Voting is open
Pet dragon sound fun, can you immagine him going "I'm gonna devor your souls" and one of the mistifs going "he is adorable, can I keep it Karen?" and another saying "he is just like my old cat if he could talk! I want it!" because seriously a pet minidragon seem like a pet mini-tiger and they make for great pets!
[X] Seal him in a less imposing physical body, with his powers sealed as well (somewhat harsh, renders him almost completely harmless while still giving him physical freedom. Implement chibi Dazarel).

I'm torn. I'm more interested in self-seal for narrative reasons, for the potential power to aid us in being a Protector and for what I feel to be a better chance at safe containment of a threat in tumultuous times.
But. I also think this could be terrible for our relationship with Jaron and Jaffur in particular -- and everyone else besides. Who wouldn't hold some fear over what we would contain? Would it directly damage our amazing diplomacy -- even as much as we stand to gain from the prestige of this legendary victory?
We're already pursuing so many paths and our split attention could have cost us dearly -- it seems like it nearly did.
Can we really afford to take on the task of reforming and even protecting Dazarel almost completely alone?

And more importantly, do we really have the right to keep the misfits from a teensy-widdle grumpy-wumpy formerly-world-ending-but-now-he's-a-good-boy, oh yes he is, Dragon?
Dazzarel knows we are saiyans so he actually can't be allowed to meet the Misfits or anyone save Maya or a member of Exile society. So no, he is not going to be a pet for the Misfits.

In addition to that, and independent of that, if we start interacting consistently with the dragon and especially if we start tapping the dragon for power, which is basically the only point of doing this at all AND the only reason the "Ambitious" trait is being applied to it...

It is not the only reason. Dazzarel is also a source of knowledge about the galaxy and by sealing him inside Kakara, we would be aware of anyone who would want to benefit about said knowledge (since they would have to ask him through us) and it would let us decide what of it we would want to leak to the population. If he has dangerous information we don't want others to know, this is the option which lets us control that.

I'm betting his 'knowledge of the galaxy' is actually fairly limited. "That planet had enough warriors who were strong enough that I couldn't be sure to beat them all before they could really hurt me, so I never went there. I can tell you all about the dozen planets over that way, or at least how they were before I made them into rubble."

Among the things he knows:

It knows about Kannasa, which is from where our seer powers come from and was actually alive when they were, around 400 years ago. It also has more information about what it means to be a psychic than presumably our seer have so it would let us have first access to said knowledge since he could only talk to us.

It also knows we are a saiyan, so we can ask about saiyans or the Enemy without arousing suspiscions unlike with the aliens. And while he admitedly knows little about them:

low, grinding snarl in the rhythm of a chuckle rings out. Ah, now there's the nerve. You know, Princess, I have longed for centuries to taste the ki of your kind. Why, you're practically a delicacy in the modern era. So few, and fewer all the time.

You frown. "Fewer? There are more of us here than there have ever been! And all of us ready to fight you!"

It growls. Spare me your threats. I do not refer to this pathetic, self-crippled backwater. I refer to that. It sweeps out a wing across the sky above. Did you forget that your last King had two sons? Your distant cousins have not been enjoying the time since your exile began. It brings its head close to yours, gleaming fangs a mere foot from your nose. Isn't it appropriate for family to share, Princess?

He huffs. I don't know any more than you! Somehow the galaxy found out that your Enemy keeps on talking about himself as an agent of the void. Void this, void that! I...hoped to borrow some menace, secondhand.

That is still more than we did and at least he can tell us where he learnt about said rumors so that we have an idea what the Enemy has been up to these last 300 years or how the galaxy fared immediately after the destruction of Earth.

It knows about Dragons and their abilities. Given some of the spoilerboxes in the thread, we might want to be careful about how much can that knowledge be spread.

It has been alive for a long time. Any information from the distant past, he is more likely to know about than a random alien. He might know things Gohan doesn't for that and might know about other such strange creatures like Dragons that it has encountered in his life and might become a threat in the future.

It implied that it knows what has Beerus and the Kais busy. We could learn it from Gohan but we don't know yet if it is something we would want spread. If we are the only ones who can talk to Dazzarel, we can also use him as an excuse as for where we learn things that in the future Gohan might tell us and that we don't want to reveal their source. Example, random trivia about the Enemy, who blocked any scrying attempts on him and thus we can't use our Sight as excuse.

