Brockton's Celestial Forge (Worm/Jumpchain)

The persona of Jozef Duris The College Dropout, rather than Apeiron, has not responded to Parian's attack yet for good reason - Jozif Duris was not present and should not know about the accusation yet. When the information gets back to him through a regular channel, he should have a chance to respond. But until then, it's properly Survey/Delphine's issue.
A very good point but Joe's reaction suggest that even IF this information reaches him "officially" (though he always has an excuse that Aisha told him that his ex tried to screw him over) he would do absolutely nothing aside from shrugging and saying "It is what it is".
 
When people walk all over you, you have exactly two choices: either confront them, fight back and make them stop or run away. Even the act of stopping some from walking all over you IS a fight.
That's... not true. There's more to social dynamics than offensive or defensive. This isn't a fight to the death. Joe's found it healthiest for himself to completley disengage, and that's what he's been doing. With his family, and now with Sabah.
Because Joe didnt even ask Survey to do so; it was her own initiative.

As for reaction... literally anything, including just acknowledging how fucked up it was instead of just brushing it aside. For Apeiron The Enigmatic Artificer yes, it wasnt even worth thinking about; for Jozef Duris The College Dropout slash Community Handyman this could've been absolutely devastating.
Because Survey is a good friend, and he thanked her for that.
I will say, Joe didn't seem to have a particularly strong emotional reaction, but that seems to have mainly been driven by him being distracted by her obviously spiraling and her passenger acting up, as highlighted by Tetra.
What exactly is the difference between being attacked and not defending yourself and 'letting people walk over him'. I mean how exactly do you define that phrase that makes it somehow a different thing? I'm sure when Joe was being a doormat in his past, he had all kinds of excuses for why he was just eating it. They are having a stressful day, they didn't mean it like that, they didn't really intend for it to be as bad as it was. That all look pretty familiar? All kinds of excuses for why he shouldn't push back, it would just cause more problems, just make everything worse. The fact that those kind of excuses pretty much line up with his reasons for not doing anything in this chapter is why a lot of people feel like he's falling back into doormat behavior.

Edit: I want to note that I'm not actually sure that Joe should do much different from what he did. Certainly some extreme pushback isn't a good idea, I like some of the comments about Survey maybe pushing her to apologize or otherwise somehow calling Sabah on her bullshit seems viable. But that doesn't change that his actions in this chapter strongly resemble doormat behavior.

Edit2:



Saw this after I posted and I realized it was true. I went back and reread the chapter to be sure and there is no point in the chapter where Joe actually objects or states that he has a problem with Parian attacking him like that. From the get go he was either defending her, or focusing on how her action might hurt Aisha. At no point did he at all acknowledge that he was the main one being attacked. I think this is another reason people, including me at this point, say that he's falling back into doormat behavior.
He didn't let himself actually get hurt? Like, the distance he creates isn't him submitting to Parian and letting her screw him over, he's stopping any further conflict from breaking out. Maybe if he'd never made Survey or Fleet he'd be dealing with that on his own, but he's fortunate to not be alone anymore.
Like, imo the doormat thing would've just been letting Parian talk without interruption, freaking out about how these things keep coming back to bite him in the ass, and then trying to "sort it out" later. That's what early Joe prolly would've done.
And like, to be fair, did he activley intervene? No.
Is he activley defusing the situation? No.
But he doesn't need to, and if anything his involvement would make things worse. More importantly, he doesn't want to.
Also, does Joe really need to explicitly say "What Sabah did to me is bad"??
"During a discussion of volunteer activities, Parian has raised the topic of your encounter with Sabah." Survey said.

I managed to keep myself from freezing at the news. As my mind spun off to some unpleasant place, I forced myself to reply. "Raised in what context?" I asked.

"A concerningly negative one." She responded. "Though she is not elaborating and is resistant to the matter being investigated."

I didn't know what to make of this. Sure, it wasn't a pleasant encounter, but Sabah had seemed fine when she left. I knew she was upset, but she effectively left on a strong note. I can understand her being upset, but not to the point or raising concerns to her employer. Her cape employer who would then raise them to other people.

"One moment." Survey said. Honestly, I could have just observed what was happening in the room. I probably should have, but I'm not sure I wanted to do that. Setting aside the intrusion it represented, this really wasn't something I wanted to deal with through remote observation.

