Jello_Raptor
(Confirmed Jelly)
- Location
- Left of Center
With a house band : Straak and the Whisperers
Some sort of Electronic hard rock with a lot of choral whispering?
Last edited:
Saavik is a Canon Character™, not much could be done about it in the first place.Now, I know Straak, but that's mitigated because I haven't quite managed to differentiate his name from Saavik and to me she's just "the Vulcan that isn't Straak or T'Lorel", so when she comes up there's more disappointment that she isn't who I thought she was than investment in the character she presumably is. This can't be fixed now, but in the future avoiding concurrent captains with super similar names would be nice.
So who wants to bet that if the Orion Union joins the Federation, they'll get in a slapfight with the humans and their representatives over genetic modifications? I don't see the Tellarites, Vulcans or Andorians having big horses in the Genetic Engineering ban, it's mostly a human thing and nobody else had any objections-until now.
We've had so much else going on, nobody's really zoomed in on her. Plus, I've always found Vulcans hard to write... do other people find it so?
Hm. Saavik needs some support then.
I mean, there are marvelously compelling events that have happened to her. She's got a personality, too. The problem is just that she's not in the spotlight. She's interacting with some of the more obscure species (like the Qloath), and her big adventures consist of narrow escapes (like the giant metal dinosaur and the hijackers).
We've had so much else going on, nobody's really zoomed in on her. Plus, I've always found Vulcans hard to write... do other people find it so?
Yeah, but as late as the Mid-23rd Century, adherents to Eugenics philosophy still held some sway on earth's colonies-it's been a drawn-out thing, and bits of it like Khan occasionally drift up out of the sea of the past, unlike most of the others.Why do you see it as as humans being the only ones to have objections? I figure everyone has their genetic engineering horror stories. Humans aren't so special there.
Briefvoice and AKuz have given me some things about. If the gel for me I might try to give Saavik a bit of a boost. Dunno.
EDIT:
It also just occurred to me that if her Memory Beta background is taken as a guideline... Because going by Memory Beta, Saavik is to Romulans something pretty close to what Worf is to Klingons- a rescued orphan brought up in Romulan culture until the age of ten, then adopted (by Spock and his family).
The big difference compared to Worf is that instead of being raised by a bunch of biologically alien lifeforms he can never fully be a part of, she was raised by people who are literally the same species as her, but who are culturally very different. So she could assimilate into her adoptive world fully, rather than having to stubbornly insist on her birth identity in order to have any identity at all.
So... "Romulan pretending to be a Vulcan" is actually a really good description of Saavik, except she's pretending to everyone including herself and the pretense has become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
On the other hand, this benefits other people (like AKuz) a lot more than it benefits me, because I have no idea how to write a Romulan convincingly.
I have no idea whether Saavik is half-Romulan or not in Boldly Go. If you read the Memory Alpha entry there was a hell of a lot of back and forth with the character in the movies, as they kept adding plot points and taking them out before the final cut. Put it this way:
The idea that Saavik is half-Romulan has the same level of canonicity as the idea that Saavik is the mother to Spock's child.
Yes, but the idea that Saavik was born on a Romulan colony planet, lost/abandoned/orphaned, picked up and adopted into Romulan society is interesting. It's a plot hook, it's a clue to what is going on inside her head, which is exactly the kind of thing one needs to think about and develop on if one wants to do a competent job writing her.I have no idea whether Saavik is half-Romulan or not in Boldly Go. If you read the Memory Alpha entry there was a hell of a lot of back and forth with the character in the movies, as they kept adding plot points and taking them out before the final cut. Put it this way:
The idea that Saavik is half-Romulan has the same level of canonicity as the idea that Saavik is the mother to Spock's child.
I could go either way on that question, honestly.I was always sort of leery about that. It always felt like shipping for the sake of shipping. "Any other Vulcan women? No? You sure we can't do slash? Fine. Saavik it is"
Hm. Saavik needs some support then.
