Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
An excerpt from the journal of Soizic d'Karak, a Questing Knight 28
An excerpt from the journal of Soizic d'Karak, a Questing Knight-


Dear diary, today I have the day free of my duties, and ere dusk grows near I shall endeavor to commit unto you all that has happened these last weeks. I sit at a table near the foot of Karag Lhune, the King's Stair behind me and the occasional gyrocopter beating through the air above.

To my right is a pond, though I shan't call it large or small- and t'is no lake by any means. It comforts my soul nonetheless, and the babble of the small fall of water from the recently completed aqueduct comforts the ear worn keen by the dust and rock of Death's Pass.

Recently completed- dear diary I feel the urge to strike out the words and look guiltily about me for any dwarves with grey in their braids, chin or head! In truth even I can see the roughness and speed with which it was made functional, for though the foundations have long been laid and the soaring arches and buttresses well-cured, the Two-Day War intervened before the water-course was more than half-complete. Returning to tools after was, to hear the rumors tell it, perhaps the least happy a dwarf has ever been to work with stone. To see the West Gate hanging open from where they labored was irksome enough to cause more than a few grumbles, but to know they were *needed* reconstructing defenses and unable to leave until the water reached the catchment pond? Such speed I have never seen before! In the four days between leaving and returning from Karag Ulric the whole of the remainder was done and not a dwarf stood atop it.

The naturalistic, almost romantic style suits it in my opinion- stone carved only where it presses against stone, water flowing over rough grain and small outcroppings, down a thousand tiny waterfalls rather than a smoothly sloped gutter. It feels more human, and for the number of times I hear umgi mutter under beards at it the dwarves think so too.

To my left is a small flagstone plaza with scattered tables and others dining under the sky, then the wall and back entrance to The Green Shoots (a clever bit of a pun a retired field warden had to explain to me- the obvious green shoots of a new field in spring, but also a warning to the enemies of the halflings when shoots is read as a verb).

Below me I know shot and powder flows north to Karagril when the waxing and waning of the orcish assaults heeds foreign rhythms.

What else I know but cannot see is the feverish efforts of the miners and scouts to appraise the tunnels below us, even now months on from the end of the real fighting. Such is the focus of Thane Dreng, who esteems me now highly enough that I am included in the meetings of the Thanes; it seems also the undumgi are now considered solid enough to be counted along the throngs in his planning.

The Western Gate and it's bastions are half-built, the work a stark contrast to the aqueduct's competition; even now I would not wish to challenge the entrance without a half-dozen cannon behind me. The focus of the masons and the rangers remain there, and on gaps that lie between the southern mountains- and here the grumbling holds an odd note, for as much as the works of their ancestors had been preserved by the egos of those occupiers who dreamt of holding the whole Karak, the truth is that they were designed in an age before gunpowder.

Fields of fire, enfilade and defilade- much have I learned working alongside Oswald these last few years. A good man, but proud of his contrivances in a way that I cannot quite understand. Perhaps had I been a knight nearer the seacoast such would not seem so strange...

Regardless, the work of laying out cannon port and powder magazines occupies those dawi not in the tunnels or the west gate. Much of the rest of the industry in the Karak goes short-staffed, though this I know from Francesco: he speaks much in the confidence of Oswald and myself, of how sore tested he finds himself. His instincts for records and bills from his prior life has kept him from drowning thus far, but dear diary I worry for him- what was ten thousand men has become near twenty thousands of people.

Have I not mentioned the growth? Dear diary, I skim back quickly and see only passing reference to my duties, and find my pen remiss.

It was the Two-Day War that changed everything.

Before, easy as it was to forget from close, we were living on the very ramparts of civilization, staring out over the cliff at entire mountains of foes close enough that a good shout might reach them. It was a place for warlike folk, with the few like Sarah unusual for lacking sword-callouses.