"What is it?" I asked hopefully.

"Gully has spoken on the matter, likely in reference to details relayed to her by Crystal Pelham and your own interactions." Survey said.

I felt some of my concerns settle, really there were only complicated by the new development. Now it was multiple capes involved with their versions playing out for the people in that room. The rather influential group of people in that room. Even if I effectively owned Uppercrust, this wasn't an entanglement I wanted to deal with.

Once again, I was stuck between my desire to know what was happening and my dread at seeing this mess play out in real time. I took a breath. Survey was on site and would be able to recognize any key information that needed to be communicated.
Joe's clearly immediatley very uncomfortable and anxious.
Then he focuses more on the fact that one of the capes there is riding the edge of her Sechen range really hard, and is on the verge of a second trigger. Given the forces arrayed in that meeting room, to be honest, I get his concern shifting to that detail.
Like, you have Gully's shard, whose prolly been researching Dust. Uppercrust's Shard, whose experienced modification by Apeiron's tech and has seen some of it first hand. Parian's shard, whose been watching Garment for the last while. While only Parian might be second triggering, the nearby shards could totally agree to do some budding for more DATA gathering potential. Also Aisha's shard would get involved, whose experienced modification, seen some tech firsthand, whose host has been popping into a wierd pocket dimension and knows things she shouldn't know, and it might skew the rules a bit and aslo decide to toss in some buds of it's own.
The persona of Jozef Duris The College Dropout, rather than Apeiron, has not responded to Parian's attack yet for good reason - Jozif Duris was not present and should not know about the accusation yet. When the information gets back to him through a regular channel, he should have a chance to respond. But until then, it's properly Survey/Delphine's issue.
That rumour isn't flying beyond those who were in that room, with how strongly it was discredited.
Now, if it did, Jozef Duris would prolly have to react in some manner, but thanks to his friends (and friendly acquantiences, and maybe his luck powers) that's not happening.
A very good point but Joe's reaction suggest that even IF this information reaches him "officially" (though he always has an excuse that Aisha told him that his ex tried to screw him over) he would do absolutely nothing aside from shrugging and saying "It is what it is".
There's only really two channels through which it could reach him "officially"; the general rumor mill, in which case he'd certainly have to deal with it, or through Mrs. Gartenberg telling him, in which case he could thank her for standing up for him and move on.


Speaking more generally, it seems to me the consistent theme that's emerging in a lot of these complaints is that Survey can't be trusted to deal with the matter, and that Joe needs to be Strong and use that strength to... do something about Parian. Because not being a doormat apparently means being aggressive.
 
There is nothing about protecting or being concerned for others. Why people so insisting on adlibing some virtue into Sabah's reasoning? It is pretty clear from her interlude that she thought only about her own good, so all the presumptions that Sabah tried to be martyr to save innocents from an awful monster are kind of baffling.

Ahh, this is the miscommunication. My statements are not attempting to project any virtue upon Sabah. My read of the text suggests she is honestly terrified of Joe joining the Elite and ending up in a position of power over her, again. Her intention wasn't to hurt Joe but to protect herself, but like any drowning person they're damn dangerous to get near.
And her shard is apparently doing everything it can to make things worse because its drooling in glee at the idea of feeding a substandard host into the woodchipper that is Aperion.

I have empathy and pity for her because if Joe had normal Worm powers Sabah would be utterly fucked. Even now the situation ain't good. And those people insisting she needs more punishment feels a lot like 'piling on'.
 

Well, if you're asking if Joe, as Servant, can be awoken to this origin mystic code power, then the answer is probably no. Even ignoring the frankly insane method of activation, that power seems to require the Servant to have some significance at the core of their legend (Gil - the oldest hero and demigod; Tamamo - actual goddess; Nero - beast-to-be; Nameless - protagonist privileges), meanwhile Joe is a Servant without core or even any kind of proper legend behind it. The fact of the mater - Crafter is just too insignificant to meet the requirements for that mystic code.

Now, if you're actually asking if Joe Faster Than Light, then the answer is yes. You can't convince me that duplicates did not install FTL drive somewhere on Joe cybernetic body while he was sleeping. That's a stupid hill I'm wiling to die on.
 