And I strongly suspect that this wouldn't work, because it would be the equivalent of saying "having a dragon chattering in your head grants a free action to socialize the dragon." Given how strict Poptart is about socialize actions, I don't buy that. The limiting factor on how much time we spend interacting with people isn't our physical access to them, since most of the people we'd choose to socialize would happily spend more time with us if we wanted. It's attention; we've got so many irons in the fire and do so many things that we have to go out of our way to make time to interact with people in a way likely to significantly improve our relationship with them.

Having the dragon inside our mind, as opposed to being a chibi-dragon pet floating around the Hall or something, doesn't mean we have more time, energy, and concentration to spare for interactions with it.
Actually, something about this has been asked before. Or at least Poptart replied to a comment regarding this:

So, definitely gonna need to take an action to spend time with Dazarel next year... mellow him out through contact through Kakara. (Though, that didn't work on Dandeer...)
There's a significant extent to which you don't need to do this with somebody living in your own head, but you can.

So it would make at least minimum of socialisation, like how we still hang with the misfits to play even without especific actions to do so in the yearly plans.

Also, I get that the seal on Dazarel is SUPPOSED to be invulnerable, but I can't bring myself to totally discount the possibility of there being some way, shape, or form in which it might leak, be bypassed, or something. It's unlikely, but still at least plausible. In the sense that "if I told you the plot was that the invulnerable seal turned out to be only imperfectly invulnerable, you wouldn't really be surprised to hear that."

Didn't you mention a few pages back, when someone pointed that reforming an enemy like this wouldn't be out of place for a shonen/dragon ball genre, that Poptart can subvert expectations and thus genre savvyness should not change our reasoning overmuch? From what we know of magic, he shouldn't be able to:

We haven't brought up the possibility of allowing the dragon to put its energy through the seal to use it ourselves, so we actually don't know that it's safe to do so. We can certainly find out very quickly though! @PoptartProdigy, would making use of Dazarel's power be dangerous, or can the sorcerers lock down any such power to be strictly under Kakara's control?

Possible. The way their envisioned seal works is as a massive wall with no seams or doors. Looking for a clever way through would be like looking at a giant steel block and saying, "yeah, I bet there's a loophole through this thing." Just...not applicable. The analogy is not perfect, though, since Kakara can, at will, change how or if it is permeable.

How exactly you would or could make use of Dazarel's power is a big unknown.
Plus what Dandelor told us about magic before:
Magic is best described as the art of literalizing concepts. Ki users can accomplish a lot of what we do, but for you it's a matter of knowing how, in the real world, that would work. You could hypnotize somebody by twisting their ki. You could level a mountain by firing your ki. You could probably make a Masque by moving the right way and changing how your signature outputs, in fact. It would just be incredibly uncomfortable, in that case. But magic requires me to express a figurative concept in a literal way. I tried to literalize my personal connection to Jaffur into a direct line of communication to what I thought was his sleeping consciousness." He looks aside, a mournful look on his face. "...it wasn't enough. I'm not close enough to him for that concept to work, and I don't have a better backup to work with. I don't have much of a teacher relationship, and I'm hardly invested with the rebel mindset beyond getting him out, so there's nothing deep enough to reach. Not even with him awake."

Our sorcerers said they work with well known concepts and that our genki dama would supercharge the spell so it would require a similar amount of power to break it with force. The only way I can see around it is if someone on the caliber of the Enemy is involved and by that point I would like to think that not only would we have bigger problems but that we would have other people who can handdle Dazzarel.


Which means I want to at least consider the possibility that having a passenger inside our body/mind who has potential access to all our secrets and secret actions, but who also has reason to wish us ill... Miiiight backfire at some point.
We may well give the dragon opportunities to learn or deduce things, despite our having "mute/deafen" buttons for the dragon's interactions with us.

Sure, we could give the dragon such opportunities under the "chibi dragon" plan, but the "chibi dragon" gives us less incentive to build a strong relationship with the dragon and rely on it for advice or power.

