Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Right so if we want a Favor 15-20 weapon we need to lure out Kragg or travel down of Karak Azul and talk with Thorek. I'll keep that in mind.
 
I've said that 10 favours is the conventional maximum, and higher amounts are only possible with access to the likes of Kragg and Thorek. I've said that 25 is right on the very edge of what is possible, and I've said a number of times as people name ridiculous amounts of favours that even Dwarven craftsmanship has a limit. I don't think this is a matter of misapplied scaling, I think this is just an inherent part of what a lot of Questers like, which is the biggest shiniest shineys that ever shined, and there'll always be a faction for "there is a point where we needed to stop and we have clearly passed it but let's keep going and see what happens".

That said, the previous rules of thumb still apply, which is 10 points to the favour and have at the Dwarf Army Book, and very approximately one favour per casting value for battle magic.
The most dangerous thing about OP items is that we'll be driven to USE them. And one day, those Dice are gonna ditch us.

How many time our ass have been save because of the Seed and the Rune? A bit to many.
She got favors from dwarves, a lot of favor. But we still have to spend it wisely. Otherwise she'll ends up with too powerfull a weapon, she'll fight directly.
And where's the fun in that

I find it more amusing on how she makes 'smart' kill, Hitman/assasin creed style, instead of a conventional sword+10 to the gut approach.
 
[X] Write a series of papers on the magical phenomena you witnessed. Or better yet, get your Journeymanlings to do the actual writing.
This suggests a future of investigation and study at Karak Eight Peaks, and perhaps helping Johann poke at Skaven technology.

[X] King Belegar is allowing you to use the King's Armoury. Recover your extant study materials from Stirland and tuck them away safely in there.
This suggests a future catching up on your pre-existing study topics.


[X] This is Magister Weber's money. Make no attempt to push the funds through any of the available loopholes and spend it all in plain sight of the College. You would be beholden to spend it on ways at least nominally good for the Empire, and soon.

Why am I going with this one? Well, I had a thought: maybe if we spend a lot of money on the Colleges, they will realize that there is a lot of money to be made here.

In short, it can act as a form of advertising.

They will see that this is a very profitable for the Empire, and the Colleges, endeavor to engage in, and so they will send more support. And will throw some political weight towards that.

... Also, it avoids us having to wonder if we skirted the edges of the rules or did something risky in regards to the money. Avoids us with the issue of 'as soon as we got our hands on tons of money, we spent it all on ourselves.' But mostly, yeah, I really really want to know: can we use that money as a lure for the Colleges and the Empire?
 
personally, i dont see a need to spend more than 20 favor on a single item.

our belt is amazing and it costed 15 favor.
I agree. While I understand the mentality and agree that generally two 7-point items are going to be strictly inferior to a 15-point one making the latter the rational choice, there is a point where artifacts start stretching my sense of disbelief and look way too overpowered, and 15 is about the cutoff point for me.
 
I really want to see what 10 favour Tower and 10 favour toolset would do.


But hm, maybe instead we should take time to learn something like proper shooting from dwarfs?
Or better yet, explosives! Seeing as we are not Bright Wizard, knowing basics about blowing things up can be of value.
 
Ten and ten for a tower and sword definitely sounds acceptable for me. My preference would be for fifteen and ten and then spending the remaining thirteen on learning things that need learning or for banking for later, but I definitely understand where folks are coming from there.
 
@killfr3nzy
Yeah, I reckon you've sold me on it.
It's a place of power to us so let's keep it.
 
Last edited:
Personally I think we should go ham on our tower simply because that'll help everyone's peace of mind. "A runelord made this tower safe for magic things" is not just nice for us to know, it also makes the dwarves and men who have to live in the same mountain as our experiments happy.

It'll also help against outside dangers, like the Skaven assassins we want kept away from us and our stuff.

Also, on weapon requests, any sneaky quality we want should be describes as it relates "ranger-like activities", and most certainly never the word "assassin".
 
Last edited:
Now instead of sleeping, review!
The sheer power of concentrated Runecraft in the hands of Clan Angrund, the spectacular display of the Anvil of Doom, the induced inversion of a Waaagh field. All sights unknown, as far as you are aware, to the Colleges of Magic. It feels wrong to let this opportunity slip away, and yet in such a pivotal moment in history there are more opportunities than any one person can grab, so the best you can do is have your flock of Journeymanlings jot down their observations so that they will still be available when you have time to fully translate them into something more suited to academia. With Esbern and Seija looking like they would soon depart, it could be that there would never be an opportunity to get this many perspectives on foreign magic.
I wonder how often it is that you have wizards from four different orders observe two other races using battlemagic while in a position to actually observe the battle rather than frantically try to survive it.
With that task finished, you travel with the three Knightly Orders and the mass of now-united Ulricans as they march out the East Gate, up Death Pass and through the Underway to the once-pristine valley that was soon to be colonized, the Demigryph Knights having agreed to help the Winter Wolves range out from what is to be their new home to ensure a lack of immediate threats and carefully gauge the inevitable less immediate threats. You decide to lend your own horse to this task.
Jolly Cooperation!
Also lionbirds would go a long long way to getting the local wildlife and lingering orcs...pruned.

Thunder Mountain lies nearby, the mighty volcano that the Anvils of Doom were once forged in, and the possibility of Dragon Ogres atop it concerns you greatly. The only thing that keeps the terrible beasts in check is their reliance on revitalizing lightning, and if the constant storm of ash and volcanic gases serves to bypass this weakness, the colony might be doomed before it even begins.