My two cents:
Joe acted sensibly with the information and resources he has.
  1. He's trusting his teammates to make the decision on if he should know about Parian's identity. If the hyperintelligent AI, eldritch horror and the only sane human in the Forge collectively come to the decision that Joe needs to know, they have his green light to tell them.
    I nodded. "That's good to hear." I said, then let out a breath. "And I know that there's something, with Parian and Sabah that you, Tetra, and Aisha know about."

    Survey looked at me, and then nodded. "I suspected your abilities would be sufficient to discern as much, though not the full account?" I shook my head. "Do you wish to be informed?"

    "If it becomes necessary." I said. "Really, I'd say I want to give Sabah some space, but I think I just want to move on. This, all of this, wasn't something I saw coming. It's not something I want to have to deal with if I don't have to. It sounds like you have the situation under control, and I'm happy to see that. I'm here if there's something I can help with, but you don't need to keep me posted unless there's something you think I need to know."

  2. He's acting in a manner that reduces any future impact on him. He's acting in self care here, and not taking any action that he might regret later. No harm was actually done and he's giving her a chance in light of her existing traumas.

  3. That doesn't mean he's doing nothing. He's allowing the two most capable of his assets to prevent this problem from expanding. Not to mention that Survey and Tetra aren't inclined to view Parian positively and he's aware of that. Given what he knows about the situation as it occured, Parian is already in some shit and the only thing that Survey and Tetra will do is stop her from second triggering.

  4. He's letting Parian suffer the consequences of his own actions for the moment, and between Garment rendering her utterly irrelevant in the cape scene now that she no longer wants to work with her, Gartenberg no doubt plotting revenge and Gully being present and no doubt sharing what happened with Crystal and the PRT Parian is going to have enough problems even without Joe stepping in.

    The only spot of luck Parian has is Uppercrust goving her a little consideration based on her discomfort with the Elite, but I wouldn't be suprised if the ascendant Rogue/Villian still has a bad image of her. With how prominent Uppercrust is going to be in the near future that leaves Prarian in an even worse situation.
 
So... yeah, there's now officially nowhere anybody can hide. Even if someone outdoes Toybox with pocket dimension shenanigans, they're only a phone call away.
and you munchkined away the one thing that was repeatedly stated not to work in the chapter multiple times, I'm in stitches and if Lord didn't realize this himself I hope he sees the comment and realizes that the forge is smart enough to use this themselves..then again the reason he said powers are inactive in the call might be forr that gamebreaking reason, since i's a 200 point perk and not a 600-800 one
 
Oh boy. Do I have bad news to y'all.
Lord quote from AO3:
LordR said:
If she [Survey] decides to tell him she'll just tell him. Given Joe's past with Sabah, addressing that aspect of her situation would be a considerable drain on his focus at a time when they are actively managing a developing gang war and multiple S-class threats. The details of Sabah's cape identity can wait a few days while other matters are addressed.
Edit: Also, because I think it's relevant enough based on previous comments:
LordR said:
Many commenters have brought up the title, claiming that it's inappropriate. Catharsis is what the chapter's about, not what it offers to the reader. There's a difference, but I understand where the confusion is coming from. A lot of the time, people seek emotional relief, essentially catharsis, from the fiction they consume. This is doubly true for Fanfiction which tends to be an easy fix for such things. Coming into a chapter that sounds like it's going to provide an emotional high only to find that it's about characters struggling with that topic would put a lot of people off.
 
Last edited:
Just read the chapter and he's going to let deformation go? This doesn't even only effect him but Aisha. He may let it go but the others involved should have the right to make their own decisions. This is a serious accusation that when it's safer to pursue should be pursued.
 
Sabah is going to try something. Probably related to Joe's family. And be Cursed for her trouble.
Also, I am really looking forward to seeing the Celestial Forge vs S9 fight. Or curbstomp.
 
Sabah is going to try something. Probably related to Joe's family. And be Cursed for her trouble.
Yeah, no. Survey isn't gonna let that happen. Parian is done.
Taking Parians vague canon backstory and making this whole narrative situation out of it feels kinda gross ngl
It seems like Roust decided he wanted to use a semi-canon character as his protaganist, picked out Joe from Sabah's backstory for some reason (possibly whim), decided to make it a misunderstanding because writing about a rando dickhead wouldn't be fun for him, and then the consequences of those choices, combined with the rest of the plot propogated out into this scenario.
I'm really glad that this storyline is done though.
 
Yeah, no. Survey isn't gonna let that happen. Parian is done.