If you are going to be wary about something like THAT, then how about this: Dazzarel had time to read our mind before we enacted our mind delve defenses. How do we know it hasn't learned about the conspiracy to undo the sealing and has a chance to tell people if we leave him with his own body? If he is sealed inside Kakara, the only way it has to talk to other people is through Kakara. So no matter what he learns, the only way it can act on it or tell others is if he is released from the seal if he is inside of her, while the other options actually lets him conspire with other people.


Lastly... @PoptartProdigy given that we spent half an hour before the sorcerers came with an option and that Dazzarel was open to answering questions, can we use the [ASK] votes to ask him about the context of some of the things it said? Like, he said the Galaxy somehow learned things about the Enemy and he doesn't know how but we could ask him about where he heard that. Or we could ask him what is happening to Tarble's descendants. Or about Dragons in general and what made him focus in Garenhuld so that we can avoid it in the future.
 
Last edited:
[X] Seal him in your own head. You will be his prison and his warden, and see what benefits you can gain from having a dragon chained in your body (x1.25, from, "ambitious." Middling harshness, Dazarel is as restricted as the inanimate object version but has you on hand for conversation and interesting experiences, renders him completely harmless, may or may not allow Kakara to exploit him for power).
 
Well, unless we decide to inform them. If we go the headpet route, we likely have enough political capital for that.
You... do realize that Jaron is part of the Misfits?

Besides, dad already warned us about stuff like this when we first started training Maya. He told us it set a bad precedent
You frown, uncertain. A part of you had considered leaving your friend unaware of the Masquerade, but you had also weighed the possibility of letting her in on it. You're not even considering telling her?

What? No, of course not. We have held the Masquerade through three centuries of exile. It's a matter of survival, and exceptions are bad precedents to set. One exceptional girl is not going to change that. That said, she does present an opportunity. After all, we have our Masques.
Dad leans forward, his eyes glittering in anticipation behind his hands. I once dreamed that our people could return to the stars. With this friend of yours running around, being visibly human, who would question our own existence? Your friend would be the perfect smoke screen for saiyans, under Masque, to emerge into the public eye.

And later when she saw Meerak, he went into further detail:
Then you reconsider. Why not push on this? The situation is already nuts. You should propose it. He'd listen. Maybe. And hey, you can always go down if he refuses. But you don't think he will. You think you have a chance. You're going to do it! You're going to tell Dad that you should tell Maya everything-!

"What? No."

You deflate. "But-"

"Kakara, our people have maintained the Masquerade for over three centuries. Do you really think I'm going to peel it back for even a single person just because they're your friend?" Dad kneads at his forehead. "I understand why it's tempting. Keeping the secret is hard. It's hard for all of us. Any of us who actually have lives in the human world have friends there, and we all have to suck it up and lie to them. And by and large we get away with that since there's nothing that would make them guess the truth. But Kakara, what would our people -- our people, who all have to go along with this -- think if the first human let in on it outside of accident or marriage just so happened to be your friend?" He shakes his head, leaning back. "I'll tell you right now: 'If I have to watch my strength in order to avoid my girlfriend noticing that I can turn boulders into powder and so that I don't kill her, then you can suck up and deal with having the most open and honest human friendship any of us have ever had.'" He shifts. "That's not what I feel, but that's what they'd say. Maya's already in on the ki secret. Nobody would be in a mood to tolerate you dropping the Masquerade for her as well. No."

You turn scarlet. The idea that people would imply that you're acting entitled infuriates you more than you can say. "I-"

"We will instead, as was my plan, wait until later," says Dad, taking out an apple and biting into it.

You blink, brought sharply up. "...what?"

"We'll tell her later," he says, chewing and swallowing. "Give it a couple of years. Deal with the scouts. Let her know the year the army is due to arrive. I'd hoped I could wait even longer, but with an army en route I'm pretty sure we need all hands on deck and at full capacity for this. She'll need to be in on it."

You gape. "Why would you rather wait?"

"Because ideally, I'd wait until she was a grown woman capable of making informed decisions on the matter. What do you take me for? Just because she's learning ki doesn't mean I get to use her like a tool. If I had my way she'd live a normal life, with ki added in, and when she turned eighteen I'd have you tell her the truth. Sure, I gain politically by her mere existence, but I'm keeping her out of it. Given my choice of events, that would be it. Let her have as normal a childhood as possible. But events force my hand." He fishes out another apple. "You hungry?"
 
