7734
Trust and verify.
- Location
- Philmont
And on those happy thoughts, I'm going to embarrass/credit @Strypgia by using his story as an example in writing lectures provide you all a valuable lesson in writing romance, basic wordcraft, and fiction writing.
(note- original transcript can be found on my Discord if anyone's curious)
Please be careful with the commenting, I don't want to accidentally derail the thread.
(note- original transcript can be found on my Discord if anyone's curious)
The three items needed for crystalizing that "maybe" romance into that "definetly" romance, a lecture.
(Link to Chapter 1 go here.)
First thing to analyze- the background enviroment. We start off with the classic Type A Tsundere arangment, variant 2- The Doormat. Normally, this is a passive MC and a very active Tsundere who sticks by him for any one of a number of reasons. Here, this is known as Asuka riding roughshod over Shinji whenever she damn well pleases. As all tsunderes in the wild are wont to do, she eventualy decides she wants to advance the romance with Shinji. In the cannon, this goes horribly wrong because of reasons. They're kids, it's not NGE if something goes right, blah blah blah. Here, we meet the divergence point- where Shinji slips.
Now, there are three large-scale items needed to progress a relationship from one holding pattern, or level to another. I prefer holding pattern, as it implies movement, versus level which is static. These three macroitems are a low point or disruption of routine, realization, and a stabilization. The low point is so there's a chance for a deeper romantic connection to happen, the realization is the moment the connection is made, and the stabalization is what prompts a permanent shift in holding pattern and therefore relationship.
Now, both in cannon and here, there's been certain environmental pressures that have brought Shinji and Asuka to their resepctive hiccup in life. It's not really much to go over- Asuka decides that now would be a great time to give things with Shinji a kick, and said kick is swiftly applied via kissing him.
Here's the point of divergence from cannon- Shinji looses his footing and starts to slip and stagger, pulling Asuka in closer. At first glance, barely worth a mention, right? Wrong. The slip and after show off the three essential items necessary for a romance- interdependancy, physical reaction, and honest expression of intent. Or, in plain English, Shinji grabs Asuka and Asuka grabs back, they both like kissing each other, and they both keep kissing each other. There's no wild gesticulation, there's no frantic stoppages, there's just one long, slightly awkward makeout scene. A good couple (and the entire premise of the fic is making Shinji and Asuka a reasonably good couple) tends to trust each other first, and go for them first. Interdependancy, check. Good couples have physical chemistry on some level. If there's no chemisty, you have philla, not eros. Can you build a relationship off of it? Sure- just not one that has sexual portions. Instead of Antony and Cleopatra or Romeo and Juliet, you end up with Rolland and Oliver or Legolas and Gimli. Not the intended result, that. Then there's honest expression of intent. Shinji falls over holding Asuka, and the first thing she does when they're done falling? Keep kissing him. It's not a trap, and Shinji, instead of running, decides to keep at it too.
So, we've got our hiccup in routine down to jar the couple, and an event to move their relationship forward. However, if we stop here all we have is the same old same old, now with more kissing between sporadic bouts of violence. Not exactly a major improvement to bring about significant change, so the author prints out this.
Remember, three things to move a relationship towards romance- initial incident, realization, and finally something to make the change in relationship stick. This, right there, is the definition of making the new change stick. To do this, the author had to deal with two issues- one, the fact neither character had a very solid understanding of the other's background, and two; deal with the fact both of the characters believe, quite rightly, that they are unique to the world. To fix both issues in one conversation, he had this little heat-to-heart happen which gives both characters common ground with each other. This is important- no amount of personal chemistry and animal magnatism will save a doomed relationship if there's nothing for it to work with. The other thing this talk does is diabuse them of their special snowflake "You don't know what I've been through" issue- because, while neither has lived in each other's shoes, they both have a pretty damn good idea of what it's like.
So, to finish, three things are needed to get a relationship to transcend friendship to romance. There needs to be an initial incident, a moment of clarity and romance to boost the relationship, and an event that solidifies the relationship at it's newest pattern. Here, we have the kiss, the continuation of the kiss and tacit acceptance of the other party, and the discussion after the kiss. Each part sets up the next, and the whole system works beautifully to show progression in the lives of characters and in the story itself.
(Link to Chapter 1 go here.)
First thing to analyze- the background enviroment. We start off with the classic Type A Tsundere arangment, variant 2- The Doormat. Normally, this is a passive MC and a very active Tsundere who sticks by him for any one of a number of reasons. Here, this is known as Asuka riding roughshod over Shinji whenever she damn well pleases. As all tsunderes in the wild are wont to do, she eventualy decides she wants to advance the romance with Shinji. In the cannon, this goes horribly wrong because of reasons. They're kids, it's not NGE if something goes right, blah blah blah. Here, we meet the divergence point- where Shinji slips.
Now, there are three large-scale items needed to progress a relationship from one holding pattern, or level to another. I prefer holding pattern, as it implies movement, versus level which is static. These three macroitems are a low point or disruption of routine, realization, and a stabilization. The low point is so there's a chance for a deeper romantic connection to happen, the realization is the moment the connection is made, and the stabalization is what prompts a permanent shift in holding pattern and therefore relationship.
