Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
This is not quite true.
Even disregarding that I am unsure how much the hag witches could actually contribute in an university setting, like explained in an earlier post, would we be talking about any place in the Empire, I would be inclined to agree with you, but with Kislev, not so much. They are very isolationist, do notice that just giving access to a trading company in good standing needs a royal boon.
And we do want access to them - not only do they have Waystones nobody had studied or even described, alone their geographic position near the Chaos makes them the ideal location for our experiments and stone placements.

Consider how interested Boris was in the ability, then consider that if we get both Hag and Ice witches working on the framework then we would go to negotiate with both of their main magical traditions giving the idea a thumbs up.

Finally, even if for some weird reason they still say no. There are a huge amount of other areas we could do prototyping in, after which we could come back with an even more desirable product.
 
Last edited:
Why waste an action on potentially recruiting the Hag Witches with the facet of the Father. After all, picking faith in Ranald wouldnt give us AP hell. Now we have an in by another action, let us use it.

Nothing stopping people from waving the coin around at the Hag Witches at a later date aswell, anyhow.
 
The Hags aren't particularly influential in Kislev, it's the IW who are closer to the nobility.
This isn't exactly true. The Ice Witches have pull with the nobility, but the Hag Witches are incredibly influential with the Ungols, who form a substantial portion of Kislev's populace. Their political power isn't high, but their communal power is a different matter. They've got access to all sorts of weird and esoteric subjects and concepts that very few if any magical traditions have access to, like the ability to reverse mutations. No other lore is capable of doing that except Chaos itself.

I'm not necessarily arguing for the Hag Witches. There are many factors playing into this beyond just their abilities. But I do have to outline all the factors involved so everyone is informed.
 
Why waste an action on potentially recruiting the Hag Witches with the facet of the Father. After all, picking faith in Ranald wouldnt give us AP hell. Now we have an in by another action, let us use it.

Nothing stopping people from waving the coin around at the Hag Witches at a later date aswell, anyhow.
Is there a theory saying the Hags serve a Daughter? There is a fairly convincing one for the Halethans, but I don't remember anything about the Hags.

I'm also not sure they will be that useful for the project. The IW are maintaining special Waystones, so they're interesting for us, but I don't remember Hags being associated with waystones. And even if they were, I consider Kislev's support and access to be more important.
 
If all it takes for the foundation to be flawed is not including one niche magical tradition, despite having elves, dwarfs (the original builders), 2 Orders and the Ice Witches, I don't think there's any chance for the Project to succeed.

The Hags aren't particularly influential in Kislev, it's the IW who are closer to the nobility.

The Hag Witches have a particularly unique perspective, very different from the paradigms we have involved already. The elves and the orders are probably significantly overlapping with a lot of redundancy in their knowlege. The Hags are mich more likely to have something new to add. And they something may be talking to spirits who have an even more different perspective.

This is, I think, a very, very, very hard problem that we need to give ourselves as many significantly different perspectives from people with the institutional capability to record knowledge on it as we can. That's why I'm also in favour of recruiting the Damsels next turn, as they have yet another different view.
 
Is there a theory saying the Hags serve a Daughter? There is a fairly convincing one for the Halethans, but I don't remember anything about the Hags.

I'm also not sure they will be that useful for the project. The IW are maintaining special Waystones, so they're interesting for us, but I don't remember Hags being associated with waystones. And even if they were, I consider Kislev's support and access to be more important.
Mathilde theorises on the Hag Witches earlier on in the Ostermark arc:
"Third is the local leaders of the settlements actually within the Shirokij. Even more than most Kislevite stanitsas, the forest stanitsas are very reliant on Hag Witches to placate the local spirits, and they're right in the middle of all of this. Hag Witches are said to know a great deal about pacifying the spirits of the land and cleansing the taint of Chaos. If that involves Waystone, great, and if it doesn't, then they're somehow able to do the same thing that Waystones do."
Either they have something to do with Waystones or do the same thing in a different manner, both would be useful.
 
The Hag Witches have a particularly unique perspective, very different from the paradigms we have involved already. The elves and the orders are probably significantly overlapping with a lot of redundancy in their knowlege. The Hags are mich more likely to have something new to add. And they something may be talking to spirits who have an even more different perspective.
True, but we can always recruit Hags later, while Kislev's support is probably a one-time opportunity. And I think we already have plenty of different traditions, especially with the IW. Imo it's enough to begin.
 
Last edited:
The Elves and Orders are explicitly not supposed to have redundancy because most of what we're collecting information on is stuff that Teclis wouldn't tell the Orders about. We're attempting to extract pre-collegiate knowledge, Jade Order with their Druidic traditions and the semi-Nehekharan knowledge of the Light Order. Both are different paradigms to Teclisean teachings, even if they might not necessarily be incompatible.
 
I personally don't see a world where a successful waystone reconnection/creation/cleansing does not get noticed by Kislev, especially when both of their major magic institutions are present and have desired it in the past. I think all it might do is take Kislev away as a testing ground.
 