Well, unless we decide to inform them. If we go the headpet route, we likely have enough political capital for that.
We can also just tell Dazarel that he is not to tell them certain information, while this isn't foolproof he does have an incentive to not actively antagonize us in the short term. Also as he'd only be able to talk to them while we're around too its likely we could just bap him on the head the minute he starts to say something forbidden, again not perfect but its not like the first thing he's going to do when introduced to people is try and exposition all over them about Saiyan's.
 
Last edited:
Let me just say that there are several other reasons why not to vote for sealed-in-head.

There could be the fact that, to our current knowledge, the self-seal choice is a brief period of prison (our lifetime, which would be brief to him) with only one true point of contact followed by him being stuck in solitary (just like the regular seal-in-inanimate-object choice, except it starts out being our dead body) for the rest of the time. For everyone going on about the whole "solitary is torture" thing and also voting for plan Jinchuriki, how do you reconcile this?

There is also the idea that we'd be a lot more likely to convert Daz if we are not his jailer... that giving HIM the opportunity to get away from US at times will keep him from feeling entirely trapped and developing a higher feeling of resentment than he is likely to already feel.

I could also mention that if we want to socialize him, actually enabling him to socialize (albeit in a limited state) is much more likely to help than just forcing him to watch the Kakara TV Channel: All Kakara, All The Time!

Furthermore, I (apparently like @Simon_Jester) feel that a "completely new and untested, yet totally unbeatable, we promise" seal is too good a lead in to a potential story hook about something going wrong and the "unsinkable ship sinking" to be overlooked, and can't 100% believe that our illustrious author would never touch such a ready-made plot twist.

To be honest, I could even point to the meta-narritive: that by jumping at the [ Ambitious ] plan without a good in-game reason for it besides us being ambitious and thinking that this may bring us more power, it advances the "Kakara's ambition is growing" narritive... I mean, we just pulled demigod-like power out of our ass, if Kakara's next thought is that we should be Daz's Jinchuriki to get more power, it says a few things about Kakara that I'm not sure I want to say. And sure, there's an argument to be made that we're going to seal him inside us to pump him for information, but that falls apart when we can just put him in a headlock and pump him for information when he's not sealed inside us too.
 
Didn't you mention a few pages back, when someone pointed that reforming an enemy like this wouldn't be out of place for a shonen/dragon ball genre, that Poptart can subvert expectations and thus genre savvyness should not change our reasoning overmuch? From what we know of magic, he shouldn't be able to:
Firstly, I'm pretty sure I was saying that in a different context, but either way, this kind of misses my point.

My point is, if you had omniscience about the future plot of this specific game, and you learned that the plot was "the sorcerors were sure we could keep Dazarel sealed forever, but the bad guy we ran into in Year 15 was able to break the seal with a weird power the sorcerors had never heard of," it wouldn't seem all that surprising in advance. This isn't about genre conventions. It's that in many settings, both physical and real-world, "they thought this could never happen but they were wrong" turns out to be exactly what happens. It is not unusual.

That doesn't mean every seemingly impossible thing can happen. But it does mean that we should exercise some degree of precautions when dealing with situations where our safety relies entirely on the experts fully understanding the interaction of one unfamiliar phenomenon with another.

If you are going to be wary about something like THAT, then how about this: Dazzarel had time to read our mind before we enacted our mind delve defenses. How do we know it hasn't learned about the conspiracy to undo the sealing and has a chance to tell people if we leave him with his own body? If he is sealed inside Kakara, the only way it has to talk to other people is through Kakara. So no matter what he learns, the only way it can act on it or tell others is if he is released from the seal if he is inside of her, while the other options actually lets him conspire with other people.
Okay, that is a valid point. Although I strongly suspect that Dazarel didn't read our mind for details of saiyan politics, and didn't seek out that information, because he fully expected to kill and eat everyone involved in said politics long before it could matter.

Are you still riding under the impression that we can't just lock him out at will?
I'm under the impression that we very probably can, but that insofar as he is useful to us as a passenger, it'll be because we're engaging with him and giving him more freedom. The more we give him, the more likely that something will go wrong.

