[X][PRIORITY] Star-Kin: Refit Monastery as Long-Term
[X][PRIORITY] Caldonians: Refit old Science Cruisers as Long-Term
[X][PRIORITY] Orions: Move Inc Crew/Res to Medium Term
[X][PRIORITY] STO: Increase BR/SR as Medium-Term


[X][ORION] Adopt Project Emerald as a new light frigate, capable of being built in 600kt berths. (+10 pp)
[X][ORION] Support development of a Miranda-B variant (-10 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer one Miranda-B to the Orion Union as soon as the project is complete, in an Orion berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense).
[X][ORION] Adopt Kepler as a new scout frigate, building in 2.25 years, with crew cost O2 E3 T4.
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Greenleaf as a new skirmish frigate, with build time 2 years, cost 80-85 BR & 55-65 SR, and crew cost O1 E2 T2. (+10 pp)
[X][ORION] Wait to refit existing cruisers

[X][LAIO] Support the construction of a shipyard. (-11 pp, Laio Shipyard with 1x2mt berth will be built at Laian)

[X][FRIGATE] Adopt Project Emerald (-5 pp for facilitating technical assistance, prototype begins production in 2325Q3 at Bidva, -70 br, -55 sr OR additional -15 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
[X][FRIGATE] Back the Miranda-B project (-2 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer a Miranda-B to the Laians as soon as the project is complete (in a Laian berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense))
[X][FRIGATE] Transfer mothballed Amarki frigates to the Laians (-2 pp for facilitating minor technical assistance; Laio acquires 2 Brieca-As and scraps three frigates, in 2325Q1, reduce the br & sr cost of any other [FRIGATE] option taken by 90 br & 55 sr (or additional pp cost by 15 pp))


Breaking with SWB on this one. The Torqui Leb Lagans are Explorers, meaning they can't enter Vanguard and cost more to draft for SF service. They're also massive crew hogs (6O 6E 5T) and can't be refit until 2329... an eternity away. Meanwhile the Renaissance-As can be started this year and done by mid-2328 while freeing up more crew and fighting comparably.

[X][STO] Scrap the Torqui Leb Lagans and replace with three Renaissance-A.

Also going to go with Mielab so Caitains don't have to do berth upgrades.

[X][CAT] Adopt the Mielab in its current form.

[X][BETZA] Rename the class the Bird of Paradise, as an analog to the Klingon Bird-of-Prey but for much more peaceful ends.
 
Last edited:
Ah, thank you Alliterate, that was the thing I was looking for, generally, but I was hoping there was a similar sheet for Starfleet's yards.
 
Ah, thank you Alliterate, that was the thing I was looking for, generally, but I was hoping there was a similar sheet for Starfleet's yards.
There is, but it's someone else's personal sheet and I'm not at liberty to fling the link around.

Also going to go with Mielab so Caitains don't have to do berth upgrades.
I mean, I don't think that'll really be necessary for a scout they might only ever build one of domestically. They do have a few berths large enough.

However, I do think I'm gonna swap to this (back in my vote post), too.
[][STO] Scrap the Torqui Leb Lagans and replace with three Renaissance-A.
 
Last edited:
As I just pointed out in Discord chat, we gave the Apiata some ancient shipyard berths back in the 2323 Snakepit that aren't showing up on their Shipyard sheet.

An ancient shipyard, still partially intact, was discovered at 33 Azzadi. Two 2000kt berths can be restored to functionality. The question is, who should operate the shipyard?
[ ][OLDYARD] Starfleet (Lose 30 pp; acquire 2x2000kt berths in six turns)
[ ][OLDYARD] Apiata (Gain 20 pp; Apiata acquire 2x2000kt berths in six turns)

Should be active this turn!
 
Meanwhile, at Colhane Industrial:

"The MWCD recommended us. You realize what this means?"
"We're going to be filthy rich?"
"Yes, yes, but also those snooty bastards at Molhane and Nelhiar can go to hell! None of this 'we built the Navy' condescending crap anymore! We built the Union Navy, and everyone else's!"
 