As it turns out, the cure may be worse than the disease. Your careful scouting reveals to you many Dragon Ogres living at the rim of the volcano, but each is sickly and listless. Their inhuman constitutions may allow them to survive the horrific environment, but they certainly aren't thriving, and it seems the volcanic lightning lacks at least some of what makes the power of storms so revitalizing to them. Though they remain quite capable of picking off individual greenskins to feed upon, you fancy the chances of the Winter Wolves against this enemy, and are able to turn away from them with a clean conscience.
Huh...interesting. If volcanic lightning isn't working for them but natural lightning does, the Dragon Ogres feed on Azyr. The Aqshy laden lightning from the volcano, and the general sulfurous environment is doing a number on their health.

...I wonder if the Ambers might be interested in studying magical creatures like that.
Turning your attention west, you range across quite a lot of empty land. According to conventional maps this is the Border Princes, but it is the southernmost part of it, sandwiched between Iron Rock and the Badlands. Those foolhardy enough to settle between the Howling River and the Blood River discover even poorer soil and drier weather than the rest of the region, and soon come to the attention of the Ironclaw Orcs. It doesn't take long to realize why most of the inhabitants of the Border Princes remain north of the Black Gulf. With the Blood River to act as a barrier and land that seems better worth the effort, you think that the Ulricans will have much better chances.
And a bit of realization with Panoramia's insights: the Border Princes are extra fucked up because agriculture requires that you either rejuvenate the soil, hold the temporarily unprofitable land long enough for it to recover naturally over decades, apply magic(divine or arcane) to the problem, seize them from a gribbly, seize them from forests(and the beastmen/fey in them) or seize them from orc occupants.

Because the orcs are basically migratory and we know their fungus basically wipes the local area dry to spawn and feed more orcs, so any areas which don't already have an orc tribe in there is because they won't support an orc tribe and are basically laying fallow until they do again.
You return to the valley, where already trees have begun to fall as the Ulricans turn their axes to timber instead of greenskin. The Barak Varr trades delivering supplies to Karak Eight Peaks have been talking to the Ulricans, and before you leave the valley the first Dwarf Monitor has docked at what's being called Ulrikadrin, accepting silver and disgorging tools and supplies. For now, the Winter Wolves will be living in tents, and as soon as the tools are put to use they'll be living in wooden bunkhouses, but as soon as the Knights make up their mind on some of the details, the residents of Karak Eight Peaks will be travelling here to carve paths and a suitable Chapter House into one of the peaks overlooking the valley.
Ulric would probably approve of this lifestyle. He likes the whole frontiersman thing, though going by his creed they usually start facing identity crisis once they actually urbanize and become agrarian to transition to Taal and Rhya.

Can't be helped. Warrior gods are good for eking out a living on harsh land, but once you make it NICE they slowly marginalize themselves.
But theres always more orc and forest to fight. A question for another thousand years down the road.
Back at Karak Eight Peaks, Karag Nar is the sight of no small amount of grumbling and you wade in before it gets much worse. Though the men are currently sleeping on bedrolls in communal halls in the Karag, what their future situation will look like is still undecided, and in between making final preparations to leave Codrin is keeping the peace but making no long-term decisions for his soon-to-be former charges. You're not sure if some new leader would have emerged if things went on much longer, but you'd much rather not risk the future of Death Pass on a maybe, so you step in.
That sounds like if we left it alone it'd have PROBABLY turned into some kind of wild west frontier town pretty quick.
Everyone, it seems, wants to stake a claim on a set of quarters adjoining the central staircase, and with no other landmarks in the entire mountain you can see why. You refresh your own scouting memories with some poking around, and in a temporary office you work on a MAP of the main branches of the Karag. You map out a market for visiting merchants, a dining hall for group meals, and an armoury for the tools of the Undumgi's trade, and put word out for anyone who wishes to stick around without combat in their future, and there's a handful - young mercenaries think they'll be happy to fight their entire lives, but old ones start to dream of a tavern or a grocer or some other peaceful retirement, and you carefully distribute some of the larger rooms to them. Some are of a religious bent, and you approve shrines to Shallya, Ulric, Myrmidia, Ursun, and the Lady. You also receive a few unexpected requests, and after a word to an equally bemused King Belegar, you plot out the future locations of shrines to Grimnir and Valaya.
Brief interesting thought: I wonder if it'd be worth it to create an enchanted MAP of Karag Nar and place it somewhere nice and visible. Shouldn't be too hard I think.

You can see all the stuff Mathilde learned from her council experience. She might not be the best steward, but she's seen them at work, and knows what needs to be taken care of.
The dining hall is an especially nice touch for forging bonds within the community.

Also hmmm:
-Shallya - Theres probably a bunch of adventurers who picked up basic surgery and herblore out of necessity, and with this they can retire from war. The Shallyan nurses here are going to be really big beefy orderlies though.
-Ulric - Naturally, not sure how well his shrines fit inside a massive cave complex but hey, they make it work for Middenheim.
-Myrmidia - Some adventurer did their stint in Tilea huh? These guys would be useful in planning the regional strategy. Makes good Martial Advisor material.
-Ursun - How are his dudes taking to living in a very very nice cave?
-The Lady - Man, these adventurers come from many places. I didn't know anyone but Bretonnian nobility worshipped her, did we have some stray knights in the lot? Still, technically nothing wrong with a credo of purity, nobility and courage. Might not be bad law enforcement hereabouts.
-Grimnir - This is VERY weird...but if anyone could understand the mentality of a Slayer adventurers might. Facing certain death time after time could change a guy.
-Valaya - They're living in a dwarfhold, so its only right to pay respects to her. Being a god of brewing doesn't hurt, after months of living on dwarf alcohol...
With landmarks more plentiful and more scattered, instead of fighting over the most central positions the Undumgi start making decisions based on their preferences. Some want a nearby tavern, some want a favoured shrine close by, some want to be a good distance from the shopping and the prayer. Before long everyone has a room that you've had the few literate Undumgi write the names of their owners onto in charcoal, and you have full blueprints tucked away in case anyone gets cheeky and tries to replace a name with their own.
Manipulation at its best.
People are kind of like Ulgu.
Try to force them to move and its like catching fog.