Now, both in cannon and here, there's been certain environmental pressures that have brought Shinji and Asuka to their resepctive hiccup in life. It's not really much to go over- Asuka decides that now would be a great time to give things with Shinji a kick, and said kick is swiftly applied via kissing him.
Here's the point of divergence from cannon- Shinji looses his footing and starts to slip and stagger, pulling Asuka in closer. At first glance, barely worth a mention, right? Wrong. The slip and after show off the three essential items necessary for a romance- interdependancy, physical reaction, and honest expression of intent. Or, in plain English, Shinji grabs Asuka and Asuka grabs back, they both like kissing each other, and they both keep kissing each other. There's no wild gesticulation, there's no frantic stoppages, there's just one long, slightly awkward makeout scene. A good couple (and the entire premise of the fic is making Shinji and Asuka a reasonably good couple) tends to trust each other first, and go for them first. Interdependancy, check. Good couples have physical chemistry on some level. If there's no chemisty, you have philla, not eros. Can you build a relationship off of it? Sure- just not one that has sexual portions. Instead of Antony and Cleopatra or Romeo and Juliet, you end up with Rolland and Oliver or Legolas and Gimli. Not the intended result, that. Then there's honest expression of intent. Shinji falls over holding Asuka, and the first thing she does when they're done falling? Keep kissing him. It's not a trap, and Shinji, instead of running, decides to keep at it too.
So, we've got our hiccup in routine down to jar the couple, and an event to move their relationship forward. However, if we stop here all we have is the same old same old, now with more kissing between sporadic bouts of violence. Not exactly a major improvement to bring about significant change, so the author prints out this.
Asuka just narrowed her eyes at him. "What Sensei?"
"The one my father abandoned me with after my mother died in an accident with the Eva! Not that you'd understand that," he bit out. It was not a comfortable memory. He pinched his eyes closed as the painful image of his father's retreating back welled up once again.
But when he opened them again, Asuka was staring at him like she'd seen a ghost. "Me too."
Shinji blinked. That couldn't be what she just said.
Her arms squeezed him tighter as her gaze went far away. "My mother... There was an accident with Unit-02... She... died, eventually. My father... didn't mourn very long." Her mouth twisted sourly. "So yes, Third Child, I know exactly what that felt like!"
Shinji sat stunned, his mind trying to grapple with her shocking revelation. Asuka... had felt the same kind of loss as he had? She'd had her mother ripped away from her, and even younger than him? She... was like him?
"Your father abandoned you after your mother was gone," he said.
She looked at him sharply again. She opened her mouth to say something, but stopped. Her forehead wrinkled in thought for a moment. "You have nightmares all the time about it. The memory keeps coming after you when you try to sleep," she said eventually. It was only half a question.
Shinji nodded slowly, never breaking her eyes. A memory of Asuka weeping in her sleep, whimpering for her Mama floated across his mind. "It's hard to sleep. You feel lonely and cold at night, because no one ever held you after that," he finally replied. It was even less a question. There weren't questions. They were connections. Confessions.
Asuka barely let him finish before she replied. "You never had many friends before you came here. No on ever wanted to just talk to you for you."
She knew... This was his life. And hers? "Your father never explained or apologized for why he just left you."
"No one even tried to understand your pain. No one cared." Her eyes were magnetic, her voice hypnotic.
"You miss her every day, but don't even have any pictures, barely any memories. No one tells you about her." He almost felt like it wasn't his own voice speaking anymore.
Her arms tightened around him even more, almost a desperate grip now. "And there was never any point in talking about it to anyone, because there was no one in the world who could understand what being an Evangelion Pilot was like," she said softly.
Silence hung heavy between them. Shinji vaguely noticed they were breathing in synch, faces just inches apart.
"You're just like me."
He blinked. He wasn't sure which of them had started saying it first.
Remember, three things to move a relationship towards romance- initial incident, realization, and finally something to make the change in relationship stick. This, right there, is the definition of making the new change stick. To do this, the author had to deal with two issues- one, the fact neither character had a very solid understanding of the other's background, and two; deal with the fact both of the characters believe, quite rightly, that they are unique to the world. To fix both issues in one conversation, he had this little heat-to-heart happen which gives both characters common ground with each other. This is important- no amount of personal chemistry and animal magnatism will save a doomed relationship if there's nothing for it to work with. The other thing this talk does is diabuse them of their special snowflake "You don't know what I've been through" issue- because, while neither has lived in each other's shoes, they both have a pretty damn good idea of what it's like.
So, to finish, three things are needed to get a relationship to transcend friendship to romance. There needs to be an initial incident, a moment of clarity and romance to boost the relationship, and an event that solidifies the relationship at it's newest pattern. Here, we have the kiss, the continuation of the kiss and tacit acceptance of the other party, and the discussion after the kiss. Each part sets up the next, and the whole system works beautifully to show progression in the lives of characters and in the story itself.
Please be careful with the commenting, I don't want to accidentally derail the thread.