Meanwhile, at Colhane Industrial:

"The MWCD recommended us. You realize what this means?"
"We're going to be filthy rich?"
"Yes, yes, but also those snooty bastards at Molhane and Nelhiar can go to hell! None of this 'we built the Navy' condescending crap anymore! We built the Union Navy, and everyone else's!"
Hyperelite Technology really hit the goldmine with their budget frigates.
 
For anyone who name-voted me, I've swapped to recommending to scrap the Torqui Leb Lagan in favor of Renaissance-As, due to the 2325 (2328 completion) vs 2329 (2330 completion) argument.


Question for @OneirosTheWriter & @SynchronizedWritersBlock

The Emerald's Wiki entry mentions this, "Note: Can be fitted with a 50kt module for +1C, +1S or even an OSA +1P module for only +5BR/+5SR and no change in crew."

Does this mean that Members who chose the Emerald have to lock themselves into an option or can they build the base Emerald and Module-varients on a case-by-case basis?
No known answer from my end, as the designer I only note the possibility.

The Emerald (a different export version actually) was designed that way for Yrillian work gangs who might want some customization. If Emerald-S, Emerald-C, and Emerald-P variants pop up at all it's most likely going to be Yrillian ones.
 
Last edited:
No known answer from my end, as the designer I only note the possibility.

The Emerald (a different export version actually) was designed that way for Yrillian work gangs who might want some customization. If Emerald-S, Emerald-C, and Emerald-P variants pop up at all it's most likely going to be Yrillian ones.
The modularity is cool, it inspired the same capability on the Envoy.

Hmm. Are the Yrillians building both Emeralds and New Orleans(An open-source speedy skirmish frigate design that popped up on Yrillian interwebs)? I guess they do hit slightly different niches.
 
Last edited:
[X][PRIORITY] Star-Kin: Refit Monastery as Long-Term
[X][PRIORITY] Caldonians: Refit old Science Cruisers as Long-Term
[X][PRIORITY] Orions: Move Inc Crew/Res to Medium Term
[X][PRIORITY] STO: Increase BR/SR as Medium-Term


[X][ORION] Adopt Project Emerald as a new light frigate, capable of being built in 600kt berths. (+10 pp)
[X][ORION] Support development of a Miranda-B variant (-10 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer one Miranda-B to the Orion Union as soon as the project is complete, in an Orion berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense).
[X][ORION] Adopt Kepler as a new scout frigate, building in 2.25 years, with crew cost O2 E3 T4.
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Greenleaf as a new skirmish frigate, with build time 2 years, cost 80-85 BR & 55-65 SR, and crew cost O1 E2 T2. (+10 pp)
[X][ORION] Wait to refit existing cruisers

[X][LAIO] Support the construction of a shipyard. (-11 pp, Laio Shipyard with 1x2mt berth will be built at Laian)

[X][FRIGATE] Adopt Project Emerald (-5 pp for facilitating technical assistance, prototype begins production in 2325Q3 at Bidva, -70 br, -55 sr OR additional -15 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
[X][FRIGATE] Back the Miranda-B project (-2 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer a Miranda-B to the Laians as soon as the project is complete (in a Laian berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense))
[X][FRIGATE] Transfer mothballed Amarki frigates to the Laians (-2 pp for facilitating minor technical assistance; Laio acquires 2 Brieca-As and scraps three frigates, in 2325Q1, reduce the br & sr cost of any other [FRIGATE] option taken by 90 br & 55 sr (or additional pp cost by 15 pp))

[X][STO] Adopt the Torqui Leb Lagan Flight II (C7 S7 H4 L6 P7 D7, 200 br 140 sr 6O 6E 5T, 35 br & 35 sr refit cost) and refit in 2329

[X][CAT] Adopt Project Carbon (Requires shipyard upgrades to produce at home, -10 pp to rent an Orion berth for the initial build)

[X][BETZA] Rename the class the Artful-class, after the first unit.
 
