"1000 lovers" probably means "1000 utterly devoted zealots", - not "1000 utterly broken r*pe victims". At least, I hope so.
I doubt very much that she was a mega rapist or else Sigmar and everyone else would not have thought of her as an ally with friendly relations to the Unberogens, who were relatively honorable amongst the tribes. So, yeah.
In my view, those three old gods represent stone age archetypes. Taal is about solitary survival in the wilds, like a beast. Rhya is about communal survival in the wilds, as a pack. Ulric is about dominating wilderness, by carving a piece from it. All three archetypes predate civilization, with Ulric being civilization's starting point, so his followers are drawn to the edge of it.
So...no?
Not really, sorry. It's...hmm. Okay.
Taal and Rhya are a split set of deities who originally began, in the olden olden times, as Ishernos, who actually
was as close to a Stone Age God as you can get in terms of beliefs. Ishernos was the God of all of nature, and had both male and female aspects, specifically depending on the seasons as to which aspect was more dominant. The eldest symbols of worship for the ancient stone cairns are a triskeles set, which to some people makes sense, because over
time eventually Ulric showed up more and more, and took on the aspect of Winter, and eventual Ishernos became more separated into Taal and Rhya, with Taal representing nature, beasts, mountains and forests, and Rhya 'the Earth Mother' representing agriculture, fertility, and nature. Taal, if anything, is a specific repulsion of civilization, his Cult disdains 'works of science' and industry, like, steel and iron made with forges, and prefers just pure leathers, furs, cloth, etc. instead of armor or more. His more extremist devotees, the Wild Men (And women) wear no clothes, use only hands and body, live in the deep woods, filthy and bestial, and so on.
Plus, there's even other elder Gods that other Gods slowly gobbled up, replaced, were named in place of, reconsecrated, presumed dominant, and more, who faded away into local legends, smaller spirits, or even less than that. As the tribes that crossed into the West carrying the worship of Ulric with them, many of these were deposed or submitted to other Gods.
Ahalt the Drinker was the former Nature God of the Menogoths, God of the Hunt and Fertility, and the Cult of Taal and Rhya literally went after his ass hardcore, hunting down, forcibly converting, etc. his followers until he ran away with a tiny Cult that kept him sustained enough to eke out a half-existence down the centuries. But as Gods can change, and do, so did Ahalt, and he became a twisted, bloodthirsty being who's rites and rituals and worship became bloodsoaked blasphemies compared to the true ancient ways, and he's still a problem in the southern provinces even now. He
explicitly did not start out that way, and was driven to it out of anger and fury and hate against Taal and Rhya booting his ass in so hard that he was nearly unmade entirely.
So the problem with your assertion that what they represent is a stone age thing is that they, quite frankly,
don't.
Taal was essentially the King of the Gods at one point, and ruled the places of nature while his wife built and championed civilization and quite literally represented the calming of nature's wrath through the work and patience of the wife (and humanity) through their doings. And he is the one who built his city, Taalheim, first, in the huge crater in near center of the Empire. He is a God who disdains civilization, wishes the wild places to grow unchecked by it:
Taal represents the power and majesty of nature, not only of the physical world of stone and wood, but also the primal urge of life within all creatures. He is not only the physical heart of a person, but also the spark that makes the heart pump. Taal represents vigour and growth in all its forms -- especially the transitions from childhood and adulthood, when life is at its peak. Taal inspires wildness; the primal fury of the beast is his domain and he is primarily worshipped by hardy woodsmen, trackers, and rangers.
You've sort of gone completely wrong with Taal, he most emphatically does
not represent solitary survival in the woods. His thing is literally ALL nature, from the trees to the wood to the beasts and more. He is not solitary survival, he is nature itself, which thrives and survives against itself and within itself. Ulric is the God of Wolves, but Taal is the God of a shit ton of other animals too that travel in herds, in groups, in families, from beavers to deer to bears to stags to rabbits to birds and more. And Rhya, in turn, is part of that relationship as well, in a different aspect but one just as important. Ulric may well have once been part of Ishernos, but became his own God in his own right in his own way, with his people carrying his fire and faith into the lands and settling atop Middenheim and building a city. You quite simply cannot have a God function as 'on the edge of civilization' as you wish to claim Ulric to be, when one of his first known great acts was to smite a mountaintop and install upon it a plateau such that his people might rule from a mighty
city that they would claim as their home and holy place forevermore. Like, here's a myth between Taal, Rhya, and Ulric.
