Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
But Thorek's conversation -- and I feel like Mathilde's own bias would be "Bullshit the High King is stealing stuff, I think I just fucked up and convinced Belegar of Thorgrim's further ill intent when it's not true." Even in the scene where she reports it and Belegar has his rant, she mentions feeling bad and not wanting to be praised for it; that leads me to suspect that Belegar and Mathilde have preexisting biases concerning Thorgrim, yes... but very different biases -- enlightens things a good bit.

The fact that she had had the Gunnars scene, about Karag Dum, just the turn before Thorek... that kind of neatly formed an example of "This is what people believe about people from Karag Dum" followed up by a "... And this is why they believe that way" revelation/explanation from Thorek.

So anyway yeah, I think I stand by my conclusion. I think Mathilde is more likely to be put in mind of Thorek's observation on the Cult of Thungni and the resultant cultural shifts and beliefs of the Karaz Ankor, and how the return of Karag Dum might affect all this. And she might worry about new political ripples and tsunamis being caused.

Although there's another possible angle to this, too. Namely that... because Karag Dum's people know what the Waystones are doing... That means that Karag Dum can potentially prove themselves via evidence. And if they can potentially lean on the High King to do so, then... they'd have a hell of a character witness. (The High King on the other hand, would probably rather not have a huge divide explode in the middle of the Cult of Thungni or the Karaz Ankor. On the other hand, he probably realizes that it'd probably be unreasonable for Karag Dum to be sanguine and okay with their reputation in the rest of the Karaz Ankor, especially after having just come out of a 200-year siege by Chaos. Coming out of 200 years of siege, only to be looked at by suspicion or confusion and uncertainty by most younglings? They're not going to feel okay with their pride and standing being besmirched like that.)

We might, potentially, have a role to play in Dwarf politics after this whole thing. ><

In trying to keep things from blowing up or breaking up. If the Runelords raise a bit stink or something. Or if the Karag Dum people make demands or whatever.

... And meanwhile, there are people who are young and enthusiastic, or are fired up by the reclamation of Holds and are just excited to be doing stuff or are radicals or whatever or are apart from all this being Imperial or young Dwarfs or... I dunno.

Thorgrim may have quite a lot of balancing and delicate diplomacy on his hands. On the one hand, it's probably better than a slow inevitable doom that he can do nothing about. On the other hand, how shitty would it feel to have dodged inevitable demise by sheer luck, only to then fumble sticking the landing and have things break apart on your watch anyway?

God, I hope we find out enough about Waystones -- and Dwarf politics and attitudes in general -- in Karag Dum that we can take our knowledge and stuff back to Belegar, and convince him not to exacerbate things with Thorgrim and convince him about what is really going on and what is really at stake. Because Belegar certainly could probably makes things worse, no doubt. Especially if he acts out of opportunism, to take shots at Thorgrim in exchange for concessions or just to dunk on him a bit, and isn't aware of the greater Karaz Ankor-wide diplomatic and national political effects it might have. Or is somewhat aware of it, but takes some sort of "Good riddance to bad rubbish!" conclusion about Thorgrim.


... Hm. Hell, for all we know, it's possible that Thorgrim will start throwing resources towards Vlag and Dum... And Belegar might view that as the exact same sort of "He's only giving resources because it lets him continue harvesting energy!" And make a stink about the distribution of resources and political focus, thinking that the resources and focus could be better spent on closer threats or whatever. ... And Belegar could probably find a lot of support amongst the Runelord-influenced sorts who have reason to be against Karag Dum.

... On the other hand, nah. Belegar was one of the people who provided a dramatically-useful figure to the Expedition; that of Mathilde Weber. And so, Belegar might join in on the Karag Dum side. Because they would have a lot of reason and motivation to be very grateful to him...

... Which might result, amusingly, in a Belegar that is part of a wide-umbrella political faction that includes Thorgrim too. Both Belegar and Thorgrim being pro-Vlag and pro-Dum. And Belegar being annoyed as hell at the fact that he has found himself on the same political/diplomatic side as Thorgrim.

In which case, it might be better to smooth things out between Belegar and Thorgrim, so that they can work together more easily. Because if they are going to be forced to work together anyway, then better that it be smooth-ish cooperation rather than incredibly teeth-grit cooperation.

... Actually, I am really liking -- and finding amusing -- the possibility of Belegar and Thorgrim finding themselves on the same 'side' by happenstance and sheer alignment of politics/economy/Hold-reclamation-stuff.

It's a very tricky and interesting situation. And one which might be nudged one way or another. Thus making it interesting. And also making it a place that we can intervene in, because he have huge Dwarf cred, and have huge favor and friendship with Belegar too. In fact, wouldn't it be funny if King Belegar ended up taking a wife from Karag Dum, as part of this weird new-and-old-Holds-and-High-King political quasi-faction?