After? I am told that news of our victory washed over the border princedoms and lands beyond a like a spring flood, washing hundreds and thousands away from the lives they knew to settle in our basin. T'was within a bare week that the first serious caravan of settlers arrived, and though it was merely that slapdash rabble of humans who had been living in or near Barak Var taking advantage of the news that the dwarf hold with an entire human mountain had proven it could survive a full waaagh.

In truth these were the folk with whom the Karak was already near familiar- some merchants who regularly made the trip already and decided to base themselves where warehouses and living quarters were cheap, some elder and younger dependents of the undumgi who had refused to move closer least they be eaten by orcs, some adventurous types local to the areas that King Belegar had been searching for pirates, made curious but the new dwarf King. A surprising number of craftsmen from Ulrikadrin, drawn by the growing concentration of industry here and I think a subtle pressure from the more faithful in that town, who still clung to the idea of a settlement of woodcutters, hunters, and knights.

But that was months ago. Five days past I met at Karag Ulrik a caravan more typical of these weeks, though with an unusual passenger- fourteen wagons flying the flag of the EIC, loaded with wool and glass, festooned with travelers hitching rides. Some strapping young men, I will admit, but mostly women in colorful skirts and drab cloaks, some few with children. I spoke to them, as my pikes marched perfect posture in flanking array (to my dismay, suddenly patrols to escort eastbound caravan have become a fought over assignment, and my men have become *scrupulous* with their armor and appearance the night before meeting for the first time) and discovered that for all the many, many villages and towns they hauled from in Tilea or the Princedoms, there was a group of about twenty whose stories of home were quite similar.

"I'as lived by the grace of my mother in law un'er her staircase af'er my 'usband dinna come back. 'Erd bout a big whooping win by 'em dorfs an the invi'ing of us humans in 'cause we helped, yeah, but eh hadn't won proper yet 'cause I asked and there was still orcs inside it. But few years goes by an I'm thinkin' me in-laws be starting a forget I'za part o their family with my 'usband not ere to remind em, and then we get the news that this new king tosses all the gribblies out o'da hold in two days and kills a waaagh comin' to take it back to boot! So now I'm thinkin' a new 'usband 'ere might be just the thing, an a dorf 'old outta legend's bout as far from 'at drafty nook un'er the stairs as a girl like me can right get."

Dear diary forgive my transcription, but Gwen was quite charming and I still to do her justice here in your pages. For despite her rough-spun exterior I discovered that said mother in law was in truth the princess-dowager of one of the lands to the west southwest of Blackfire Pass, and though she had been born a shepherdess her husband had been the prince.

It t'wasn't until the second night (the first spent under stone at the Watchtower) when she joined me as I stood my vigil under the bright moon that I managed to piece together the hints her companions had dropped and confront her about it. She shrugged with an astounding degree of nonchalance and reached into her belt-pouch to produce a circlet of iron, with a double-bitted axehead upon the brow and an empty setting for a jewel within it. She told me that the jewel had been traded for passage for her and the two-dozen women who accompanied her when she slipped away, for there were many who lived frustrated lives in the dusty foothills who dreamed of more, and she had kept her friendships from her shepherdess days.

My Lady of still and silent waters, shelter those under my care, and let your blessing fall with liberal grace upon these new friends. I give you thanks for all you have given me, and I strive to seek your will and see it done.

I must say that amongst the books of romance passed to me by halfling matron's that deal with mine homeland, there are some storylines much repeated. One was my own- a woman disguised as a knight, who falls in love with... Sometimes another knight? Sometimes a woman- and though such urges would have much smoothed my deception I knew that I was faking such to my brother knights. Most often with her liege, for such pining is classic love's whimsy. Another story was that of the shepherdess who caught the eye of the duke, perhaps while he was in disguise, and after a whirlwind seduction was elevated far beyond her station.

Such tricks life plays on us, non?

Perhaps Ranald is to blame.

But for as much as I have lived a warped-mirror's version of a storybook romance, so too has Gwen. For unlike settings such as Carcassonne, elevation to a princess meant quite less in a minor land of harsh terrain. And yet, the jealous mother in law, the callous brothers, the swirl of status between her and the servant's (farmhands and milkmaids, really)... It was all echoed.