Put the right lures and they'd move themselves!
Soon, wood will flow from Ulrikadrin and supplies from Barak Varr will include trade goods, and people will be able to start making proper homes for themselves. Long term, you expect companionship to be a concern, but word of almost six thousand newly enriched, well-employed and very eligible bachelors will soon reach Barak Varr and start radiating through the Border Princes and heading towards Black Fire Pass, and with a little luck the problem will solve itself.
So...theres going to be armies of thirsty maids inbound.
Traditionally settling armies would take wives amongst the locals but there aren't any humans hereabouts, or from the camp followers, but we've sort of outpaced the whole thing too fast.

The supply is likely to exceed demand in a few months I expect. Then we're going to need to import bachelors!
[Total payment: 54.]
[How did Mathilde's share do?: 37.]

Speaking of payment, the first round of it has gone out. Belegar had expected to pay in ingots, but at you presenting the paperwork of your one-night gambling hall, he had grumbled in an extremely unconvincing way and then hurried enthusiastically off to rummage through the carefully packed heirlooms that had been passed down through generations of exile. With the careful oversight of suitably skilled Longbeards, for the first time in three thousand years a coin is struck bearing the Eight Peaks you had all fought for. Each of the ingots would make 60 silver coins, each similar in weight to the silver shilling of the Empire but a great deal purer in content, and 20 silver shillings were worth a gold crown. The final division of the ancient stockpile of silver, minus the amount Belegar saw fit to keep for his Kingdom, saw each share worth fourteen ingots. Any man foolish enough to trust the sums of an Empire moneychanger would receive 42 gold crowns for them, whereas their true value would be closer to 55. The striking out of money owed to and from the dead saw your own 'share' fall by about a quarter, three thousand, six hundred and seventy had been set aside in the safety of the King's Armoury for you to decide the fate of. The equivalent of fourteen thousand gold crowns, give or take. You try not to think about the Oath of Poverty you were supposed to be following, and start trying to make plans for the money. You've some available loopholes, but that does mean you'd have to predestine at least three quarters of it towards a single area.
Man, this is an insane sum even if we rolled lower here. It seems that Mathilde might not be facing a big headache from adventurers realizing a lot of people lost their shares...because most of those who lost their shares are too dead to protest.

And I see Belegar is pretty cunning here. One of the most important tasks for a new king is minting their currency. It gives visibility, everyone would be looking at the new coin(first to make sure its authentic, second to find out what place is minting out high purity silver coins), which means the traders would scent profit and they'd bring profit.

Stewardship King!
[ ] Karag Nar penthouse
The first possibility that leaps to mind is the uppermost dwelling of Karag Nar, with a beautiful 360-degree view and a commanding position. The Black Orc Warboss' reasons for taking it for his own are obvious, and though it will take some time and effort to clear out the possessions that hadn't been safely stowed in the King's Armoury, it is bursting with potential and would allow you to keep a careful eye on the Undumgi and Death Pass.
I imagine the rumors are probably passing around that we knew what Panoramia was doing(I doubt the halflings didn't eavesdrop) despite being not on the same battlefield at all.
If Mathilde takes this spot, she's probably going to be setting up a bunch of curtains, dividers and probably mirrors to manage the light...and probably randomly checking on stuff below with Zoom And Enhance to maintain the image.

...it also helps that the wide open spaces means that mishaps can vent into the air where nobody's near to be bothered.

[ ] Citadel Tower
Third, the Citadel is being repaired of the damage that Kragg and cannon dealt to it, as well as three thousand years of neglect, and though the two towers were once a key part of its defensibility, with the only enemy approach being within the caldera that height advantage should no longer be needed. It makes for a much more traditional Wizard's Tower than one in a mountain peak, and though it's currently part of the defensive line against the untaken parts of the Karak, that also means that there'll always be plenty of protectors on hand, and perhaps you'd like to be able to help repulse any attackers.

A good place for a martial bastion, but a dangerous one. You probably don't want your wizard lab to be directly over where they're fighting Skaven in the tunnels.
Or for the matter, in a building which "reduce it to rubble with cannon" was an option.

[ ] Karag Nar temple
Your previous 'tower' was nothing of the sort, and perhaps you wish to continue that trend. If so, the site of you and Ranald triumphing over Gork and Mork would certainly be equally auspicious. It's a convenient distance from the population centers of the Karag and has a nearby side-entrance you could properly conceal and keep for your own use. (note: if you don't choose this as a tower, you can still use it in the future for a shrine or some other purpose. Nobody but you, Belegar, and Kragg know its significance, and everyone else just sees it as a former greenskin temple an inconvenient distance from the rest of the Karag.)

Good holy site, but a little cramped, a little lacking in exposure to Ulgu and...well really when you think of it like that its kind of like the old place in Wurtbad.
[ ] The Grand Abyss
If you value secrecy over all else, you could go just as far down as you can up. Deep below Karag Lhune lies the Lhune Deeps, and below that is the Grand Abyss. The Dwarves never were able to plumb the extent of its depths, and that is somewhat concerning, but it would certainly be impressive to have a tower built atop a bottomless pit.
And this is dramatic as all hell, but lets not tempt the gribblies.
And the Skaven.
And the Skaven gribblies.