Aaaaaaaaaaand closed.

NetTally, take it away:

Vote Tally : To Boldly Go... (a Starfleet quest) - Sci-Fi | Page 4155 | Sufficient Velocity [Posts: 103880-103991]
##### NetTally 1.9.9
[X] SWB
No. of Votes: 1
Katsuragi

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: PRIORITY
[X][PRIORITY] Star-Kin: Refit Monastery as Long-Term
No. of Votes: 21
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][PRIORITY] Caldonians: Refit old Science Cruisers as Long-Term
No. of Votes: 21
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][PRIORITY] Orions: Move Inc Crew/Res to Medium Term
No. of Votes: 21
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][PRIORITY] STO: Increase BR/SR as Medium-Term
No. of Votes: 21
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: ORION
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Emerald as a new light frigate, capable of being built in 600kt berths. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 23
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
Ukrainian Ranger
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Greenleaf as a new skirmish frigate, with build time 2 years, cost 80-85 BR & 55-65 SR, and crew cost O1 E2 T2. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 22
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][ORION] Wait to refit existing cruisers
No. of Votes: 22
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Maelore
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][ORION] Adopt Kepler as a new scout frigate, building in 2.25 years, with crew cost O2 E3 T4.
No. of Votes: 19
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Hadanelith
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][ORION] Support development of a Miranda-B variant (-10 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer one Miranda-B to the Orion Union as soon as the project is complete, in an Orion berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense).
No. of Votes: 18
sunrise
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Hadanelith
kimagurena
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Carbon (2324 variant) as a new scout frigate, building in 2 years, with crew cost O2 E3 T3. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 2
Steven Kodaly
Gingganz
[X][ORION] Adopt Comet as a new skirmish frigate, with build time 2.5 years, cost 105 BR & 75 SR, and crew cost O2 E3 T3.
No. of Votes: 2
Steven Kodaly
chriswriter90
[X][ORION] Adopt the Envoy as a new diplomatic cruiser
No. of Votes: 1
Ukrainian Ranger
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Emerald as a new light frigate, capable of being built in 600kt berths. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 1
Maelore
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Carbon (2324 variant) as a new scout frigate, building in 2 years, with crew cost O2 E3 T3. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 1
Maelore
[X][ORION] Adopt Project Greenleaf as a new skirmish frigate, with build time 2 years, cost 80-85 BR & 55-65 SR, and crew cost O1 E2 T2. (+10 pp)
No. of Votes: 1
Maelore

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: LAIO
[X][LAIO] Support the construction of a shipyard. (-11 pp, Laio Shipyard with 1x2mt berth will be built at Laian)
No. of Votes: 21
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
kimagurena
Maelore
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X ][LAIO] Support the construction of a shipyard complex. (-54 pp, Laio Shipyard with 1x2mt berth, 2x1mt berths will be built at Laian)
No. of Votes: 2
Ukrainian Ranger
chriswriter90