A woman, heavy with child, was lost in the woods. Ulric claimed her fate was his to decide, for she was in the domain of his pack. His brother Taal declared that the wild must be free to do as it will. Only Rhya stood in defiance of her consort and his brother. She showed them the she-wolf defending its cubs. She showed them the eagle feeding eaglets in the nest. She showed them that even the serpent warms its new-hatched young. Ulric and Taal softened, bowed to Rhya, and she guided the mother back to her hearth.
So the thing about this, is that's something Rhya does. But what gets me is the statement that Rhya is the communal survival in the woods, as a pack, thing? That's...that's
literally one of the things that Ulric talks about. Surviving as a pack, a pack of wolves, a pack of brothers in battle, and so on. So that's just a half-skip jump right off the road there, man.
Ulricans see arguments, flaring passions, and even fist-fights simply as part of the order of things. Most Ulricans harbour no ill-will from defeat to another Ulrican since, to them, the best teacher is the defeat you survive, and for many conflict forms tighter bonds of friendship. Brothers-in-arms will frequently fall into brawls, but Ulric's devotees know that they are strongest together, like a pack of wolves.
However, Ulric also demands that his followers should be strong alone, and expects independence to be displayed in all walks of life. He is a distant, harsh and unforgiving god who expects his followers to stand on their own two feet, relying on their individual strength and putting their faith in martial prowess. He is considered to be indifferent to the outcome of wars, and watches over battles letting warriors live or die by their own skill. The least Ulric expects of his followers is to keep his lands free of his enemies, and to always meet them face to face without fear.
^ So even then, the solitary survival thing you attributed to Taal? Quite simply, nope. That's Ulric. Taal believes in knowing how to treat nature not simply as a peer, but a superior. If you can hunt something, do it honorably, do it preferably without metal, just wood and stone. But nature will take its course, and there's whole swathes of his Cult and his faithful going out into the woods to learn naturecraft with their fathers, as a father-son-familial bonding exercise and passing of knowledge. There are lodges out in the woods where they go - as groups, the Taalites - to murmur of things of Man and not Woman. Meanwhile, the Cult of Rhya has their own similar things that they go off and do.
Ulric has never been about dominating nature. He just isn't. He's about dominating your enemies. Respectfully hunting a wolf is one thing, but overall dominating nature? Not really. At most, you should be capable of surviving in bad conditions, with strength, skill, bravery, and hopefully with the aid of your pack with martial prowess against beasts you're hunting. But overall nature domination isn't the same thing, and certainly isn't some kind of overarching focus.
Rhya is the taming of nature, the turning of wild things into softer things, of agriculture, of creating fields of grain and orchards of fruit rather than simply picking at randomly placed bushes of berries or picking a fruit from a single tree in the forest.
None of these Gods are a 'beginning of civilization' God. Ulric was carried west and literally bludgeoned into dominance over the land, and even then, Taal and Rhya had Taalheim which would become Talabheim, a vast forested land, that none of the other majorly Ulrican tribes could take from them. They were violent, nasty, conquering every other God and deity that they could which dared to shared similar aspects to them. Taal and Rhya whupped the ass of every other Nature God up and down the proto-Empire until everyone else was subordinate to them, to the King of Nature aka Taal, and could only pray to Rhya that she could calm him down from ripping them several new assholes even more so than he'd already done, only to miss the fact that she was the one rubbing her hubby's shoulders and back as he sat and took a rest from how much ass kicking he was doing to the other nature Gods to get him ready to go and do it again.