Oh! Hark, she comes in sight, walking up the irrigation channels towards where I sit. Sarah, my friend in the EIC, walks with her, for I introduced the two as I gave the new residents the tour of Karag Nar and recorded their choice of rooms. Normally another would do it, but I have taken to watching more closely, for it soothes my fears of losing touch with our glorious City of Sunrise, our Karag Nar, as it grows and changes so swiftly. Francesco has set aside an area as a sort of unmarried women's quarter, where the newcomers might get their feet underneath them- either before moving in with new spouses, or for a place of more security should they support themselves with their own work. I suspect that in some years it will also be a popular location for girls getting out from under their mothers...

But I must set you aside for a time now, dear diary, whilst I sup with new friends. I shall not forget my promise of recording the rest of the news, but for now, dear diary, wish us luck!
 
Last edited:
I mean, I'm not proposing "this is a giant problem we need to add to our plate." I'm proposing "something fucky is going on and has been for a long time, why don't we spend a half-AP to see if we can find out what?" Then if it's big and important, we'll know about it and be able to decide what is correct to do, whether that be "try to handle it ourselves" or, more likely, kick it over to someone whose area of responsibility it is more directly because we'll be busy saving the world with big rocks.

"We have to ignore it or we'll be adding to our to-do list forever" is a false dichotomy, if for no other reason than the simple fact that if something is in fact going on with Kurnous and Anath Raema and their crew, it's not going to not happen just because we aren't looking at it. The world keeps doing things in the background even if it's not "on screen"; other characters have agency in this quest and exercise it intelligently. I would much rather have an idea of what is in play rather than be blindsided in however many turns.
 
I'm sorry, but I firmly reject this. As a member and Lord Magister of the Grey Collage we explicitly have a mandate to seek out and remove anything that harms the unity and prosperity of the Empire, up to and including the Emperor himself. It doesn't matter if that threat is military, magical, financial, spiritual, political or any other kind of -al you can think off. The problem has ended up on our desk; either we pass it on to someone we trust or we handle it personally, but we can't ignore it and hope someone else deals with it, because we are the people who deal with stuff like this.

No. As a member of the Grey College our job is to investigate attempts at subversion using dark magic and only that, meaning Chaos Sorcerers and vampiric infiltration as well.

Other kinds of threats to the Empire are other people's jobs. Not ours. Political disunion, cult conflicts, mercantile disputes are all explicitly outside our scope, and the responsibility of other people.
 
Last edited:
No. As a member of the Grey College our job is to investigate Chaos Cult subversion and only Chaos Cult subversion, possibly extending to vampiric infiltration as well.

Other kinds of threats to the Empire are other people's jobs. Not ours.
...that's straightforwardly false within the context of the quest.
And Wilhelmine von Bucht, who shattered the House of Goellner when they thought their trade empire had made them too powerful to tax, who dismantled every Smuggler Guild from Middenheim to Fortenhaf, who concealed the Imperial Regalia and forced the just-deposed Dieter IV to retreat to Talabheim without performing one final theft. Who in the twilight years of a successful career settled down to serve her College as Bursar. Who is now sitting across from you and offering you a nice cup of tea.
Just an example off the top of my head because I went through this chapter recently in my proofreading. Where do you get the notion that the Greys are only the anti-Chaos and maybe anti-vampire folks? In the quest it's been very consistent that our mandate is much wider than that.
 
...that's straightforwardly false within the context of the quest.

Just an example off the top of my head because I went through this chapter recently in my proofreading. Where do you get the notion that the Greys are only the anti-Chaos and maybe anti-vampire folks? In the quest it's been very consistent that our mandate is much wider than that.

The fact that Grey Wizards don't stay in their lane doesn't mean it isn't their lane.
 
The fact that Grey Wizards don't stay in their lane doesn't mean it isn't their lane.
What is your source that that is their lane?

