Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Notably, the only two mentions of True Dhar in Winds of Magic were removed after errata, and the term exists nowhere else in 4e. It doesn't look like it was judged to be a concept well-suited to continued existence.
Makes sense. The term and its definition is convoluted and kind of unnecessary. It just complicates things.

What I'm a bit surprised by is Winds of Magic already receiving Errata. Wasn't it recently released?

As an aside, it would be nice if I could get the physical book. I thought London would have it stocked but I could only find the Core Book, Middenheim and Altdorf.
 
What I'm a bit surprised by is Winds of Magic already receiving Errata. Wasn't it recently released?
It was released May 18 and got an updated release on May 30, though I believe the cut-off point for taking in errata (or fixing it) was May 23 since the errata I submitted after that date didn't get fixed. It was still a lot done; of the around 10k words of errata I submitted, 7k of that was before the cut-off date, and they fixed everything that was in error.
 
Last edited:
Makes sense. The term and its definition is convoluted and kind of unnecessary. It just complicates things.

What I'm a bit surprised by is Winds of Magic already receiving Errata. Wasn't it recently released?

As an aside, it would be nice if I could get the physical book. I thought London would have it stocked but I could only find the Core Book, Middenheim and Altdorf.
the physical book is not out yet: only pre-order from the main cubicle7 site.
 
the physical book is not out yet: only pre-order from the main cubicle7 site.
I am confused by the ways of the future. Is this how books work nowadays? Online release earlier than physical distribution? I know this is often how things work for novelists, but I really didn't know big companies would be doing this. Or is the pre-order thing a preview of the final product that people can submit feedback on, like some sort of Beta.

I feel out of touch.
 
I am confused by the ways of the future. Is this how books work nowadays? Online release earlier than physical distribution? I know this is often how things work for novelists, but I really didn't know big companies would be doing this. Or is the pre-order thing a preview of the final product that people can submit feedback on, like some sort of Beta.

I feel out of touch.
The RPG publishing market has figured out that pdfs and 'print after sell' (e.g printing a book after someone has already paid for it) has a way, way, way better profit margin then making a lot of books to sell to shops.

pdfs cost nothing to copy and sell so they are all profit, and because they are much cheaper on the customer side people buy more of them.

RPG companies basically only pre-print the core books and a few of the 'best sellers' supplements for shops now has the 'bait' products.
 
I am confused by the ways of the future. Is this how books work nowadays? Online release earlier than physical distribution? I know this is often how things work for novelists, but I really didn't know big companies would be doing this. Or is the pre-order thing a preview of the final product that people can submit feedback on, like some sort of Beta.

I feel out of touch.
Cubicle 7 publishes books as PDFs as full releases, then publishes physical versions of those books several months later. The PDFs aren't betas, it's just that PDFs don't need printing and shipping and the like, so they're way faster to push out the door. I wouldn't call C7 a big company though, more of a small company.
 
I'm trying to update my KAU document but finding trouble in figuring out some things. I've been marking books which definitely don't exist with a forward slash (/) and books whose existing status is unknown with a question mark (?), but it's difficult to go through the thread searcher to figure out which is which, and I'm not inclined to ping Boney for this.

Instead I'm asking everyone else for their wisdom and/or memory:
  • Are there more Dwarven Magic books asides from the ones we already have? We currently have Extensive for Sevir, Chaos Sorcery, Waaagh Magic, Skaven Warp Magic and Warpstones, and up to Esoteric for Waystones and Henges - is it correct to assume that's basically all there is on them, or are there more that we could have gotten at some point but decided not to because of focusing on other topics?
  • Is Kislev the only source available on their own gods and spirits?
  • Does Bretonnia have any books on magic or magical phenomena, given their whole deal with The Lady?
And if anyone knows any particular topic that simply doesn't have books up to Esoteric or whatever, please let me know.
 