Conversely, the more we keep him sealed up inside a giant indestructible shell of magical seals, the more pointless it was to keep him sealed inside of us.
 
Firstly, I'm pretty sure I was saying that in a different context, but either way, this kind of misses my point.

My point is, if you had omniscience about the future plot of this specific game, and you learned that the plot was "the sorcerors were sure we could keep Dazarel sealed forever, but the bad guy we ran into in Year 15 was able to break the seal with a weird power the sorcerors had never heard of," it wouldn't seem all that surprising in advance. This isn't about genre conventions. It's that in many settings, both physical and real-world, "they thought this could never happen but they were wrong" turns out to be exactly what happens. It is not unusual.

That doesn't mean every seemingly impossible thing can happen. But it does mean that we should exercise some degree of precautions when dealing with situations where our safety relies entirely on the experts fully understanding the interaction of one unfamiliar phenomenon with another.

Okay, that is a valid point. Although I strongly suspect that Dazarel didn't read our mind for details of saiyan politics, and didn't seek out that information, because he fully expected to kill and eat everyone involved in said politics long before it could matter.

I'm under the impression that we very probably can, but that insofar as he is useful to us as a passenger, it'll be because we're engaging with him and giving him more freedom. The more we give him, the more likely that something will go wrong.

Conversely, the more we keep him sealed up inside a giant indestructible shell of magical seals, the more pointless it was to keep him sealed inside of us.
I feel that engaging with him is more important than giving him freedom, and it's pretty easy to engage with someone when you're in contact with him 100% of the time. Dazarel's pride is such that being locked in Kakara's head is equivalent to freedom of movement in a limited form, so getting close contact with him means more.
 
Godspeed Yammar, godspeed.
Yeah as funny as that is it isn't going to happen. PoptartProdigy isn't the kind of QM to give us these options let us pick them then immediately go "LOL all that was for nothing, why did you think your choices would matter?" so while our Chibi friend might indeed get killed as some point its not gonna go down like that
 
Yeah as funny as that is it isn't going to happen. PoptartProdigy isn't the kind of QM to give us these options let us pick them then immediately go "LOL all that was for nothing, why did you think your choices would matter?" so while our Chibi friend might indeed get killed as some point its not gonna go down like that

Lawful evil, and the choice wouldn't be meaningless because there at least two options which might prevent that outcome. Chibi just isn't one of them.
 
AHA!
I caught up!

Why is no one voting to kill the dragon? there is even good reason to do it!


sure it's RP reason but come on!
Wait is Multivoting allowed? brb, got to check this.
(preferred order: Kill the Dragon, Get Dragonballs from the dragon, become its jinchuuriki, do something extremely humiliating to the dragon.)
EDITS:
[X] Do not pursue a magical solution.
-[X] Kill him. (x0.1)

[X] Seal him in your own head. You will be his prison and his warden, and see what benefits you can gain from having a dragon chained in your body (x1.25, from, "ambitious." Middling harshness, Dazarel is as restricted as the inanimate object version but has you on hand for conversation and interesting experiences, renders him completely harmless, may or may not allow Kakara to exploit him for power).
 
Last edited:
Lawful evil, and the choice wouldn't be meaningless because there at least two options which might prevent that outcome. Chibi just isn't one of them.
So your contention is that the only two choices here are Seal it into ourselves or kill it? And as most of us are for keeping the Dragon alive actually the only choice is plan Jinchuriki? That would be wildly out of tone for this sort of setting.

Also wouldn't change my vote, as much as I'm interested in seeing some of the things that come from having Dazarel around might open up I'd rather he just get killed then get put inside our head.
Why is no one voting to kill the dragon? there is even good reason to do it!
I'm sorry man, I know you really wanna kill it, but its just too out of character for Kakara for pretty much all of us. Also turning him into Dragon Ball's isn't even on the table, our Sorcerer's wouldn't know how to do it. Besides we need a snarky animal side kick!
 
Last edited:
So your contention is that the only two choices here are Seal it into ourselves or kill it? And as most of us are for keeping the Dragon alive actually the only choice is plan Jinchuriki? That would be wildly out of tone for this sort of setting.