Last edited:
True, but we can always recruit Hags later, while Kislev's support is probably a one-time opportunity. And I think we already have plenty of different traditions, especially with the IW. Imo it's enough to begin.

Why is it a one time opportunity?

Repeating myself a bit but I truly do not expect negotiating access to waystones to be a challenging prospect. Considering A: Most of the nobility isn't really going to know or care much about them and will lean to magical traditions that we'll in all likelihood have already recruited for advice. And B: We've got an all-star lineup of talent people are going to be impressed by and think will know what they're doing.
 
[x] [KISLEV] Waystone Project: Hag Witches
[x] [KISLEV] Library: Bokha Palace
[x] [KISLEV] EIC Foothold
[x] [KISLEV] Boon
[x] [WIDOW] Waystone Project: Ice Witches
[x] [WIDOW] Library: Ice Court
 
True, but we can always recruit Hags later, while Kislev's support is probably a one-time opportunity. And I think we already have plenty of different traditions, especially with the IW. Imo it's enough to begin.

Most of what we have is teclisean or teclisian adjacent.

The only true outliers are Dwarves and now potentially the ice witches, getting the hags onboard is a really good idea.

Ideally we should go for both Kislevian magic traditions now and next turn make one final push for recruitment. Get the Damsels, get the hedgewise then next turn Lay the foundation and begin.

I think starting the foundations next turn would amount to thread impatience, if we're laying the foundation next turn then we're not using the father face of the coin.

[X] [KISLEV] Waystone Project: Hag Witches
Boris has a strong relationship with his Ungol subjects, and would be able to arrange Hag Witch cooperation for the Waystone Project if you ask for it.
[X] [WIDOW] Waystone Project: Ice Witches
You've worked well with the Ice Witches multiple times now. Seek to continue that trend by bringing them in to the Waystone Project.
 
Last edited:
Why is it a one time opportunity?

Repeating myself a bit but I truly do not expect negotiating access to waystones to be a challenging prospect. Considering A: Most of the nobility isn't really going to know or care much about them and will lean to magical traditions that we'll in all likelihood have already recruited for advice. And B: We've got an all-star lineup of talent people are going to be impressed by and think will know what they're doing.
Weighing in on this, the Waystone I'm most interested in exploring is the one under Bokha Palace and whatever the one in Praag is supposed to be, because it's likely to give us clues as to what the hell is happening in Kislev that's redirecting the energy flow. We might be able to get access to the Bokha palace one from the favor we've accrued with Boris and Vladimir, but not so much with the Praag one. Praag is under the control of a Z'ra. We'd have to pull some serious political weight to get free reign in that city and start exploring its secrets.

I don't think this is a one time opportunity, but I have a feeling that if we want to explore Praag and we don't choose Kislev here, then we'd likely have to perform a favor for the Z'ra to get access to that city's secrets. Action investment, drawbacks and the like.
 
[x] [KISLEV] Waystone Project: Kislev
[x] [WIDOW] Waystone Project: Ice Witches

Why I am not voting for hag witches:
remember how the mode of operation of hedge witches differed from Mathilde's understanding of magic enough for it to be all but incompatible? It should be worse with hag witches. Their inspiration were slav folk tales, see Baba Yaga, or, to use a more known example, Pratchett's discworld witches were inspired by the same source.
So I do not expect for hag witches in a university setting to be helpful.
On the other hand, securing the cooperation of Kislev in the Waystone project to operate on their soil with impunity… This well may be the only chance for that, given that Kislev is not exactly welcoming to foreign magicals, and we want to build our future stones here, because they are nearest to the Chaos.
Literally the entire project is built on gathering nominally-incompatible magical traditions and building a model of the Waystones that doesn't contradict any of them. A weirdly incompatible lore of magic isn't a problem, it's the point.
Why waste an action on potentially recruiting the Hag Witches with the facet of the Father. After all, picking faith in Ranald wouldnt give us AP hell. Now we have an in by another action, let us use it.

Nothing stopping people from waving the coin around at the Hag Witches at a later date aswell, anyhow.
You're thinking of the Hedgewise, the Hag Witches don't have a patron goddess.

[x] [KISLEV] Waystone Project: Hag Witches
[x] [WIDOW] Waystone Project: Ice Witches
 
I don't think this is a one time opportunity, but I have a feeling that if we want to explore Praag and we don't choose Kislev here, then we'd likely have to perform a favor for the Z'ra to get access to that city's secrets. Action investment, drawbacks and the like.
That seems a likely enough sequence, but if we don't recruit the Hag Witches here, we'll have to spend an action to do so later, and possibly/probably another to do their payment-favour. Then to get the benefit, probably a Re-Laying of the Foundations action to incorporate their perspective (alongside any other participants we've grouped for that phase).

Thus it seems to me likely more action-efficient to get as many Magical Traditions as possible on board here?

Laying those Foundations is more time sensitive than poking specific Waystone locations, too, to my mind. Form the theory framework against which we will do that later fieldwork.

So my vote is:

[x] [KISLEV] Waystone Project: Hag Witches
[x] [WIDOW] Waystone Project: Ice Witches
 
Last edited:
Why is it a one time opportunity?