[ ] Eastern Valley tower
Though it's soon to be filled with Halfling fields and cottages, they'd be happy for you to become their neighbour, and if you want to start from scratch you certainly have enough wealth and favours accumulated to build a tower of your own.
Not sure if we want to conduct magical experiments near farmland.
Its a cheery place though.

Once chosen, there'll be a great deal of paperwork to fill out. Those few manlings allowed to live in Dwarfholds are typically given 'only' a lifetime lease, and for you to have an actual permanent claim to what you've decided upon takes a lot of carefully-worded documents that basically say 'no really, we mean it, forever'.
Karag Nar would be interesting in all kinds of precedents wouldn't it?

King Belegar stuck around long enough to greet King Kazador and the Throng of Karak Azul, and was introduced with the subtlety of a thrown brick to King Kazador's daughter, Princess Kazrina. There's some grumbling that they've missed the actual establishment of the Karak, but are heartened that there's still six peaks left untaken and Ulthar steps in to pass on everything the Expedition knows of the other concentrations of greenskins and Skaven. A slightly smaller group splits off from the Throng, as for the first time in a dozen Dwarven generations the rest of the world is accessible to Karak Azul without incredible danger to life and limb, and they're not letting the chance pass
Kazador: "Oh no, the Umgi took the glory!"
Belegar: "Theres more goblins and skaven over there, don't you sweat it"

Once again, Belegar has made it such that their self interest would encourage them to further HIS self interest.

A third group is happily accepted into Karag Lhune - those of the lesser Clans of Karak Eight Peaks, who for three thousand years have longed for a return to the home of their ancestors rather than putting down roots where they were. In the coming weeks, others will join them from further holds, as many Dwarves have lived and died in exile rather than letting themselves find new homes among other holds. Both tragic and typically Dwarvish.
They're finally home~
Kragg has decided to stay just a little longer in Karak Eight Peaks, which is absolutely nothing to do with the arrival of Thorek Ironbrow, the closest thing to an equal Kragg has. The two very loudly criticize every detail of each other's work in terminology too arcane for you to begin to understand, and you're not entirely sure if this is a feud or a friendship, but either way Kragg seems to be enjoying himself, and he's finally surrendered his iron grip on the Gyrobomber that was to be his Anvil of Doom's escape route if everything went wrong. Without the incredibly dense weight of gromril weighing it down, it's more than capable of taking passengers, and with representatives from Karak Izor, Karak Norn, and Karak Hirn, you set off.
Just...take it for a moment. Kragg has decided to stick around. He thinks this place is worth his time.
I really want to save up some favors for some directed tutoring from him at some point. The tricky part is finding out what is worth his time, and learning all the basics first so he can teach mastery.

Also that sounds like two tsunderes at work.
You had thought your Shadowsteed a miracle of transportation, but even though the gyrobomber is built for cargo rather than speed, it must be covering ground at least twice as fast as you could, as well as easily capable of flying over terrain you'd have to ride around. It doesn't help that the 'passenger rack', though sturdy enough, offers little more protection from the elements than the back of a wagon, and does nothing to block out the noise of Dwarven machines. The pilot flies low to prevent the ambient air from freezing his passengers, so the view is as breathtakingly beautiful as it is terrifying, even though you're flying over the thoroughly unimpressive terrain of the Border Princes.
It is in this moment that Mathilde resolved to figure out how to fly.
As it begins to pall, the terrain changes to the endless green of the Forest of Gloom, and you keep your eyes peeled, knowing the next destination would be Karaz-a-Karak.

You had braced for it, and still you find yourself stunned.

You had seen drawings, and heard the boasts of Dwarves, but nothing prepared you for the reality. The Gates of Karaz-a-Karak stand four hundred feet tall, unadorned save for the Rune of Valaya similar to the one on your Belt. Once, according to history so far back as to be legend, the Gates stood open to welcome all to the capital of the Karaz Ankor, but when the earth shook and the Underway was shattered and greenskins and Skaven poured in, they were closed, and now only open when the Dwarves march to war.
Yet another tragedy.
The symbol of confidence, power and friendship...now only opens for war and death alone.

Visitors, you've heard, can enter through a smaller door that the Gatekeeper can open in the face of the gate, and the tallest visitors have found themselves having to crawl.
And having been through Lhune and Nar, we know dwarfs do build doorways which humans can pass through with minor difficulty. This is no accident or design flaw. They WANT human visitors to bow, or crawl.

Subtle symbolism?
A Gatekeeper, runic hammer and all, waits at this miniature gate, and it is he that finally asks who has come and what their business is.

"King Belegar of Karak Eight Peaks, here to see the High King," is the ritual answer. That is how King Belegar would have always introduced himself, and how each of his ancestors would have, so the news he brings remains uncommunicated, and though curiousity burns on the Gatekeeper's face he will not go against tradition.
So...how many unlanded dwarf Kings are out there anyways?
How many gave up on their title?
Clearly news would have to have been sent ahead, though you don't see the precise mechanism; you wonder if it is due to some clever invention of the Guild of Engineers or an ancient mechanism the Dwarves have always known.
My money's on speaking tubes. Its a well known and simple technology, if a little expensive without cheap metalworking to install on a large scale.
The Great Hall itself you had heard tales of, of it's massive size and towering height, and sure enough you're able to see for yourself that an entire human town could fit comfortably within it. But despite its size the Great Hall does not hold the population of a small human town, or anywhere close to it. Even though every major Hold and Clan, and every minor Hold and Clan with ambitions to become Major, each has a representative in the Great Hall during its hours of operation, the crowd would be a poor gathering for the Marktag of a medium-sized village. It is a walk of considerable distance before you approach the nearest member of the small, sad gathering of the remnants of the Karaz Ankor, and the constant murmur of discussion echoes through the emptiness.