It's just...you're approaching all three Gods from just the wrong stance entirely. Gods change. Sigmar popped up, a different God entirely. Gods have different interpretations, different faces that they're known more by in certain areas, they're not solely monolithic beings a lot of the time. Taal and Rhya are the modernized version of Ishernos, who himself is quite possibly a bastardized version of Kurnous and Isha as best as the humans of the Old World could interpret from elven ruins after the War of Vengeance. Ahalt the Drinker was a major tribe's Nature God, and he was reduced to a blood-hungry throat-opener bastard after Taal and Rhya decided they wanted to straight up kill him by taking out all of his worshippers entirely and subsuming his lands and area, which they very nearly did except a tiny little surviving remnant that escaped and hid themselves well enough. There's different myths about the invasions of Chaos, one where Taal led everyone, one where Ulric led everyone and Taal didn't believe it, and so on. Manann is the unrestrained child of Taal and Rhya, as well, so that's another thing entirely, while Verena is married to Morr, who from their union spawned Shallya and Myrmidia. And even then! You have 'white bird = healing Goddess' but Shallya and Salyak are not the same, with wholly different priesthoods and clearly distinct differences. Different tales as to how Ranald is/became a God too. Is Ptra the God of the Sun and other things in Nehekhara just Asuryan of the elves? Nope! Despite having a multitude of similarities, possibly inspirations of the latter to creating the former, Nagash turned servants of Ptra into horrid abominations,
not Asuryan. Gods change. Gods diverge. Gods are static and flowing at the same time.
"
Evina Klug, Verena's high priestess in Middenheim, allowed me to access her libraries, and there I uncovered the tale of Lupos, a Wolf God associated with Taal and Rhya, possibly as part of an ancient triumvirate. In particular, the White Wolf was of especial importance to that deity, and represented the long-dead religion's ferocity and passion. Does it not seem likely that the early Teutogens may have absorbed the Cult of Lupos, probably at the end of an axe. Thus, Ulric's association with wolves may be stolen from another cult, and may have nothing to do with the original cult at all? If my suspicions are true, they will bring many Ulrican religious texts into question, for wolf iconography is now associated with Ulric from the beginning of time-and I believe that may be a lie!"
—The third journal of Werner Stoltz, Sigmar's High Capitular in Middenheim
In your view, you're approaching them as stone age archetypes.
They are not. That would have been Ishernos, and that God is long gone, sublimating into distinct sums greater than their former whole. Ulric is a conquering God who came from the east, and was
installed into power and dominance with bloodshed over peoples, not nature, and was set up with Middenheim, his great bastion city. Stone age was not building big cities. Just wasn't. Ulric is not a God at all representative of civilization's starting point, he is a God of
people, of their wars, of winter itself, of wolves, who came with already established peoples who already had a culture and a way of doing things and they fought their way in to start it in a place that already had a grand originating city in Taalheim under Taal. Verena is the Goddess of Wisdom, sciences, laws, writing, scribes, knowledge. Myrmidia is a Goddess of Arts, Architecture, War, Love, and yes, Civilization in certain interpretations.
Also, the 'territory and lesser wives/concubines' thing doesn't work either. You appear to have missed my post earlier on Boris Todbringer, a major Ulrican man, and how having extra women outside of his marriage was not considered a good thing, at all. It's just. Not. A. Thing. There is no pack/territory/extra women situation going on with the Ulricans, man. There just plain old isn't.
And I would not say they're like hobbits either. The Teutogens, the tribe that ruled from Middenheim, were amongst the most bloodthirsty and warmongering of all the tribes, and well known for it. The only instance of non-strict monogamy was introduced into 4th Edition Warhammer between Taal and Rhya,
not with Ulric or his followers, and even then, that's brand new potential canon, not established in the prior editions.
This whole 'carving a piece of the wilderness' thing out is just not a big part of Ulric or his Cult, Ulric has never focused on nature being unrivaled and dominant or nutured and transformed as with Taal and Rhya. His concerns are of War, Winter, Wolves. And generally, it's about Winter being Winter and how people deal with it, survive in it, or don't, not 'carving' a season out for himself or any of that business.
So, again, no.
Also, Freya can have had sex with 1000+ men consensually, I don't understand why you had to bring up them being possibly rape victims in the first place.