Also wouldn't change my vote, as much as I'm interested in seeing some of the things that come from having Dazarel around might open up I'd rather he just get killed then get put inside our head.

I'm sorry man, I know you really wanna kill it, but its just too out of character for Kakara for pretty much all of us. Also turning him into Dragon Ball's isn't even on the table, our Sorcerer's wouldn't know how to do it. Besides we need a snarky animal side kick!

-or convince it to reform and let it leave, or kill it herself. -and how many actions are you expecting the thread to devote to socializing with it? There are other actors involved here who recognize what an extreme danger letting this infohazard run around is. The sorcerers have presented a list of options, but the GM is under no obligation to ensure that they work ito as naively expected when interacting with other actors.


As for everybody concerned about safety, while there isn't any DBZ canon suggesting the sorcerers are wrong about sealing it away inside Kakara, Captain Ginyu does not provide a terribly reassuring precedent for chibifying an enemy and then forgetting about them.
 
Last edited:
TBF, captain Ginyu had control over what chibified him.
 
There could be the fact that, to our current knowledge, the self-seal choice is a brief period of prison (our lifetime, which would be brief to him) with only one true point of contact followed by him being stuck in solitary (just like the regular seal-in-inanimate-object choice, except it starts out being our dead body) for the rest of the time. For everyone going on about the whole "solitary is torture" thing and also voting for plan Jinchuriki, how do you reconcile this?
One thing I'll note is that Dazarel seems very solitary by nature anyway, and spends most of his time hanging out in space. Not being human, it's quite possible that solitary is not torture for him.
There is also the idea that we'd be a lot more likely to convert Daz if we are not his jailer... that giving HIM the opportunity to get away from US at times will keep him from feeling entirely trapped and developing a higher feeling of resentment than he is likely to already feel.
Eh, maybe true, maybe not. It's quite plausible that he'd feel just as trapped withing such a tiny, weak body without his powers.
Furthermore, I (apparently like @Simon_Jester) feel that a "completely new and untested, yet totally unbeatable, we promise" seal is too good a lead in to a potential story hook about something going wrong and the "unsinkable ship sinking" to be overlooked, and can't 100% believe that our illustrious author would never touch such a ready-made plot twist.
Firstly, I'm pretty sure I was saying that in a different context, but either way, this kind of misses my point.

My point is, if you had omniscience about the future plot of this specific game, and you learned that the plot was "the sorcerors were sure we could keep Dazarel sealed forever, but the bad guy we ran into in Year 15 was able to break the seal with a weird power the sorcerors had never heard of," it wouldn't seem all that surprising in advance. This isn't about genre conventions. It's that in many settings, both physical and real-world, "they thought this could never happen but they were wrong" turns out to be exactly what happens. It is not unusual.

That doesn't mean every seemingly impossible thing can happen. But it does mean that we should exercise some degree of precautions when dealing with situations where our safety relies entirely on the experts fully understanding the interaction of one unfamiliar phenomenon with another.
I'm going to disagree with this argument, for one main reason: it doesn't matter. Whether he's inside Kakara, or sealed into chibi form, such a thing would release him. There's no real difference. And before you grow concerned the unsealing process would harm Kakara, we've seen things been unsealed in Dragon Ball media, and it leaves the container unharmed.
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Gore17 on Mar 1, 2018 at 10:47 PM, finished with 266 posts and 69 votes.
 
-or convince it to reform and let it leave
I don't this is possible in the short time we have, like I wouldn't even want to guess at the communication DC to flip someone's alignment in a short conversation.
Again Wildly out of character for Kakara, I doubt our QM made a mostly Pacifist character and then cackled as they made sure no confrontation could be solved without murder.
-and how many actions are you expecting the thread to devote to socializing with it?
Hopefully at least 1 a year for a bit, however that's not up to me, though I will be advocating for it. The only time I can see us possibly ignoring him is going to be in the immediate term as we cram for the invasion first, but even then I'd be pushing for it.

I know its not likely to be a super popular opinion but eh being a good person is hard, much easier to be a murder hobo, story would be much more boring though.
 
I don't this is possible in the short time we have, like I wouldn't even want to guess at the communication DC to flip someone's alignment in a short conversation.