It seems like Roust decided he wanted to use a semi-canon character as his protaganist, picked out Joe from Sabah's backstory for some reason (possibly whim), decided to make it a misunderstanding because writing about a rando dickhead wouldn't be fun for him, and then the consequences of those choices, combined with the rest of the plot propogated out into this scenario.
I'm really glad that this storyline is done though.

Oh, Survey's not going to need to do anything.

Sabah is going to get herself all worked up into a paranoia spiral, and then she's going to do a few web searches into Joe's family (because she can't consider that an error might be made out of ignorance instead of malice), then the curse kicks in.

I want to see that.
 
You know Riley would consider people as deserving of mercy more then that? She's only act on that after having recovered from her programming but she'd understand the concept.

oh yeah cuz joe cares so much about what a hypothetical future riley thinks about when dealing with the react actual threat of Bonesaw.

He already thinks the fandombrain Thinker power is amoral and foolish, why would it think for a nanosecond that it's worth spending time on deprogramming a lunatic who literally turns people into art sculptures?

Oh, Survey's not going to need to do anything.

Sabah is going to get herself all worked up into a paranoia spiral, and then she's going to do a few web searches into Joe's family (because she can't consider that an error might be made out of ignorance instead of malice), then the curse kicks in.

I want to see that.

You won't. There's been a dozen of random bloodthirsty comments for goddamned weeks and it's fucking tiring and a dead horse as bad as the pacing complaints in the few weeks since the first chapter of this event was posted and it's explicitly thru WoG not going to happen.
 
You won't. There's been a dozen of random bloodthirsty comments for goddamned weeks and it's fucking tiring and a dead horse as bad as the pacing complaints in the few weeks since the first chapter of this event was posted and it's explicitly thru WoG not going to happen.
I just reread the fic after months of being too busy with work to have time to reread it. Sorry if I am not up to date on all the complaints and reader commentary.
So yeah, I want to see what the curse DOES.
Too bad it won't hit Parian.
Any hints on who it will discharge onto?
 
Too bad it won't hit Parian.
Any hints on who it will discharge onto?

Most likely Coil given he's the most disrespectful of the unwritten rules in-setting, and with his power he'll be the one to make the most attempts. He's already been trying to find out who Aperion is early-on in this story. He even killed Joe in a dropped timeline. Literally could have ended the story right then and there if he kept it.

Other than that, an evil Echidna clone of any of the characters that know Joe. Like an echidna clone of Lisa in an alternate timeline. Doubt any of the Forge itself would get cloned.
 
I just reread the fic after months of being too busy with work to have time to reread it. Sorry if I am not up to date on all the complaints and reader commentary.
So yeah, I want to see what the curse DOES.
Too bad it won't hit Parian.
Any hints on who it will discharge onto?

At a guess based on canon's events around this time? Coil's breaking of the Unwritten Rules writ large implies it's going to be him.
 
At a guess based on canon's events around this time? Coil's breaking of the Unwritten Rules writ large implies it's going to be him.
If Coil then releases identities out of spite as a final FU then it could start striking out at large numbers of people. And government officials. And maybe the Simurgh?
 
oh yeah cuz joe cares so much about what a hypothetical future riley thinks about when dealing with the react actual threat of Bonesaw.

He already thinks the fandombrain Thinker power is amoral and foolish, why would it think for a nanosecond that it's worth spending time on deprogramming a lunatic who literally turns people into art sculptures?
If people aren't willing to consider the potential of others for peace then all that is left for their consideration is the peace of the fucking grave.
 
If people aren't willing to consider the potential of others for peace then all that is left for their consideration is the peace of the fucking grave.

Weird to call for the death of the main character over a hundred chapters in but OK.

If Coil then releases identities out of spite as a final FU then it could start striking out at large numbers of people. And government officials. And maybe the Simurgh?

The curse would stop him from being able to reveal the identities of the Forge at all, if he even manages to collect them. That's kind of the point of it.
 
Weird to call for the death of the main character over a hundred chapters in but OK.
I meant the peace of everyone else being in the grave; since you didn't set a cut-off point for what you think should happen to Bonesaw and everyone like her, didn't suggest a lower limit to how similar they had to be to her to deserve the same treatment as her, that is the logical conclusion of applying it to people.
 
