Welcome!
Yes. Homura sees any Madoka contract as a Bad End scenario, and tbh even with our grief powers it still means Madoka's in danger of becoming a Universe-consuming Eldritch Abomination if we ever fuck up, which given an infinite amount of time is inevitable. Even within a normal human lifetime it's an unacceptable risk.
It's something we could encourage Mami to do (via telepathy) at some point in the future. It...might be pushing for too much, too soon to do it today. We'll see if the opportunity comes up, I guess.
Not necessarily. If Madoka makes her canon Wish, except for the part about her becoming the concept, it'd all be fine. And it isn't inevitable, since the obvious alternative to Witching out is having one's soul gem destroyed or destroying one's Soul Gem oneself.
I'd rather not risk it when the fate of the world is at stake.
Neither of those is an acceptable outcome for us, either.
It's a shame really. Madoka could do so much good and we know for certain that particular wrinkle can be ironed out by wishing good. Can we even stop Madoka once she has the whole picture? I know Homura managed to convince Madoka to not contract in an alt timeline but that Madoka didn't know about Madokami.
Well, if we've got a mindguca employed, we could just add in an extra sibling. Hackerguca to take care of official records.
Way to ignore my main point, Narrator. Again, if Madoka makes her canon wish without the part that makes her into a concept, her Witch would never come to pass.
Yes and no.
Them turning into witches is less than ideal, but we can hold onto their Grief Seeds until we figure out dewitching. Madoka turning into a witch means everything's fucked.
Thinking about it, if everything you mean the city, thats okay. Heck even the earth, solar system and galaxy is reversible given enough time and effort of millenias. Universal everything or multiversal, we're fucked right?
Mobile fortress just became a legit spaceship through force of will.
Funnily enough, it was, in my extremely limited experience. They had a shocking collection of English songs, pop and older, as well as Disney songs, and there was one Italian opera. My friend loved that one.
That's one thing - if you explicitly want to show off with your powers for songs beyond the scope of the karaoke machine, you can vote for it, yeah.
That works, yeah! Explicit song votes are fine, but I've read through the thread picking out songs, too.
...that is wrong on every level. The series and Rebellion both show, repeatedly, that causality doesn't work that way. Retroactive wishes are entirely possible.
And I'd prefer not to gamble on that wish coming out just right when it hasn't worked in the last hundred loops. And there's a decent chance that, without a cosmic retcon taking her timelooping powers away, Homura will loop again and undo everything we've accomplished. She won't accept a contracted Madoka.
I said "neither is an acceptable outcome" in response to you describing two ways that Madoka's Soul Gem could be broken before she witches out. Alternatives that involve a dead Madoka are not workable alternatives.
Everything means the planet, at a bare minimum. And no, seven billion people dying is not okay. As far as I know, we don't have the power to bring the dead back to life in any meaningful way.
That's not true. Most Wishes aren't retroactive. Madoka's and Homura's are unusual in that way. So unusual that Kyubey actually comments on it.