Repeating myself a bit but I truly do not expect negotiating access to waystones to be a challenging prospect. Considering A: Most of the nobility isn't really going to know or care much about them and will lean to magical traditions that we'll in all likelihood have already recruited for advice. And B: We've got an all-star lineup of talent people are going to be impressed by and think will know what they're doing.
Yes, but if we choose Kislev rn the access will be even wider, and we would potentially get a monetary contribution, which is bound to be considerable. I think financing the project is also an important part of it.

Most of what we have is teclisean or teclisian adjacent.
Yeah, and it was Teclisian theory combined with the Dwarfs that created the original network.

We also have probable Druidic secrets with the Jades and Nehekharan ones with the Lights, plus the forest spirits of Cadaeth. We do not need the Hags.

I think starting the foundations next turn would amount to thread impatience, if we're laying the foundation next turn then we're not using the father face of the coin.
Yes, so what? I read this quest because it is enjoyable, and I would enjoy more reading about beginning the Project than about yet another recruitment turn. And Imo we at last have a wide enough variety of traditions to lay the foundation in an effective manner, especially with the IW on board.

If we hadn't had those 2 mini arcs, I would be more open to the idea of another recruitment turn. But as nice and enjoyable as they were, if another round of recruitment means months irl before finishing the turn, I'll pass.
 
Last edited:
That seems a likely enough sequence, but if we don't recruit the Hag Witches here, we'll have to spend an action to do so later, and possibly/probably another to do their payment-favour. Then to get the benefit, probably a Re-Laying of the Foundations action to incorporate their perspective (alongside any other participants we've grouped for that phase).

Thus it seems to me likely more action-efficient to get as many Magical Traditions as possible on board here?
I agree with that as well. I was simply pointing out possible cons attached to one of the choices. I'm not too invested one way or the other and would be fine with either Kislev or Hag Witches winning.

On a side note, I went to look back and check on the Informational posts to see if there have been any updates:
The lower half of an Ulgu-wielding Branchwraith.
We have Drycha's lower half in Character Sheets under magical components and artifacts in the "Home in K8P" bar, but not the accumulated artifacts bar.
Kurgan enchanted weapons (approx. 12)
Boney has specified how many Kurgan weapons we have.
 
We also have probable Druidic secrets with the Jades and Nehekharan ones with the Lights, plus the forest spirits of Cadaeth. We do not need the Hags.
Except for their specific, unique ability where the Hags can do what Waystones do, and purge corruption.

That's a thing they currently, definitely know how to do, either via Waystone techniques, or their own.

Sounds like damn useful insight to me.
 
Last edited:
Yes, so what? I read this quest because it is enjoyable, and I would enjoy more reading about beginning the Project than about yet another recruitment turn. And Imo we at last have a wide enough variety of traditions to lay the foundation in an effective manner, especially with the IW on board.

Okay, but you're not the only person in the thread, you want to start next turn no matter and I don't so I'm explaining why I think it's a bad idea to attempt to sway others, so that's what.

I disagree we have a wide enough variety of traditions as basically all of them Empire orientated rather than from wider human culture which has waystone experience..
 
Okay, but you're not the only person in the thread, you want to start next turn no matter and I don't so I'm explaining why I think it's a bad idea to attempt to sway others, so that's what.
I'm aware I'm not the only person in the thread. I was pointing out why I think thread impatience is a valid reason to begin the Project next turn.

I disagree we have a wide enough variety of traditions as basically all of them Empire orientated rather than from wider human culture which has waystone experience..
Guess we must agree to disagree then. Also, we can always recruit them later.

Except for their specific, unique ability where the Hags can do what Waystones do, and purge corruption.

That's a thing they currently, definitely know how to do, either via Waystone techniques, or their own.

Sounds like damn useful insight to me.
Dammit, you're right 😉 Guess I'll have to change my vote.

[x] Waystone Project: Hag Witches
[x] Waystone Project: Ice Witches
 
Last edited:
@Boney:
-Have Kislev forces actually reached the formerly besieged Shirokij villages yet?

No.

-Will there be an option to go to the Eonir and say "do you have any experts on Athel Loren and can they make anything of a lilac themed Ulgu wielding spirit of vengance attempting to kidnap a Kislevite noble?"

The Eonir know even less about modern Athel Loren than the Empire does.

-Will Mathilde be delivering her report to Panaroth in person or will she leave him a message at the College (or is that yet to be determined)?

Wait and see.

-Same question as the above, but regarding Mira.

Wait and see.

And the most important question:
-Is Drycha's bottom half long enough to be carved into a staff?

Yes.
 
@Boney I'm fully expecting a "no" as an answer to this question, but I still have to ask. Partly out of amusement and partly out of practicality.

Does Mathilde know how valuable Manticore dung is? If so, does she know the process of safely handling it for collection? I doubt Tzar Vladimir cares much about the dung so we probably wouldn't have to ask him for it. Then again, we don't know where the Manticore's territory is, so chances are it's a complete wash. I still feel the need to ask.
 
Back
Top