I mean, there are marvelously compelling events that have happened to her. She's got a personality, too. The problem is just that she's not in the spotlight. She's interacting with some of the more obscure species (like the Qloath), and her big adventures consist of narrow escapes (like the giant metal dinosaur and the hijackers).
We've had so much else going on, nobody's really zoomed in on her. Plus, I've always found Vulcans hard to write... do other people find it so?
I've done one and a half on her, but got distracted by other game events for a bit. If I get inspired, I want to do more.
I'm just trying to get the pacing right so she can be the bride at Spock's wedding in 2329 where the young Lieutenant Picard is in attendance for no good reason.
I'm planning on posting some Stargazer stuff in the next few days, focusing on Maryam's bridge crew more than Maryam herself (I'm a bit wary of developing her character since she's AKuz's baby, though I plan to continue fleshing out her past adventures). But I agree that we need some extra flavor on the regular explorer corps captains as well.
I've done one and a half on her, but got distracted by other game events for a bit. If I get inspired, I want to do more.
I'm just trying to get the pacing right so she can be the bride at Spock's wedding in 2329 where the young Lieutenant Picard is in attendance for no good reason.
I'll be sure to emerge from my lurker's cavern to vote for her, when the time arrives.If people will pick T'Rinta for the Odyssey I promise a minimum of three omakes.
I'm planning on posting some Stargazer stuff in the next few days, focusing on Maryam's bridge crew more than Maryam herself (I'm a bit wary of developing her character since she's AKuz's baby, though I plan to continue fleshing out her past adventures). But I agree that we need some extra flavor on the regular explorer corps captains as well.
Eh, I find the whole idea of her and Spock to be kind of icky. That's probably because I was heavily influenced by some novels I read where Saavik was clearly presented as Spock's adopted daughter. It seems way too incestuous, if not in a literal sense.
If my experience with T'Lorel is a guide, she doesn't even need omake support, just a couple mentions in the logs amounting to "remember that other time this thing happened? That was her too." I don't remember T'Lorel because of omakes, I remember her because of The T'Lorel Maneuver and the song when she met the Sydraxians.Hm. Saavik needs some support then.
I mean, there are marvelously compelling events that have happened to her. She's got a personality, too. The problem is just that she's not in the spotlight. She's interacting with some of the more obscure species (like the Qloath), and her big adventures consist of narrow escapes (like the giant metal dinosaur and the hijackers).
We've had so much else going on, nobody's really zoomed in on her. Plus, I've always found Vulcans hard to write... do other people find it so?
Honestly it probably won't matter much. There'll be a line - "genetic engineering issues have been resolved with a compromise" - and it'll probably never come up again.![]()
Anger or one emotion take over. I think an unregulated Vulcan would go through wild, extreme moodswings, like Picard channeling Sarek.That's Vulcans. They have constructed the perfect metal fortifications to hold their emotions in check, but the pressure is always there inside. Whenever I write one, I remember that they're always choosing not to be angry.
I was just reading how they also considered pairing her with Kirk on her Memory Alpha page, and all I can think is it's the ultimate proof of Kirk/Spock OTP that they came up with a Vulcan romance option for him.I was always sort of leery about that. It always felt like shipping for the sake of shipping. "Any other Vulcan women? No? You sure we can't do slash? Fine. Saavik it is"
I don't know why, but for me Saavik is like, the Die Hard captain (maybe Indiana Jones would be a good touchstone as well). She always ends up in some ridiculous, insane situation of sabotage or peril and then gets herself her way out of it. I guarantee you on one of her visits to an Orion planet she's going to wind up in some vents, with no boots and in the Starfleet Tank Top and have to outwit a bunch of thieves posing as Augment terrorists. Her 'bad luck' just means she somehow has a sense of where the danger is and thus is the woman to solve it -- see the near hi-jacking of her ship.If my experience with T'Lorel is a guide, she doesn't even need omake support, just a couple mentions in the logs amounting to "remember that other time this thing that happened? That was her too." I don't remember T'Lorel because of omakes, I remember her because of The T'Lorel Maneuver and the song when she met the Sydraxians.