Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
To be fair to Mathilde, we the questers have some unfair advantages in working this plan out, so it's not surprising she didn't think it was an "obvious" solution.

• We have a lot of everyday experience with electric circuits, and have thus internalized the logic of "shutting off the power" to a greater extent.
• We have OOC info on what the dwarves are doing with the Waystone energy that Mathilde doesn't, which makes us think of it in a different context.
• "Turn it off and on again" is a literal meme, and something that Mathilde wouldn't immediately think of for very obvious reasons.
 
Hm. Are Asarnil and Deathfang going to make an appearance on the "Members of the Karag Dum Expedition" section?

Or the Ice Crone Ljiljana?
 
if they have had a general purpose yank things into the Realm of Chaos spell, that they could use every few days, for the past 200 years why is most of kislev not there right now?
Because not all of Kislev is within spitting distance of a waystone channeling enough magic to reduce a small city to a crater?
 
We have a lot of everyday experience with electric circuits, and have thus internalized the logic of "shutting off the power" to a greater extent.
Honestly, that probably makes the most sense of all the reasons I've heard. It's just hard to remember sometimes that someone wouldn't look at a flow of power as something that could be affected, but rather as a basic, natural function of things that must be worked around. Even with the knowledge of blocking or unblocking Waystones she got from the lessons, it was more "don't fuck with them if possible, but if you have to here's how you fix a problem", and the ability to to make a clog rather than remove it was just doing the opposite. So actually using them as a tactical option outside the typical "let's power a big ritual" bad guys sometimes use wouldn't ever be considered. Which actually honestly makes me think we should totally write a paper or something on how even magic can be subject to deprivation of resources if this works. If people knew how to shut off rituals without having to personally destroy it, a lot of baddies would have a harder time doing stuff.

Anyways, my concern was more over how Boney missed the solution, not so much Mathilde, but that's been answered as well.
 
I love how the plan is basically the magical equivalent of pulling the plug from a giant robot you often see in cartoons
 
I don't think they have that, but the plan to fortify the place where gates used to be has us standing for days in the place that was yanked already not long ago and in spitting distance of the place that is in realms of chaos right now which I'd say increases the risk just a tad.
considering that the road and watchtowers are currently not in the Realm of Chaos, while the rest of Vlag is, I think its safe to assume that the road and watchtowers are no longer under the effect letting Vlag toggle back and forth.
 
Dwarven belief is that if someone isn't given the proper rites, they'll be reborn at some point in the future as another Dwarf.
That's a dark glimpse of the dwarfs. Being reborn is seen as a failure/ the future is so doomed that slayers actively work to avoid being reborn? The level of cynicism behind that is pretty heart breaking.

@Omegahugger

Suddenly I'm not convinced on reanimating dawi.
 
[X] Waystone Clog

We are a good friend of Ranald, and if there's one thing we're good at, it's stealing shit!

That's a nice Karak you have there Tempter, it'd be a shame if I unplugged your power strip

WAHAHAHAHA VICTORY FOR RANALD! PRAISE THE BIG STEAL
 
Wait. Wait wait wait. I just realized something. We wandered in and poked about curiously, wondering just what Chaos we're doing over here. In response we got An annoyed brush off, like they were trying to brush us away and shoo us off. Now we're going to go duck behind their desk and muck around with their wiring system until we pull out the power strip.

That? That right there is quintessential cat behavior guys. Like, seriously. This is just full Meowthilde mode.
 
I love that what may be one of our greatest feats, rescuing a Dwarf Hold that's been trapped in hell for NaN years, boils down to Mathilde doing plumbing. Magical plumbing but ultimately still plumbing.
 
That's a dark glimpse of the dwarfs. Being reborn is seen as a failure/ the future is so doomed that slayers actively work to avoid being reborn? The level of cynicism behind that is pretty heart breaking.

@Omegahugger

Suddenly I'm not convinced on reanimating dawi.
It's been explicitly stated that after the arrival of chaos, the world itself has changed to become hostile to dwarves: "Dwarves are as stone and the winds of magic strip away the metaphorical aspects of that statement, and turns an unprotected dwarf literally into stone;" to paraphrase.

Being reborn is not seen as any sort of failure, it is seen as unnecessary (and usually avoidable) suffering - it is better to exist in Gazu's realm after death than to return to a world that is inimical to your very existence, or at least your life.

Where new-born dwarf souls come from is unclear, (the impression I have is that the number of births > number of deaths-without-rites) but failure and/or doomedness is a not framework that matches how BoneyM has described dwarven perspective on this.
 