No wonder they despair. The traditions they would never abandon are a constant reminder of how great they once were.
The design sounds like its intended to allow thousands of representatives to talk, or even yell at each other without making the chamber an unbearable, endless racket?
The crowd falls silent and parts as King Belegar approaches, and recognition is on every face; each then scans those following him, and most then school their expression into stony impassiveness, but you catch despair on some before they manage. It takes you a second to realize what they're seeing - they're seeing what they expected to see. The leader of the Expedition has returned, and without Kragg. There surely will have been enough vengeance to strike off a debt or two, but then Kragg's loss will be written in in their place, and the Karaz Ankor would have receded a little more.
I can't believe Belegar or Kragg could have missed what kind of impression that this entrance would give. They planned this well ahead of time. Its a political statement.

You see only a single exception: the representative wearing the stylized sea-gate Rune of Barak Varr, whose eyes are locked on the silver crown atop King Belegar's head, two sapphires twinkling in the torchlight.
You could see the dollar signs pop in his eyes.
The others in King Belegar's party break off to meet their counterparts, and a murmur of conversation begins to break the mournful silence as Belegar climbs the stone steps at the head of the hall. Atop them sits the Throne of Power, the one place the High King is permitted by tradition to sit. It is said to bear the Rune of Eternity, the sole work of the Ancestor-God Grungni that he was ever satisfied with. You cannot see it for yourself, because it currently also bears the High King, Thorgrim Grudgebearer, who stares impassively down at the approaching King.

"What news of the Everlasting Realm?" The High King asks, and you're glad you've been picking up Khazalid because of course tradition would trump politeness.

"The Queen of the Silver Depths is once more the home of Clan Angrund."

The hold falls silent once more, the whisper from Dwarf to Dwarf rendered unnecessary by the simple proclomation. To you King Belegar's words were a puzzle until you remembered the ceremonial name of Karak Eight Peaks, but to the Dwarves behind you the words of King Belegar hung in the air and shattered what the Dwarves thought they knew about the world they live in.
Minds blown.
That said, I *think* Belegar might have said the same for his OTL achievements? If with a rather different mood.
A lesser Dwarf might have asked King Belegar to repeat himself, but instead the High King's eyes flicked to you, and you saw his curiousity, and then to the others that had come and noted who they were standing next to. The Younger Holds, who the High King had been told had contributed significantly to the Expedition, and in response the High King had not sent his own forces, but something possibly more precious and definitely harder to replace: Kragg the Grim, and his Anvil. So the High King simply gave a nod, granting King Belegar permission to continue.

"Crescent Mountain, Sunrise Mountain, and the Citadel have been taken. The Hall of Oaths and the King's Armoury survived. Death Pass is open."
Victories.
Another big statement of the past glories reclaimed. Though the desecrated temples have been quietly left out?
"The cost?" asks the High King, his eyes flicking to the crowd again.

"There are still some that may or may not survive their wounds, but of the fifty thousand Dwarves that marched, the final tally will be about nine thousand Dwarves dead, seventeen hundred of them Slayers. Additionally, of forty thousand humans, three thousand died for the Queen of the Silver Depths." King Belegar sees the eye-flick again, and answers it. "Runelord Kragg has remained to study the hammer-runes found in the King's Armoury, and further contribute to the rest of the retaking."
Another subtle political statement. What they'd be hearing is:
-The humans nearly matched the dwarf contingent in number.
-The humans somehow lost less, but no mention was made of cowardice, so reading between the lines they'd conclude that certain operations could only be done by and for dwarfs.
-No irreplaceable assets were lost.
-No new Grudges will need to be borne.
"And of Vengeance?"

"The Crooked Moon and the Broken Toof were shattered. If they have no other branches, they are destroyed."