...

...

... Just had a thought/realization.

So, uh.

Karag Dum knows a lot about Waystones, right.

Um. So. Who do we know, that would want to know a lot about Waystones?

King Belegar.

I started this off by thinking to myself, after I wrote the latest big paragraph above, with "In fact, wouldn't it be funny if King Belegar ended up taking a wife from Karag Dum?" And then I realized the further implications and consequences of that.

Namely that...

If Belegar, married somebody from Dum, he might potentially gain access to Waystone knowledge.

Hooooly moly. And, in fact, Belegar might even go for it. If he thought that he needed the Waystone knowledge for the good of his people... ... And then found out more of the truth of things, and found out that the whole of Dwarfkind is at stake on the Throne of Power? And that he would have to reorient or hold aside his opinions of Thorgrim and work with him despite his personal feelings towards him, because of how important it is both for Karak Eight Peaks and all of the Karaz Ankor?

Now that's some interesting Drama.

Of course, maybe it won't be Belegar. Maybe it'll be a nephew of his that does it. Or maybe somebody from Kazador's brood, and Belegar gains the knowledge by proxy of the Belegar-Kazador friendship and alliance.

But still.

How interesting all these ideas are.

There's some serious potential for politics, drama, cool stories, cool outcomes, teeth-gritted cooperation, slowly growing trust or affection (between husbands and brides or etc), slowly growing reconciliation (or slowly growing pains and irritations anyway)...

A coalition of the new and the old amongst the Karaz Ankor. And, a question of what the hell does "old" mean anyway, if the "old" is represented by Karak Azul and Karag Dum, and yet they act so weirdly anyway? And even Karaz-a-Karak -- or at least the High King -- is in this faction anyway, but there's definitely friction there, and yet they work together, and yet...

... This could potentially be a pretty exciting and fascinating time for historians of the Karaz Ankor to be alive in. So much potential history being made.

And not just dramatic and almost-mythical rescues and reclamations of Karaks. But also more... normal history. Normal, yet the sort that the history and spirit of a people and a nation are made of.

Honestly, I didn't believe Karak Dum was reclaimable, until I realised that reclaiming it would create more complications/troubles for Karaz Ankor than not reclaiming it.

That realization updated the possibility of reclaiming it, in my mind, from "need so many crits it is a statistical impossibillity" to "maybe doable with statistically reasonable good luck and good decision making"
 
Last edited:
@Garlak though I broadly agree with you about not taking undue risks with dwarf paranoia I feel I must push back on the assumption that any Waystone studies will benefit primarily us and our polity. The issue with the waystones indeed the issue with the whole world is that they were made during the Golden Age on the assumption that they would be maintained in perpetuity by their builders. That is no longer true, there aren't enough elves, there aren't enough dwarfs and the world is falling more into chaos and madness with every fallen stone.

What the world does have enough of or at least a hope of having more of in the future is humans and ultimately human wizards. Designing a way for them to do more than the bare minimum of tech support, ideally to make Waystones where they have been broken is a matter of worldwide survival. If we figgure this out it should not be a secret we keep for the Greys, the colleges or the Empire. We should teach the Kislevites, the Bretonians, hell even the Tileasn Estalians and Arabeyans, contingent on finding trustworthy polities.
 
Last edited:
@Garlak though I broadly agree with you about not taking undue risks with dwarf paranoia I feel I must push back on the assumption that any Waystone studies will benefit primarily us and our polity. The issue with the waystones indeed the issue with the whole world is that they were made during the Golden Age on the assumption that they would be maintained in perpetuity by their builders. That is no longer true, there aren't enough elves, there aren't enough dwarfs and the world is falling more into chaos and madness with every fallen stone.

What the world does have enough of or at least a hope of having more of in the future is humans and ultimately wizards. Designing a way for them to do more than the bare minimum of tech support, ideally to make Waystones where they have been broken is a matter of worldwide survival. If we figgure this out it should not be a secret we keep for the Greys, the colleges or the Empire. We should teach the Kislevites, the Bretonians, hell even the Tileasn Estalians and Arabeyans, contingent on finding trustworthy polities.

Widely distributing a method of gathering and funnelling enormous amounts of magic might be counterproductive when it comes to keeping the world intact.

Is that real? If so, where may I find it?

He's a character in Warhammer 40k, and also a 19th-century English poet.
 
I take this moment to remind everyone that the first named Inquisitor was Obiwan Sherlock Clouseau.

I mean, I don't think he's canon anymore, but still.
 