Realms of Sorcery says this, page 103:

But where the Hierophants are predominantly exorcists, seeking out and aiding only those who are possessed by daemons or the very darkest magic, the Shadowmancers serve as diplomats, spies, and even assassins, tasked with finding and eliminating the networks of illicit organisations that work away in the shadows undermining the acceptable civil, military, political, and religious structures of the Empire.
It's an explicit contrast with the Light Order who only really worry about Chaos and Dark magic, which would suggest that the Grey Order cares about other things.
 
@Alratan much as I wish the EIC would get eaten by ogres I have to agree with the other side on this, when dealing with the games of spies and secret police there is very little the other institutions of the Empire could do to complain about lanes. I mean that are the witch hunters going to do? Complain to the Emperor about a surfeit of help? They would have a hard time even proving with meddled at all and as long as we do not mess up spectacularly it would sound remarkably petty.
 
No. As a member of the Grey College our job is to investigate attempts at subversion using dark magic and only that, meaning Chaos Sorcerers and vampiric infiltration as well.

Other kinds of threats to the Empire are other people's jobs. Not ours. Political disunion, cult conflicts, mercantile disputes are all explicitly outside our scope, and the responsibility of other people.
I think that you are confusing a wizard dealing with chaotic or sorcerous corruption being their Prime concern with it being their Only concern.
 
Article:
Shadowmancers, like Hierophants, are tasked primarily with the persecution of the enemies within Imperial society and the protection of the ideals of the Empire. But where the Hierophants are predominantly exorcists, seeking out and aiding only those who are possessed by Daemons or the very darkest magic, the Shadowmancers serve as diplomats, spies, and even assassins, tasked with finding and eliminating the networks of illicit organisations that work away in the shadows undermining the acceptable civil, military, political, and religious structures of the Empire. In this work their spells of persuasion, distraction, concealment, and deception are of considerable worth.

Article:
Their goal was to oppose Chaos in all its forms, not to unduly influence the internal political struggles of the Empire.

The wiki article is confused and gives the order two (complimentary) goals. But not all illicit organizations are Chaos cults.

But I think the first one is more accurate in quest.
 
Article:
Shadowmancers, like Hierophants, are tasked primarily with the persecution of the enemies within Imperial society and the protection of the ideals of the Empire. But where the Hierophants are predominantly exorcists, seeking out and aiding only those who are possessed by Daemons or the very darkest magic, the Shadowmancers serve as diplomats, spies, and even assassins, tasked with finding and eliminating the networks of illicit organisations that work away in the shadows undermining the acceptable civil, military, political, and religious structures of the Empire. In this work their spells of persuasion, distraction, concealment, and deception are of considerable worth.

Article:
Their goal was to oppose Chaos in all its forms, not to unduly influence the internal political struggles of the Empire.

The wiki article is confused and gives the order two (complimentary) goals. But not all illicit organizations are Chaos cults.

But I think the first one is more accurate in quest.

From what I gather from other people's comments, the wiki is a shitshow, hard to use to prove a definite either way. The fact the wiki itself is confused is... fitting.
 
Last edited:
Those are both verbatim from Realms of Sorcery.

I'd say that opposing Chaos is the most important duty of everyone but that doesn't mean other things don't matter as well.
Also, the most likely way to find chaos activities is to look into other sorts of criminality.

True, the most dangerous Chaos cultists are those that keep their nose otherwise clean, but there's thankfully a lot fewer of those.
 
I mean its pretty obvious that there is something wonky with Anath Raema and Kurnous worship going around, probably encroachment from Athel Loren. I understand Pickle's desire to check it out. But OTOH, its just one more time in long litany of cases of the more extreme Elf cults making landfall in the Empire. I kinda feel its the one kind of threat that our homeland is equipped to deal with on its own.

That said, i would still probably vote for trying to get into it because its making me curious, i just severely doubt our only spy network of note is in any way equipped to sniff out this specific brand of cultism.
 