Ea-Nasir it says, using the stilted form it uses when phonetically spelling non-Khazalid words. Copper merchant. Tylos. Account opened 11.5.2702.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I missef that the first time around. Someone needed to store their treasures far away so as to escape impromptu sword-based customer complaints, it seems :p

Edit:

"Don't you ever get sick of just... preventing everyone from starving to death? Ever want to branch out into some sort of dubious megaweapon?"
There are so many references in this story, I completely forgot :p
 
Last edited:
Are there more Dwarven Magic books asides from the ones we already have? We currently have Extensive for Sevir, Chaos Sorcery, Waaagh Magic, Skaven Warp Magic and Warpstones, and up to Esoteric for Waystones and Henges - is it correct to assume that's basically all there is on them, or are there more that we could have gotten at some point but decided not to because of focusing on other topics?
I don't know about the specifics, that's something that @picklepikkl is more likely to know. However I do know that there is more to Dwarven Magic knowledge, but it's locked under Guild and Cult secrets because it's Runesmith stuff. We can acquire some of that knowledge if we swear the necessary oaths and promise to not reveal it to anyone except our disciples.
Is Kislev the only source available on their own gods and spirits?
I don't see how there would be other sources. The Empire already has its hands full with its own supernatural occurences, and there is no other organisation likely to have written records of Kislev's spirits. I could posit that Gospodar and Ungol views on the Gods and Spirits could be different enough that they count as different sources, but it's not like we have a deep enough connection to acquire that information. It's not like Hag Witches and Ice Witches are usually the type to write stuff down after all. Zlata was chosen partially because she was one of the rare literate ones, and Hag Witches are even less likely to write books.
Does Bretonnia have any books on magic or magical phenomena, given their whole deal with The Lady?
They most likely do, but that would be the sort of stuff kept in private collections belonging to Damsels, Prophetesses and the Enchantress. Damsels are some of the most mysterious spellcasters in the Old World. If we want magical books from Bretonnia, it would have to be arranged with the Enchantress or a particularly influential Prophetess.

EDIT: I would like to issue a correction. I think the Empire probably has basic knowledge on Kislev's pantheon, but it's questionable if it provides anything more than Kislev's own words on their own gods. Different perspective perhaps? Spirits I don't think so. Spirits are tied to local culture and superstition that Imperials are not immersed in.
 
Last edited:
I've always wondered if the dwarven "don't teach this to anybody except your apprentices" vow includes perpetual apprentices such as the Hochlander, or if it has to be actual master and student apprentices.

I suspect it's the latter, if only because teaching perpetuals feels like playing silly buggers with the vow and dwarves don't like that.
 
I've always wondered if the dwarven "don't teach this to anybody except your apprentices" vow includes perpetual apprentices such as the Hochlander, or if it has to be actual master and student apprentices.

I suspect it's the latter, if only because teaching perpetuals feels like playing silly buggers with the vow and dwarves don't like that.
I'd have to agree, given the usual dwarven way of doing things as well as the specificity of their language. It likely refers to direct apprentices, as in a personal student, someone we take in as an initiate and who would call us Master. Someone who's skill, fundamental approach at our tradecraft, even personality and view on world to some degree we have or will be shaping.
So by this definition, the Hochlander is not our apprentice. He holds it as a tradecraft title, but is by dwarven reckoning likely just our employee as faar as these things are concerned.

Eike on the other hand...
 
Last edited:
Instead of a gate in the side of a mountain he'd been expecting, a gate between two mountains had opened into a idyllic farm valley dotted with cottages and filled with Halflings, giving him the momentary but terrifying thought that he'd gotten turned around at some point and ended up at the Moot
Truly a fate worse than death for any Stirlander.
 
I wonder what the smallest possible waystone vortex is. There might be energy requirements that need additional waystones to feed Wind into the waystone circle. How far apart do the four waystones need to separated in order to produce a useful effect? There is a natural presumption with regards to pyramids if they turn out to make use of this style of magic.
 
If I remember right, the reason runesmithing secrets are guarded at all you don't need to be descended from Thungni to do runesmithing. I believe that Thungni descent is needed to be allowed to do runesmithing.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top