Honestly, the threat posed by the Romulans should not be that great as long as we maintain detente with the Klingons, and keep a watch on the Neutral zone. But committing to opening full peace talks within ten years is hopelessly optimistic. Even in canon they never managed to open full peace talks Khitomer accords style before Romulus went poof.

As far as the Excelsiors go, I think we can stave off replacement indefinitely as long as refits are kept up. After all in Canon, the Ambassadors saw little use and the Excelsiors were still around and kicking ass well into the Dominion war. And in canon Ambassadors are not introduced for a couple decades yet. We should focus on Excelsiors, and use them for five year missions (Never mind that in this period they are impressive as all get out capital ships, which would keep aggressors off our backs while we poke anomalies with sticks)

We should also be committing to replacing the Constitutions still in service.

[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

("Increase yard space for "Project Observer" which is laying down as many Excelsiors as possible to vastly expand our pool of ships available for 5-year missions. Heck I would like to go over 5 ships on 5-year missions if at all possible.)

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
Not running everything off of Earth and the USA in particular? Are you *mad*? You act like this is some sort of *Federation*!

Oh, wait.
 
As it is:



[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

("Increase yard space for "Project Observer" which is laying down as many Excelsiors as possible to vastly expand our pool of ships available for 5-year missions. Heck I would like to go over 5 ships on 5-year missions if at all possible.)

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)

I find @AKuz's plan to be convincing, the reasoning sound, and it'S much more in character than generically Increase The Budget.
 
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet would see at least two new species join the Federation by 2311.
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)

I'm convinced, plus the reasoning not to replace Excelsiors is sound
 
"Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction."

With Regards to this modifier, I'd probably implement it as another discount on the Political Will cost of Shipyard expansions. Those requests will be the sort of thing you can apply for starting next year.

This is my WIP list:
Federation Council Options
  • Request mining colony on Josephine III 10pp (4 turns, then +15 Br/turn)
  • Request expansion of San Francisco Fleet Yards, 20pp (4 turns, gain new 1m t berth)
  • Request expansion of 40 Eridani A Shipyards, 20pp (4 turns, gain new 1m t berth)
  • Request Excelsior berth at 40 Eridani A Shipyards, 20pp (6 turns, gain new 3m t berth)
  • Request new Shipyard in orbit around Tellar Prime, 40pp (12 turns, gain new shipyard starting with one 2.5m t berth)
  • Request new Shipyard in orbit around Andor, 40pp (12 turns, gain new shipyard starting with one 2.5m t berth)
  • Request funding to start Utopia Planitia Shipyards, 175pp (20 turns, gain new shipyard starting with 2 3m t berths, 2 1m t berths)
  • Request new Starbase [Write in Sector]
  • Request to Reduce Defence Requirements in Sector [Write in]
  • Reduce Militarisation Level 25pp
  • Increase Threat Level 25pp
  • Request Budget increase 25pp (Roll for success)
  • Request Allocation for an Excelsior's resources, one-off-infusion of an Excelsior's cost, 10pp
  • Request Academy Expansion, 20pp (Gain +.5 Officers/Enlisted/Techs)
  • Request Temporary Explorer Corps Recruitment Drive, 20pp, (Gain 2 Officer, 2 Enlisted, 2 Techs, Convert 2 Officer, 2 Enlisted, 2 Techs from normal service)
  • Request Start of Ambassador class project, receiving one-off boost of Research Points and go-ahead for some projects, 50pp
  • Request Start of Renaissance class project, receiving one-off boost of Research Points and go-ahead for some projects, 50pp
  • Request Start of Custom ship project, receiving one-off boost of Research Points and go-ahead for some projects, 75pp
 
Last edited:
"I want the people of Tellar and Andoria to be able to point up when the new ships are launched and say 'We built that'. When we discover new life, when we map new systems, I want Andorians and Tellarites to be able to say 'That was us, we helped'. When, heavens forbid, those ships fight, the Andorians and Tellarites can say, 'That Shield of the Federation, we built that'. I want every member of the Federation to look up at the stars, see the points of light crossing them, exploring them. And I want them to say, 'We did that, all of us, we did that together' "
-Fleet Admiral Vitalia Yukiko Kahurangi, Address to the Federation Council, 20611.1

EDIT: I don't know why but I am legitimately super excited about this quest. (As you can probably tell)​
 
Last edited:
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.

Spreading production around seems like a good idea. Don't put all your eggs in one basket and all that.
 
New:

[x] AKuz

On second thought, there's so much in the galaxy to see. We need more ships and explorers!
 
[X] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.
Bigger docks! Always a good early-game move in Rule The Waves.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new Excelsiors by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
 
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.

[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
(commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards. These vessels will specifically be mandated for 5-year missions and be home ported out of Andoria and Tellar)
 
Also next meeting we should either push for an increased threat level or raise the minimum combat level. We have 29 points to give before going over the cap and each Excelsior adds 6 at base, with it increasing by 1 for each level of veterancy. Oberths also will add one each and we need two of those, and if they get past green would contribute 2 each reducing our points available to 25. Also we have 18 points in combat that will be finished at the start of next year reducing our points to 7 which would only allow one Excelsior with one increase to crew rating between it and the two at blooded. And we want Excelsiors for the 5 year missions as they have the highest combo of Science and Presence along with the hull and combat to survive any problems they encounter.
 