"Our Rangers will watch for them." The Throne of Power features a lecturn to hold a single book of overwhelming significance: The Dammaz Kron. The High King lifts the book from where it rested alongside his throne, and runs a finger along the pages before opening it about a third of the way along its pages, and needs only leaf a few more to reach where he was looking for. "There are many Grudges from that time that cannot be clearly attributed," he says musingly. "And much of what happened are the acts of Skaven. But you have accounted for many an Old and heavy Grudge. The Elders wise in Grudgelore will measure your Vengeance against the Grudges and determine what will be struck out."
@BoneyM I presume the matter of the Black Orcs were already sent ahead of this?
If its not spoilery I'm curious how they took it.
The Book of Grudges, as all who know even a little of the Dwarves know, is the single tome containing every wrong the Dwarven Empire has yet to avenge. What even a little knowledge of their history would indicate is that no one tome could contain those Grudges with enough detail for those born long after those acts to avenge them. King Belegar was told to follow the High King, who told you to follow him, and the two of you walk out of the Hall and into a room that could be described as large were it not for the one you just left. Row after innumerable row of bookshelves of the Archives of the Karaz Ankor bridge the terse inventory of the Dammaz Kron with the exhaustive detail that would allow the Dwarves to know that vengeance has been done, and the room is a hive of busy activity, as a dozen venerable Longbeards each act as the center of their own swarms of younger disciples. As the High King orders the retrieval of the books on the Siege and Fall of Karak Eight Peaks, your eyes widen as you run your eyes over perfectly-preserved tomes of recorded history.
So...the actual Book of Grudges sounds more like a library index.
Also thats one thing we want to buy with the gold for sure: dwarf histories. Complete and unabridged copies.
The Light Order do their best, but the Colleges have only been around for a fraction of the Empire's length, and before that a hundred tragedies each shaved away a record of history. The Great Library of Mordheim died with the city, the Sieges of Altdorf each resulted in a freezing populace burning books for heat, the Imperial Library suffered attrition every time the capital moved and was stolen back and forth a dozen times during the Age of the Three Emperors, and Dieter IV sold a good deal of what little survived to reach him to anyone willing to pay. And if that wasn't enough of a reason for his soul to be damned, when he sold Marienburg its independence, it took the Great Library of Verena with it, and ever since the self-righteous custodians have delighted in denying entry to citizens of the Empire. The Vaults of the Great Cathedral of Sigmar are purged every time a more conservative Grand Theogonist takes office, and there's Witch Hunters out there who consider literacy to be compelling evidence of witchcraft, and even when some poor scholar escapes the pyre it's not always guaranteed their books will.
And this is one reason why I suspect the Van Hals kept the book.
The Empire has had a poor record of keeping important knowledge in the face of politics and wealth.
Individuals can be trusted. Institutions cannot.
The most venerable of the Longbeards begins to leaf through at the High King's instruction, who then turns his attention to King Belegar. "If you can keep the fight going until a Throng gets there, we may be able to double the harvest of avenged Grudges. How long can your foothold last?"

"How long can yours?" King Belegar responds, and you fight to keep your expression neutral. The moment stretches as the two stare obstinately at each other.
Hot damn. This was PROBABLY why Thorgrim took him to the records chamber for the talking. He knew from how Kragg's survival was handled that Belegar had WORDS, best handled in relative privacy, with longbeards with known discretion.
"The East Gate is taken and fortified. Karag Nar is completely cleared, Karag Lhune has only a colony of spiders that are deciding whether to starve or be shot until it is the same, and both are fortified against any intruders from below. The Citadel is taken, and the caldera has been burned clear and by the time I return there will be enough artillery mounted that anything foolish enough to show itself will die. Kvinn-Wyr is infested by feral trolls, as much an obstacle to our enemies as it is to us, and that flank too is being fortified.
I suppose the Fire plan had some handy auxillary benefits too.
Karak Azul's Throng has reached us and King Kazador has sworn to me that each one will die before he lets his people be cut off again. Karak Norn is selling us war machines on credit. Karak Izor sent colonisers three months ago. Barak Varr is already counting their profits. There are manlings building houses. There are Halflings building houses. As far as I can see, Karak Eight Peaks has a brighter future than any Hold east of Black Fire Pass." He points at the Book, which stopped having its pages flipped as the Elder turned to watch. "That Karak is three thousand years dead. If the one that exists today holds no interest to you, I have no business here."
And here's the Stewardship pro at work again.
Look to the future. For there is a future.
The entire room is still, as all present turn to watch the confrontation. You included. You've never even heard of a Dwarven civil war, but you might be about to witness the beginning of one.

[High King's reaction: 84]

High King Thorgrim Grudgebearer is famed for being as implacable as the Dwarf Kings of old, and not a hint of what he could be thinking is visible upon his face as the silence stretches. Then he blinks once, and nods, and turns and leaves, pausing at the door to give a 'well?' look at the two of you, and you follow.
Thank you Ranald for a well placed high roll.
Definitely more important than the loot roll.
The Council Chamber of the High King is adorned with a model of the Old World, with what looks like the accurate to-scale height of every mountain from the Sea of Claws to the Sour Sea. You find the easy landmark of Barak Varr and follow the Blood River to where its tributaries disappear into the valleys, and then you spot the now-familiar cluster of mountains you've been calling home. Seconds later the door opens once more and a red-faced and surprisingly young Dwarf enters at a run, the summoning apparently as unexpected as it was urgent. "This is Prince Gotri Stoneheart. The title is still being debated, but for now he is 'Sky-Thane'. Gotri, put a branch of the Aircorp in Karag Lhune."

"Isn't it-"

"Yes. It's retaken. Have the hangars been cleared?"

"Aye," says King Belegar, too stubborn to show any bewilderment.

"They'll need a branch of the Engineer's Guild to maintain them, so see to that as well." The rest of the details are shaken out in rapid-fire fashion, and mere minutes later you find yourself climbing the innumerable stairs once more.
And Eight Peaks now has air support. Awesome.
And Engineers. Which bodes well for our ability to buy their services in the coming turns!
"I'd intended to tell of your contributions," King Belegar says to you, as the gyrobomber is hastily refuelled for an unexpectedly early departure. "Now I daresay that you'd find it no favour to have your name attached to mine in the halls of Karaz-a-Karak."

"I thought it was about to be war," you admit.

"Might have been close. Never could tell what he was thinking." But the message of your abrupt departure was clear - if King Belegar wanted to focus on tomorrow's victories, he would be denied yesterday's glories.
The only cure is more success I suppose.
[Joined the Expedition: +1]
[Battle of Und-Uzgar: +2]
Taking a watchpost without a fight and causing many deaths to Skaven +2.
[Battle of the East Gate: +4]
Defeating enemy heroes in battle +4.
[Battle of Karag Lhune: +12]
Sabotaged the Doom Divers +2, assassinating the Warboss +2, tripping the troll trap +4, preventing disaster in the Chiselwards +4.
[Battle of Karag Nar: +5]
Assassinating the Warboss +2, sabotaging Idol of Gork +3.
[Battle of the Citadel: +8]
Countering the Shamans +4, dispelling the Waaagh-field that empowered the Orcs +4.
[Grudges Avenged: --]
Nullified by Belegar-Thorgrim troubles.
[Finished the Expedition: +3]

[Total: 35.]
[Dwarf Favour cannot be spent in Karaz-a-Karak]
Damn that is a lot of Favor earned.
Pity about the Grudges, but holy shit look at Lhune.
We took an Enthusiastic Walk.

