not consider us a threat? That would explain why we were not targetted over Kadesh - to a foe who doesn't understand the value of advanced sensors, an Oberth presents no more threat than a Klingon Bird of Prey, but is harder to defeat, and hence is not a logical target while combat-oriented ships remain on the field.
However, it does not explain the events at Koba, or the ambush. The Biophage has never before failed to even attempt to exploit a loss of shields, and yet at Koba, the T'Mir lost shields early in the battle, and was never again fired on by the enemy. My ship could not have remained combat-effective after a solid strike to the hull, but the enemy failed to follow up. Why? I do not believe that Lieutenant Solln's tweaks to T'Mir's ECM systems and Lieutenant Dolos's evasive maneuvers could have been so effective that the Biophage would give up on targeting our ship when our shields were down. And yet it remains an undeniable fact that the Biophage did not follow up properly on that opening.
To look further back, our task group was never even targeted in the ambush, though it was perhaps the weakest group. This I can explain, but only in hindsight, and only by questioning the competence of a very dangerous foe. In retrospect, it appears that the Biophage did not seem to have an actual plan in it's targeting of the shuttle strikes. It switched between fairly effective strikes on the Riala's task group and the Romulan Quarantine Fleet, and completely futile strikes against the Courageous and Enterprise task groups. If the forces sent at the Enterprise or Courageous group had been sent at Challorn's group instead, I would almost certainly not be writing this log, and the Biophage might have won at Koba or Kadesh.
If this was the only knowledge I had of the Biophage's tactical abilities, I would suggest that the T'Mir survived the ambush because the Biophage lacked the ability to logically analyze the situation, and so made distinctly illogical use of its available assets. But I know of the subterfuge it employed to conceal the Dunwich IV infection, and of the tactical skill it demonstrated in the clashes over Solitude and other colonies. The Biophage pursues a monstrous and illogical goal, but it has been intelligent in that pursuit.
I must conclude that perhaps there is not a logical explanation for these events. The T'Mir may have simply been lucky. Whether my crew created that luck with electronic warfare and evasive flight, or whether it was simple chance beyond our control, the T'Mir's survival does not appear to have a purely logical cause.