OneirosTheWriter said:
The first person to speak is Lieutenant Uhura at Comms. "Captain, I'm picking up distress signals, Starfleet ones. One near the third planet, one near the fourth. They are both very old, enough that our computer is having trouble piecing them together."
"What else can you tell me about them?" asks Kirk.
"The one by the third planet is the older one, but is a stronger signal," says Uhura. She pauses and tilts her head, listening to her earpiece carefully. "Captain, if I'm not mistaken, it may even be a United Earth Starfleet code. The other is definitely a Starfleet code."
"Very well," says Kirk, returning to his command chair. "Mr Chekov, give me a course to-"
Two Federation ships have gone missing in Aga Carmide. One was the
Lion, some years ago (in Sousa's proper time). The other was the
Enterprise-B, just now. It is likely, though not certain, that each of those ships is the source of one of the signals in question. The big question on my mind is: is the
Lion, which was taken by the anomaly first, the older signal from the third planet? If so, the
Enterprise-B is probably around the fourth planet... but there's a problem. Kirk's
Enterprise arrived after BOTH 2300-era ships. If the older signal around the third planet is coming from
Enterprise-B, then the anomaly is pulling ships back to semi-random times.
Or, is the anomaly running in reverse chronological order? In which case the
Lion would have arrived AFTER the
Enterprise-B, and the
Enterprise-nil would have arrived after both of them. If so, then
Lion is around the fourth planet and the
Enterprise-B is around the third.
Also, one might expect an
Excelsior to send a stronger signal than a
Miranda, all else being equal- and the stronger signal is around the third planet.
But then, the
Miranda might have taken less damage in the process of being naturally swallowed by the anomaly (which did not harm Connie!
Enterprise, you will note). Whereas the
Enterprise-B might have taken considerably more damage in the process of being pulled through an ARTIFICIAL time portal exploiting the anomaly and/or fighting a Licori tech-ship, AFTER having pushed her warp core to the brink of explosion chasing the tech-ship.
So... hard to say, really. The more 'Starfleety' distress signal MIGHT be the
Enterprise-B, but the
Lion was a Starfleet ship too... and I'm deeply worried about red herrings here.
Hopefully Kirk will figure out which planet has the iocane powder in it.
...
Basically, I see one of two narratives:
If the
Enterprise-B is around the third planet, then the anomaly is grabbing ships and dumping them at quasi-random times. The
Enterprise-B is in good shape or at least no worse shape than the
Lion physically, and for some reason is transmitting an ambiguous maybe-Earth distress code.
If the
Enterprise-B is around the fourth planet, then the anomaly is grabbing ships and dumping them in reverse order (the sooner you go into the anomaly, the later the time you come out of the anomaly ten million years in the past).
Enterprise is in bad shape (enough to be transmitting weaker signals than a
Miranda), but somehow has a more authentically 'Starfleety' distress signal.
The wild card is that either ship could be an alien vessel (e.g. the Licori ship) faking a Starfleet signal.