The whole Ritual hijinks was probably tactfully left out, but I wonder if the Longbeards might audit the Grudge count and credit after the rift amended, or if they'd leave it to "King Belegar's Expedition"?

Because part of it is that from what I'm seeing, Thorgrim's concern is basically "is this a fluke?"
He'd need to hold all eight peaks for a few centuries to convince the Grudgebearer that maybe this might be worth it.
 
I've said that 10 favours is the conventional minimum, and higher amounts are only possible with access to the likes of Kragg and Thorek. I've said that 25 is right on the very edge of what is possible, and I've said a number of times as people name ridiculous amounts of favours that even Dwarven craftsmanship has a limit. I don't think this is a matter of misapplied scaling, I think this is just an inherent part of what a lot of Questers like, which is the biggest shiniest shineys that ever shined, and there'll always be a faction for "there is a point where we needed to stop and we have clearly passed it but let's keep going and see what happens".

That said, the previous rules of thumb still apply, which is 10 points to the favour and have at the Dwarf Army Book, and very approximately one favour per casting value for battle magic.
It kind of is misapplied scaling - but one that is rather hard to avoid. Speaking as voter in a quest, it is hard for me to see things as special when one Mathilde is narratively surrounded by them. Dwarf runes are incredibly valuable, unique things. Products of genius and mastery that takes hundreds of years to perfect. But expedition to K8P have huge concentration of rune items. Hammerers are visible. Kragg is visible and outshining battle mages with his runic craft. Longeards seems to have runic items. There is armory from the 'good old times' filled with such items... so while item with even a single rune remains valuable, I need to keep reminding myself that it is so. Anything below rune items, even highest tier craftmanship - it feels like a trash tier now.

I think this is part of why voters keep thinking of spending 25+ points of favor on items. With so many rune armor and weaponry around a "mere" runic item feels underwhelming. Also, to be honest, it is a good way to go about those things. We will never exchange our Belt. It serves Mathilde well and if it was only gain that came out of Drakenhoff, it would be worth it. It is better to have one legendary-tier item rather than two or three of lesser quality. I feel that way, and majority of thread feels that way too: if You go to the shop, get best quality possible.

(BTW, it may be nice narrative point to include in a quest. Mathilde's life is now rather removed from normality of Empire. Clash of between her life and point of view and those of others may be interesting.)


As for voting, I really hope current vote will not make working as Belgar spymaster harder. Going by the comments, good portion of voters very much wants to go that road but are voting for other things due to them being time-sensitive and just wanting to get them the out of the way. (Ranald shrine, convincing Esbern and Seija, writing papers). I hope it can be represented in Mathilde's attitute 'in character'.
 
I've not seen an argument justifying losing the Amber Wizards and letting them go,
Because if they wanted to stay they'd be staying. We're prevailing upon their good natures (or their pocketbooks, or whatever) to keep them from doing whatever they want to be doing with their lives. To raise our dinosaurs, or negotiate with goddamn spiders, or whatever.
We'd be ordering our Amber Wizards to take care of the dinosaurs and train others in dealing with them, that's not going to cost us favors.
Put yourself in their shoes for a minute. Imagine the response the thread would have if someone tried to pull rank on Mathilde this way. Like, imagine the Emperor is like, 'Hey Matty, I know you like hanging with your dwarf friends or whatever, but I want you to go and help the Elector Count of Middenland. Chop chop.'
If Mathilde is dead for the lack of one in a critical scenario then it doesn't matter how many favours we would otherwise be ale to earn doing something else.
"If you don't choose my vote, Mathilde is going to die!" is not particularly compelling to me.

Maybe we want to spend those 15 Favor on building multiple factories for our new Guild of Engineers to in-house a lot of their expenses instead. Get more gyrocopters in the air, ruling the skies over K8P.
I'm still not seeing any real reason for why claiming a tempel site is a critically urgent priority compared to things that actually do need to be done now?
Maybe not everyone cares about goddamn spiders okay
 
I want twenty for a sword because it's a single piece of work; we can't put in five here or five there and let them add up like we can with infrastructure, any favor spent on a sword that could have been much better is favor that might as well have been wasted.

In short, we can nickel and dime our income and our home, but not our weapon expenditures, so it's more efficient to go all in on one thing at a time.
anyone voting for the abyss, don't forget that being that far unbderground will make magic very difficult to work with- recall how mathilde could barely see in the underway and karag nar, due to the grounding effect nerfing her ulguvision
It's just a meme vote for me; I'm expecting Rat Balrogs if I accidentally win.
 
I'm late to the party (Cursed sleep!), but I just want to say that this was beautiful. Belegar throwing down was glorious, and I'm absolutely hyped for helping him prove his point.
And I think your Throgrim is also beautiful and tragic, in the original greek sense. (My experience with him so far is him causally stomping everything in Total Warhammer, because I'm a filthy casual that plays on easy. So actually a lot closer to Belegor's experience so far.)

personally, i dont see a need to spend more than 20 favor on a single item.

our belt is amazing and it costed 15 favor.
I kinda want to see what a 25 (the maximum) would look like. I admit I'm weak to shinies. Getting the Belt and Seed are still two of my favorite moments. Fuck, that belt has effectively five runes on it (2 double runes), and basically does a whole bunch of things really well. But how much better could it be? I want to find out. I want a super awesome sword (doesn't even have to be killy, though it would be nice). I want some super awesome armor (maybe a cloak of sneakiness?). That stuff is just so awesome.