She could've made a statement on Joe's conduct on behalf of Sabah as her employer (That's not what she did, she threw in an incredibly vague warning, then refused to elaborate or allow others to investigate further). She could've accused him of ill-doing that she at least knew actually happened, instead of setting implication about social interaction she knew nothing about and bringing a stranger (Aisha) down to her mess. What Sabah did was not efficient, rational or in any way a good move. Do not try to frame it as such.

Again, emphasis mine - without doxxing herself. What do you think will happen when the investigation starts, if she elaborates on Sabah's circumstances? Everything in her life will be put under a microscope. Even if she wasn't a traumatized mess, that's still her secret identity. She'd be giving the Elite a free pass to scrutinize her civilian ID and more leverage to press her into service.

And notice I did not say rational, or good. Efficient is the only word I used, and I used it in its definition of "Acting or producing effectively with a minimum of waste, expense, or unnecessary effort." She was panicking, and reached for the closest blunt object to whack her problem with it. It was efficient.

You were saying that Joe WAS excused for doing stuff to his family ("And yet, since he's the protagonist, we make excuses for him."). He never was. That's the part I was calling you out on, don't deflect it by veering into making an angle for your argument.

Even then, that is not a good angle you think it is. The fact that anyone capable of "monstrous things" is in no way an argument that actions committed without direct malice or in a bad state of mind should go unanswered. Joe, if he committed the atrocities he was afraid of, would not be excused by people decrying Sabah now (If they consistent in their beliefs), so using it as argument that they should excuse Sabah will not work.

Yeah, that was a bad argument on my part. Apologies, my desire to not give ground won when it shouldn't have.

To try to clarify in regards to 'actions committed' and my intent, I am arguing against the many, many posts in thread that are angling for the very heavens to rain down on Parian, when her only action failed utterly, stopped in its tracks as soon as it started, and there are already very clear consequences coming down the line with Garment's soft blacklisting, the darkening of her reputation in the eyes of several important people, etc. Any calls for further retribution is based on 'potential, future impacts that might have happened if she were not stopped by factors beyond her comprehension', which to mean is a dark mirror to Joe's entire deal with the Celestial Forge. Hence my comparison in the first place.

"One step further doesn't seem to be that much of a difference"? Can you stop saying stuff that makes it seem like you don't understand the difference between considering action and committing it? I know you are trying to say stuff like "She had her reasons", but the more you talk, the more it sounds like you're arguing that Sabah did nothing wrong. You're not trying to argue something THAT stupid, right?

I've done my best to be cordial in this debate, I'd appreciate it if you did the same. That includes not resorting to petty name-calling and not cutting off the final sentence of the paragraph acknowledging that this was my personal understanding of the first chapter and Joe's later introspection on how close he was to committing to monstrous action.

As far as I have understood the text, Joe was explicitly shown what his power would have been by the Forge, and further introspection by Joe show that he was cognizant enough of himself and his past mental state where he was able to extrapolate his further actions should he have gotten his original power. This tells me that Joe would have done these monstrous actions, were it not for the Celestial Forge.

Let's look at Parian now. People are calling for more punishment on top of the oncoming consequences that are already coming for her, since her actions potentially could have been life ruining for the hypothetical Joe who was not part of the Celestial Forge.

There is a clear parallel in 'actions would have been terrible, if external factors did not happen', in these two cases. The thread is damning Parian for the potential ramifications of her actions that could not have happened thanks to the Celestial Forge stopping her, and yet is the result of unchecked not!Celestial Forge Joe equally monstrous? Hence my comment on Parian being 'one step further', while not being all that different. Terrible results were stopped by the existence of the Celestial Forge. This is not a claim that Sabah did nothing wrong, only an observation that those calling for Joe and company to kick Sabah while she's down are depressingly not considering how similar the two situations are, and maybe should take a step back and reconsider.
 
I get the feeling LordRoustabout isn't the type to write 'reasons you suck' speeches, especially not for Joe, so that kind of catharsis isn't likely to happen (and we kind of got it last chapter from Gully anyway)
That's kind of the problem people are pointing out, he started this whole thing to grow as a writer. He needs to step out of his comfort zone and listen to the people that are commenting, helping, and supporting him. I am not saying he hasn't improved, he has! Unfortunately it gets to a point where an author is dragging things out for no reason and not growing their abilities. This is where most of the frustrations come from, at least that's my read.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top