The main issue with dealing with Tsubaki ASAP is that Riona is scheduled to arrive in Mitakihara tommorow or the day after, and we really need to be in town to greet her when she does. I'd be cool with contacting her with telepathy, but I'd really prefer the actual visiting not happen until the Riona thing settles down - so Friday, at the soonest.
I find this approach rather dubious. Emergency situations aren't going to wait until it's convenient for our schedule. And we're not even sure what day Riona will arrive, so you're proposing not acting for multiple days out of concern that she might show up. And once she arrives, we have no idea what new crises she will precipitate and how long they'll take to resolve. "Friday" will quickly become "next week" and then "never."

I'd rather get Tsubaki's gem clean first, so that we know she's going to be alive for the next few days while we deal with Riona. It's not like it's an all-day endeavor. We can travel extremely fast and can do a fly-by cleansing if need be.
 
I'm hoping we call Tsubaki after Hijiri.

Mami won't complain that we spend too long on the phone as long as she gets hugs. :p And she can join the conversation with Tsubaki.
 
[X] The Phoenixian

Not sure why we're delaying the Tsubaki telepathy to tomorrow, though. It's just telepathy: not exactly a huge time investment. We could telepathy now, and plan a visit for tomorrow if necessary.

I really don't want to risk her witching out more than necessary. We have no idea at what point exactly she witches out: for all we know, it could be tomorrow. Unlikely, but definitely a possibility. And from what we know of her, she definitely deserves better. Also, practically speaking, she's a huge asset, really. She's an adult bleeding heart guca, and her Wish was to kill witches. She should be amazing against Walpurgisnacht. Sayaka can also copy her powers to be similarly OP against Witches. We can also have Sayaka copy Suzune's power... Suzune's power is copying the powers of dead witches. I don't know what the heck Sayaka and Suzune would be able to get from a dead Walpy, but I sure as hell want to find out.

I doubt Tsubaki is in super immediate danger, and there's a reason for that: Firstly, It looks like Suzune hasn't contracted as of Nadia's last visit, and the impression I get is that they were together for some time. Not years, but likely months. Plus, from the look of things it seems Tsubaki only witched while she was grieving for an old, close relative on top of sharing her seeds with Suzune.

If Nadia has already met Tsubaki on this round of her travel's through Japan, then we can be pretty sure we have time. Might be worth asking Firn about that.

------

Related, of all the PMSM girls, Suzune, the Hinata sisters, and Kanade Haruka are the ones most at risk as they all seem to contract young-ish, with Chisato being a bit more ambiguous as far as the date of contract goes. Assuming Tsubaki is saved. Kanade is the next most important to intercept, as her wish, made while she thought she was dreaming due to not believing in magic, erased her sister from existence.

I kinnnnda want to prevent that.

I find this approach rather dubious. Emergency situations aren't going to wait until it's convenient for our schedule. And we're not even sure what day Riona will arrive, so you're proposing not acting for multiple days out of concern that she might show up. And once she arrives, we have no idea what new crises she will precipitate and how long they'll take to resolve. "Friday" will quickly become "next week" and then "never."

I'd rather get Tsubaki's gem clean first, so that we know she's going to be alive for the next few days while we deal with Riona. It's not like it's an all-day endeavor. We can travel extremely fast and can do a fly-by cleansing if need be.
I really don't think a fly-by cleansing is likely to be on the table. Any meetup in person with someone we haven't met in person will likely involve a longer talk. I'm willing to drop a lot for that if it's truly urgent, but it is a time constant, and it will break plans.
 
It can't be months in the future. There is no future after May 1st, 2011.
Demonstrable false: Both Kagari and Matsuri are years younger in than flashbacks to Tsubaki and when they contracted they are in the main plot of PMSM.

The only way it could be the case that that PMSM happens around now is if Tsubaki witching out just never happened either due to never meeting Suzune, or just not doing so and Suzune leaving Tsubaki's care before Nadia ever met her.
 
I doubt Tsubaki is in super immediate danger, and there's a reason for that: Firstly, It looks like Suzune hasn't contracted as of Nadia's last visit, and the impression I get is that they were together for some time. Not years, but likely months. Plus, from the look of things it seems Tsubaki only witched while she was grieving for an old, close relative on top of sharing her seeds with Suzune.

If Nadia has already met Tsubaki on this round of her travel's through Japan, then we can be pretty sure we have time. Might be worth asking Firn about that.