Again Wildly out of character for Kakara, I doubt our QM made a mostly Pacifist character and then cackled as they made sure no confrontation could be solved without murder.

Hopefully at least 1 a year for a bit, however that's not up to me, though I will be advocating for it. The only time I can see us possibly ignoring him is going to be in the immediate term as we cram for the invasion first, but even then I'd be pushing for it.

I know its not likely to be a super popular opinion but eh being a good person is hard, much easier to be a murder hobo, story would be much more boring though.

Whether you like them or the players will go for them had no bearing on whether they exist as an option.

The players couldn't be bothered to talk to the captured scouts when it could have headed off an interested war. Don't expect much enthusiasm for hounding a pet which loathed them and was incinerated minutes after its creation.
 
@PoptartProdigy I understand why he can't be turned into a human, but at some point could he be further Masque to look like, say, a lizard of some kind? Seal away the wings, fire breath, and speech, maybe with a "lighter" seal that can be more easily turned on and off....
Yeah, that could happen.
Lastly... @PoptartProdigy given that we spent half an hour before the sorcerers came with an option and that Dazzarel was open to answering questions, can we use the [ASK] votes to ask him about the context of some of the things it said? Like, he said the Galaxy somehow learned things about the Enemy and he doesn't know how but we could ask him about where he heard that. Or we could ask him what is happening to Tarble's descendants. Or about Dragons in general and what made him focus in Garenhuld so that we can avoid it in the future.
Nope. Later, sure, but not now.
They know what they're talking about, but they're also operating in previously unexplored territory, solving an unprecedented problem, in ways made possible by unprecedented new 'technology.'

The engineer who designed Galloping Gertie "knew what he was talking about" in the sense of being an experienced, competent man who had good technical training. He wasn't an idiot, incompetent, or braggart in the normal sense. His work was grounded in some of the best science known at the time.

He was, however, operating in a realm of forces and possibilities not entirely within his experience... and he missed an important problem.
And like I said, you are under no obligation not to doubt them. That being said...
Furthermore, I (apparently like @Simon_Jester) feel that a "completely new and untested, yet totally unbeatable, we promise" seal is too good a lead in to a potential story hook about something going wrong and the "unsinkable ship sinking" to be overlooked, and can't 100% believe that our illustrious author would never touch such a ready-made plot twist.
Okay, I can see that this is proving to be a sticking point. Pressed on it, the sorcerers say that they're so very sure because what they're doing is vaguely akin to building a wall with no seams or doors, which Kakara can turn insubstantial to any degree that suits her.

Upon Kakara asking them, "But how can you be sure that there's no clever loophole?" their response is a blank look and the reply of, "...because it's a seamless, doorless wall."

"But what if it's a really clever loophole, and you're just missing it? Everybody makes mistakes!"

"I- it's a conceptually seamless wall! The idea that there's a clever solution we've overlooked just doesn't work in this context!"

Kakara frowns. "But what about-?"

"Yes, even that."

She folds her arms. "You don't-!"

"That too."

"STOP INTERRUPTING ME!"

"Stop telling me I don't know what two plus two is when you've never opened a math textbook."

The concept of a loophole is simply contextually inappropriate. The seal proposed is not an issue that admits of clever solutions; if it were, it would be something differently entirely. That's more or less what they're doing -- literalizing, in a way, the concept of a wall which cannot be passed by any means. Nothing is passing that; that's what it is. The controller can control what the wall is, but that's because it's their wall. Otherwise, the wall just sits there, being completely impassible. It's essentially the Platonic form of a barrier in the path of travel. This is a very basic concept to the sorcerers; they know exactly how it works and what it does, and for the vast majority of them, it's the first thing they ever did with magic. There's a reason they're offering such a high confidence estimate here, and it isn't hubris; it's because it's the magical equivalent of two plus two.

Now, again, if you still don't believe them -- that's fine. If you still want to vote against a head dragon, for this or other reasons -- also fine. I have no particular investment of either of those outcomes. But this particular objection is one the sorcerers simply won't allow to pass in character, because again, it's very much like somebody who's never opened a math textbook challenging them on their ability to judge the odds of successfully figuring two plus two. Vote whatever way you please, but it's important to me to make sure that everybody is voting that way in the presence of adequate and accurate information.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top