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: FRIGATE
[X][FRIGATE] Transfer mothballed Amarki frigates to the Laians (-2 pp for facilitating minor technical assistance; Laio acquires 2 Brieca-As and scraps three frigates, in 2325Q1, reduce the br & sr cost of any other [FRIGATE] option taken by 90 br & 55 sr (or additional pp cost by 15 pp))
No. of Votes: 22
Ukrainian Ranger
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
Night
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][FRIGATE] Adopt Project Emerald (-5 pp for facilitating technical assistance, prototype begins production in 2325Q3 at Bidva, -70 br, -55 sr OR additional -15 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
No. of Votes: 22
Ukrainian Ranger
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Jrin
Night
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][FRIGATE] Back the Miranda-B project (-2 pp cost to a Miranda-B refit, Starfleet must refit and transfer a Miranda-B to the Laians as soon as the project is complete (in a Laian berth if necessary, but at Starfleet expense))
No. of Votes: 22
Goat
Alliterate
Briefvoice
brmj
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Hadanelith
Jrin
kimagurena
Night
Oshha
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][FRIGATE] Put the Mielab into production (-8 pp for facilitating technical assistance, 1-2 ordered 2325Q3, -40-80 br, -40-85 sr or additional -8-18 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
No. of Votes: 3
Maelore
Derpmind
kimagurena
[X][FRIGATE] Put the Mielab into production (-8 pp for facilitating technical assistance, 1-2 ordered 2325Q3, -40-80 br, -40-85 sr or additional -8-18 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
No. of Votes: 2
Ukrainian Ranger
Steven Kodaly
[X][FRIGATE] Adopt Project Emerald (-5 pp for facilitating technical assistance, prototype begins production in 2325Q3 at Bidva, -70 br, -55 sr
No. of Votes: 2
Maelore
kimagurena
[X][FRIGATE] Adopt Project Emerald (-5 pp for facilitating technical assistance, prototype begins production in 2325Q3 at Bidva, -70 br, -55 sr OR -15 pp to arrange a resource transfer from the Honiani)
No. of Votes: 1
Raw90
[X][FRIGATE] Put the Mielab into production (-8 pp for facilitating technical assistance, 1-2 ordered 2325Q3)
No. of Votes: 1
Raw90
[X][FRIGATE] Transfer mothballed Amarki frigates to the Laians (-2 pp for facilitating minor technical assistance; Laio acquires 2 Brieca-As and scraps three frigates, in 2325Q1, reduce the br & sr cost of any other [FRIGATE] option taken by 90 br & 55 sr
No. of Votes: 1
Maelore

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: STO
[X][STO] Adopt the Torqui Leb Lagan Flight II (C7 S7 H4 L6 P7 D7, 200 br 140 sr 6O 6E 5T, 35 br & 35 sr refit cost) and refit in 2329
No. of Votes: 13
Raw90
brmj
Chaos Blade
Derpmind
Gingganz
Goat
kimagurena
Maelore
Night
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
Theunderbolt
Ukrainian Ranger
[X][STO] Scrap the Torqui Leb Lagans and replace with three Renaissance-A.
No. of Votes: 13
SynchronizedWritersBlock
agumentic
Alliterate
Briefvoice
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
charysa
chriswriter90
Enerael
Hadanelith
Jrin
Oshha
Simon_Jester

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: CAT
[X][CAT] Adopt Project Carbon (Requires shipyard upgrades to produce at home, -10 pp to rent an Orion berth for the initial build)
No. of Votes: 18
Raw90
Alliterate
brmj
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Enerael
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
Maelore
Simon_Jester
Steven Kodaly
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][CAT] Adopt the Mielab in its current form.
No. of Votes: 8
Ukrainian Ranger
Briefvoice
Brogatar
Derpmind
Jrin
kimagurena
Oshha
Steven Kodaly

——————————————————————————————————————————————Task: BETZA
[X][BETZA] Rename the class the Bird of Paradise, as an analog to the Klingon Bird-of-Prey but for much more peaceful ends.
No. of Votes: 19
Raw90
Alliterate
Briefvoice
Brogatar
Captain Hunt
Chaos Blade
charysa
Enerael
Finagle007
Gingganz
Goat
Hadanelith
kimagurena
Maelore
Oshha
Simon_Jester
sunrise
SynchronizedWritersBlock
Theunderbolt
[X][BETZA] Rename the class the Artful-class, after the first unit
No. of Votes: 7
Ukrainian Ranger
brmj
chriswriter90
Derpmind
Jrin
Night
Steven Kodaly
Total No. of Voters: 28
 
[X][STO] Adopt the Torqui Leb Lagan Flight II (C7 S7 H4 L6 P7 D7, 200 br 140 sr 6O 6E 5T, 35 br & 35 sr refit cost) and refit in 2329

Because this is way more efficient than Ren-As for the STO!

fasquardon
 
Back
Top