------

Related, of all the PMSM girls, Suzune, the Hinata sisters, and Kanade Haruka are the ones most at risk as they all seem to contract young-ish, with Chisato being a bit more ambiguous as far as the date of contract goes. Assuming Tsubaki is saved. Kanade is the next most important to intercept, as her wish, made while she thought she was dreaming due to not believing in magic, erased her sister from existence.

I kinnnnda want to prevent that.


I really don't think a fly-by cleansing is likely to be on the table. Any meetup in person with someone we haven't met in person will likely involve a longer talk. I'm willing to drop a lot for that if it's truly urgent, but it is a time constant, and it will break plans.

The thing is, I don't think there's any real drawback to establishing contact with Tsubaki right now. It's not as if telepathying her locks us into visiting tomorrow or something. If we tell her that we have a busy schedule for the next few days but saw no reason to not establish contact in advance, I'm sure she'll understand.


It can't be months in the future. There is no future after May 1st, 2011.

As the others have said, it is entirely plausible that Suzune Magica takes place at a later date than PMMM. Timelines keep going after Homura loops back: she hops to different timelines, she doesn't just reset the same one. And in the early timelines, Madoka's witch wasn't powerful enough to wipe out humanity, so in those timelines humanity would simply have kept going. And thus, it is entirely plausible that Suzune Magica took place in 2020 or something.

Hmm, one thing, though... Have we seen this Tsubaki Mikoto referred to as an 'adult' in PMAS? Has Nadia called her an adult? If she's an adult,then we have less time. She was only in her twenties when she Witched, after all. Which would make Suzune Magica taking place many years in the future rather less likely. If she's not an adult, then we have a ton of time. Maybe we should ask Nadia how old Tsubaki is?
 
(Topic: convincing Homura Sabrina she(Sabrina) is another thing Homura can call her own, beyond her obligation to Madoka)

It would be good to be able to convince Homura of that, wouldn't it- I'd really just want to be sure we approached it from the "we are family and we care and accept and support you, you have us, and just by being yourself you do so well by us, we could not have done any of of what we've done, for ourself or to help you, without you being you; you are, yourself, enough" direction and didn't accidentally step into the other direction that one could go with suddenly having a basically-independent kid, with the "suddenly you have a lot more responsibility and obligation that you never asked for, but it automatically means more if you don't live up to it even though you never asked for it because you have a kid, and are you supposed to parent, how do you keep them safe when you both go around fighting dangerous shit, you aren't ready for this, you could have been their friend or ally or mentor but how can I be responsible for this person?"
That's the point. In-quest, Sabrina has already establisheed as a powerful and reliable magical girl before raising the wish issues with Homura so it wouldnt be much problem on that front.

I hope.

I really don't think a fly-by cleansing is likely to be on the table. Any meetup in person with someone we haven't met in person will likely involve a longer talk. I'm willing to drop a lot for that if it's truly urgent, but it is a time constant, and it will break plans.
How much longer it'd really be, anyways? Because I can expect Sabrina spending more time traveling from/to Mitakihara than the actual talk if she's in a hurry.


(Sorry if what follows doesn't make sense, I didn't know there was a PMSM until today, some link to know stuff about them would be nice)
Didn't someone claim it was a acquantance of Mami's or I just misunderstood? In that case we can ask her to come to Mitakihara for a cleanse if we are really pressed for time.
 
The rest of the conversation passes with unimportant gossip, though you do take the opportunity to ask about older magical girls in Japan itself - apparently Tsubaki Mikoto is alive and well, but Nadia hasn't heard of Suzune. Which does hopefully mean that Kagari Hinata isn't a threat, but you're not entirely sure you can bank on that.

The relevant quote.

And no, unlike Kazumi, Tsubaki hasn't had any contact with Mami before.
 
Last edited:
[X]Onmur

It should be noted that she does this by using her magic and just reversing the direction, essentially, rather than "literally doing the opposite of what her magic's meant to do."
Ah, good to know. That makes it less likely that we'll be able to work out a way for Kyouko to get anti-illusion powers or some shit, alas. Still, the fact that Mitama can still use that magic despite rejecting her wish might be notable.
 
Actually, I did think of a small thing that I want to add to the SCIENCE.