Since we can now get access to Kragg or Thorek whenever for a commission like that, I'm also willing to wait. That said, I think I'll run into FOMO (fear of missing out) hard if we do commission something. How much better could it have been? And also the underlying thought of "Now those favors will be wasted if we ever want to upgrade our weapon". It's only sorta true, but that doesn't mean I don't feel that way.

Personally, I think we should go full ham on a weapon, and keep the remaining favors in reserve. There's gonna be plenty of opportunity for more favors in the future (finalising the reconquest of K8P, and then helping Belebro in whatever he does to prove himself further). Use those and our reserves for the stuff we need/want. If we get another huge pile somehow, then we can commission another sweet piece of gear.
 
Just something to consider given that Runic items can't be traded or sold, or for that matter upgraded we're probably going to want to get the maximum power in a runic item that we can as we're almost certainly never going to go "Gosh I wish my weapon was less useful" So if we have some one like Kragg the Grim or Thorek around we should absolutely slam down the full 20-25 favours on it.

I'd prefer not to waste favours getting whole new items built unless we absolutely have to.
 
Last edited:
Eh 25 is a bit much for me. I'm totally fine with a 20 Favor weapon, hopefully made of Gromril, but 25 is litterally the maximum amount possible.

@BoneyM Quick question. Say we wanted a Sword, or an Axe, how many favor's would it take for it to be made out of Gromril?
 
Say @BoneyM would Mathilde be able to make an enchanted artifact with an alarm spell that is basically a "Push button to call Grey Wizard, only use in emergency" sort of thing?
 
-Grimnir - This is VERY weird...but if anyone could understand the mentality of a Slayer adventurers might. Facing certain death time after time could change a guy.

I think it's only the Slayers that seek out death. I suspect non-slayers do infact worship Grimnir, the Slayers simply take it to the extreme.
 
Some thoughts on future targets, once K8P is fully retaken (which might take a while): I think there's two big ones.
1) Black Crag. It's a huge Orc base, and will be a threat until taken care of. However, it's also a really hard target. It's what Throgrim would do. And in the long term (and I do mean long), it must be done. But I don't think it's the best.
2) Thunder Mountain. The Dragon Ogers aer apperantly not doing so hot. They also don't have easy reinforcements. Likely a much softer Target (though that doesn't mean they don't have a whole lot of nastiness in store). Why go for this? First, it should help secure the logistics further. Second: This is where they made the Anvils of Doom. We can get the two best Runelords on trying to recover the art. If that can be managed, even in a lesser form initially, it will be a great symbol that restoration is possible. Those are some of the most revered artifacts of dwarfkind, and have been lost for a long time. If Karak Eight-Peaks can be retaken, if the Anvils can be reforged, then surely the dwarven race has a future outside the mausoleum?
 
I kinda want to see what a 25 (the maximum) would look like. I admit I'm weak to shinies. Getting the Belt and Seed are still two of my favorite moments. Fuck, that belt has effectively five runes on it (2 double runes), and basically does a whole bunch of things really well. But how much better could it be? I want to find out. I want a super awesome sword (doesn't even have to be killy, though it would be nice). I want some super awesome armor (maybe a cloak of sneakiness?). That stuff is just so awesome.

Since we can now get access to Kragg or Thorek whenever for a commission like that, I'm also willing to wait. That said, I think I'll run into FOMO (fear of missing out) hard if we do commission something. How much better could it have been? And also the underlying thought of "Now those favors will be wasted if we ever want to upgrade our weapon". It's only sorta true, but that doesn't mean I don't feel that way.

Personally, I think we should go full ham on a weapon, and keep the remaining favors in reserve. There's gonna be plenty of opportunity for more favors in the future (finalising the reconquest of K8P, and then helping Belebro in whatever he does to prove himself further). Use those and our reserves for the stuff we need/want. If we get another huge pile somehow, then we can commission another sweet piece of gear.
so a couple of things to note:

1) we cant really get a set of dwarven armor. Runes need to go on metal, and heavy armor interferes with our spell casting.

2) ideally, we would remake our armor enchantment after we get to magic 8 for the improved armor save and hopefully incorporating our anti-fatigue mastery in to it. we dont need a sneak cloak, that is what our spells are for. having permanent anti-fatigue without having to recast every few minutes is another story.

3) we have other things we can spend our favor on. Therefore, we dont want to blow it all on one item. Training to use rifles and whatever weapon we get Kragg to make us is the big one. We want it because having a hero-tier teacher is a major time saver and more likely to get us traits. We might also want to go to Zhufbar and get a custom sniper rifle commissioned.

4) and as for the fear of missing out, I wouldn't worry about it considering how powerful our belt is and the fact that one of the greatest Runelords of the current era will make it. We will get something truly great with 15 favor, just not a legendary piece of equipment.

Hell, having a legendary-tier piece of equipment is potentially a bad thing. Something on the level of Ghal Maraz (which is what I imagine a 25 favor item is approaching) is attention getting. and we might not survive the kind of attention something that powerful can draw.
 
If there's going to be a vote on spending favor for a main weapon that'll be used until the end of the quest I'm going to vote for the 25 favor great sword since it's a good idea to spend the extra five to push it to the limit.
 
Back
Top