Yes. The prohibition is mainly a wall against 'laundering' secret knowledge by very carefully circumscribing it without actually sharing any of it, allowing it to be figured out by others.
That's actually much more reasonable than I thought it to be, and it means that we can share things that we derive from it as long as we're very careful.

@BoneyM if our Dawi soul was a descendant of Thungni, would that change views on us learning more Runesmith secrets? (Not that we have the lifespan to make a proper go of it.)
 
What the world does have enough of or at least a hope of having more of in the future is humans and ultimately human wizards. Designing a way for them to do more than the bare minimum of tech support, ideally to make Waystones where they have been broken is a matter of worldwide survival. If we figgure this out it should not be a secret we keep for the Greys, the colleges or the Empire. We should teach the Kislevites, the Bretonians, hell even the Tileasn Estalians and Arabeyans, contingent on finding trustworthy polities.
The obvious counterargument is that Dwarfs have a proven track record of being really good at not letting dangerous knowledge fall into the hands of Chaos. If we decide to disseminate this information that broadly, it's only a matter of time until the other side has a broad understanding of not only how the waystone network functions, but how to tamper with it. Not just 'turn it into a Dhar factory' but, redirect the flow, establish new connections, piggyback off existing connections, etc. That's a very dangerous thing given how many waystones are basically unreachable and indefensible, in the middle of forests like the Drakwald.

What happens when this information passes from a Black Magister to the Chorfs, and from there, to the Skaven?
What happens when the Skaven start tunneling into the underground Dwarf network?

Ignorance is absolutely our ally as much as it is our enemy, and I strongly disagree with the assertion that teaching everyone how to work these things is going to lead to a better world.
I think the safest option by far is leaving it in the hands of the Runesmiths and a select handful of College personnel.
 
Then one should make peace with the notion that the world is on a timer to extinction by Chaos. If Waystones are required to keep the world from falling into the Warp, yet they keep being broken and not replaced there is only one way the story can go.

Duh? Chaos is slowly devouring surrounding lands, Waystones or no Waystones. They siphon a lot of its energy, but not nearly all of it.

Anyway. As a solution, I would suggest organizing teams of dwarves and Mages that stare angrily at each other and try to work around the fact that neither side will ever entertain revealing their secrets. That or figure out why the fuck elves stopped repairing the network and make them start again.
 
If Karak Dum is lost for whatever reason, I do hope the Dum dwarfs have the means to shut down their main Waystone safely and permanently before any hostile factions can eventually access the sealed hold though it would be crazy to turn it into nuclear self destruct that destroy the mountain and surrounding areas of Chaos for miles in exchange for huge damage to the Waystone network and whatever climate crisis.
 
The obvious counterargument is that Dwarfs have a proven track record of being really good at not letting dangerous knowledge fall into the hands of Chaos. If we decide to disseminate this information that broadly, it's only a matter of time until the other side has a broad understanding of not only how the waystone network functions, but how to tamper with it. Not just 'turn it into a Dhar factory' but, redirect the flow, establish new connections, piggyback off existing connections, etc. That's a very dangerous thing given how many waystones are basically unreachable and indefensible, in the middle of forests like the Drakwald.

What happens when this information passes from a Black Magister to the Chorfs, and from there, to the Skaven?
What happens when the Skaven start tunneling into the underground Dwarf network?

Ignorance is absolutely our ally as much as it is our enemy, and I strongly disagree with the assertion that teaching everyone how to work these things is going to lead to a better world.
I think the safest option by far is leaving it in the hands of the Runesmiths and a select handful of College personnel.

You make some good arguments, but this is at its core the same issue as 'let's not buy the meat it might be poisoned'. Just as the demigriffs cannot eat diamonds so the world cannot be bailed out of sinking into a tide of Chaos by dwarvish secret keeping. Even if there is a chance this will do more harm than good the current trajectory leads inevitably to death and worse than death, likely within Mathilde's lifepsan. When staring at the apocalypse in the face even a slim chance it better than none.

Duh? Chaos is slowly devouring surrounding lands, Waystones or no Waystones. They siphon a lot of its energy, but not nearly all of it.

Anyway. As a solution, I would suggest organizing teams of dwarves and Mages that stare angrily at each other and try to work around the fact that neither side will ever entertain revealing their secrets. That or figure out why the fuck elves stopped repairing the network and make them start again.

  1. Chaos is not devouring all the lands where Waystones are broken. Sometimes its necromancers, of greneskins looking to make and idol, yet even if you kill these enemies someone has to repair the network.
  2. The elves are in decline anyway, fixing that would be an even more complex issue than working towards restoring the network
 
Back
Top