*joins in the the romulan shilling*
[x] AKuz
Considering the presence of Archer in the namelist, is the Xindi attack et all canon for the quest ?
 
I was also looking an we need to take control of the academy as both Oberths and Excelsiors require a lot of techs and we only get one a year, which would be enough to add either an Oberth or Excelsior to the explorer fleet and then have to wait a while. Though we could have the Oberths be part of the main fleet if that meets the requirements of the council. Though it does not look like we have the income to build an Excelsior and two Oberths unless we find a good amount of SR. If we can doing so will get us close to the science requirement of 85.
 
Also next meeting we should either push for an increased threat level or raise the minimum combat level. We have 29 points to give before going over the cap and each Excelsior adds 6 at base, with it increasing by 1 for each level of veterancy. Oberths also will add one each and we need two of those, and if they get past green would contribute 2 each reducing our points available to 25. Also we have 18 points in combat that will be finished at the start of next year reducing our points to 7 which would only allow one Excelsior with one increase to crew rating between it and the two at blooded. And we want Excelsiors for the 5 year missions as they have the highest combo of Science and Presence along with the hull and combat to survive any problems they encounter.

This is a good analysis.

Also: We might end up gaining some points back due to the simple consideration that we may be decommissioning a Constitution class or two as we launch these newer vessels; this would possibly free up some crew as well
 
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new Excelsiors by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
 
Also: We might end up gaining some points back due to the simple consideration that we may be decommissioning a Constitution class or two as we launch these newer vessels; this would possibly free up some crew as well
Yes, decommissioned ships put their crew back into the pool.

Though we could have the Oberths be part of the main fleet if that meets the requirements of the council.
It would meet the requirements of the Council - the Oberths don't have to be part of Explorer Corps.

Considering the presence of Archer in the namelist, is the Xindi attack et all canon for the quest ?
Arghleblargle, um, I haven't decided on that yet. I kinda stopped watching ST:Enterprise at some point preceding that, to be perfectly honest :oops:
 
NVM I decided to say screw it and downloaded Kinimatics' tally program. So have a tally!

Vote Tally : Sci-Fi - To Boldly Go... (a Starfleet quest) | Page 6 | Sufficient Velocity
##### NetTally 1.7.4
[x] Akuz's plan
No. of Votes: 1
Plan: ◈Akuz's plan

TerrisH

Task: REQUIREMENT
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.
[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
No. of Votes: 12
AKuz
Cornuthaum
jamie96969
JMHthe3rd
KlavoHunter
Night_stalker
Random Member
Scia
tryrar
tyrolcamper
UbeOne
Void Stalker
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet would facilitate the opening of peace talks with the Romulans by 2311.
No. of Votes: 2
prometheus110
DannyboyZero
[X] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new Excelsiors by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
No. of Votes: 2
anon_user
useofstrike32
[x] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Maximum Combat should be higher.
[x] [GOAL] Starfleet would facilitate the opening of peace talks with the Romulans by 2311.
No. of Votes: 1
Artemis1992
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new Excelsiors by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
No. of Votes: 1
Briefvoice
[x] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
No. of Votes: 1
Shard
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet would see at least two new species join the Federation by 2311.
No. of Votes: 1
veekie
Total No. of Voters: 21
Here's the tally done by task.

Vote Tally : Sci-Fi - To Boldly Go... (a Starfleet quest) | Page 6 | Sufficient Velocity
##### NetTally 1.7.4
[x] Akuz's plan
No. of Votes: 1

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: GOAL
[x] [GOAL] Starfleet will have no fewer than 5 ongoing Five Year Missions by 2311.
No. of Votes: 16
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new excelsior by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
No. of Votes: 12
[x] [GOAL] Starfleet would facilitate the opening of peace talks with the Romulans by 2311.
No. of Votes: 3
--[x] [GOAL] Write in: Most notably, this would mandate an expansion of the shipyards and the commissioning of 2-3 new Excelsiors by 2306, beyond the current one under construction.
No. of Votes: 3
[X] [GOAL] Starfleet would see at least two new species join the Federation by 2311.
No. of Votes: 1

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: REQUIREMENT
[x] [REQUIREMENT] Write in: Increase berth size. Commit to expand yard space to Andoria and Tellar. Construct at least 1 2.5mt yards in each system (Capable of building and refitting Excelsior classes) this will show the Federation that all members are in this together, avoid putting the burden on any one member, and if possible commit the resources to producing at least one Excelsior class in each system out of the new yards.
No. of Votes: 14
[X] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Budget should be increased.
No. of Votes: 5
[x] [REQUIREMENT] ...the Maximum Combat should be higher.
No. of Votes: 1
Total No. of Voters: 21
 
Last edited:
Back
Top