Last edited:
I'm really glad that we are using the Protector, as otherwise to the dwarven mindset it might look like
"My job here is done."
"but you didn't do anything."
"You want me to put it back into the Aethyr again? Because I will.
You're new here, so I'll give you an opportunity to make good before things get ugly, but the traditional wage for a job done by Mathildes is paid in head pats.
Now, are you going to make good, or am I getting the grudge book out?"
 
@BoneyM curious about the validity for the idea of barricading the once entrance to the Karak Vlag. Could the dwarves mine stone and axe tree's and try to barricade the sport where the entrance once stood?

If not could we just bomb the enterence? sort of imagining it like this in the picture if i get this thing to work.

Would such suggestions be viable? Could we convince the dwarves to barricade the Karak?
 
Huh, is that why dwarven population growth is so fucked? Everytime one dies and heads to the Underearth there is one less max dwarf soul that can exist on the earth?
I theorise that is a contributing factor, yes. The only supply of Dawi souls and thus births is whatever natural process produces new ones, while all the potential rebirths are deliberately redirected to Gazuls realm.
 
Last edited:
I theorise that is a contributing factor, yes. The only supply of Dawi souls and thus births is whatever natural process produces new ones them, while all the potential rebirths are deliberately redirected to Gazuls realm.
It's also a potential cause why general standards (especially runesmithing) have fallen: New souls just don't have prior experience, and might lack metaphorical weight.
 
It's possible they're in "the warp", but if they were in the True Warp they wouldn't be location bound in realspace. That's the problem with the wastes and Chaos incursions after all. Can't just pop into reality willy nilly. Need to lock down a connection of "Warp" and "realspace". This might be shunted into one of those weird non-warp realms like the shadow realm.

so you end up with a Karak that was under siege, that is full of daemons who are immortal inside the magic realm, but are disconnected from The True Warp.

if they killed all locals they might be squatters, the rats or grobi as stated. Cut off, they wish for prey and take the attack of opportunity on Mathilde and the Gang because hungry/horny. Then it's a massive dragon and they pull out unsatisfied.

if they are still sieging . . . . let me pitch a scenario to you
___________________________________________

There is a Champion looking to ascend to be a Greater Daemon of the Betrayer during The Great War. Taking on the task of claiming an entire dwarven hold personally. The Champion is able to siphon off many followers and lesser daemons from the main host, and even slides perfectly into the dwarven waystone network to shunt the entire place into the warp through the same systems that power their runes.

This Betrayal is met with a betrayal in kind when the war is turned for Order. The warp that the karak has been shunted into is not The Warp, and so The Tempter gleefully watches their proud little worm writhe in a stew of their own creation. Using the rune magic as the means to shunt the Karak to another place was great, except it left the runes on. With no reinforcements, only the lesser daemons able to be dominated by the Champion can be used indefinitely. A battle of infinite suffering between two forces. A faltered siege led by an arrogant Champion that pulled too many away from the Everchosen's forces, whittled down slowly till only the daemons are left alive. A doomed hold, that will never be relieved as "small" numbers of lesser daemons wear it down bit by bit. A crucible-battery of suffering all made as a divine empowerment for Chaos.

In the event that the Champion does eventually win, great! They eat the divine power. They get to ascend. The Karak falls, and centuries of some of the most brutal fighting are under their belt (as well as a good lesson to not betray the Betrayer nor their Everchosen.) In the event that the Karak wins. HAHAHAHA! They can't! They are stuck in a nonsense pocket realm with an intense glamor that Teclis couldn't pierce (in the aftermath of The War) so they will literally never be saved. No Elf would take the time to check, the Dwarves hate and distrust magic, and the Humans have absolutely no reason to go all the way to that gods forsaken place.

It's the Perfect Plan(tm). Absolutely nobody could stumble into it, shift a few elements, and steal all of that delicious suffering and divine power away on a practically accidental coincidence of factors. The amount of luck involved to make that heist happen is simply inconceivable.

heh
 
considering that the road and watchtowers are currently not in the Realm of Chaos, while the rest of Vlag is, I think its safe to assume that the road and watchtowers are no longer under the effect letting Vlag toggle back and forth.
Or whoever was in charge rushed it in a panic. Give them time to think and they might not be in a panic anymore and be able to take their time on it. Even it being more likely than not that it's no longer the case would not in this instance be "safe."
 
The theory of reincarnation being equal to the birthrate can't be correct.

The golden age and the silver age happened after the world became hostile, which puts the rites of gaz's origin at the time of the fall of the gates /time of the Ancestors.
Both of them happened after a crisis (great incursion/ time of woes), but that would imply that the two periods of prosperity (and in the case of the golden age, expansion) Karaz Ankor experienced occurred with a negative population growth.
That makes no logistical sense.
The dwarf population growth needs no further maluses: they already have an unfavorable gender distribution in a hostile world.
Adding more depression is just unnecessarily grimdark.
 
Back
Top