-[] Chibi Brina: Try...
--[] Enchanting things hands-free or using chibi brina's hands
 
[X] Telepathy Kirika: Tell her about Hisaomi's diary.
-[X] Stress its infohazard nature towards Oriko.
-[X] Tell her where to find it.

[X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
-[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
-[X] Ask about her protecting all our Soul Gems.

[X] Test enchanted Grief.
-[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
-[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
-[X] While testing, with enchantment...
--[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
--[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
-[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
--[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
--[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
--[X] Leaving your range.
--[X] Enchanting things hands-free or using Chibi Brina's hands

[X] Place an order for those trackers.

[X] Call Hijiri.
-[X] Ask how she's doing.
--[X] Grief levels?
--[X] Anything she wants to talk?
-[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.

I'll insist on telling Kirika about the diary. I see no reason to wait on it, nevermind leave things to chance.

Quite a few words over 150, but it is a SCIENCE! vote.
 
Last edited:
We just learned that the fourth dimension is real and explorable. We can go kata out of the way of the air, achieve sufficient velocity, and come back ana when we feel like it.
Keep in mind , though, that we'd have to do it within 100m of us, which would still be at a "DO NOT MAKE ANTIMATTER" range.
 
... I keep changing my mind about the diary thing. Question: How would it affect others' (Homura's, Sayaka's, Mami's) perception of the verifiability of the whole "Oriko's unknown history" thing we brought out during the timestop talk, if we went and told Kirika to retrieve it in this manner? That is, how would it hurt our social and reliability for this round? How much was our discussion actually resting on that? Because this feels a little like the "ask Kirika to go check up on meguca IRCs" thing that we were gently stopped from walking into. When do we next plan to stop by, that we can ourselves potentially retrieve the diary?

For that matter- where's this diary located exactly? How much are we worried about Oriko finding it if we don't say anything; how much are we worried about Kirika finding it if we don't say anything?

... and now I'm paranoid that the diary won't be there when we go look for it. And where it was originally standing, a black feather resting on the ground. Or something suitably alarming.
 
Hm. Mami...

[X] Mami
-[X] Is the ribbon bracelet going to dissolve if you get too far apart? It's nice...

[X] Onmur
 
@Onmur Regarding the diary, is it really safe to call Kirika over telepathy?
Adhoc vote count started by Firnagzen on May 2, 2018 at 5:43 AM, finished with 137347 posts and 14 votes.

  • [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting Soul Gems with it
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk about?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
    --[X] You'd like to talk more on that, if she's willing, but telepathy is not a secure form of communication.
    [X] Look up how to buy those trackers.
    [X] Telepathy Kirika: Tell her about Hisaomi's diary.
    -[X] Stress it's infohazard nature towards Oriko.
    -[X] Tell her where to find it.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting all our Soul Gems.
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    --[X] Enchanting things hands-free or using Chibi Brina's hands
    [X] Place an order for those trackers.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
    [x] your trapped! quirk, you must escape!
    [X] Mami
    -[X] Is the ribbon bracelet going to dissolve if you get too far apart? It's nice...
    [X] Telepathy Kirika: Tell her about Hisaomi's diary.
    -[X] Stress it's infohazard nature towards Oriko.
    -[X] Tell her where to find it.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting all our Soul Gems.
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    --[X] Enchanting things hands-free or using Chibi Brina's hands
    [X] Place an order for those trackers.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
 
Actually, though, question- @Firnagzen , this:
Was in all of the potentially winning votes, whatever the exact tally looked like in the end, but it looks like it kinda got dropped? The questioning part in particular, with the "if I have any heavy topics to bring up in the future, would you rather me bring them up on a bad day, a good day, a meh day, preface the real-talk in any particular way, anything like that?" stuff. And, given, that line has been drawn pretty far away from its original conversational context, so the exact body of the vote isn't particularly informative in that regard... Or was it dropped on purpose because of not really a good place to put it, as the conversation flowed and whatnot?
Yeah, it just didn't flow, honestly, plus it wasn't really a reasonable thing to ask at the point.
Since the sheild is a sphere, does that mean the rock is floating in the middle of it, or does it fall to the bottom of the bubble?
Floating in the middle.
@Firnagzen How long did it take us to craft the Pocket Brina using enchanted Grief?
About ten-fifteen minutes.
@Firnagzen, A question: Do we see the enchantment fade in any way as it wears off?
If you're paying attention, yes, you can sense the magic fading, but it's not something you're aware of without paying attention.
Adhoc vote count started by Firnagzen on May 2, 2018 at 9:16 AM, finished with 137354 posts and 16 votes.