I'm pretty sure that we're never actually going to meet Teclis, just because it's one of those scenarios that could never measure up to our expectations.

Of course, that just means that we're going to end up chasing Teclis around the planet like an episode of Scooby Doo. He's going to be own town ahead of us, we're going to be one town ahead of him, he'll be meeting with the Grey Patriarch while we're giving a lecture two rooms over, forever.
Turns out the name Teclis is an old Ulthuan prank, and we get directed from mystic tower to mystic tower until eventually one of them sits us down and explains it.
 
Nice worldbuilding exposition as always, @Glau.

I found some typos, listed below:

It comforts my soul none the less, and the babble of the small fall of water from the recently completed aquaduct comforts the ear worn keen by the dust and rock of Death's Pass.
'Nonetheless' in the context of meaning 'however' is usually a single word.
'aquaduct' --> 'aqueduct'

In truth even I can see the roughness and speed with which it was made functional, for though the foundations have long been laid and the soaring arches and butresses well-cured,
'butresses' --> 'buttresses'

The naturalistic, almost romantic style suits it in my opinion- stone carved only where it presses against stone, water flowing over rough grain and small outctoppings, down a thousand tiny waterfalls rather than a smoothly sloped gutter.
'outctoppings' --> 'outcroppings'

Below me I know shot and powder flows north to Karagil when the waxing and waking of the orcish assaults heeds foreign rythms.
'Karagil' --> 'Karagril'
'Waking' is possibly valid, but I think you meant to use 'waning.'
'rythms' --> 'rhythms'

Perhaps had I been a knight nearer the seacoast such would not seen so strange...
'seen' --> 'seem'

Such is the focus of Thane Dreng, who esteems me now highly enough that I am included in the meetings of the Thanes,;
Extra comma.

Much of the rest of the industry in the Karak goes short-staffed, though this i know from Francesco:
'i' --> 'I'

Before, easy as it was too forget from close,
'too' --> 'to'

Five days past I met at Karag Ulrik a caravan more typical of these weeks, though with an unusual passanger-
'passanger' --> 'passenger'

It t'wasn't until the second night (the first spent under stone at the Watchtower) when she joined me as I stood my vigil under the bright moon that I managed to peice together the hints her companions had dropped and confront her about it.
'peice' --> 'piece'
 
I think it's the duty of quest GMs and fanfic writers to ignore lazy and stupid world building like that. Certainly every writer I've seen does so with regards to things like city sizes and population.

Unless you bring Tolkien back from the dead and convince him to chip in, I'm not going to rewrite the entire linguistic history of the setting. It's not just one example of a head-scratcher, it's baked into the entire thing. Reikspiel and Bretonnian are mutually intelligible, as are Estalian and Tilean, as are all the Elven dialects, despite all of the above having parted ways thousands of years ago. Khazalid hasn't budged a hair despite every Dwarfhold being essentially isolated from each other for millennia. Skeggi still speaks Norscan. Skinks have developed their own dialect of the spoken language of the Slann, and it's all mutually intelligible across two and a half continents. All Beastmen can understand each other. Most greenskins can understand each other, and when they aren't it's about subspecies, not geographic distance. I could go on and on. Completely rebuilding all of that is not inherently the 'duty of quest GMs and fanfic writers', it's a Herculean task.

Can we increase this to a full AP for a turn or two if we find a business opportunity the EIC could use to direct it there, or does it use up a social action where we go and tell Wilhelmina?

Not without severely disrupting the EIC and pissing off the other shareholders. Mathilde's either a major part of the decision-making apparatus or she's not, she can't just seize the controls whenever it takes her fancy.
 
I'm not asking you to go all Tolkien and invent your own languages. It's enough to say Reikspiel is equivalent to German, Bretonnian French, Tilean Italian, Estellian Spanish, Kislevarian Russian and so on.

But it's your quest, if you don't want to that's fine. I still think this is the best quest on SV and SB
 
Voting is open
Back
Top