  • [X] Telepathy Kirika: Tell her about Hisaomi's diary.
    -[X] Stress it's infohazard nature towards Oriko.
    -[X] Tell her where to find it.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting all our Soul Gems.
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    --[X] Enchanting things hands-free or using Chibi Brina's hands
    [X] Place an order for those trackers.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting Soul Gems with it
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk about?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
    --[X] You'd like to talk more on that, if she's willing, but telepathy is not a secure form of communication.
    [X] Look up how to buy those trackers.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting Soul Gems with it
    [X] Try willing the enchanted soft rock to
    -[X] Become something else
    -[X] Attract Grief
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk about?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
    --[X] You'd like to talk more on that, if she's willing, but telepathy is not a secure form of communication.
    [X] Call Tsubaki. Offer cleansing, Invite her to visit.
    [X] Look up how to buy those trackers.
    [x] your trapped! quirk, you must escape!
    [X] Mami
    -[X] Is the ribbon bracelet going to dissolve if you get too far apart? It's nice...
    [X] Telepathy Kirika: Tell her about Hisaomi's diary.
    -[X] Stress it's infohazard nature towards Oriko.
    -[X] Tell her where to find it.
    [X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
    -[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
    -[X] Ask about her protecting all our Soul Gems.
    [X] Test enchanted Grief.
    -[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
    -[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
    -[X] While testing, with enchantment...
    --[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
    --[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
    ---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
    ---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
    -[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
    --[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
    --[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
    --[X] Leaving your range.
    --[X] Enchanting things hands-free or using Chibi Brina's hands
    [X] Place an order for those trackers.
    [X] Call Hijiri.
    -[X] Ask how she's doing.
    --[X] Grief levels?
    --[X] Anything she wants to talk?
    -[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
 
[X] Help Homura test her enchantment.
-[X] Try and get her to pick up and hold you properly.
-[X] Ask about her protecting Soul Gems with it
[X] Try willing the enchanted soft rock to
-[X] Become something else
-[X] Attract Grief

[X] Test enchanted Grief.
-[X] Use the same enchanted Grief to make different things.
-[X] Do you need to decide what you want to build before enchanting Grief, or not?
-[X] While testing, with enchantment...
--[X] Repair Kuroki's phone. Check it afterwards.
--[X] Make a full-sized Brina clone.
---[X] Give Mami double hugs.
---[X] Let Mami examine clone for her own research?
-[X] Chibi Brina: Try...
--[X] Moving in four dimensions. And observing what's out there.
--[X] Mapping the 4d shape of your soul gem.
--[X] Leaving your range.
[X] Call Hijiri.
-[X] Ask how she's doing.
--[X] Grief levels?
--[X] Anything she wants to talk about?
-[X] Offer an update on Anri. She's safe, is detained humanely, and we did speak with her and hear what she had to say.
--[X] You'd like to talk more on that, if she's willing, but telepathy is not a secure form of communication.
[X] Call Tsubaki. Offer cleansing, Invite her to visit.
[X] Look up how to buy those trackers.

I suspect that Tsubaki can make the grocery run to visit us, therefore making a better schedule fit. For openers, really all we need to do is pull off our regular show. Clear her a seed, and maybe there will be no emergencies for a while. We now have references, so she will have the ability to make a fair decision to investigate our claims.

Our enchantment practice is lacking in rigor. The softened rock should be manipulated further. Transforming Grief is still not using 'orthodox magic.' We should develop all our alternatives, if we want to be able to use loopholes.

Willpower is the key, IMHO. Direct our will at the pre-enchanted rock, and have a strong focused imagination. It might be 'controlled,' allowing re-shaping and such, or it might be free-form 'transformation.' Try for both.
 
[x] HeroCycle

Trying to enchant an alternative to Grief Seeds is a must, and there's no reason to gamble with Tsubaki's life by putting off contacting her.
 
Yeah, it just didn't flow, honestly, plus it wasn't really a reasonable thing to ask at the point.

Huh, good to know. Guess we better keep it in mind next time there's an opening.

[x] HeroCycle

Seems comprehensive, and the call to Tsubaki kinda oughta happen, even if it's just to put it on the vote-list as a zoomed-out action.
 
Back
Top